Scotland's Debt To The Uk: Understanding The Financial Relationship

Scotland's financial relationship with the UK is a complex one, with the Scottish Government possessing the power to borrow and lend money, but also being subject to certain limitations. The Scotland Act 1998 and subsequent amendments outline the parameters within which Scottish Ministers can borrow and lend, with the UK Government playing a role in facilitating these transactions. The Scottish Government's borrowing and lending activities impact areas such as public services, schools, hospitals, roads, and infrastructure, while also influencing the economy and job opportunities in Scotland. Understanding the intricacies of Scotland's financial autonomy and its interplay with the UK Government is essential for evaluating the overall financial health and stability of both Scotland and the United Kingdom as a whole.

Scottish Ministers can borrow from the Secretary of State for Scotland

The Scottish Ministers currently have no powers to raise extra finances by borrowing or sanctioning borrowing. They can, however, borrow money from the Secretary of State for Scotland, as per Section 66 of the Scotland Act 1998. This borrowing is only to meet temporary cash shortfalls or to provide a working balance in the Scottish Consolidated Fund (SCF).

The Secretary of State for Scotland is a secretary of state in the Government of the United Kingdom, with responsibility for the Scotland Office. The incumbent is a member of the Cabinet of the United Kingdom and serves as the custodian of the Scottish devolution settlement as outlined in the Scotland Act 1998. The Secretary represents Scottish interests within the UK Government and advocates for UK Government policies in Scotland.

Section 67 of the Scotland Act enables HM Treasury to issue sums as loans to the Secretary of State from the National Loans Fund (NLF) to, in turn, loan to Scottish Ministers. Repayments from Scottish Ministers to the Secretary of State are a charge on the SCF and are not subject to authorisation by the Parliament.

The Scottish Ministers can also borrow from other sources under powers conferred by separate Acts of the UK Parliament. They possess specific and general powers to lend money, but any lending should be out of resources authorised by the Parliament by Budget Act and subject to the existence of specific statutory authority.

The Scottish Government's borrowing limit was increased in 2024-25, with the resource borrowing limit rising from £1.75 billion to £1.78 billion, and the capital borrowing limit increasing from £3 billion to £3.05 billion. This enables the Scottish Government to invest in key areas such as schools, hospitals, roads, and other infrastructure projects.

Scottish Ministers can lend money, but only from resources authorised by Parliament

Scottish Ministers have no powers to raise extra resources by borrowing or sanctioning borrowing. They may borrow sums from the Secretary of State for Scotland, but only to meet temporary cash shortfalls or to provide a working balance in the Scottish Consolidated Fund (SCF). This power is granted by Section 66 of the Scotland Act 1998. Additionally, Scottish Ministers may borrow money under powers conferred by separate Acts of the UK Parliament.

Section 67 of the Scotland Act enables HM Treasury to issue sums as loans to the Secretary of State from the National Loans Fund (NLF) to facilitate lending to Scottish Ministers. Repayments from Scottish Ministers to the Secretary of State are charged to the SCF and are not subject to authorisation by Parliament.

Scottish Ministers possess specific and general powers to lend money. However, any lending should be from resources authorised by Parliament through a Budget Act and typically requires specific statutory authority. When deciding on loan terms and conditions, Scottish Ministers should agree on an appropriate interest rate with the relevant SG Finance Business Partner. The loan period for new fixed-rate loans generally should not exceed 25 years, although the SG Finance Directorate may consider proposals for up to 50 years on a case-by-case basis.

The Scotland Act 2016 removed the UK Government's role in funding political parties, leaving Scottish Ministers solely responsible for submitting draft orders to Her Majesty. The Scottish Parliament Assistance for Political Parties Bill further transferred responsibility for setting the terms of funding for Opposition parties from Scottish Ministers to the Parliament.

Scottish Ministers can borrow from the National Loans Fund

The Scottish Ministers' ability to lend money is subject to specific and general powers. While they can lend money, it must be from resources authorised by the Parliament through a Budget Act and typically requires specific statutory authority. When deciding on lending, Scottish Ministers must exercise due diligence and consider the borrower's financial standing and ability to meet loan terms. This includes assessing the financial impact on the Scottish Government's budget.

The Scottish Public Finance Manual (SPFM) provides guidance on borrowing, lending, and investment for Scottish Ministers and the Scottish Administration. It outlines the circumstances under which sponsored bodies can borrow and lend money, emphasising the need for terms and conditions to be specified in the body's framework document. The SPFM also addresses interest rates, loan periods, and the repayment of loan principal for loans made by Scottish Ministers.

In terms of local government borrowing, Scottish Ministers play a role in consenting to local authority borrowing. While the Local Authority (Capital Finance and Accounting) Regulations 2016 do not specify the source of borrowing for local authorities, the majority of their borrowing is from the Public Works Loans Board (PWLB), which lends from the National Loans Fund. Scottish Ministers support schemes where local authorities borrow to lend to third parties for initiatives like the National Housing Trust, aiming to increase affordable housing supply.

Additionally, the Scottish Government has been considering its borrowing policies and options for bond issuance to access diverse and cost-effective capital funding. With changing borrowing limits, the dynamics of Scottish Government borrowing have evolved, and the government recognises the importance of attracting capital investment to support its transition to net zero.

Scottish Government borrowing powers have been increased by the UK Government

The Scottish Government's borrowing powers have been increased by the UK Government. This move will see the Scottish Government's resource borrowing limit increase from £1.75 billion to £1.78 billion, and the capital borrowing limit rise from £3 billion to £3.05 billion. This change will allow for more investment in schools, hospitals, and infrastructure, supporting economic growth and creating opportunities across Scotland.

The Scottish Government's borrowing powers were previously limited to £450 million per year within a £3 billion cap, as well as receiving a Barnett-based share of UK Government borrowing. Now, these amounts will rise with inflation, providing greater fiscal flexibility and certainty for the Scottish Government to manage their budget. This decision is in line with the UK Government's commitment to devolution and aims to deliver for the people of Scotland through collaboration between the two governments.

The increased borrowing powers will enable the Scottish Government to undertake capital borrowing of up to £3 billion and resource borrowing of up to £1.75 billion. This additional funding will be crucial in supporting public services and vital projects in Scotland. The Scottish Government can now better manage income fluctuations and fund capital expenditures, ensuring a more stable financial environment for the region.

The UK Government's decision to increase the Scottish Government's borrowing powers is a significant step towards empowering devolved administrations and promoting economic growth in Scotland. By providing greater flexibility in budget management, the Scottish Government can now address their financial needs more effectively and plan for future investments and opportunities for their citizens. This collaborative effort showcases the benefits of devolution and the potential for further progress when both governments work together.

Scottish students can get a loan to cover tuition fees and living costs

SAAS also offers a part-time fee waiver to help pay for tuition fees for students studying in Scotland. This does not need to be paid back. The maximum amount SAAS will pay is £1,805 a year, and students must be studying less than 120 credits a year to be eligible.

SAAS also provides loans to cover living costs, also known as a maintenance loan. This is means-tested, with parents expected to fill any shortfall. Students do not need to pay this back until after they leave university and are earning enough.

If a Scottish student chooses to study elsewhere in the UK, they will still receive funding from SAAS and will be on the Scottish Plan 4 system for repayments. However, they will need to take out a larger loan to cover tuition fees, which can be up to £9,250 a year. This will not increase monthly repayments but will mean that students will have to make them for longer.

Scottish students studying at private institutions may need to pay higher fees, as SAAS will only contribute £1,205 towards tuition fees at private universities.

Frequently asked questions