Valuing Private Equity Investments: Strategies For Success

Private equity investments are a form of investing that involves buying and selling companies or parts of them, often using debt and leverage. Unlike public companies, private companies keep their books closed to outsiders, making it challenging to determine their value. However, investors can utilise various valuation methods to assess the worth of private equity investments. This paragraph will introduce the topic of how to value private equity investments by exploring the different approaches and considerations involved in this complex process.

Discounted cash flow models

Discounted cash flow (DCF) models are one of the most widely used methods to estimate the value of a company or a project. DCF models are financial tools that project the future cash flows of a company or a project and discount them back to the present using an appropriate discount rate. The discount rate reflects the risk and opportunity cost of investing in the company or the project. The sum of the discounted cash flows is the intrinsic value of the company or the project.

To build a DCF model, you must gather relevant financial data and assumptions, such as income statements, balance sheets, cash flow statements, growth rates, operating margins, capital expenditures, working capital, taxes, and debt. The forecast period is typically between 5-10 years, and the model will have a terminal value estimate, a present value calculation, and a discount rate.

The steps for building a DCF model are as follows:

• Project future free cash flows for the forecast period.
• Calculate the terminal value at the end of the forecast period.
• Discount the forecasted free cash flows and terminal value to today's value using the discount rate.
• Sum the discounted cash flows to calculate the net present value (NPV).

The discount rate is a critical component of a DCF model. It represents the investment's cost of capital or the minimum acceptable rate of return. The discount rate is typically derived from the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) or the required rate of return for equity investors. The WACC takes into account the average rate of return expected by shareholders.

DCF models have several advantages, including the ability to focus on cash flows, capture the time value of money, and allow for different scenarios and assumptions to be incorporated. However, they also have limitations, such as the sensitivity to input assumptions, uncertainty in calculating terminal values, and the subjectivity of discount rates.

In summary, DCF models are a valuable tool for estimating the intrinsic value of a company or a project, but they should be used with an understanding of their limitations and the potential impact of inaccurate assumptions.

Publicly traded comps

Public comps analysis involves comparing the valuation multiples, averages, ratios, and benchmarks of publicly traded companies operating in a similar sector and location to the company being valued. This allows investors to gauge the current market value of the company and assess whether it is undervalued or overvalued.

• Creating a comps list: Analysts create a list of publicly owned companies that are comparable to the one they are considering based on sector, location, revenue, and market capitalization.
• Refining the list: The initial target list is refined based on more detailed financial information, including consensus estimate price.
• Identifying outliers: Analysts create custom peer group stock benchmarks to understand if the target company is at the top or bottom of a valuation cycle. This involves creating a basket of securities to compare with the target company and comparing the peer group stock index with major indexes to identify any outlying variables.

There are several common valuation measures used in public comps analysis:

• Enterprise value to sales (EV/S): Compares the total value of a company (including stock shares, debt, and cash) to its annual sales.
• Price-to-earnings (P/E): Measures a company's current share price relative to its per-share earnings (EPS).
• Price-to-book (P/B): Compares market value (a company's outstanding shares multiplied by its current market price) and book value (the value of a company's assets) by dividing the price per share by book value per share (BVPS).
• Price-to-sales (P/S): Compares a company's stock price to its revenues by dividing its current stock price by sales per share.

Public comps analysis is generally the easiest type of relative valuation model to perform because the information required to do the analysis is readily available. However, it is typically best used when a minority stake in a company is being acquired or a new issuance of equity is being considered.

Transaction comps

Step 1: Identify Recent Transactions

The first step is to research and identify a list of recent transactions involving comparable companies. This involves finding similar companies in the same industry or sector that have been involved in M&A activities. The focus should be on companies with similar characteristics, such as size, age, growth rate, and financial metrics.

Step 2: Gather Financial Data

Once a list of comparable transactions is created, the next step is to gather financial data from these transactions. This includes the sale price, revenue, gross profit, net profit, growth rates, and other relevant financial metrics. The goal is to understand the valuation multiples used in these transactions, such as the price-to-sales ratio, price-to-book value, or enterprise value multiples.

Step 3: Calculate and Adjust Valuation Multiples

After collecting the financial data, calculate the valuation multiples for each transaction. These multiples represent the relationship between the sale price and the company's financial metrics. For example, the enterprise value multiple is calculated by dividing the sale price by the company's EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization). Then, adjust these multiples to account for any differences between the precedent transactions and the private company being valued.

Step 4: Apply Adjusted Multiples

Apply the adjusted valuation multiples to the corresponding financial metrics of the private company. For example, if the average EV/EBITDA multiple of comparable companies is 12x and the private company's EBITDA is $20 million, the estimated value of the private company would be $240 million.

Step 5: Aggregate the Values

Finally, aggregate the values obtained from the adjusted multiples to estimate the overall valuation of the private company. This involves summing up the values calculated using different multiples to get a comprehensive estimate of the company's worth.

It is important to note that transaction comps are most useful when there have been recent transactions involving similar companies, especially within the same industry. This method provides a realistic view of what the market has been willing to pay for comparable assets and is particularly valuable for stakeholders in M&A scenarios. However, it is important to consider that transaction data may be limited or confidential, and past transactions may not always reflect current market conditions.

Leveraged buyouts

LBOs are typically carried out by private equity groups, which consist of a general partner (active money managers) and limited partners (passive investors). The process involves several stages: deal sourcing, preliminary due diligence and modelling, strategy formulation, LOI, debt raise, execution, and liquidation.

There are several advantages to LBOs. They allow the business buyer to acquire a company with less equity, and if the business successfully pays off the debt, the buyer gets a company for a fraction of the cost. LBOs can also create shareholder value by allowing purchasers to invest less equity in acquiring a business.

However, LBOs also come with risks. If the business's performance falters and it cannot pay off its debt, the lender may seize the company, resulting in a loss for the buyer. Additionally, LBOs introduce debt service obligations, which can increase financial risk and require steady cash flow to service the debt.

LBOs have a negative reputation due to their association with massive layoffs and asset sell-offs. However, they can also be part of a long-term plan to save a company through leveraged acquisitions. The four main LBO scenarios are the repackaging plan, the split-up, the portfolio plan, and the savior plan.

Venture capital investments

Venture capital (VC) is a type of private equity investment, involving funding for early-stage start-ups with high growth potential. This type of investment is often synonymous with early innovation and startup entrepreneurialism.

VC firms tend to focus on early to mid-stage companies, which are usually early in their lifecycle, with unproven business models and products or services that have not yet gained traction in the market. These companies are often young, growing startups with promising value.

VC investors are known for their high tolerance for risk. They are willing to take calculated risks, knowing that many startups fail, in pursuit of outsized returns. The returns from a few successful investments can often drive returns for the whole portfolio.

VC firms often provide more than just capital. They offer guidance, talent sourcing, business development support, and more, to help startups navigate the challenges of building a successful business.

Venture capitalists typically aim for an exit within six years, through an initial public offering (IPO) or acquisition by a larger company. However, VC firms may hold these investments for 10+ years or sell their shares in the private secondary market before an exit event.

Frequently asked questions