Military Personnel: Bitcoin Investment Opportunities

Bitcoin is a digital currency that is 100% virtual and computer-based. It is decentralized, meaning that no bank or government controls it, and it is anonymous and completely global. The Defense Security Service (DSS) has been ambiguous about how Bitcoin will be viewed during a security clearance investigation. While there is currently no requirement to report bitcoin ownership, the DSS has stated that guidance will be provided in the future. The U.S. Marine Corps has prohibited the use of cryptocurrency mining applications on government mobile devices, citing privacy and security concerns. Cryptocurrency is favored by cybercriminals for its anonymity and ease of use, and there are concerns that service members could use government resources for their personal gain by mining cryptocurrency. As such, the impact of bitcoin and cryptocurrency on security clearance is a topic of discussion, with some arguing that it is only a matter of time before the military places restrictions on it.

Security Clearance and Bitcoin

Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are a grey area when it comes to security clearances. While the Defense Security Service (DSS) has not issued any specific guidance on reporting Bitcoin holdings, it has stated that it is working with relevant authorities to provide clarification on the matter. In the meantime, security clearance holders are not required to disclose their Bitcoin investments, but this may change in the future.

Financial Concerns

Financial issues are the leading cause of security clearance denial, and applicants should carefully consider how their investments could impact their clearance and career. While a small investment in Bitcoin is unlikely to be an issue, cashing in substantial assets or retirement funds to invest in Bitcoin could raise questions about an applicant's reliability and trustworthiness, especially if it appears they are avoiding the traditional U.S. banking system.

Foreign Influence

The decentralised nature of Bitcoin and its potential for anonymity raises concerns about foreign influence or preference. "Bitcoin-rich" individuals may be asked about their foreign financial interests and partnerships, which could impact the "Foreign Influence" and "Foreign Preference" criteria considered during the security clearance process.

Criminal Conduct

The privacy afforded by Bitcoin and the ease of conducting transactions without government or bank oversight is appealing to those seeking to hide their financial dealings from authorities, including terrorists, drug dealers, and other illicit agents. As a result, individuals investing in Bitcoin may inadvertently contribute to criminal activity, potentially violating the "Criminal Conduct" guideline.

Use of Information Technology

Using a work-related device for Bitcoin transactions is a major offence and would call into question an individual's appropriate "Use of Information Technology."

Reporting Requirements

While reporting requirements for Bitcoin are currently unclear, the government may inquire about any cryptocurrency investments as part of the security clearance process. It is essential to understand the source and movement of your investments and to avoid investing more than you can afford to lose.

Bitcoin's Volatility

Bitcoin is considered a volatile asset. Volatility is a measure of how much the price of a financial asset varies over time. The volatility of Bitcoin is measured by how much its price fluctuates relative to the average price in a given period.

Volatility is usually associated with risk, but it can be either "good" or "bad". Bitcoin has historically exhibited high volatility but has provided investors with disproportionately positive returns. This is evident in its Sharpe ratio of 0.96 from 2020 to early 2024, indicating that investors have been more than compensated for the risk.

Bitcoin's low volatility in 2023 was accompanied by a rise in its market capitalisation, indicating that the drop in volatility was not due to a lack of interest. This could point to a growing belief that Bitcoin is maturing as an asset class.

While Bitcoin is volatile, it is less so than many mega-cap stocks, and its volatility is expected to continue declining as it matures.

Bitcoin's Anonymity

Bitcoin was once believed to be the crypto-anarchist holy grail: truly private digital cash for the internet. However, this is not entirely true.

Bitcoin transactions are recorded on a blockchain, which is visible to all. While the identities behind the payments are obscured by pseudonymous addresses, this level of anonymity can be compromised. For example, if any of the addresses in a transaction can be tied to an actual identity, it may be possible to deduce who owns the other addresses. Additionally, the use of multiple addresses by a single entity can be deduced through patterns in transaction data.

In 2013, a young mathematician named Sarah Meiklejohn demonstrated that Bitcoin transactions could be traced and users identified with even more transparency than the existing financial system. Meiklejohn's work upended the world of cybercrime, leading to the arrest of hundreds of criminals worldwide and some of the biggest law enforcement monetary seizures in the history of the US Justice Department.

While Bitcoin can support strong privacy, many ways of using it are not very private. However, with a proper understanding of the technology, it can be used in a very private and anonymous way.

Bitcoin's Legality

The legality of Bitcoin varies from one jurisdiction to another. While some states have explicitly allowed its use and trade, others have banned or restricted it.

In the United States, the Defense Security Service (DSS) has been ambiguous about how Bitcoin will be viewed during a security clearance investigation. The DSS previously advised security clearance holders to report their Bitcoin investments as an asset in their security clearance application, likely due to the possibility of foreign influence or preference. However, the DSS later clarified that there is no requirement to report Bitcoin ownership, but guidance will be provided in the future.

Bitcoin has been classified differently by various government agencies, departments, and courts. The U.S. Treasury, for example, classified Bitcoin as a convertible decentralized virtual currency in 2013, while the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) classified it as a commodity in 2015. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) taxes Bitcoin as a property.

It is worth noting that financial issues are the leading cause of security clearance denial, so military personnel or veterans seeking to maintain their security clearance should carefully consider how any investments could impact their clearance status. While some investment in Bitcoin is unlikely to be an issue, cashing in a 401(k) to invest heavily in Bitcoin could raise questions about an individual's reliability and trustworthiness.

In other parts of the world, the legal status of Bitcoin also varies. For example, El Salvador passed the Bitcoin Law in 2021, making Bitcoin legal tender in the country. On the other hand, China has taken a restrictive approach, with the People's Bank of China prohibiting financial institutions from handling Bitcoin transactions and effectively banning cryptocurrency exchanges and trading platforms.

The legality of Bitcoin is a complex and evolving issue, and it is important to stay informed about the regulations in your specific jurisdiction.

Bitcoin's Tax Implications

Bitcoins Tax Implications

The IRS treats Bitcoin and other "convertible virtual currencies" as property, specifically a capital asset, rather than a currency. This means that there are tax consequences whenever bitcoin is bought, sold, or traded. The tax treatment of Bitcoin is similar to that of owning and trading stocks or exchange-traded funds (ETFs), which can trigger capital gains taxes.

The tax implications of Bitcoin depend on how and when you acquired it. If you sell Bitcoin for a profit, you are taxed on the difference between your purchase price and the sale proceeds. This includes not just selling Bitcoin for cash but also exchanging it for another cryptocurrency or using it to pay for goods or services.

If you acquired Bitcoin through mining or as payment for goods or services, that value is taxable immediately as earned income. If you dispose of or use Bitcoin by cashing it on an exchange, buying goods or services, or trading it for another cryptocurrency, you will owe taxes if the realised value is greater than the acquisition price. This may result in a capital gain taxable at either short-term or long-term rates.

The tax rate on Bitcoin gains depends on two factors: how long you owned the Bitcoin before selling, and your total income for the year. If you owned the Bitcoin for one year or less before selling, the short-term capital gains tax rates of 10% to 37% apply. If you owned the Bitcoin for more than a year, the long-term capital gains tax rates of 0% to 20% apply.

To ensure compliance, the IRS has added a question about crypto activity to tax return forms. Additionally, crypto exchanges are required to issue a Form 1099-K to clients with more than 200 transactions and over $20,000 in trading during the year.

It is important to keep detailed records of your Bitcoin transactions to accurately report gains and losses. This includes maintaining records of the fair market value of your Bitcoin when you acquired and disposed of it.

If you fail to report Bitcoin transactions, you may face penalties, interest charges, and enforcement actions from the IRS.

Frequently asked questions