Government Workers: Cryptocurrency Investment Opportunities And Challenges

Government employees face many restrictions when it comes to investing outside their line of employment. In India, government employees can invest in the stock market, but there are guidelines and best practices to follow. For instance, they should avoid any conflict of interest and not use insider information or engage in insider trading. There are also rules regarding how much they can invest, and they must disclose their cryptocurrency holdings. However, the rules are not always clear, and there is ambiguity around the frequency of purchase and sale. In terms of cryptocurrency, this is a grey area, and while it is not deemed illegal, it is also not considered legal cash or coins. So, can government employees invest in cryptocurrency?

Indian government employees can invest in cryptocurrency

Indian government employees face many restrictions when investing in assets outside their line of employment. This includes investing in the stock market, real estate, or any other assets of large valuation.

According to the Central Civil Service Rule 16 (Conduct Rules) of 1964, Indian government employees are prohibited from speculating on "any stock, share, or other investment". However, this rule does not apply to occasional investments made through authorised stockbrokers or persons with a certificate of registration under the relevant law.

Currently, cryptocurrency falls into a legal grey area in India. The Crypto Bill, which was supposed to be introduced in 2021, has been delayed twice. As of 2022, there are no official rules, regulations, or guidelines for settling disputes involving cryptocurrencies in India. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) does not recognise Bitcoin or any other cryptocurrency as legal tender for purchasing goods and services. However, the RBI is planning to launch its own digital coin, the CBDC (Central Bank Digital Coin), which will be backed by the government.

Despite the lack of clear regulations, some sources suggest that Indian government employees are not allowed to invest in any cryptocurrency or other assets such as the stock market during working hours. They are also required to report any investments and their income to the Income-tax department.

However, other sources interpret the existing laws more leniently. According to these sources, government employees can invest in cryptocurrencies as long as they do so occasionally through authorised crypto exchanges. Additionally, they must disclose their cryptocurrency holdings and comply with relevant RBI and government notifications.

In summary, while Indian government employees do face restrictions on their investments, the exact rules regarding cryptocurrency investments are unclear and seem to be a matter of interpretation. Indian government employees should carefully consider the existing laws and regulations and seek legal advice before investing in cryptocurrencies.

It is not considered legal cash or coins

In India, government employees are allowed to invest in cryptocurrencies, but the government does not consider them legal cash or coins. This means that while Indian government employees can invest in cryptocurrencies, they cannot use them for transactions. If a government employee were to carry out a transaction using cryptocurrency, they would not be able to take any legal action in the event of an issue.

The Indian government's stance on cryptocurrency is that it is not recognised as a legal tender for purchasing goods and services. This is because the government wants to prevent it from being used to finance illegal activities or as part of the payment system. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is planning to launch its own digital coin, the CBDC (Central Bank Digital Coin), which will be backed by blockchain technology and the government.

The Central Civil Service (Conduct) Rules of 1964 state that government employees are prohibited from speculating in any stock, share, or other investment. However, occasional investments made through authorised channels are permitted. This means that frequent investments for short-term gains are considered speculation and are not allowed. As cryptocurrency is a grey area in the law, government employees can invest through crypto exchanges, which follow KYC criteria and channel transactions through the banking system.

While there are no specific laws or regulations prohibiting Indian government employees from investing in the stock market, they must adhere to certain guidelines and best practices. These include being mindful of conflicts of interest, ethical considerations, and investing within the limits set by their employer.

Employees must disclose their cryptocurrency holdings

In India, government employees are guided by the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964, which prohibit them from investing in any assets or stocks. Rule 16 of the CCS CCA (Conduct Rules) states that no government employee can speculate in any stocks, shares, or other investments. However, occasional investments made through authorised channels are allowed.

Cryptocurrency is a grey area in this law, and while it is not officially recognised as a legal tender, it is also not prohibited. As a result, government employees in India are advised to disclose their cryptocurrency holdings to remain compliant with the Office Memorandum dated 07.02.2019. This requires employees to send an intimation if their total transactions of movable property, including crypto investments, exceed six months' basic pay during the calendar year.

In the United States, the Office of Government Ethics (OGE) has issued guidance that federal employees must disclose their holdings of virtual currency. This affects around 2 million federal executive branch employees. The OGE considers cryptocurrency to be "property held for investment or the production of income" rather than a "real" currency. Employees must report their holdings if the value exceeds $1,000 or if the income produced exceeds $200 during the reporting period.

The OGE's guidance is a response to the surge in use and access to virtual currencies, as well as the increasing number of government employees seeking guidance on their financial disclosure reporting obligations. The OGE has also noted that other regulatory agencies may issue additional findings or guidance as the nature of virtual currency becomes better defined.

No trading during work hours

Government employees are subject to a variety of restrictions when it comes to investing and trading, including cryptocurrency. While the rules vary by country and are constantly evolving, one consistent guideline is that government employees are not permitted to trade during work hours. This restriction applies to all investments, including cryptocurrency, and is in place to prevent the misuse of authority and maintain a clear separation between official duties and personal financial pursuits.

The Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964, specifically Rule-16, outlines the regulations for government employees in India. This rule states that government servants must not speculate in any stock, share, or investment that could lead to short-term gains. While cryptocurrency falls into a grey area legally, the intent of this rule is clear: government employees should not engage in frequent trading or investing that could distract from their official responsibilities.

The law further emphasises that investment activities should not interfere with the job duties of government employees. As such, investing or trading in cryptocurrency during work hours is strictly prohibited. This ensures that employees remain focused on their assigned tasks and do not allow their personal financial interests to influence their decision-making or performance in their government roles.

It is worth noting that the consequences of minor violations of these rules may not immediately result in penalties. Typically, a written warning is issued to the employee, providing an opportunity to correct their behaviour before any disciplinary action is taken. However, repeated or serious breaches of these regulations can have more severe repercussions, and employees are encouraged to seek clarification from the appropriate authorities if needed.

In summary, while government employees may have the opportunity to invest in cryptocurrency, they must do so outside of work hours. This restriction is in place to maintain the integrity of their roles and prevent any potential conflicts of interest. By adhering to these guidelines, government employees can participate in the cryptocurrency market while still fulfilling their professional responsibilities and upholding the standards expected of their positions.

Employees can delegate family members to maintain investments/portfolio

Government employees face a lot of restrictions when it comes to investing in assets outside their line of employment. In this regard, the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964, Rule 16, states that:

> "No Government servant shall speculate in any stock, share, or other investment: Provided that nothing in this sub-rule shall apply to occasional investments made through stockbrokers or other persons duly authorized and licensed or who have obtained a certificate of registration under the relevant law."

This means that government employees are not allowed to trade or invest in stocks, shares, or other assets like cryptocurrency during working hours. The code of conduct for government employees is designed to prevent the misuse of authority and prohibits them from engaging in any activity that could be considered a conflict of interest.

However, the rules do not specifically prohibit government employees from investing in cryptocurrencies through crypto exchanges. Crypto is currently in a legal grey area, and regulatory authority in this area is still needed. As such, crypto exchanges are the preferred and safest mode to invest in cryptocurrencies for government employees.

Now, turning to the specific question of whether government employees can delegate family members to maintain their investments or portfolio, the answer is yes, but with certain conditions. Section 16 (2) (i) of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964, states:

> "No Government servant shall make, or permit any member of his family or any person acting on his behalf to make, any investment which is likely to embarrass or influence him in the discharge of his official duties. For this purpose, any purchase of shares out of the quotas reserved for Directors of Companies or their friends and associates shall be deemed to be an investment which is likely to embarrass the Government servant."

This means that government employees can delegate family members to manage their investments as long as those investments do not conflict with their official duties. If the employee can explain and prove that the investment does not affect their ability to perform their duties, they are allowed to invest through family members. It is important to note that any investment activity should not impact a government employee's job responsibilities.

In terms of the amount that a government employee can invest, there is no specified limit. However, it is advisable for employees to disclose their cryptocurrency holdings and comply with the Office Memorandum dated 07.02.2019. According to this memorandum, employees must send an intimation if their total transactions in movable property (including cryptocurrencies) exceed six months' basic pay during a calendar year. This intimation must be sent by January 31st of each year.

In summary, while government employees face restrictions on investing and trading, they can invest in cryptocurrencies through crypto exchanges and delegate family members to manage their investments, provided that those investments do not conflict with their official duties.

Frequently asked questions