Shark Tank: Payback Time?

Shark Tank is a reality TV show where entrepreneurs pitch their business ideas to a panel of investors, or sharks, who then decide whether to invest their own money in the venture. The show has been running since 2009 and has inspired similar programmes worldwide.

The sharks on Shark Tank typically require a stake in the business in return for their investment. However, the investments are not without risk, and there is no guarantee that a shark will get their money back or make a profit. Many Shark Tank deals go bust, and the sharks only invest if they believe they can turn a profit.

Shark Tank investments are not guaranteed to be profitable

Shark Tank deals can go bust. There are several reasons why this might happen. For example, the business may have trouble fulfilling orders, or the product may be faulty. There is also the risk of conflict between founders, which can lead to lawsuits and restraining orders. Additionally, the business model or product may simply be flawed.

The sharks are not guaranteed to make their money back or turn a profit. However, they can recoup their investment if the company is acquired or goes public and they can sell their shares. They can also make money through royalty deals or dividends.

The failure rate of Shark Tank participants is around 6%, which is much lower than the estimated 70% business failure rate. However, only about 20% of participants are not making a profit but are still operating.

Sharks may ask for a payout clause in the deal

Shark Tank is a reality TV show where startup companies pitch their business ideas to a panel of investors, or "sharks", in the hopes of securing an investment deal. While the show is entertaining, it also provides a glimpse into the world of venture capital and angel investing, where investors are always looking for new opportunities but must also manage the inherent risks involved.

One way that investors on Shark Tank mitigate their risk is by asking for a payout clause in the deal. This means that they include a clause in the investment contract that allows them to receive a payout or royalty from the company's revenue, even if the company isn't profitable. This is often structured as a percentage of the owner's salary or payout relative to the investor's ownership stake. For example, a shark might say, "I want $X every time you pay yourselves." This ensures that if the company's founder or owner pays themselves a salary, they also have to pay the shark according to the terms of the deal.

The payout clause serves as a form of protection for the investor, especially in cases where the company might not be generating profits or could have volatile cash flows. By tying their payout to the owner's salary, investors can ensure they receive some return on their investment, even if the company isn't performing as expected. This type of clause is not uncommon in the world of celebrity endorsement deals, where the investor's association with the company brings increased visibility and sales.

However, it's important to note that including a payout clause in a deal also has its drawbacks. Some critics argue that recouping investments as royalties from the company's revenue essentially turns the equity investment into a loan, which can hurt the company's cash flow. Additionally, it may be seen as an onerous term for the entrepreneur, especially if the investor is seeking a large percentage of revenue as royalty. As such, it's crucial for entrepreneurs to carefully consider the deal structure and potential impact on their business before agreeing to any investment terms.

Entrepreneurs may not pay themselves right away, instead investing all the money back into the business

Entrepreneurs going on Shark Tank may not pay themselves right away and instead invest all the money back into their business. This is because the deals they make with the Sharks on the show may be structured in a way that requires them to pay the Sharks whenever they take a salary for themselves.

Shark Tank deals can be risky for both the entrepreneur and the investor, as there is no guarantee that the business will be profitable or that the investment will be recouped. Many Shark Tank deals go bust, and it is common for startups to take years before turning a profit or breaking even. Therefore, entrepreneurs may choose to reinvest any profits back into their business rather than paying themselves a salary, to avoid having to pay the Sharks.

Additionally, entrepreneurs need to acquire new skills and continually ask themselves tough questions about their goals and strategies to build a self-sustaining company. This may involve investing in organisational infrastructure, acquiring reliable sources of capital, and hiring the best people to shape a culture that suits the venture's strategy.

Furthermore, investors are aware of the risks associated with startup investments and should only invest money they can afford to lose. Entrepreneurs should not feel guilty about losing investor money, as the risks are well-known, and investors choose to take them. Instead, entrepreneurs should focus on putting in their best effort and learning from their failures.

Shark Tank deals can go bust

Shark Tank is a popular reality TV show where entrepreneurs pitch their business ideas to a panel of investors. While the show has led to many success stories, not all deals work out. Here are some examples of Shark Tank deals that went bust:

Toygaroo

Toygaroo, a toy subscription company billed as the "Netflix of toys", secured a $200,000 investment from the show's investors. However, they fell victim to their own success, as the company grew too big, too fast. They struggled with high costs and low stock, eventually filing for bankruptcy.

ShowNo Towels

ShowNo Towels, a poncho-towel combo invented by Shelly Ehler, secured an investment from Lori Greiner on the show. However, the relationship between Ehler and Greiner soured quickly, as Greiner tried to change the terms of the deal. The business eventually shut down, although Ehler revived it later, targeting a different market.

Sweet Ballz

Sweet Ballz, a dessert company, struck a $250,000 investment deal with Mark Cuban and Barbara Corcoran. However, the founders soon fell out, with James McDonald suing his partner Cole Egger over a competing product. The conflict caused a missed opportunity, and the business never recovered, now only running as a side gig.

Body Jac

Body Jac, an exercise machine, received a $180,000 investment from Kevin Harrington and Barbara Corcoran. However, the business failed to take off, and the website shut down in 2012. Corcoran has since called it her "worst business deal".

CATEapp

CATEapp, a privacy app, raised $70,000 from Kevin O'Leary and Daymond John. However, the app failed to gain traction and went offline a few years later.

Breathometer

Breathometer, a portable breathalyzer, received a $1 million investment from all five sharks. However, they struggled to fulfil orders, and the device was found to give inaccurate results. The Federal Trade Commission ordered the company to refund customers and cease sales.

You Smell Soap

You Smell Soap, a luxury soap brand, agreed to a handshake deal with Robert Herjavec on the show. However, Herjavec went silent for six months, and when he did respond, he offered adjusted terms that the founder refused. The business eventually shut down after being bought out by another investor.

HyConn

HyConn, a fire hose connector, almost received a $1.25 million investment from Mark Cuban, but the deal fell through when Cuban tried to change the terms, wanting to license the product to other companies. The founder was pushed out, and the product never went into production.

Foot Fairy

Foot Fairy, an iPad app for measuring children's foot sizes, received a $100,000 investment from Mark Cuban. However, the app was buggy and failed to capture commission payments, leading to the business shutting down within six months.

Biem

Biem, a kitchen utensil for spraying butter, struck a deal with Lori Greiner on the show, but it fell through after a failed Kickstarter campaign and numerous complaints about faulty and undelivered products. The company is now effectively shut down.

Sharks may ask entrepreneurs if they're taking a salary

Sharks on ABC's Shark Tank are investors who acquire ownership stakes in companies for a sum of money. They do not get paid from a business they invest in that isn't profitable. However, some sharks, like Kevin, make deals that say "I want $X every time you pay yourselves." This means that entrepreneurs may not pay themselves right away and invest all the money back into the business. But if they take a salary for themselves, they then have to pay the shark too if the deal was structured that way.

Barbara, another shark on the show, puts a clause in her deals that gets her a payout. Any salary or payout that the owner gets, she gets too relative to her ownership stake.

If the founder controls the company and gives themselves a salary from the company, they're "short-circuiting" the money and bypassing the shark. The shark as an owner would only get payment via a distribution. If the founder pays themselves a large sum of money and then says to the shark "I didn't earn a profit this year, sorry!" the shark will notice and it'd probably be lawsuit time at that point.

Frequently asked questions