Multiple Buyers: Boon Or Bane For Loans?

When it comes to taking out a loan, there are several factors to consider, including the number of buyers or borrowers involved. In general, having multiple buyers can have both advantages and disadvantages. On the one hand, multiple buyers can increase the chances of securing a loan and may result in a more competitive interest rate. Additionally, sharing the financial burden can make homeownership more accessible. However, it is important to consider the financial strength of each buyer, as a poor credit score or high debt-to-income ratio from one buyer can negatively impact the group's qualification. While applying to multiple lenders can provide benefits such as the ability to compare rates and fees, it can also lead to multiple credit inquiries, potentially impacting the credit score of the buyers.

Multiple buyers can improve loan qualification

Additionally, having multiple buyers can provide access to a larger down payment, which can result in lower interest rates and monthly mortgage payments. This shared financial burden makes homeownership more accessible to those who may not be able to afford it alone. For example, friends or unmarried couples can consider co-buying a home, allowing them to purchase a more substantial property or live in an area they might not have been able to afford individually.

Furthermore, multiple buyers can benefit from claiming mortgage interest on their taxes. While the total amount of interest must be split among the co-buyers, this can still provide tax advantages for all involved. It's important to note that lenders will consider the financial situation of all applicants, so a weak application from one buyer can negatively impact the group's chances of qualification. Therefore, it is crucial to carefully consider the financial situation and commitment of all potential co-buyers before applying for a joint loan.

Lenders will consider all applicants' finances

Lenders will also consider the relationship between the applicants and how they plan to manage the home. It is recommended that co-buyers set expectations upfront and enlist the aid of a real estate attorney to draft a side agreement that indicates who is responsible for what.

Additionally, it is important to note that applying for a loan with multiple lenders can impact the credit score of the applicants due to multiple credit inquiries. However, this impact is typically small and temporary, and there are ways to mitigate this, such as comparing rates and fees before applying and limiting the number of applications.

Overall, while having multiple buyers can improve the chances of securing a loan, it is crucial to carefully consider the financial situation and relationship of all applicants to ensure a smooth process and maintain a good credit score.

Multiple credit checks can lower credit scores

Multiple credit checks can impact your credit score negatively, but the effect is usually minimal. A single hard inquiry, which occurs when you allow a lender to scrutinize your credit report, will drop your score by no more than five points, and often, no points are subtracted. However, multiple hard inquiries can deplete your score by as much as 10 points each time.

It is important to note that soft inquiries, which are done without your permission, are harmless and will go unnoticed. On the other hand, hard inquiries can leave a mark on your credit report, especially if you are rapidly applying for credit in a short time span. Lenders and credit-scoring models view multiple credit applications in a short amount of time as a sign of risk.

FICO's research shows that opening several credit accounts in a short period of time represents a greater credit risk. People with six or more recent hard inquiries are eight times more likely to file for bankruptcy than those with none. However, inquiries play a minor part in your FICO score, contributing only 10%. More important factors are how timely you pay your bills and your overall debt burden.

To avoid the negative impact of multiple hard inquiries, it is recommended to spread out your credit applications. Additionally, when you request a preapproval for a mortgage, multiple inquiries from different lenders within a 45-day period are counted as a single inquiry, allowing you to shop around for the best rates without significantly affecting your credit score.

Co-buyers can include family, friends, and unmarried partners

There are no lending rules against purchasing a home with someone who is not your spouse or family. Co-buyers can include siblings, parents with children, unmarried partners, friends, and more. For example, an adult child buying with their parent or step-parent, or co-ownership with a fiancé(e), boyfriend, girlfriend, or partner. Two individuals can also co-own an investment property together.

When buying a home with a friend or unmarried partner, it is important to decide how you will own the property, or "take title". This decision has huge and lasting consequences, particularly on estate planning issues. For example, if one partner is the sole owner of the property, they could grant a life estate to the other partner, giving them full use of the property until their death, after which the home would pass to the heir. Alternatively, if both partners want equal ownership of the property, they can become "joint tenants with right of survivorship" (JTWROS). However, this could create estate tax problems if only one person has contributed to the purchase. In this case, "tenants in common" might be a better option, as it results in unequal property ownership.

It is important to be aware of the risks involved in putting a jointly owned house in one person's name. If your partner is the sole owner and sells the house, you could be left without a say or any of the money. Similarly, if they die, they may leave the property to someone else. While you can sue for your financial interest in the property, these lawsuits are often expensive and difficult to win.

While co-borrowing can make it easier to qualify for a loan, it is important to consider the financial situation of all borrowers before applying. Lenders will look at both parties' financial strengths and weaknesses, and a poor credit score or high debt could hurt the other borrower's chances of qualifying.

Having multiple buyers can make it harder to sell the property

While having multiple buyers can increase the chances of securing a loan and getting a competitive interest rate, it can also make it harder to sell the property. This is because each co-borrower is on the hook for repaying the mortgage loan, and they all have an ownership stake in the property.

If one owner wants to sell the home, they will need to buy out the portions of the other owners or request that they refinance the loan without them. This can be a difficult process, especially if the co-borrowers have unequal financial strengths and weaknesses. For example, if one co-borrower has a great credit score and the other has a poor credit score, lenders will factor the poor credit score into the equation, potentially reducing the amount they can collectively afford.

Additionally, if one co-borrower has a high debt load, it can count against all borrowers' combined debt-to-income ratio, making it harder to qualify for a loan. It is important for all co-borrowers to be on board and willing to keep up with the financial commitments to avoid disagreements and legal issues down the road.

To mitigate these issues, experts suggest creating and signing a legal contract, with the help of an attorney, that stipulates what happens if one or more owner/borrower parties want to sell the home. It is also important to consider each co-borrower's full financial picture and how they will responsibly manage the home before entering into a joint mortgage.

Frequently asked questions