Mexican Coins: Worthy Investment Or Risky Business?

Mexican coins are steeped in a rich history that dates back to the country's colonial past. Over the centuries, Mexico has introduced various currencies, with the first mint in the Americas being established in Mexico City in 1536. The country's numismatic heritage has produced some of the world's most beautiful and valuable coins, attracting collectors and investors alike. The discussion of whether Mexican coins are a good investment centres around their historical and cultural significance, rarity, and the precious metals they contain.

Mexican coins: historical value and cultural significance

Mexico's numismatic heritage dates back nearly 500 years and is renowned for its beauty and value. The story of Mexican coins begins in April 1536, when the first mint in the Americas was established in Mexico City, marking the birth of the peso. This three-century period saw Mexico become a major supplier of silver coins worldwide, with the large silver 8 reales coin, or the "piece of eight", becoming the first global currency. It was widely used in trade from Asia to Europe and the Americas and remained legal tender in the US until 1857.

During the Mexican War of Independence (1810-1821), provisional coinages were issued by both supporters and opponents of the Spanish monarch, with coins struck in both silver and gold. These coins are among the rarest and most valuable in Mexican numismatics, with some known examples selling for hundreds of thousands of dollars at auction.

After gaining independence in 1821, Mexico continued to produce high-quality gold and silver coins featuring iconic national symbols like the eagle and the liberty cap. The early republic era, often referred to as the Golden Age of Mexican Numismatics, produced some of the most prized coins in Mexican history, including the 1824 "hookneck" 8 escudos and the 1870 Hookneck "pattern" peso.

The late 19th and early 20th centuries saw the introduction of Mexican coins with remarkable artistry and technical sophistication. The gold centenario coins, struck from 1921 to 1947 to commemorate the centennial of Mexico's independence, are a notable example. The 50 pesos centenario, containing 1.2057 ounces of pure gold and featuring art nouveau designs, remains a popular investment choice.

Other exceptional coins from this golden age include the 1919 "Caballito" peso, the rare 1927 "Indian Head" 50 pesos, and the 1921 20 pesos "Aztec Calendar" coin.

Mexican coins have a rich history and cultural significance, reflecting the country's struggle for independence and combining art and enduring value. They offer something for every collector, from colonial "pieces of eight" to stunning gold coins of the 20th century.

When it comes to investing in Mexican coins, it is important to consider their historical and cultural value, as well as their rarity and condition. Building a collection can be a rewarding pursuit, offering a connection to Mexico's rich numismatic heritage.

Gold and silver coins: bullion value and investment potential

Mexican coins are a great addition to any collection due to their rich history and cultural value. The country's numismatic heritage dates back to the 16th century, when the first mint in the Americas was established in Mexico City. Over the centuries, Mexican coins have featured intricate designs and high gold and silver purity, making them a good investment choice for collectors and investors worldwide.

Bullion Value

The bullion value of a coin is determined by its precious metal content. Mexican gold and silver coins have relatively high bullion value due to their high purity. The Mexican 50 Peso Gold Coin, for instance, is made of .90 pure gold, while the Mexican Gold Libertad Coin boasts an even higher purity of .999. The silver coins also have high bullion value, with the Mexican Silver Libertad containing .999 fine silver.

Investment Potential

Mexican gold and silver coins have strong investment potential due to their historical significance, limited mintage, and increasing popularity among collectors and investors. Here are some key factors to consider:

• Historical Significance: Mexican coins have a long and fascinating history, with some dating back to the country's War of Independence in the 19th century. These coins often feature iconic symbols such as the eagle and the liberty cap, reflecting Mexico's rich cultural heritage.
• Rarity and Collectability: Ancient Mexican coins are typically hard to find, making them highly sought-after by collectors. Some coins, such as the 1812 Guadalajara 8 escudos, are extremely rare, with only a few known examples existing today.
• Design and Aesthetics: Mexican coins are renowned for their intricate designs and beautiful artwork. The Mexican Gold Libertad, for instance, features an exquisite depiction of Libertad, the feminine personification of liberty, on its obverse. The reverse showcases Mexico's coat of arms, with a detailed portrait of an eagle gripping a snake.
• Popularity and Demand: Mexican coins have gained international recognition, with investors and collectors embracing the country's multiple bullion coin programs. The Mexican Libertad coins, in particular, have become increasingly popular in recent years, offering beautiful designs at affordable prices.
• Diversification: Mexican gold and silver coins provide an excellent opportunity for investors to diversify their portfolios. The numismatic value of these coins can help protect against market downturns, as their collectability and historical significance contribute to their overall value.

In conclusion, Mexican gold and silver coins offer a unique combination of bullion value, historical significance, and aesthetic appeal. With their high purity, limited mintage, and increasing popularity, these coins make a strong investment choice for those looking to diversify their precious metals portfolios while also appreciating the rich cultural heritage that Mexican coinage represents.

Rare coins: factors influencing value and demand

The value of rare coins is influenced by several factors, including age, condition, rarity, historical significance, and market demand.

One of the most important factors is the age of the coin; generally, the older the coin, the more valuable it is. This is because older coins are rarer, as fewer of them remain in existence. For example, the 1538 Mexico 8 Reales, one of the earliest coins minted in the Americas, sold for a record-breaking $528,000 at auction in 2016.

The condition of a coin also plays a crucial role in its value. Collectors seek out rare coins in the best possible condition, making coins with minimal wear, scratches, and other imperfections more desirable. Grading systems are used to standardise the assessment of a coin's condition, with higher grades indicating superior condition and, therefore, higher value.

Rarity is another key determinant of a coin's value. The rarer a coin, the higher its value tends to be. Rarity is determined by the mintage (the number of coins produced) and the surviving population (the number of coins still in existence). For instance, the 1811 Zitacuaro 8 Reales is highly valued due to its rarity, with only three known examples existing.

Historical significance can also increase a coin's value. Coins associated with important events, famous figures, or unique designs often command higher prices. For example, the 1823 Republic of Mexico 8 Escudo Type II coin, minted just two years after Mexico gained independence from Spain, is highly sought after by collectors.

Market demand is a significant factor influencing coin values. High demand for a particular coin can drive up its price, while low demand can have the opposite effect. Demand can be influenced by factors such as limited supply, new discoveries, or changes in the economy. For instance, the gold content and historic value of Mexican gold pesos make them popular among investors.

Other factors that can affect the value of rare coins include the supply or availability of the coins and the precious metal content, especially for older coins made from gold, silver, or platinum. Errors and unique varieties on coins can also increase their value, as they are highly sought after by collectors.

Overall, the value of rare coins is determined by a combination of factors, including age, condition, rarity, historical significance, and market demand. These factors work together to shape the value and desirability of rare coins among collectors and investors.

Coin grading: understanding quality and condition

Coin grading is a way of determining the physical condition of a coin. The process is both an art and a science, and the grade given to a coin is based on factors such as the strength of its strike, wear, contact marks, and eye appeal. The higher the grade, the more valuable the coin.

The Sheldon Grading Scale, developed by Dr William H Sheldon in 1949, is the industry standard for coin grading. The scale runs from 1 to 70, with 1 being the lowest grade and 70 being a perfect, flawless coin. The lower the number, the more heavily worn the coin. On a Poor 1 (PO-1) coin, for example, the type and date are discernible, but not much else. You will typically be able to see the outlines of major devices, but no detail and little to no lettering.

The lowest grade where the design really starts to become visible is Good 4 (G-4). Most of the lettering is visible, though not all, or it may be very hard to make out. Coins from G-4 through Very Good 10 (VG-10) show quite a range in terms of how much detail is visible, but all are heavily circulated and clearly spent a lot of time in use.

Starting at Fine 12 (F-12), the lettering and digits should all be clear and crisp. All the way up through Very Fine 35 (VF-35), circulation wear is still easily visible on high points with the naked eye. This wear will be visible down to recessed areas at F-12, but only noticeable on high points by VF-35.

Extremely Fine 40 and 45 (EF-40 or XF-40) is the lowest grade where you might not notice any circulation wear at a glance. However, under close inspection, minor wear on the high points will be visible, and with practice, it becomes easier to spot. Traces of original mint luster may remain in areas protected by design elements.

Almost Uncirculated 50, 53, 55, and 58 (AU) coins are generally desirable and attractive. These coins will display very little wear, usually discernible only by minor softness or colour difference on the highest points of the design. They should show some original mint luster and can easily be mistaken for uncirculated specimens by the untrained eye. AU-58 coins, in particular, are typically very well-struck and appealing pieces that often come with a premium due to their inclusion in "everyman sets", which are entirely made up of coins graded AU-58 or below.

No numbers are skipped between 60 and 70, and all of these grades are considered Mint State (MS). This is because uncirculated coins tend to be in greater demand by advanced numismatists. Minute differences in contact marks can translate into huge price differences. These are coins that show no evidence of circulation wear and look the same as when they were first minted. The differences within Mint State grades are determined by the quality of the strike, luster, severity and location of contact marks, and, most importantly, the general eye appeal of the piece. An MS-60 coin is usually rather unattractive, often accompanied by numerous bag marks and a very weak strike. An MS-70 is nearly impossible to find among older coins, and only modern issues tend to attain this grade.

Coins that have been properly stored since the day they were minted are called "uncirculated" or "mint state". If a coin saw circulation for a short time but still looks nearly brand new, it is called "about uncirculated".

The most respected third-party grading services are the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) and the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS). Before grading a coin, both services first authenticate it to ensure it has not been cleaned, altered, or tampered with. Professional grading is a team effort, with at least two highly trained graders examining every coin.

Coin collecting: storage, preservation and display

Coin collecting is a rewarding pursuit, but it's important to know how to store, preserve and display your collection properly to maintain its value. Here are some tips for collectors:

Storage

• Specialise: Focus on a particular period, denomination or style that appeals to you. This will help you become an expert in your niche and avoid overspending.
• Set a budget: Mexican coins can range from a few dollars to hundreds of thousands. Set realistic goals and stick to them.
• Protect your coins: Store your collection in inert plastic holders, paper envelopes or albums and keep them in a dry, temperate environment. Handle coins over a soft surface and by their edges to avoid damage.

Preservation

• Study: Learn as much as you can about the coins you collect. Join collector clubs, read books and forums, and attend shows to gain knowledge and connections.
• Use reliable dealers: Look for reputable sellers, ideally specialists in Mexican coins. Check feedback and return policies, and don't be afraid to ask for more information or photos.
• Focus on quality: Buy coins that have been authenticated and graded by respected third-party services. Be wary of cleaned, polished or damaged coins unless they are priced accordingly.

Display

• Network: Join groups on social media or attend local coin club meetings to meet fellow collectors. Numismatists love to share knowledge, and you may even find great deals through collector networks.
• Enjoy the hunt: Collecting is not just about the coins themselves but also the thrill of the chase. Be patient, stay focused, and remember that building a great collection takes time.

Coin collecting is a fascinating hobby that combines art, history and value. By following these tips and staying dedicated to your collection, you can create a rewarding and valuable collection.

Frequently asked questions