The Risk Of Investing In Cds: Systemic Danger

Certificates of Deposit (CDs) are a type of savings account with a fixed interest rate and term. They are considered a safer investment than stocks and certain types of bonds. CDs are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) and the National Credit Union Association (NCUA) and are therefore considered a safe place to keep your money. However, there are some risks associated with investing in CDs, including early withdrawal penalties, inflation risk, and interest rate risk.

Inflation risk

While CDs are considered a low-risk investment option, they are susceptible to inflation risk, especially in a high inflationary environment. This means that if the interest rate on a CD fails to keep up with the inflation rate, the money invested loses purchasing power over time.

The primary objective of investing in CDs is to earn a higher rate of interest than a standard checking or savings account, without the risk associated with market-based assets. However, if the rate of inflation surpasses the interest accrued on the CD, it defeats the purpose of investing in the first place.

For example, as of April 2022, the best one-year CD rates were 2.25%, while the average was 0.17%. At the same time, inflation was running at record highs. When compared to the standard Consumer Price Index (CPI) rate, the rate of inflation was significantly higher than the return paid on CDs. This disparity becomes even more pronounced when compared to the Core CPI rate, which includes oil and food prices, and is the metric that most economists tend to follow.

The interest earned on CDs is also subject to taxation, further reducing the net return. Therefore, if the effective tax rate is 25%, the net return of a CD yielding 1% is only 0.75%.

In a rising inflation environment, investing in CDs may not be advisable as individuals could be locking in their money at too low a rate. This is especially true for long-term CDs, which have longer maturity periods, exposing them to greater inflation risk. As a result, the money invested in CDs may not be able to keep up with the rising cost of living.

To mitigate this risk, individuals can consider alternative investment options, such as Series I U.S. savings bonds (I bonds), Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS), or floating-rate notes. These options offer better inflation protection than traditional CDs, either by adjusting their interest rates in line with inflation or by being tied to changes in the CPI.

Additionally, there are certain types of CDs that offer adjustable rates, such as variable-rate CDs and bump-up CDs, which can provide some inflation protection. However, these products tend to offer lower initial interest rates, and there is a possibility that the variable-rate CDs' interest rate could fall if inflation declines.

In summary, while CDs offer a stable and secure investment option, they are vulnerable to inflation risk, particularly in periods of high inflation. To preserve the purchasing power of their investments, individuals should carefully consider the prevailing inflation rates and explore alternative investment options that offer better inflation protection.

Interest rate risk

To protect against interest rate risk, investors should shop for the best CD rates and lowest fees. They can use a CD calculator to compare rates and ensure they are getting a good deal. It is also important for investors to budget properly and manage their cash flow to effectively structure a CD ladder.

Additionally, investors should be aware of inflation risk, which can erode the value of their CDs over time. They can use a CD calculator to compare rates under different inflation scenarios and stay informed about economic cycles and news.

Bank failure risk

When you invest in a Certificate of Deposit (CD), your money is generally considered safe and secure, even in the event of a bank failure. Here's why:

• FDIC Insurance: CDs held in banks that are members of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) are insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, and per ownership category. This means that even if the bank fails, you are guaranteed to recover your savings up to the insured limit.
• NCUA Insurance: For CDs held in credit unions, the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) provides similar insurance coverage. Credit unions offer "share certificates" that function similarly to CDs and are insured by the NCUA.
• Fixed Rates and Predictable Returns: CDs typically offer fixed interest rates, which means that your money is not directly exposed to market volatility. The fixed-rate structure ensures predictable returns, allowing you to know exactly how much you'll earn over the CD's term.
• Diversification: Investing in CDs from multiple banks can further reduce bank failure risk. By diversifying your CD holdings across different financial institutions, you minimize the impact of a potential failure at any single bank.

Early Withdrawal Considerations:

While CDs offer safety and security for your investments, it's important to remember that early withdrawals from CDs typically incur penalties. These penalties can eat into your interest earnings or even result in a loss of principal if the CD is withdrawn shortly after opening. Therefore, it's crucial to ensure that you won't need the funds during the CD's term.

CD Laddering for Risk Mitigation:

To balance the need for liquidity and the benefits of long-term investments, consider a CD laddering strategy. This involves opening multiple CDs with different maturity dates, allowing you to access funds at regular intervals while still taking advantage of the higher interest rates that come with longer-term CDs.

In conclusion, investing in CDs carries relatively low bank failure risk due to the protections provided by FDIC and NCUA insurance, as well as the fixed-rate nature of CDs. However, it's important to be mindful of early withdrawal penalties and consider strategies like CD laddering to optimize liquidity and return.

Tax risk

Investing in CDs can expose you to tax risk. Interest earned on CDs is considered taxable income by the IRS, and must be reported and taxed annually, even if the CD has a term longer than one year and cannot be cashed in until maturity. This is true regardless of whether the interest is received in cash or reinvested in a new CD. The tax rate on CD interest depends on the dollar amount of your gain and your income tax bracket.

The tax implications of CDs can be mitigated by including them in your retirement savings strategy. Many banks offer IRA CDs, which allow you to postpone paying taxes (Traditional IRA) or avoid paying them altogether (Roth IRA). Health savings accounts (HSAs) and 529 CDs are other options for tax-advantaged savings.

Compared to CDs, US Treasury bonds offer tax benefits as they are exempt from state income taxes. For investors in high-tax states, the impact of state income taxes can make Treasuries a more attractive option, even though CDs may offer higher yields for maturities of one year and beyond.

Liquidity risk

One of the main drawbacks of CDs is the early withdrawal penalty. CD account holders are typically required to keep their money in the account for a specified term, and if they need to access their funds early, they may face a penalty. This can result in a loss of principal or a reduction in the expected interest rate. Therefore, CDs may not be suitable for investors who require immediate access to their funds or who are uncertain about their liquidity needs.

To mitigate this risk, investors can consider implementing a CD ladder strategy. This involves staggering the maturity dates of multiple CDs so that at least one CD is close to maturity at any given time. As each CD matures, the funds can be reinvested to take advantage of higher rates or used to meet liquidity needs. This strategy provides flexibility and helps to spread the risk across different maturities and interest rates.

Another aspect of liquidity risk in CDs is the potential impact on the underlying bond market. Credit default swaps (CDS) are often used to hedge credit risk and can affect the liquidity of the bonds they are based on. In some cases, losses on CDS positions may force investors to sell their bond holdings, reducing the liquidity of their portfolios and potentially leading to a downward spiral in bond prices.

Additionally, it is important to consider the impact of interest rate changes on liquidity. CDs are subject to interest rate risk, and if rates fall, investors may be locked into lower returns for an extended period. This can create a situation where investors are unable to withdraw their funds without incurring penalties, affecting their overall liquidity position.

In conclusion, while CDs offer a relatively low-risk investment option, it is crucial to carefully assess and manage liquidity risk. By implementing strategies such as CD ladders and diversifying across different maturities, investors can enhance their liquidity position and better navigate potential challenges associated with early withdrawals and changing interest rates.

Frequently asked questions