Should You Invest Your Pension In Bitcoin?

Investing pension funds into bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies is a highly contested issue. While some people argue that pension funds should not be used to invest in volatile, poorly regulated assets, others highlight that pension funds have historically dabbled in many non-traditional investments, which have since become core holdings. In the UK, you can invest your pension in bitcoin through a Bitcoin Exchange-Traded Note (ETN) or a Small Self-Administered Scheme (SSAS). However, it is important to carefully assess the risks and ensure you are fully informed before investing your pension funds into bitcoin or any other cryptocurrency.

Pension funds burned by crypto investments

Investing pension funds in cryptocurrencies like bitcoin is a highly debated topic. While some argue that it could be a lucrative opportunity, others warn of the high risks and volatility associated with these unregulated investments.

In recent years, several pension funds have made losses due to investments in cryptocurrencies and related companies. For instance, Canada's largest pension fund, CPP Investment (CPPI), managed to avoid losses by steering clear of crypto investments, while two other major Canadian pension funds suffered significant setbacks. Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan Board had to write off its $95 million investment in the crypto exchange FTX, and Caisse de Depot et Placement du Quebec wrote down its $150 million investment in the crypto lender Celsius Network.

In the US, state pension funds have also been eyeing crypto investments, encouraged by industry lobbyists who tout the potential for sky-high profits. However, critics argue that these investments could expose retirees' savings to significant risks and volatility. The collapse of the crypto giant FTX in 2022 highlighted the dangers, as at least 15 US public pension funds with 36 retirement systems appeared to have indirect exposure to the failed company. While the losses did not affect their ability to pay benefits, it served as a warning to pension funds about the risks of embracing digital assets too aggressively.

Despite the potential for high rewards, investing pension funds in cryptocurrencies carries significant risks. The unregulated nature of the market, the volatility of crypto assets, and the potential for fraud and theft are all factors that pension funds must carefully consider before making any investment decisions. As a result, pension funds that have invested in cryptocurrencies have faced scrutiny and criticism for taking on such high-risk ventures with other people's money.

In conclusion, while the potential rewards of investing pension funds in cryptocurrencies like bitcoin may be enticing, the risks and volatility of this unregulated market have burned several pension funds in the past. Therefore, pension funds considering crypto investments must exercise extreme caution and carefully assess the potential risks and rewards to avoid losses that could impact retirees' savings.

The pros and cons of investing your pension in bitcoin

Investing in Bitcoin for retirement is a natural choice for many fans of cryptocurrency. They believe in its long-term potential and are willing to take on the substantial risks of holding BTC over the long term.

A Bitcoin IRA can provide you with the tax advantages of traditional and Roth IRAs, but there are additional IRS rules and regulations to navigate.

Pros

Diversification: Cryptocurrency is not correlated with stocks and bonds, which is what most Americans hold in their retirement accounts. This may help protect your retirement balance, even though crypto prices can be quite volatile.

Potential returns: While Bitcoin is very volatile, it also offers the potential for huge gains.

Tax advantages: Buying and selling crypto in a self-directed IRA alleviates the burden of capital gains taxes as you aren't taxed as long as the money and assets remain in your account. You also benefit from the compounding growth of value.

No limitations: Because cryptocurrency investments are unregulated, you won't be subject to any limitations on your investments.

Cons

Unregulated: The most glaring con of investing in cryptocurrencies is that they are unregulated and will likely remain so. This lack of regulation means your financial interests are at risk.

Volatility: Cryptocurrency investing is notoriously volatile. Holding crypto assets should be reserved for people who are comfortable with risk and who can afford to take the lows with the highs.

Risk: There are numerous elements of risk to consider when investing in cryptocurrency, including technology risks, liquidity risks, volatility risks, and counterparty risks.

Additional fees: Self-directed IRAs typically come with several additional fees, including set-up fees, transaction fees, and annual account management fees.

Complexity: Investing in Bitcoin for retirement adds a layer of complexity to your retirement planning. You will need to have at least one other account for the balance of your retirement investments.

The risks of investing in bitcoin

Investing in bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies is risky due to the market's volatility and lack of regulation. The price of bitcoin fluctuates constantly, and there is no way to predict whether investors will get a return on their investment. The market is also prone to cyberattacks and fraud, with many buyers losing their investments on exchanges and through mining losses.

The lack of regulation in the bitcoin market means that investors are not protected by financial authorities. Cryptocurrency is not widely accepted as a currency, and it is not taxed, which could lead to problems if it were to become competition for government currency. The lack of taxation may also be a concern for investors, as it could indicate a lack of legitimacy in the eyes of financial authorities.

Another risk of investing in bitcoin is the potential for block withholding. This is where a mining pool uses computational power to mine a block and hide it from honest miners, rather than reporting the new block to the network. This allows a select few to benefit while others lose out.

The decentralised status of cryptocurrency also poses a risk to investors. Cryptocurrencies are not backed by a central authority, which means that investors may be left without recourse if complications with transactions or ownership arise. The lack of a central authority also means that there is no standard practice for recovering missing funds if a cryptocurrency exchange is hacked and customers' holdings are stolen.

Finally, the newness of cryptocurrency technology means that there is no guarantee that it will develop into a solid, stable investment. The market is constantly evolving, and there is no way to predict how it will change in the future.

How to buy bitcoin with a pension fund

Investing pension funds in Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies is a highly risky and complex endeavour. Before proceeding, it is important to understand the volatile nature of the cryptocurrency market and the regulatory considerations involved.

Firstly, it is worth noting that pension trustees and financial advisors often consider cryptocurrencies too risky for pension investments due to their high volatility and lack of regulatory oversight. However, if you are a trustee managing your own pension, you have more flexibility in deciding the investment strategy and risk appetite.

One option for investing pension funds into Bitcoin is through a Small Self-Administered Scheme (SSAS). A SSAS is a type of pension set up by an employer for a limited number of individuals, typically key owners or managers of the business. SSAS rules allow members of the pension scheme to act as trustees and make investment decisions, including investing in cryptocurrencies. To set up a SSAS, you need an active company or business, a minimum of £50,000 in pension funds or transfer, or an intention to make pension contributions of at least £25,000. There are also professional fees and ongoing costs associated with establishing and maintaining a SSAS.

Another option is to use a Self-Invested Personal Pension (SIPP). A SIPP allows individuals to hold a wide range of investments, including stocks, shares, and commercial property. Cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin can be held in a SIPP through a Bitcoin Exchange-Traded Note (ETN), which tracks the performance of your crypto investments. It is important to note that investing in cryptocurrencies through a SIPP is very risky due to the lack of regulatory oversight and the volatile nature of the market.

Before investing pension funds into Bitcoin, it is crucial to carefully consider the risks involved and ensure you are fully informed about the investment process and associated fees, rules, and regulations. Additionally, it is essential to seek professional investment advice and ensure that any investment decisions are made in accordance with your fiduciary duties and the best financial interests of the pension members.

Lastly, it is worth noting that the regulatory landscape for cryptocurrencies is evolving, and pension funds must carefully assess the risks and rewards of investing in crypto assets.

Crypto regulatory clarity

The regulatory landscape for cryptocurrencies is complex and constantly evolving. While some countries, like El Salvador, have embraced Bitcoin as legal tender, others are still grappling with how to classify and regulate these digital assets.

In the United States, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Department of Justice (DOJ) have taken a proactive approach, pursuing enforcement actions and lawsuits against crypto platforms and exchanges, including Nexo, Binance, Coinbase, and Gemini. These actions indicate that regulators believe the current regulatory framework is sufficient to address crypto-related crimes. However, the industry has been calling for "regulatory clarity," seeking more transparent guidelines for crypto-related products and services.

The lack of clear regulations has led to concerns about the risks associated with crypto investments, especially for pension funds. While some pension funds have started exploring crypto investments, others remain cautious due to market volatility, regulatory uncertainty, and reputational concerns. The recent collapses of major crypto entities like Celsius and FTX have further highlighted the need for thorough due diligence before investing in this space.

To address these concerns, lawmakers and industry experts have been advocating for regulatory clarity. Congressman Tom Emmer introduced the Blockchain Regulatory Certainty Act (BCRA), which aims to provide clarity by distinguishing between blockchain developers and service providers that do and do not custody consumer funds. This bill recognises the unique nature of blockchain technology and seeks to encourage innovation while providing necessary consumer protections.

Additionally, there is a growing consensus that the current federal framework in the US, such as the 1933 Securities Act, is inadequate for the dynamic nature of crypto and blockchain technology. As a result, crypto developers face challenges in offering their tokens as payment options, as they may be deemed a security risk. This highlights the need for regulations that are specifically tailored to the nuances of the crypto industry, providing a balanced approach that encourages innovation while mitigating risks.

As the crypto industry continues to evolve, regulatory clarity will be crucial in providing a stable environment for investors, innovators, and consumers. A well-defined regulatory framework will help pension funds make more informed decisions about crypto investments, ensuring they are fully aware of the risks and potential rewards.

Frequently asked questions