Etfs And Unit Investment Trusts: What's The Difference?

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and unit investment trusts (UITs) are both investment vehicles that offer investors the ability to diversify their portfolios. However, there are some key differences between the two. ETFs are traded on a stock exchange like individual stocks, while UITs are not traded on an exchange. ETFs are open-ended, meaning the number of shares available can increase or decrease based on demand, whereas UITs are closed-ended with a fixed number of shares available. ETFs are typically low-cost investments designed to track an index, while UITs are actively managed and may have higher fees. UITs have a stated expiration date, and their portfolios are not managed but supervised, with holdings only being eliminated in extreme circumstances.

ETFs vs Unit Investment Trusts

ETFs are open-ended, meaning shares can increase or decrease based on demand

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are open-ended, meaning that the number of shares available can increase or decrease based on demand. This is in contrast to closed-ended funds, which have a fixed number of shares available.

Open-ended funds can issue an unlimited number of shares. When someone buys an open-ended fund, new shares are created, and when someone sells, shares are removed from circulation. The price of these shares is based on the net asset value (NAV) of the fund, which is calculated at the end of each trading day. Open-ended funds are usually bought and sold directly from the company that issues them, although they can sometimes be bought and sold on the secondary market.

Most mutual funds and ETFs are open-ended. Open-ended funds are more common than closed-ended funds and are the bulk of the investment options in company-sponsored retirement plans, such as 401(k) plans. They are also more flexible than closed-ended funds, as investors can usually buy and sell shares whenever they want, rather than having to wait for a specific time.

The first ETFs were structured as unit investment trusts (UITs). UITs are registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940 and are required to attempt to fully replicate the underlying index by owning every security in the index. They are not permitted to partake in securities lending and are not allowed to hold futures, options, or swaps. As a result, they are not subject to counterparty risk.

The majority of ETFs today are registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940 as open-end management companies. Open-end funds have specific diversification requirements, such as a limit of 5% of the portfolio being invested in the securities of a single stock. This structure offers greater portfolio management flexibility compared to UITs, as they are not required to fully replicate an index.

Investment trusts are closed-ended, with a fixed number of shares available

Investment trusts are closed-ended investment funds that are listed on a stock exchange. They are actively managed by a professional fund manager who is responsible for investing the money held in the trust. The fund manager uses the money to buy a portfolio of assets such as stocks, bonds, or property. The price of the investment trust's shares is determined by the value of the assets held in the trust.

Investment trusts are structured as public limited companies and issue a fixed number of shares at inception. This is in contrast to open-ended funds, which can issue new shares and buy back their own shares on demand. A closed-end fund, like an investment trust, issues a fixed number of shares through one initial public offering (IPO) to raise capital for its initial investments. No new shares will be created, and no new money will flow into the fund.

The initial capital for a closed-end fund is raised through a one-time offering of a limited number of shares in the fund. The shares may then be bought and sold on a public stock exchange, but no new shares can be created. This means that investment trusts have a fixed number of shares available, which can limit the ability of investors to redeem their holdings during times of market stress.

The closed-ended structure of investment trusts has several implications for investors. Firstly, it means that the share price of an investment trust is determined by market forces of supply and demand, rather than being directly linked to the net asset value (NAV) of the fund. This can result in the shares trading at a premium or discount to the NAV. Secondly, the closed-ended structure limits the liquidity of investment trusts compared to open-ended funds. While open-ended funds can usually be purchased directly from the fund's sponsoring company, investment trusts can only be bought and sold on a stock exchange, typically requiring a brokerage account.

In summary, investment trusts are closed-ended funds with a fixed number of shares available, which distinguishes them from open-ended funds that can issue new shares and buy back their own shares. This closed-ended structure has implications for the pricing and liquidity of investment trusts, and it limits the ability of investors to redeem their holdings.

ETFs can be bought and sold throughout the trading day

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are bought and sold on exchanges at market prices that change throughout the trading day. These market prices are mostly based on the underlying value of an ETF's holdings, as well as other factors like supply and demand.

ETFs can be traded on an exchange, just like stocks. This means investors can buy and sell ETFs throughout the trading day and have the flexibility to trade them in a variety of ways, including through a broker or online.

The ability to trade ETFs throughout the trading day offers investors greater trading flexibility as they can monitor how the price is doing and don't have to wait until the end of the day to know their purchase or sale price.

When buying or selling ETFs, investors can use a variety of order types, including market orders (an order to buy or sell at the next available price) or limit orders (an order to buy or sell shares at a maximum or minimum price set by the investor).

It is worth noting that the 10 minutes after North American markets open at 9:30 am and 20 minutes before they close at 4 pm EST may be potentially volatile and sometimes result in slightly higher trading costs.

Investment trusts are traded once per day at the end of the trading day

Investment trusts are closed-ended investment funds that are listed on a stock exchange. They are traded only once per day at the end of the trading day, unlike ETFs which can be traded throughout the day. This is because, with investment trusts, investors are transacting directly with the fund, whereas with ETFs, investors are trading on the secondary market.

The price of an investment trust's shares is determined by the value of the assets held in the trust at the end of the trading day. Investment trusts are managed by professional fund managers who are responsible for investing the money held in the trust. They use this money to buy a portfolio of assets such as stocks, bonds, or property.

Investment trusts are actively managed and therefore have higher fees than ETFs. They also have a fixed number of shares available, whereas ETFs are open-ended, meaning the number of shares can increase or decrease based on demand.

Investment trusts offer advantages such as diversification, the ability to borrow, and income potential. However, investors should be aware of potential disadvantages, such as limited gearing and limited redemption.

ETFs are typically lower-cost investments

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are typically lower-cost investments compared to other types of investment vehicles, such as mutual funds and investment trusts. This is primarily due to their passive management structure, which results in lower fees and expenses.

ETFs are designed to track the performance of a particular market index, sector, or asset, and they require less active management than other types of investments. This passive management approach means that ETFs do not involve frequent trading and typically have lower expense ratios. As a result, more money remains invested, helping to boost returns over time.

The cost structure of ETFs is an important consideration for investors, as it directly impacts the overall returns on their investments. The low-cost nature of ETFs makes them an attractive option for investors seeking to minimize fees and maximize returns.

Additionally, ETFs offer investors the ability to diversify their portfolios across a wide range of assets, providing risk reduction through spreading investments. This diversification, coupled with low costs, makes ETFs accessible to a wide range of investors, regardless of their level of experience or the amount of capital they have to invest.

It is worth noting that while ETFs are generally lower-cost investments, there may be additional costs associated with trading them on exchanges, such as brokerage fees and transaction costs. However, the overall expense ratios and passive management structure contribute to ETFs being a cost-effective option for investors.

Frequently asked questions