Consumer Reports Vs Mortgage Reports: What's The Difference?

When it comes to financial management, understanding the difference between mortgage and consumer credit scores is crucial. While checking your credit score is a good idea, it's important to note that the number you see may not be the same as the one your mortgage lender sees during your loan application. This is because consumer credit scores and mortgage credit scores are calculated differently, with mortgage scores often being lower than primary credit scores. Mortgage lenders typically use the FICO scoring model, which considers factors such as payment history, credit utilization, and credit mix, while consumer credit scores may be based on VantageScore or other models that emphasize different aspects of your credit profile.

Mortgage credit scores are calculated differently to consumer credit scores

Mortgage credit scores and consumer credit scores are calculated differently. While both scores are influenced by your payment history, there are several differences in how they are calculated.

Mortgage credit scores are calculated using a FICO score, which is a credit scoring model created by Fair Isaac and Company. This model is used by over 90% of mortgage lenders and focuses on several factors, including payment history (35%), credit utilization (30%), credit length (15%), credit mix (10%), and inquiries (10%). The FICO score ranges from 300 to 850, with 850 being the highest possible score. Mortgage lenders use this model because it is specifically designed to assess an individual's creditworthiness for mortgage loans, which often involve large sums of money and long repayment periods.

On the other hand, consumer credit scores are typically calculated using the Vantage 3.0 model. This model emphasizes different factors, such as payment history (40%), age and type of credit (21%), credit utilization (20%), balances (11%), recent credit (5%), and available credit (3%). Like the FICO score, the VantageScore also ranges from 300 to 850. Consumer credit scores are designed to provide a more general assessment of an individual's creditworthiness and are used by a variety of lenders for different types of loans, such as auto loans or credit cards.

It is important to note that both mortgage and consumer credit scores can vary depending on the specific version of the scoring model used and the credit report on which they are based. For example, FICO has multiple versions, including FICO Score 2, FICO Score 5, and FICO Score 4, each of which may weigh the factors slightly differently. Additionally, mortgage lenders often use tri-merge credit reports, which include credit information and scores from all three major credit bureaus (Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion), further contributing to the variation in scores.

Mortgage scores are harder to improve

The FICO model considers several factors to determine an individual's mortgage score. These include payment history (35%), credit utilization (30%), credit length (15%), credit mix (10%), and inquiries (10%). Payment history is the most significant factor in the FICO score, and late payments can negatively impact the score. Credit utilization is also a critical factor, as too much outstanding debt can make it challenging to secure a new mortgage.

To improve a mortgage score, individuals must focus on making timely payments and maintaining a low debt-to-income ratio. This involves paying bills on time and in full, keeping credit card balances low, and ensuring that the debt proportion remains manageable relative to their income. It is also important to review credit reports from major credit bureaus for any inaccuracies or errors that could negatively impact the score and dispute them promptly.

Additionally, when applying for a mortgage, individuals should be cautious about the number of applications they submit. Each application triggers a hard inquiry, which can slightly lower the credit score for a short period. While shopping around for the best mortgage rates is common, these multiple inquiries can collectively impact the credit score.

FICO scores are used by mortgage lenders

FICO scores are the scores most widely used by lenders, with over 90% of mortgage lenders in the United States depending on these numbers. Mortgage lenders use a unique version of your credit score, called a FICO score, to evaluate creditworthiness. This score is different from the Vantage 3.0 consumer credit score that individuals may access through services like Credit Karma.

FICO scores are calculated by the company of the same name and are used by lenders to determine a prospective borrower's creditworthiness. FICO scores come in different variations, with FICO Score 5 being the most common for mortgage lenders. This is because FICO 5 is more comprehensive, including information on employment and residential history, and is less forgiving of unpaid collection accounts. FICO 8, on the other hand, is more common for credit card issuers as it is more forgiving of one-off late payments and has a higher sensitivity to highly utilized credit cards.

When applying for a mortgage loan, the qualifying FICO score is determined by the middle score out of three versions: FICO Score 2 (Experian), FICO Score 5 (Equifax), and FICO Score 4 (TransUnion). These scores are calculated based on factors such as payment history, credit utilization, credit length, credit mix, and inquiries. A good credit score can save borrowers thousands in interest payments over the life of a mortgage.

It is important to note that your mortgage credit score may differ from your consumer credit score. This is because mortgage lenders use a different credit scoring model that places a heavier emphasis on credit mix and length. Therefore, even with a good consumer credit score, individuals should work with their lender to raise their mortgage credit score.

Mortgage scores are often lower than consumer credit scores

One of the main reasons for the difference in scores is that mortgage lenders use a different credit scoring model than consumers have access to. Mortgage lenders predominantly use the FICO scoring model, which was created by Fair Isaac and Company and is utilised by over 90% of mortgage lenders. FICO scores take into account factors such as payment history, credit utilisation, credit length, credit mix, and inquiries. On the other hand, consumers typically access their credit scores through services like Credit Karma, which provide a VantageScore 3.0. This model emphasises payment history, age and type of credit, credit utilisation, balances, recent credit, and available credit. The VantageScore model is designed to be more consumer-friendly and may not accurately reflect the criteria considered by mortgage lenders.

Another factor contributing to the lower mortgage scores is the weightage assigned to different components of the credit score. For example, while both models consider payment history as a crucial factor, the FICO model used by mortgage lenders places a higher emphasis on credit mix and length. This means that factors such as the variety of debt a consumer can handle (credit cards, mortgage loans, personal loans, etc.) and the age of their credit history carry more weight in the FICO score. Additionally, certain financial decisions, such as having a high credit utilisation rate or a history of late payments, can negatively impact a mortgage credit score more significantly than a consumer credit score.

Furthermore, the mortgage credit scoring formula has not kept up with the consumer-friendly changes introduced in newer scoring models. For instance, under newer FICO scores, medical debt is counted less heavily, whereas it may still significantly impact the mortgage credit score calculated using the older formula. Similarly, debt collections that have been paid off are not considered in newer scoring models but can still negatively affect the mortgage credit score. These discrepancies can result in a lower mortgage credit score, even for individuals with good financial habits.

It is important to note that individuals have multiple potential credit scores at any given time, and these scores can vary depending on the credit report used and the scoring model applied. This variation in scoring models and the weightage of different factors can lead to a lower mortgage credit score compared to consumer credit scores. However, it is possible to improve mortgage credit scores over time by adopting good financial habits, such as paying bills on time, minimising the use of credit, and refraining from opening new accounts.

Payment history is important for both scores

Payment history is a crucial factor in both consumer and mortgage credit scores. It can significantly impact your financial health and creditworthiness. Lenders want to see that you have a history of honouring your financial commitments, so making payments on time is essential. Late or missed payments can negatively affect both your consumer and mortgage credit scores, making it harder to obtain loans, credit cards, mortgages, or other financial products in the future.

Your payment history is built over time, with creditors, vendors, and service providers reporting your monthly payments to the three major consumer credit bureaus: Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. These reports include information on whether payments were made on time, creating a month-by-month rating that appears in your account payment history profile. This history helps lenders assess your financial track record and determine your creditworthiness.

When applying for a mortgage, lenders will review your credit report to assess your payment history. They will consider your history with previous mortgages, if applicable, and evaluate any delinquencies or late payments. This information helps them determine your ability to honour future mortgage payments. It's important to note that mortgage lenders primarily use the FICO scoring model, which weighs payment history as 35% of your score.

On the other hand, consumer credit scores use the VantageScore model, which also considers payment history as extremely influential. While the exact weightings may differ, both models recognise the importance of timely payments. Maintaining a positive payment history across both scores is crucial for maintaining good financial health and increasing your chances of securing loans, mortgages, or other financial opportunities.

To improve your payment history and, by extension, your credit scores, focus on paying your debts on time and in full. Prioritise high-interest debts and consider consolidating or negotiating with creditors to manage your payments effectively. Remember, your payment history is a key factor in both consumer and mortgage credit scores, and it plays a significant role in shaping your overall financial profile.

Frequently asked questions