Vanguard's Crypto Investment Plans: What You Need To Know

Vanguard Group Inc. has sparked controversy in the crypto world by refusing to offer Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) on its trading platform. The company has also removed all crypto products from its platform, including futures-backed Bitcoin funds. This decision goes against the trend of other investment firms, which have jumped at the opportunity to offer their clients access to Bitcoin funds. While some have criticised Vanguard's move, the company maintains that it is acting in the best interests of its investors, as it considers crypto to be a speculative asset rather than a long-term investment.

Vanguard's stance on Bitcoin ETFs

Vanguard has made clear that it has no plans to offer a bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) or any other cryptocurrency-related products. Nor will it allow any such products from other firms to be offered via its brokerage arm.

Janel Jackson, Vanguard's global head of ETF Capital Markets and Broker and Index Relations, explained that crypto is more of a speculation than an investment. She also said that it is an immature asset class with little history, no inherent economic value, no cash flow, and can create havoc within a portfolio.

Andrew Kadjeski, head of Brokerage & Investments for Vanguard’s Personal Investor business, added that Vanguard is purposely structured to meet the needs of its investor-owners, most of whom are long-term, buy-and-hold investors. He also noted that the extreme volatility of bitcoin makes it unsuitable for Vanguard's products and services, which are designed to help investors save more, trade less, and take a long-term approach.

Vanguard's decision to refuse Bitcoin ETFs has angered some investors, with "#BoycottVanguard" trending on social media. However, industry experts believe that it is highly unlikely that the boycott will make a dent in Vanguard's business.

The company's philosophy on crypto

Vanguard's philosophy on crypto is clear: the company does not offer any crypto-related products and does not plan to launch its own crypto fund or exchange-traded fund (ETF). This decision is in line with the company's conservative investing approach, which focuses on investing in stocks and bonds that generate cash flow, dividends, and interest payments. Vanguard's late founder, John Clifton "Jack" Bogle, advised people to “avoid Bitcoin like the plague,” and the company continues to adhere to his investment principles.

Vanguard's stance on cryptocurrencies is based on its belief that they are highly volatile and speculative assets that do not have long-term investment merit. The company's global head of ETF Capital Markets, Janel Jackson, has stated that crypto is "more of a speculation than an investment" and that it is an immature asset class with little history, no inherent economic value, no cash flow, and can create havoc within a portfolio. Vanguard prioritises the interests of its clients, who are mostly long-term, buy-and-hold investors, and believes that cryptocurrencies do not meet their needs.

While Vanguard does not offer crypto-related products, it recognises the impact that cryptocurrencies are making in the investing world. The company acknowledges the underlying blockchain technology and its potential applications beyond cryptocurrencies. Vanguard is actively involved in research to utilise blockchain technology to make capital markets more efficient.

Vanguard's decision to stay away from crypto has drawn criticism from some investors and has even sparked a #BoycottVanguard movement on social media. However, the company remains steadfast in its philosophy, prioritising the long-term interests of its clients over short-term trends.

Vanguard's conservative approach to investing has been a key factor in its success, and the company continues to attract a loyal base of investors who appreciate its commitment to putting clients' interests first.

Crypto's speculative nature

The speculative nature of cryptocurrencies has been a topic of discussion and concern for many. Tim Berners-Lee, the inventor of the World Wide Web, has called crypto "dangerous" due to its highly speculative nature, comparing it to gambling and the dot-com bubble of the late 1990s and early 2000s.

Vanguard, one of the top investment firms, has also expressed a similar sentiment, advising its clients to steer clear of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. Janel Jackson, the firm's global head of ETF Capital Markets, stated that "crypto is more of a speculation than an investment."

This view is supported by the fact that crypto has little history, no inherent economic value, no cash flow, and can create havoc within an investment portfolio. The extreme volatility of cryptocurrencies further adds to their speculative nature, with double-digit price drops being common.

A study by Jiri Kukacka and Ladislav Kristoufek published in the journal 'Financial Innovation' in 2023 examined the pricing dynamics of five crypto assets: Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, XRP, and Dogecoin. The study found that the price dynamics of these crypto assets, except for Dogecoin, were influenced by both fundamental and speculative components, including episodes of price bifurcations.

The speculative component was driven by investor attention and off-chain activity, while the fundamental component was driven by on-chain activity and economic factors. The study also found that crypto markets are not detached from traditional financial markets, as both sides of the pricing system are influenced by stock market dynamics.

In conclusion, the speculative nature of cryptocurrencies is a significant concern for investors and financial experts. The extreme volatility and lack of inherent value make cryptocurrencies a risky investment, and their price dynamics are influenced by a complex interplay of fundamental and speculative factors.

Crypto's risk-reward ratio

As one of the world's largest investment management firms, Vanguard's views on any asset class are significant. Vanguard has been vocal about its stance on cryptocurrencies, advising its clients to steer clear of them. The firm has stated that it has no plans to offer a bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) or any other cryptocurrency-related products, and it will not allow such products from other firms to be offered through its brokerage services. This decision is based on Vanguard's view that cryptocurrencies are more speculative than investment assets.

The risk-reward ratio is a valuable tool for crypto traders to make informed decisions about potential trades. It measures the expected return of an investment relative to the amount of risk assumed. Crypto investors can use this ratio to increase their profitability by setting strategic stop losses and take-profit orders. The ratio is calculated by dividing the potential return by the amount of risk involved, and it can be expressed as a percentage or a ratio.

For example, if an investor is considering two investments with identical expected returns but different risk levels, they would prefer the investment with the lower risk. However, if one investment has a higher expected return and a higher level of risk, the investor would likely choose the investment with the higher expected return.

In crypto trading, the risk-reward ratio helps traders minimize risk and maximize profitability. It is calculated using the entry price, stop losses, and take-profit orders. The ideal risk-reward ratio varies from trader to trader, but most traders seek trades with a ratio of at least 1:2, meaning they expect to earn at least twice what they risk. Some traders may accept higher risk for the potential of greater returns, targeting a ratio of 1:3 or higher.

It is important to remember that the risk-reward ratio is not the sole factor in trading decisions. Other considerations include the time frame of the trade, the overall investment strategy, and the entry and exit points. Additionally, while a high-risk-reward ratio indicates a favourable investment, it does not guarantee success.

Vanguard's stance on cryptocurrencies aligns with its history of scepticism towards speculative and trendy investments. By refusing to offer crypto-related products, Vanguard prioritises the long-term interests of its clients, who are primarily retail investors with a buy-and-hold strategy.

In summary, Vanguard, a leading investment firm, rejects cryptocurrencies due to their speculative nature and potential harm to retail investors' portfolios. Crypto traders can utilise the risk-reward ratio to make more informed decisions, balancing potential returns with risk levels. This tool helps traders optimise their entry and exit points, manage risk, and increase profitability.

Crypto's lack of regulation

Vanguard, one of the top investment firms, has no plans to offer a bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) or any other cryptocurrency-related products. The firm's global head of ETF Capital Markets, Janel Jackson, has stated that crypto is "more of a speculation than an investment".

The lack of regulation in the crypto market has been a cause for concern for many, including global regulators and watchdogs. The volatile nature of cryptocurrencies has been highlighted by the recent collapse of one of the largest crypto platforms, which resulted in significant losses for investors. This incident, along with the repeated cycles of boom and bust in the crypto market, has brought to light the risks associated with crypto assets that lack basic protections.

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has published two timely reports on regulating the crypto ecosystem, recommending that crypto asset service providers should be licensed, registered, and authorized. They also suggest that stablecoin issuers should be subject to strict prudential requirements to maintain monetary and financial stability. Additionally, regulatory authorities should quickly manage risks from crypto while not stifling innovation.

The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board is facing calls to regulate auditors of cryptocurrency companies, even though the majority of crypto businesses fall outside its jurisdiction. This highlights the challenges of regulating an industry that operates across multiple sectors and borders.

While Vanguard has taken a cautious approach towards cryptocurrencies, some other investment firms have started offering crypto-related products to their clients. However, it is important to note that crypto investments have often resulted in financial disasters for ordinary investors, with stories of life savings lost being all too common.

Frequently asked questions