Cryptocurrency Investment: Risks And Rewards

Investing in cryptocurrency has become an increasingly popular topic of discussion. Cryptocurrency is a digital currency that uses cryptographic systems to secure transactions. While it can be a great investment with astronomically high returns, there are also considerable downsides. Cryptocurrency is highly volatile, and investors need to be prepared for significant price swings and potential losses. It is also subject to security breaches, fraud, and theft, which can result in significant financial losses. Additionally, there is a lack of regulation and consumer protection in the cryptocurrency market, and transactions are irreversible. On the other hand, cryptocurrency offers protection against inflation, provides cost-effective transactions, and can be a good diversification tool for an investment portfolio. Ultimately, investing in cryptocurrency carries risks, and individuals should carefully consider their financial goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon before deciding to invest.

Cryptocurrency's volatility and risk

Cryptocurrency is a highly volatile and risky investment. Its value is based on speculation, which makes it susceptible to significant price swings. The market is also relatively new and largely unregulated, making it more vulnerable to fraud and security breaches.

Volatility

Cryptocurrency experiences huge fluctuations in its valuation, and this quality is known as volatility. This volatility is due to the speculative nature of the investment, as its value is based on how much people are willing to trade for it. This means that the investment's value is not very grounded and is sensitive to slight changes in investors' expectations or perceptions.

For example, Bitcoin's value dropped 30% in one day, and its ascent has not been linear. It has experienced sharp rallies and price declines, and there is no way to predict how it will behave in the future.

Risk

The risks of investing in cryptocurrency include:

• Financial loss due to its highly volatile nature.
• Future regulation – cryptocurrency is currently not extensively regulated, but this could change in the future, impacting its value.
• Fraud and cybercrime – there have been instances of hackers stealing large amounts of cryptocurrency, and the decentralised nature of cryptocurrency makes it attractive for illegal transactions.
• Theft or loss – if login credentials are lost, hacked, or stolen, access to the cryptocurrency could be denied.
• Minimal consumer protections – compared to traditional financial products, cryptocurrency exchanges lack basic consumer protections like insurance protection.
• Irreversible transactions – if you accidentally send cryptocurrency to the wrong address or wallet, the transaction cannot be reversed.
• High transaction fees – Bitcoin, for example, is subject to hefty transaction fees, limiting its use as a medium of exchange.

Cryptocurrency is a highly volatile and risky investment. Its value is based on speculation, and it is sensitive to various factors such as news, investor expectations, and perceptions. The market is also relatively new and largely unregulated, making it more vulnerable to fraud and security breaches. Therefore, it is essential to carefully consider your risk tolerance and financial situation before investing in cryptocurrency.

The irreversible nature of transactions

The irreversibility of transactions is a key feature of trading cryptographic tokens. Cryptocurrencies being a decentralized system, do not have a central entity that operates, controls, and verifies them. Instead, it employs a consensus among all connected nodes that are guided by the same protocol and a Proof of Work (PoW). So, when used correctly, Bitcoin's base layer transactions on the blockchain are irreversible and final.

Each time a cryptocurrency transaction is made, it is transmitted to the network of miners who validate it. They take the transaction and add it to a block. Once the block is generated and validated, the transaction can be said to have been committed. This process is repeated as new blocks are generated and added to the verified history of the blockchain. Each new block created is a new commit received by previously committed transactions. It is this incremental process of confirmations and how the blockchain is structured that makes the transactions irreversible.

However, a transaction with a single confirmation can be reversed if one has the computing power necessary to do so. For example, in the case of Bitcoin, it is recommended to wait for 5 to 6 confirmations to safely consider a transaction. Once this point is reached, we can say that the Bitcoin network has irreversibly validated our transaction. Other cryptocurrencies also have a similar process, such as Ethereum, where it is recommended to wait for 20 confirmations.

The irreversibility of transactions in cryptocurrencies avoids many fraudulent practices. In fact, transaction reversal fraud, or chargeback fraud, costs companies about $4 trillion.

Despite the benefits, the irreversibility of transactions in cryptocurrencies also poses challenges in terms of consumer protection. For example, if someone gains access to your wallet, there is no way to cancel the transaction or get a refund. This is in contrast to traditional payment methods, where it is often possible to contact the credit card company or the merchant to cancel or reverse a transaction.

To address this issue, some sources suggest the use of custody services, multi-signature smart contracts, or money-back agreements between the merchant and the customer. Additionally, consumer protection can be implemented on a layer on top of the base layer blockchain, such as through the use of escrow agents or multisignature smart contracts.

Lack of consumer protection

Investing in cryptocurrencies is risky due to the lack of consumer protection. The market is highly volatile, and consumers have little recourse in the event of financial loss. Crypto assets are not insured, and there is no government agency that protects consumers if their crypto is stolen.

The crypto market is largely unregulated, and consumer protection laws do not cover crypto products and providers. As a result, customers do not benefit from the rights and protections available in regulated financial services, such as transparent and comprehensive disclosures, advertising and marketing standards, suitability assessments, complaints functions, and recourse mechanisms. The initial small size and novelty of the crypto market led many regulators to take a "wait-and-see" approach to regulating crypto. However, in the wake of recent fraud and scandal cases, the crypto market has been receiving heightened attention, and many countries are now looking at how they should approach the regulation of crypto assets.

The lack of regulation means that crypto firms have weak governance and risk management, uncertain operational resilience, and opacity. A key issue for consumers is that many crypto assets are not subject to fund-safeguarding rules or investor protection mechanisms. Customer funds are at risk when they are commingled with other assets of the crypto service providers, or when the fund-safeguarding practices are not subject to proper audit and internal controls. In addition, customers may face losses from insolvent crypto firms, as they may have lower priority than a firm's other creditors in the event of bankruptcy.

The basic consumer protections that are typically available in traditional financial products, such as insurance protection from the Securities Investor Protection Corp. and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., are lacking in the crypto market. This leaves consumers vulnerable to financial loss, fraud, and cyber-attacks.

The consequences for the leaders of disgraced crypto firms such as Terra and FTX remain to be seen, but the need to provide better protections for their customers is increasingly urgent, especially for those who are low-income and least able to weather losses.

Potential for fraud and cybercrime

Cryptocurrency fraud has become a growing global concern, with governments reporting an increase in the frequency and losses from scams involving cryptocurrencies. The decentralised, pseudo-anonymous, and transparent nature of cryptocurrencies makes them particularly susceptible to fraud and cybercrime. Here are some key points regarding the potential for fraud and cybercrime in the cryptocurrency space:

Prevalence of Cryptocurrency Fraud

Cryptocurrency fraud is a significant issue, with a growing number of scams and increasing financial losses reported worldwide. Between 2017 and 2018, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission registered a 190% increase in losses from cryptocurrency scams. Similarly, in 2019, the United Kingdom Financial Conduct Authority issued a warning after reports of cryptocurrency scams tripled. This trend suggests that criminals are actively exploiting the cryptocurrency space for financial gain.

Types of Cryptocurrency Fraud

A scoping review of academic literature and grey literature identified various types of cryptocurrency fraud, including Ponzi schemes, high-yield investment programs, initial coin offering (ICO) scams, phishing scams, and exchange scams. The lack of clear definitions and differentiation among fraud types in the literature makes it challenging to fully understand the nature and impact of each scheme.

Cyber-Enabled and Cyber-Dependent Crimes

Most sources characterise cryptocurrency fraud as cyber-enabled crimes, where traditional financial frauds such as Ponzi schemes and market manipulation are facilitated by the use of cryptocurrencies. However, there are also cyber-dependent crimes that rely solely on information and communication technologies, such as crypto-mining fraud and wallet and exchange service fraud. As cryptocurrency becomes more mainstream, new forms of cyber-dependent fraud may emerge, particularly in the decentralised finance industry.

Collaboration and Research Gaps

The fight against cryptocurrency fraud requires better collaboration between sectors, including law enforcement, financial intelligence units, the private sector, and academia. There is a recognised need for improved information sharing and joint efforts to address these crimes effectively. Additionally, the rapid evolution of cryptocurrency fraud has outpaced research efforts, highlighting the importance of ongoing and adaptive research agendas to stay ahead of emerging threats.

Regulatory Challenges

The anonymous and decentralised nature of cryptocurrencies poses challenges for regulatory authorities. The lack of legislation and standardisation regarding virtual assets makes it difficult to seize and recover funds lost to fraud or cybercrime. The COVID-19 pandemic further exacerbated the use of virtual assets for illegitimate purposes, underscoring the urgency for comprehensive regulatory frameworks.

Regulatory uncertainty

The regulatory landscape for cryptocurrencies is complex and constantly evolving, creating uncertainty for investors. While some countries have embraced and adopted crypto, others have banned it, and the lack of consistent global regulations poses risks for investors.

In the United States, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has historically had a chilly relationship with the crypto market, expressing concerns about volatility, inadequate investor protections, and insufficient regulations. However, in 2024, the SEC approved spot bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs), signalling a cautious move towards mainstream acceptance. Despite this, the SEC Chair, Gary Gensler, emphasised the need for investors to remain cautious about the risks associated with crypto.

The regulatory uncertainty is further highlighted by the actions of major financial institutions. Citadel Securities, one of the world's biggest market-making firms, has refrained from trading cryptocurrencies due to regulatory uncertainties. Ken Griffin, the founder of Citadel Securities, stated that he did not want to take on the regulatory risk in the absence of clear regulations.

The regulatory landscape is also shaped by concerns about privacy and financial transparency. Governments and regulators are imposing stricter requirements on financial institutions to report transactions, including those involving cryptocurrencies. This has particularly impacted 'privacy coins', which promote privacy as a key feature. The Financial Action Task Force (FATF), a global AML agency, has increased transactional reporting requirements for virtual asset service providers (VASPs), making it more challenging to maintain privacy in the crypto space.

The regulatory uncertainty extends to the classification of cryptocurrencies. SEC Chair Gary Gensler stated in 2022 that some cryptocurrencies "have the key attributes of a security", while Bitcoin, in his view, "is a commodity". This lack of clear classification further complicates the regulatory environment and contributes to the uncertainty faced by investors.

In conclusion, the regulatory landscape for cryptocurrencies is complex, inconsistent, and subject to rapid change. Investors face challenges due to the lack of global regulatory consensus, evolving regulatory responses, and concerns about privacy and transparency. While some regulatory bodies are cautiously moving towards acceptance, others remain sceptical, creating a volatile environment that investors must navigate with caution.

Frequently asked questions