The Lucrative Side Of Investment Banking: Buy Or Sell?

The investment banking industry is a complicated ecosystem of interdependent entities, each with unique functions. At the core of this ecosystem is the notion of the buy side and the sell side, which entails the main tasks and objectives of market participants. The buy side refers to the side that buys and invests large portions of securities for the purpose of money or fund management. The sell side, on the other hand, deals with the creation, promotion, and selling of traded securities to the public.

Buy-side firms typically raise money from institutions and wealthy individuals and invest on their behalf, profiting from management fees, performance fees, or both. Examples include private equity firms, hedge funds, and venture capital firms. Sell-side firms, on the other hand, earn money from commissions charged to facilitate deals and to sell, market, and trade equity, debt, and other securities. The best example of a sell-side firm is an investment bank.

While it is generally safe to assume that you can make more on the buy side, it is important to note that the compensation structure varies depending on the specific job, performance, and seniority.

Buy-side vs sell-side compensation

Buy-side and sell-side compensation structures differ, with buy-side performers having performance-based compensation and sell-side performers having fee-based structures. Buy-side jobs typically require more experience, and professionals often ""graduate"" from sell-side to buy-side roles.

Buy-side jobs have a performance bonus element, which can lead to significant upside potential income if investments perform well. For example, in private equity, there is a carried interest, and in hedge funds, there is the 2-and-20 structure. Sell-side jobs also have performance bonuses, which can be based on both personal performance and the performance of the firm.

It is generally assumed that one can make more on the buy-side, but a high-performing investment banker on the sell-side can also earn massive amounts of money.

Buy-side firms typically structure their remuneration as a base salary and annual bonus. The bonus is usually linked to the performance of their stocks. However, total compensation depends on various factors such as the size of the firm, seniority, and business performance.

Sell-side roles usually have a bonus dependent on clients' trading activity, revenue generated through the execution of recommendations, the performance of stocks on "watch lists", individual performance, and overall business performance.

In terms of working hours, buy-side firms like hedge funds and private equity firms often require long hours, with some cases of up to 80 hours per week. On the other hand, sell-side firms usually offer a better work-life balance, with a typical workweek of around 50 hours.

Buy-Side vs Sell-Side: A Recap

The buy-side of investment banking involves finding potential investments, often by working with private equity firms to find companies that may be looking for funding or to be purchased. The sell-side involves representing a company looking for an investor, often to spur future business growth or merge with a larger business.

Buy-side firms include mutual funds, pension funds, hedge funds, and private equity funds. Sell-side firms include investment banks, brokerage firms, and advisory firms.

Investment horizon

Buy-side firms focus on long-term investments, aiming to outperform the market and achieve capital growth. Their investment horizon is usually long-term, spanning several years. This approach allows them to explore investment opportunities that may require more time and are less concerned with short-term profits.

On the other hand, sell-side organisations implement a short-term benefit strategy and market-making activities. They are more focused on immediate gains and facilitating transactions for their clients.

The buy-side's long-term perspective enables them to capitalise on investment opportunities that may require a longer timeframe. This strategy contrasts the sell-side's emphasis on shorter-term returns.

In terms of client base, buy-side firms typically serve investor groups such as pension funds and endowments, while sell-side firms target retail investors and corporations.

The differences in investment horizons and client bases result in distinct roles and responsibilities for each side. The buy-side refers to investment and asset management firms, making investment decisions on behalf of their clients. In contrast, the sell-side covers transactional activities, research, and advisory services, helping companies raise capital and facilitating trades.

Client base

The client base served by buy-side and sell-side firms differs significantly. Buy-side firms typically serve institutional investors, including pension funds, mutual funds, hedge funds, and private equity funds. These firms manage the money of high-net-worth individuals, family offices, banks, insurance companies, and endowments.

On the other hand, sell-side firms target retail investors and corporations. They work with companies to help them raise capital by issuing and selling securities. Sell-side firms include investment banks, advisory firms, and corporations.

Buy-side firms focus on long-term investment strategies and are less sales-oriented, while sell-side firms are more focused on short-term transactions and have a broader client base.

Roles and responsibilities

Buy-Side Investment Bankers

Buy-side investment bankers work for firms that manage money, such as hedge funds, pension funds, mutual funds, insurance companies, and private equity groups. They are responsible for making profitable investment recommendations for their funds and are compensated based on the accuracy of their recommendations.

Buy-side investment bankers have a vested interest in the performance of their investments and tend to be more cautious and risk-averse. They are responsible for identifying promising prospects, analyzing financial statements, meeting with company management, and building financial models to forecast future performance. They then advise portfolio managers on whether to buy, hold, or sell specific securities.

Buy-side investment bankers also conduct in-depth research on securities, sectors, and markets to help their firms make better investment decisions. They generally cover more areas and sectors than their sell-side counterparts.

Sell-Side Investment Bankers

Sell-side investment bankers work for investment banks, brokerages, advisory firms, and corporations that sell financial products. They help companies raise capital by issuing, selling, or trading securities to investors, such as mutual funds, hedge funds, insurance companies, endowments, and pension funds.

Sell-side investment bankers have several key functions, including:

• Advising corporate clients on transactions, mergers and acquisitions, and capital raising
• Facilitating the buying and selling of securities in the secondary market
• Providing research and insights to support the capital-raising process and sales
• Equity capital markets: Guiding corporations through the process of raising equity capital
• Debt capital markets: Similar to equity capital markets but focused on debt capital
• Sales and trading: Contacting investors and selling securities, as well as facilitating trades in the secondary market

Sell-side investment bankers are often paid based on the quality of their research, the revenue it generates, and the performance of the firm. They tend to have more salesmanship in their roles and are responsible for building relationships and winning new business.

Performance-based vs fee-based structures

Investment banking is a complicated ecosystem of interdependent entities, each with unique functions. At the core of this ecosystem are the notions of the buy side and the sell side, which entail the main tasks and aims of market participants.

The buy side and the sell side differ in terms of compensation structures. The buy side has performance-based compensation, whereas the sell side can have fee-based structures.

Performance-based Structures

Buy-side jobs typically require more experience, and professionals often ""graduate"" from sell-side to buy-side roles. Buy-side jobs have a performance bonus element, which can lead to significant upside potential income if investments perform well. This performance bonus can be a carried interest in private equity or the 2-and-20 structure in hedge funds.

A performance fee is a payment made to an investment manager for generating positive returns. This is in contrast to a management fee, which is charged without regard to returns. A performance fee is usually calculated as a percentage of investment profits, both realised and unrealised. Performance fees are largely a feature of the hedge fund industry, where they have made many fund managers among the wealthiest people in the world.

Fee-based Structures

Sell-side jobs also have performance bonuses, which can be based on both personal performance and the performance of the firm. Sell-side firms earn their fees through fees and commissions. Their main goal is to make as many deals as possible.

A fee-based investment is a product that is recommended by a financial planner whose compensation includes a percentage of assets under management (AUM) rather than a commission from clients. This may be in addition to an hourly rate and other flat fees or performance-based fees. Fee-based investments can be offered by investment companies, banks, or other financial institutions.

A fee-based advisor typically charges clients a fee but may also receive commissions from sponsoring companies for recommending specific investment products.

Frequently asked questions