Equity Investments: Are Commissions Included?

When considering equity investments, it's important to understand the costs involved, including any commissions or fees. Commissions are charges levied by brokers or investment advisors for providing investment advice or executing transactions on behalf of their clients. These costs can impact the overall profitability of an investment, and vary across different firms and types of securities. Therefore, when evaluating equity investments, it is essential to factor in any associated commissions to make informed decisions and accurately calculate returns.

Commission-based advisors make money by selling investment products

Commission-based advisors derive their income from selling investment products such as mutual funds and annuities. They can also receive payments from front- or back-end load fees that a mutual fund charges the investor when its shares are bought or sold. The more their clients invest, the more the advisor earns.

For example, when an investor buys a mutual fund with a sales load, part of that additional expense is used to pay a commission to the advisor. Mutual funds also charge a 12b-1 fee as part of their expense ratio collected each year, and part of that goes towards paying the broker a trailer commission as long as the client remains invested in the fund.

Commission-based advisors have been criticised for engaging their clients in active trading to increase their income, even if this style is not suitable for the client. They may also sell products that are not optimal for the client to increase their commissions. This practice is known as ""churning" and is considered unethical.

Commissions are charged when an order is filled, cancelled or modified

Commissions are a crucial aspect of investing, and understanding when they are charged can help investors manage their expenses effectively. In this regard, it is important to know that commissions are typically charged when an order is filled, cancelled, or modified. This means that investors may incur charges not only when they buy or sell securities but also when they make changes to their orders.

When an investor places a market order that remains unfilled, no commission is usually charged. However, if the investor decides to cancel or modify that order, additional charges may be applied on top of the standard commission. This is an important consideration, as it can impact the overall cost of investing and, consequently, the returns. For instance, if an investor cancels an order that has not been filled, they may be charged a fee, increasing their expenses.

It is worth noting that different brokerage firms have varying commission structures. While some firms may charge a flat rate or a percentage of the assets under management, others may have complex fee schedules for various services. Therefore, it is essential for investors to carefully review the commission and fee structure of a brokerage firm before deciding to use their services. This transparency ensures investors are aware of potential costs and can make informed decisions.

Furthermore, investors should also be mindful of additional fees associated with specific types of trades or transactions. For example, trading certain securities, such as futures, options, or bonds, often incurs fees, and these can vary depending on the broker. Thus, it is prudent to consider these fees when strategizing to minimise costs and maximise returns.

In summary, commissions are an integral part of investing, and they can be charged when an order is filled, cancelled, or modified. By understanding when these charges apply, investors can make more informed decisions and effectively manage their investment expenses. Additionally, considering the varying commission structures of different brokerage firms and the fees associated with specific types of trades can help investors minimise costs and maximise their investment returns.

Commissions and fees vary from firm to firm

Brokerage fees are usually charged annually to maintain client accounts, pay for research and/or subscriptions, or to access any investment platforms. These fees may be charged as a certain percentage of the balance held in a client's account or as a flat fee.

Brokers and investment advisors often charge clients commissions, also called trading fees, for using their services. These commissions are paid for investment advice or to execute orders on the sale or purchase of securities, including commodities, options, and bonds.

Commission-based advisors or brokers make money by selling investment products and conducting transactions with the client's money. They derive their income from the sale of investment products and the number of transactions made with the client's money.

Fee-based advisors, on the other hand, charge a flat rate for managing a client's money, which can be a dollar amount or a percentage of assets under management (AUM).

It is worth noting that most online brokers no longer charge commissions for buying and selling stocks. However, commissions can still be charged for other types of trades, such as futures and bonds.

When considering a brokerage or advisor, it is important to look at the full list of commissions for services and be cautious of financial advisors who seem more interested in selling products for commissions rather than for the client's best interest.

Robo-advisors are a low-fee alternative

Robo-advisors are a great choice for investors who want to simplify their investment management at costs below that of traditional financial advisors. They are a low-fee alternative to traditional investment management companies and financial advisors, which tend to charge high annual management fees.

Robo-advisors use algorithms to build and manage an investment portfolio for you, based on your answers to a handful of questions about your risk tolerance and investment goals. They also offer other features such as tax-loss harvesting and automatic rebalancing, which can boost your returns and make investing as hands-off as possible.

Robo-advisors are paid through their account management fee, which is usually shown as a percentage of the money that you invest. For example, if you put $1,000 into a robo-advisor investment account and it charges a 0.25% fee, you'd pay $2.50 for that year's worth of investment management.

Some robo-advisors will manage small amounts of money for free, while others don’t charge a management fee at all. However, you’ll typically still pay fees for the funds that are used to build your portfolio.

• Wealthfront: Low management fee, no account minimum, and advanced tax optimization strategies.
• Schwab Intelligent Portfolios: No management fee and fund fees ranging from 0.02% to 0.19%.
• Fidelity Go: Free management on balances below $25,000 and uses its own index funds with no fees for investors.
• Interactive Advisors: Free if you manage the portfolio yourself; otherwise, a low annual fee of 0.20%.
• Ally Invest Robo Portfolios: No advisory fee if you choose the "cash-enhanced" portfolio option, which keeps 30% of your money in cash.

Management or advisory fees are charged by companies that run investment funds

There are several types of fee structures that financial advisors or investment fund managers may use:

• Assets Under Management (AUM) Fees: This is a common fee structure where clients are charged a percentage of the total assets under the management of the advisor or fund manager. The fee is usually calculated annually and can range from 0.25% to 1% of the total assets. Some traditional human advisors may charge higher fees for smaller accounts and lower fees for larger accounts.
• Flat Fees: Some advisors charge a flat annual or monthly fee for their services, which is typically not linked to the amount of money the client has invested. This type of fee structure is often used by online financial planning services and can range from $2,000 to $7,500 per year.
• Hourly Rates: Certain financial advisors charge by the hour for their services, with rates ranging from $200 to $400 per hour. This structure allows clients to pay only for the time they need and can be useful for specific tasks or meetings.
• One-Time Financial Plan Fees: In this case, the advisor charges a flat fee for creating a financial plan, and the client carries out the plan on their own without ongoing management or oversight. The cost for this type of service typically ranges from $1,000 to $3,000.
• Commissions: Some advisors are paid through commissions on the investments they recommend, which are paid by the client. Commission-based advisors make money by selling investment products and conducting transactions with the client's money. Mutual fund sales loads, for example, can range from 3% to 6% of the investment amount.

It is important to understand the differences between these fee structures when considering hiring a financial advisor or investing in an investment fund. Commission-based advisors may prioritize selling products that offer higher commissions rather than those that are in the best interest of the client. On the other hand, fee-based advisors may have a greater incentive to grow their clients' assets, as their fees are tied to their performance.

Frequently asked questions