Cryptocurrency's Esg Investment Future: Sustainable Or Risky?

The relationship between cryptocurrencies and ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) investments is a complex and evolving topic. Cryptocurrencies, such as Bitcoin, have surged in popularity and value in recent years, but they have also raised concerns about their environmental, social, and governance impact. The process of mining cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum requires significant computational power and energy consumption, leading to concerns about their carbon footprint and contribution to climate change. However, supporters of cryptocurrencies argue that they can provide financial inclusion, transparency, and accessibility, benefiting underserved communities and individuals who may not have access to traditional banking services. The decentralised nature of cryptocurrencies also presents challenges in terms of governance and regulation, as no single entity has control. As investors increasingly consider ESG factors when allocating their portfolios, the question of whether cryptocurrencies align with ESG principles remains a subject of debate and scrutiny.

Crypto's environmental impact

Cryptos Environmental Impact

Cryptocurrency has a large environmental impact. It requires energy, equipment, internet, and a global networking infrastructure to be useful. Some cryptocurrencies, such as Bitcoin, require large amounts of energy to perform crypto mining. Crypto mining is the automated process of validating transactions without the intervention of trusted third parties like banks. The way the transaction validation process is designed makes it dependent on the computational power of thousands of computers, which helps maintain the security of cryptocurrency blockchains.

The energy used for crypto mining typically comes from burning fossil fuels. According to a White House report, cryptocurrency mining accounts for 140 million metric tons of CO2 per year, or 0.3% of all global greenhouse gas emissions. This amount is greater than the emissions produced by many individual countries, including Argentina and the Netherlands. The competitive nature of blockchain mining has also been criticised for wasting resources.

Additionally, crypto mining operations can generate air, water, and noise pollution in the communities where they are located, as well as electronic waste. The computer chips used to mine cryptocurrency are made with toxic chemicals and precious metals, which require mining to produce, damaging landscapes and depleting finite resources.

However, it is important to note that not all cryptocurrencies use a system that depends on large amounts of energy to run. Some cryptocurrencies, such as Ethereum, Solana, and others, use a system that requires very little energy.

The environmental impact of cryptocurrencies has led to increased scrutiny and calls for more sustainable crypto mining practices. New companies are beginning to develop with commitments to utilize 100% green energy in their crypto mining operations. There is also a growing focus on utilizing green energy mining to reduce carbon emissions from Proof of Work model mining. The "Bitcoin Mining Council" was recently formed to standardize energy reporting and correctly track how much of bitcoin mining utilizes renewable energy sources.

Crypto's social impact

The social impact of cryptocurrencies is a highly debated topic. Cryptocurrencies can promote financial inclusion, allowing anyone with an internet connection to own and transact with them. This can be especially beneficial in developing countries where there is limited access to traditional banking services. Cryptocurrencies can also support faster and more affordable cross-border transactions, which can be crucial for people sending money to relatives in other countries.

However, it is argued that claims about the promotion of financial inclusion are illusory. The necessity of owning a smartphone and an internet connection does not help the world's poorest inhabitants. Even for those who can access cryptocurrencies, they face severe price volatility and high costs when converting to traditional currencies to purchase goods and services.

Another social concern is consumer protection. Cryptocurrencies are highly volatile and complex, making them unsuitable investments for most people. The lack of proper regulation in the industry also means that there is a high risk of fraud and misinformation.

Some also argue that the pseudo-anonymous nature of cryptocurrencies can protect vulnerable individuals from oppressive regimes. On the other hand, it can facilitate criminal activities such as tax evasion and money laundering.

Overall, while cryptocurrencies have the potential to positively impact society, there are also significant social risks and challenges that need to be addressed.

Crypto's governance

The governance aspect of ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) criteria relates to how transparent a company is, the composition of its board, and holding boards accountable for the promises they make to their shareholders. Governance also covers a company's leadership, executive pay, audits, internal controls, and shareholder rights.

Cryptocurrencies, by their nature, are decentralised, meaning there is no central party in control. However, in reality, many cryptocurrencies are centralised and have a single organisation that acts as their creator, maintainer of the network, and prime beneficiary from their sales. This raises questions about the governance of these digital assets and whether they align with ESG principles.

One of the key governance challenges with cryptocurrencies is the lack of regulation. Cryptocurrencies are not regulated in the same way as traditional financial products, and the creators of these assets often avoid being held responsible for misinformation spread to encourage sales. This lack of regulation can make it difficult to hold boards accountable for their actions and ensure they are acting in the best interests of shareholders.

Another concern is the potential for conflict of interest in the choice of board members and senior executives, as well as the use of political contributions to obtain preferential treatment. The anonymous nature of cryptocurrency transactions can also make it difficult to ensure compliance with environmental and social regulations.

However, proponents of cryptocurrencies argue that decentralisation is a form of good governance as it prevents any single entity from having too much control. Additionally, the blockchain technology that underlies cryptocurrencies provides enhanced transparency and accountability. Each transaction is recorded on a decentralised, immutable ledger, making it easy to cross-check and verify transaction details.

To improve the governance of cryptocurrencies and bring them more in line with ESG principles, there have been calls for increased regulation. The US Department of Justice, for example, has proposed rules to require banks, exchanges, and other entities dealing in cryptocurrencies to make a greater effort to identify users and track transactions.

Additionally, the formation of the "Bitcoin Mining Council" aims to standardise energy reporting and track the use of renewable energy sources in crypto mining. This move towards greater transparency and accountability in energy usage can help address environmental concerns and bring cryptocurrencies closer to ESG alignment.

In conclusion, while the decentralised nature of cryptocurrencies presents challenges for governance, there are also opportunities for enhanced transparency and accountability. Increased regulation and standardisation in the industry can further strengthen the governance of these digital assets and their alignment with ESG criteria.

Crypto's role in financial inclusion

Cryptos Role in Financial Inclusion

Cryptocurrencies have the potential to promote financial inclusion through low entry barriers, a decentralized nature, cross-border transactions, access to credit, empowering the unbanked, and as a store of value. They offer an alternative for people who lack access to traditional banking services due to financial or geographical constraints and can reduce the cost of financial transactions, making them more affordable for low-income individuals and small businesses.

Low Entry Barriers

Cryptocurrencies have easy-to-meet requirements for entry, such as a smartphone or internet access, compared to traditional banking services. This means that people who may not have access to traditional banking services due to financial or geographical constraints can still use cryptocurrencies. For example, someone in a remote area without a bank branch can use cryptocurrencies to send and receive money without traveling long distances.

Decentralized Nature

Cryptocurrencies are not controlled by any central authority or traditional financial institution, making them independent of the banking system. For instance, in countries with a history of corruption or an unreliable banking system, cryptocurrencies can be a valuable alternative for individuals to store and transfer their wealth without relying on traditional banking institutions.

Cross-Border Transactions

Cryptocurrencies can help people send money to their families living in other countries. They can also reduce the cost of financial transactions, making them more affordable for low-income individuals and small businesses. Traditional financial institutions often charge high fees for cross-border transactions, which can be a significant barrier for people living in developing countries. However, cryptocurrencies can facilitate borderless transactions with minimal costs, enabling people to send and receive money globally.

Access to Credit

In many parts of the world, traditional banking systems are inadequate or non-existent, leaving people without access to essential financial services like loans, savings accounts, and insurance. Cryptocurrencies can provide these services through decentralized applications (DApps) that operate on blockchain networks. For example, DApps like AAVE, Compound, and MakerDAO allow users to earn interest on their cryptocurrency holdings or borrow against them without needing a traditional bank account.

Empowering the Unbanked

Cryptocurrencies can give people who don't have access to banks the power to control their own money. For example, imagine a farmer in a remote village who doesn't have a bank account. With cryptocurrencies, they can store and manage their money using a digital wallet on their phone without relying on a traditional bank.

Store of Value

Cryptocurrencies can also store value for those who live in countries with high inflation rates or unstable economies. Cryptocurrencies are not tied to any government or financial institution, and their value is determined by supply and demand. This means that they can provide a stable store of value in volatile markets, allowing people to protect their savings from inflation and economic turmoil.

In conclusion, cryptos have the potential to promote financial inclusion by providing access to financial services, reducing the cost of transactions, and providing a stable store of value. However, for cryptocurrencies to reach their full potential, governments and financial institutions must work together to create a regulatory framework that ensures consumer protection, prevents money laundering, and promotes innovation. With the right policies, cryptocurrencies can play a significant role in promoting financial inclusion and creating a more equitable financial system.

Crypto's role in illegal activities

Cryptocurrencies have often been associated with criminal activity, but this is largely a myth, especially in the modern day. While it is true that cryptocurrencies serve as a financial enabler for illegal activities such as dark marketplace trading, it is a misconception that they are completely anonymous. In reality, cryptocurrencies are transferred between peers with no prior acquaintance, but the transactions are not anonymous. All transactions that occur on the blockchain are kept on a public record and are accessible to anyone for review. However, the identities of the transaction makers remain unknown, as transactions are made from one or more crypto addresses to one or more destination addresses. This means that criminals can seemingly trade drugs, weapons, explosives, and child pornography without revealing their identity. Similarly, terrorists can ask for funding and donations for extremist organizations anonymously.

Another reason why cryptocurrencies are used for illegal activities is that they are not tied to traditional financial institutions. Banks are highly regulated and must comply with specific requirements and restrictions, such as Know Your Customer (KYC) regulations. They also require identification documents and are subject to governmental sanctions, such as accounts being frozen or seized. In contrast, cryptocurrencies are digital assets that are not controlled by a central authority, which means they are always available and there is no need to validate transactions with a central body. This makes it easier for criminals to store and transfer large amounts of money without attracting the attention of thieves or authorities, and without the risk of funds being seized.

The ease of storage and transfer of cryptocurrencies also enables criminals to steal and launder funds more effectively. For example, in the largest cryptocurrency heist ever, hackers stole $600 million from the Blockchain site Poly Network by exploiting a vulnerability in its system. The stolen tokens were transferred in small amounts to an online wallet controlled by Poly Networks, eventually amounting to hundreds of millions of dollars. Cryptocurrencies also enable international trading, which, in a criminal setting, translates to trafficking.

Despite the challenges it poses for law enforcement, the transparency of blockchain technology and the active involvement of crypto exchanges are helping to combat criminal activity. Law enforcement agencies are using blockchain analytics tools to investigate illegal activity and secure convictions. In addition, crypto exchanges such as Binance are actively assisting law enforcement by sharing expertise and resources and helping to detect financial and cybercrimes.

Frequently asked questions