Vanguard And Bitcoin: Exploring Investment Opportunities

Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies have become increasingly popular in recent years, with many people investing in them. However, Vanguard, a well-known investment company, has stated that it does not plan to create a Bitcoin fund or offer crypto-related products on its brokerage platform. This decision is based on Vanguard's belief that cryptocurrencies are highly speculative and lack underlying economic value, making them unsuitable for long-term investment portfolios. While Vanguard acknowledges the impact of cryptocurrencies in the investing world, the company chooses to focus on its investing philosophy of long-term, low-cost, and conservative strategies. As such, investors looking to add Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies to their Vanguard portfolios may be disappointed, but there are other investment options available within the company that offer similar risk and reward profiles.

Vanguard's stance on Bitcoin

Vanguard has made it clear that it does not plan to create a Bitcoin fund or offer crypto-related investment products on its brokerage platform. Tim Buckley, the CEO of Vanguard, stated in 2018 that "You will never see a fund from Vanguard on bitcoin." This stance is based on the belief that Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies lack underlying economic value and are highly speculative investments. Buckley compared Bitcoin to gold, another asset class that Vanguard avoids due to its lack of fundamental value.

Vanguard's investing philosophy emphasizes long-term investing and tuning out short-term trends. The company believes that cryptocurrencies are highly volatile and do not have a place in long-term portfolios. Vanguard also considers crypto to be a speculative investment rather than a true commodity. The company acknowledges the potential of blockchain technology but maintains that crypto is an immature asset class with little history, no inherent economic value, no cash flow, and the potential to create havoc within a portfolio.

While Vanguard does not offer direct investment in Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies, it does have exposure to the crypto industry through its ETFs and other funds. For example, the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI) and the Vanguard Extended Market ETF (VXF) have allocations to Riot Blockchain, a crypto mining company. Additionally, Vanguard uses Symbiont's blockchain technology for foreign exchanges, demonstrating its involvement in the crypto atmosphere.

In summary, Vanguard's stance on Bitcoin is that it is a highly speculative and volatile investment that lacks underlying economic value. The company does not plan to offer crypto-related investment products, including a Bitcoin fund, due to its investing philosophy and commitment to meeting the long-term needs of its investors. However, Vanguard recognizes the impact of cryptocurrencies in the investing world and will continue to monitor their development.

Bitcoin's value and volatility

Bitcoins Value and Volatility

Bitcoin's value is derived from its scarcity, as it is generated through a digital process called "mining". However, its value is highly volatile, making it a risky investment. Bitcoin's price is influenced by supply and demand, investor and user sentiments, government regulations, and media hype.

Volatility Analysis

Bitcoin's price volatility is almost 10 times higher than the volatility of major exchange rates (US dollar against the euro and the yen). This excess volatility hinders Bitcoin's potential role in investment portfolios and as a currency. The high volatility of Bitcoin prices makes it difficult to use as a medium of exchange and a unit of account.

Factors Affecting Volatility

• Supply and Demand: The limited supply of Bitcoin and increasing demand influence its market value.
• Investor Actions: Bitcoin whales, or investors with large holdings, can impact the market value by liquidating their positions.
• Media and Influencers: News, media outlets, influencers, and industry moguls can create investor concerns or hype, leading to price fluctuations.
• Government Regulations: Government agency views and regulations on cryptocurrency can significantly impact Bitcoin's price. For example, China's ban on cryptocurrency transactions in 2021 affected Bitcoin's price.
• Speculation: As Bitcoin is still in its infancy, its price is influenced by speculation about future developments.

Store of Value

Despite its short-term volatility, Bitcoin can be considered a store of value over the long term due to its deflationary design and limited supply. The long-term price trend of Bitcoin has been positive, and it has shown store-of-value characteristics over long horizons.

Comparison with Other Assets

Bitcoin's volatility is higher compared to gold and other major currencies. The volatility of gold averages around 1.2%, while other major currencies average between 0.5% and 1.0%.

Risk Considerations

The high volatility of Bitcoin means that it is a risky investment. On any given day, its value can fluctuate substantially. This risk has led Vanguard CEO Tim Buckley to state that Vanguard will never offer a Bitcoin fund, as they tend to stay away from assets that don't have underlying economic value.

Vanguard's investment philosophy

Vanguard has been investor-owned since its founding in 1975, and its interests have always aligned with those of its investors. Vanguard's investment philosophy is centred on a client-first ethos, focusing on what's in the best interest of its clients over time. Vanguard's investment management approach is one of unwavering focus on its clients' success, and it uses proven methods and principles to fuel the performance of truly enduring investments.

Vanguard's Principles for Investing Success are based on four pillars of investing that represent an enduring philosophy centred on giving investors the best chance for financial success. These principles are:

• Create clear, appropriate investment goals: Investors should have explicit investment goals that help them turn their aspirations into reality. Both savings (the amount invested initially and over time) and investment returns play crucial roles in achieving any investment goal.
• Keep a balanced and diversified mix of investments: By diversifying investments across stocks, bonds, sectors, and countries, investors can reduce overall portfolio volatility and guard against large losses. A well-diversified portfolio that matches an investor's level of comfort with market ups and downs is crucial.
• Minimize costs: Taxes and investment costs, such as expense ratios, transaction costs, and sales charges, can cut into investment returns. Lower-cost investments have been shown to outperform higher-cost alternatives, improving investors' chances for success.
• Maintain perspective and long-term discipline: Discipline in investing refers to the ability to adhere to an investment plan over time. Reacting to market volatility can jeopardize returns, so it's important to stick to one's plan and understand one's goals.

Crypto's impact on Vanguard ETFs

Vanguard has made it clear that it will not be offering a Bitcoin fund or any crypto-related products, including ETFs, due to the speculative nature of cryptocurrencies. This decision is in line with Vanguard's conservative investing philosophy, which focuses on long-term, low-cost investments with underlying economic value.

Vanguard's leadership, including CEO Tim Buckley, has expressed the view that Bitcoin lacks fundamental economic value and is too volatile for their investment approach. They believe it does not belong in a long-term portfolio, especially for investors saving for retirement. Buckley has compared Bitcoin to gold, another asset class that Vanguard avoids due to its lack of underlying value.

Instead of offering direct exposure to cryptocurrencies, Vanguard offers alternative investment options, such as the Vanguard Information Technology ETF (VGT), which provides exposure to the volatile tech industry while reducing risk through diversification. This ETF has generated substantial returns, outperforming the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF, which tracks the broader market.

While Vanguard does not plan to offer crypto-related products, it acknowledges the impact of cryptocurrencies in the investing world and recognises the potential of blockchain technology. The company continues to monitor the development of cryptocurrencies and may reconsider its stance if the asset class evolves to meet their investment criteria.

In summary, Vanguard's stance on cryptocurrencies has impacted the availability of crypto-related ETFs, with the company prioritising its conservative investing philosophy and the long-term interests of its clients over the short-term trends and volatility associated with cryptocurrencies.

Vanguard's crypto alternatives

Vanguard does not offer crypto-related products on its brokerage platform, including Bitcoin ETFs. The company's leaders, Janel Jackson and Andrew Kadjeski, have stated that they do not believe cryptocurrencies have an appropriate role to play in long-term portfolios. They consider crypto to be more of a speculation than an investment due to its volatility and lack of inherent economic value.

However, if you are looking for Vanguard crypto alternatives, there are several options to choose from. Here are some of the best alternatives to Vanguard in the market:

• Interactive Brokers: This is an international broker that provides access to all asset classes. It has been recommended for traders looking for broad market access and a professional trading environment.
• EToro: eToro is a global social trading broker that allows for social trading (i.e. copying other investors' trades) and zero-commission stock trading. It is recommended for traders interested in social trading and a user-friendly platform.
• Fidelity: This is a US stockbroker that offers solid research and great trading platforms. It is recommended for investors and traders looking for comprehensive research tools and a wide range of products.
• Zacks Trade: A US discount broker that provides comprehensive research tools, a wide product selection, and low fees. Recommended for traders and investors seeking these features.
• Charles Schwab: A US discount broker with solid research, low fees, and great customer service. Recommended for investors and traders seeking an easy-to-use platform.
• Webull: Another US discount broker with zero-commission trading and a focus on the US market. Recommended for investors looking for a simple platform.
• SoFi Invest: A US discount broker with zero-commission trading, focusing on the US market. SoFi Invest is recommended for beginners and investors with a buy-and-hold strategy.
• Alpaca Trading: A US API broker for traders interested in algorithmic stock trading.
• Robinhood: A US zero-fee discount broker for beginners and buy-and-hold investors focusing on the US stock market.
• Merrill Edge: A US discount broker with low fees, quick account opening, and simple platforms. Recommended for investors seeking a straightforward platform.

Additionally, if you are specifically interested in Bitcoin investments, you may want to consider the Vanguard Information Technology ETF (VGT). While it is not a direct investment in Bitcoin, it is considered a high-risk, high-reward investment that has experienced substantial gains and can be a good alternative for those seeking significant returns with slightly less risk than Bitcoin.

Frequently asked questions