Crypto Investing: Wise Choice Or Risky Gamble?

Investing in cryptocurrencies is risky due to the potential for high losses from security breaches and fraud. However, it can also provide astronomically high returns overnight. Cryptocurrencies are highly volatile and unpredictable, but they have outperformed most asset classes in recent years, including stocks, gold, and real estate.

Cryptocurrencies are decentralized digital assets, most often based on blockchain technology. They enable secure online payments without the use of third-party intermediaries. The advantages of cryptocurrencies include cheaper and faster money transfers, and decentralized systems that do not collapse at a single point of failure.

The risks of investing in cryptocurrencies include user risk, regulatory risks, counterparty risks, management risks, programming risks, and market manipulation.

The potential for large gains

Cryptocurrency can provide astronomically high returns overnight. For example, Toncoin increased by more than 250% over six months in 2024, entering the top 10 cryptocurrencies by market cap. In previous years, we've seen even bigger gains, with Shiba Inu shooting up by over 40,000,000% and Solana exploding by more than 10,000% in 2021. Bitcoin has also skyrocketed in price, with a growth of 11,280% between May 2016 and September 2024.

The prospect of large gains is further demonstrated by the performance of some of the best-known cryptocurrencies:

• Ethereum: 21,196% increase from April 2016 to September 2024
• Binance Coin: 519,478% gain from 2017 to September 2024
• Solana: 17,280% rise from 2020 to September 2024
• XRP: 8,858% increase from the beginning of 2017 to September 2024
• Wall Street Memes: a new meme coin that raised over $25 million in less than three months of its presale in 2023
• Bitcoin BSC: a fast-selling crypto that raised $200,000 within 72 hours in its 2023 presale
• Chimpzee: an environmental sustainability token that raised over $1.2 million in its 2023 presale
• Lucky Block: a crypto casino that generated gains of over 6,000% within a month of launching in 2022

However, it's important to remember that while cryptocurrency can provide the potential for large gains, it also carries significant risks. The volatile nature of the crypto market means that prices can fall just as quickly as they rise, and there is no guarantee that investors will not lose money.

The risks of financial loss

Investing in cryptocurrencies can be risky due to the potential for high losses. Here are some key points to consider regarding the risks of financial loss when investing in crypto:

Volatility and Price Fluctuation

The price of cryptocurrencies is highly volatile and subject to frequent, rapid changes. This volatility means that crypto investments can experience extreme highs and lows. While various factors influence price fluctuations, the overall trend is that crypto values are unstable and prone to significant shifts.

Regulatory Uncertainties

Government regulations surrounding crypto are constantly evolving and vary across different regions. These regulations can impact how investors use and access their crypto holdings, leading to uncertainty and potential losses. The relative novelty of crypto means that clear and consistent guidelines from policymakers may take time to establish.

Security and Scam Risks

The lack of centralised regulation makes cryptocurrencies vulnerable to security breaches and scams. Investors need to be cautious as there is no protection or insurance for lost or stolen crypto assets. Some platforms are more secure than others, and newer coins may pose a higher scam risk than more established ones. It is crucial to research thoroughly before investing.

Storage and Accessibility Concerns

Storing cryptocurrencies securely is a challenge. Private storage in non-custodial wallets on personal devices or cold storage wallets comes with risks. If an investor loses their private key, experiences a hard drive crash, or has their wallet corrupted by a virus, they may lose their funds entirely.

Centralised storage through third-party custodians also has risks. Exchanges can be hacked, and investors may lose access to their assets if the exchange freezes funds or goes bankrupt.

Lack of Fundamental Value

Crypto-assets, by their nature, often lack an underlying claim or right to future cash flows. This makes their valuation difficult and highly speculative. As a result, crypto prices can be extremely volatile, exposing investors to potential significant losses.

Interconnectedness and Systemic Risk

The interconnectedness between the crypto market and the traditional financial system can transmit risks to the broader economy. Financial institutions' exposures to crypto assets, investment vehicles, and retail payments linkages create potential financial stability implications. In extreme scenarios, the widespread adoption of crypto for retail payments could have significant implications for monetary policy and economic activity.

The pros and cons of crypto ETFs

Crypto ETFs, or exchange-traded funds, are a way to invest in cryptocurrencies using traditional market instruments. They are traded on traditional exchanges like the NYSE or Nasdaq, rather than on a cryptocurrency exchange. Crypto ETFs can be an attractive option for investors who are familiar with stock assets but are hesitant to enter the crypto market directly. Here are some of the pros and cons of crypto ETFs:

Pros

• Simplicity and ease of use: ETFs can be bought, sold, and held using traditional brokerage accounts, eliminating the need for investors to navigate the complexities of setting up digital wallets and managing private and public keys.
• Regulation and security: ETFs are issued by regulated companies, reducing the risk of fraud and scandals associated with direct crypto investments. They are also highly regulated, providing protection against price manipulation.
• Diversification: ETFs hold a basket of digital tokens and currencies, allowing investors to diversify their portfolio and minimise the impact of losses if a specific currency's price drops.
• Tax advantages: In certain countries, such as Canada, crypto ETFs are eligible for investment via government-regulated tax plans, providing tax efficiency benefits.

Cons

• Loss of independence: Crypto ETFs contradict the core idea behind cryptocurrencies, which is to provide an alternative financial platform free from government regulation. By investing in ETFs, investors give up the independence and decentralisation that cryptocurrencies offer.
• Reduced volatility: ETFs inherently reduce the volatility of cryptocurrencies, which is a significant factor in attracting traders and investors to the market.
• Management fees: Crypto ETFs often come with high management fees, which can accumulate over time and impact overall returns.
• Tracking errors: The performance of an ETF may not always match the actual price movement of the underlying crypto assets due to management fees, transaction costs, or logistical issues.
• Regulatory uncertainty: The regulatory landscape for cryptocurrencies is still evolving, and changes in regulations can impact the legality, trading, and valuation of crypto assets, introducing uncertainty for investors.

The regulatory landscape

The US, for example, has seen a battle between users, issuers, businesses, and regulators in the court system. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has been regulating the sector, filing lawsuits and complaints against crypto-centric businesses such as Ripple, Coinbase, and Binance. However, the industry scored a partial victory in 2023 when a district court of appeals decided that Ripple's sale of XRP was only a securities offering when sold to institutions and not on exchanges.

In contrast, China has taken a hard line against cryptocurrencies, banning crypto enterprises from operating in the country and outlawing Bitcoin mining in May 2021. This forced many miners to close operations or relocate to other countries.

Other countries have adopted a more nuanced approach. Canada, for instance, does not consider Bitcoin legal tender but has approved a Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF). Crypto trading platforms in Canada must register with provincial regulators, and all crypto investment firms are classified as money service businesses (MSBs).

Japan has also taken a progressive approach, recognizing cryptocurrencies as legal property under the Payment Services Act. Crypto exchanges in the country must register with the Financial Services Agency and comply with anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing (AML/CFT) obligations.

The European Union has been at the forefront of regulating crypto, becoming the first to adopt measures requiring crypto service providers to detect and stop illicit cryptocurrency uses. The EU's Fifth and Sixth Anti-Money Laundering Directives have tightened Know Your Client (KYC) and AML/CFT obligations, and the EU has also proposed the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA) to increase consumer protections and establish explicit industry conduct guidelines.

As the market for cryptocurrencies continues to grow and mature, the regulatory landscape will likely become even more complex. Efforts to better define an appropriate regulatory regime may require legislative change, and the interplay between different regulatory bodies and jurisdictions will need to be carefully managed to avoid gaps and overlaps.

The future of crypto as a global currency

The future of cryptocurrency is uncertain, but it has the potential to become a global currency. Cryptocurrency has grown faster than ever in the last few years, with its value reaching over $1 trillion. This growth has been driven by increasing adoption among everyday consumers and institutional investors, as well as its decentralised nature, which allows for quick and anonymous transactions even across borders.

However, there are several challenges and risks associated with cryptocurrency that could hinder its widespread adoption and impact its future as a global currency. These include:

• Illicit activities and criminal usage: Cryptocurrency has been used by cybercriminals, drug cartels, money launderers, and terrorist organisations due to the anonymity it provides.
• Terrorism and sanctions evasion: Cryptocurrencies allow states to evade economic sanctions imposed by the US and other countries.
• Environmental concerns: Bitcoin mining, in particular, is an energy-intensive process that consumes more electricity than many countries, contributing to climate change.
• Volatility and lack of regulation: The rapid rise in value and the emergence of decentralised finance (DeFi) enterprises have resulted in billions of dollars in transactions occurring in an unregulated sector, raising concerns about fraud, tax evasion, and financial stability.
• Security breaches and technological threats: Cryptocurrency exchanges are vulnerable to hacking and other criminal activities, posing significant risks of capital loss for investors.
• Government regulations and restrictions: Some governments have embraced cryptocurrencies, while others have banned or restricted their use. The lack of consistent global regulations and the potential for government intervention create uncertainty for investors.

Despite these challenges, there are several factors that could contribute to the long-term growth and stability of cryptocurrencies:

• Increasing regulatory clarity: The US and other countries are developing legal frameworks and taxation systems for cryptocurrencies, which could increase consumer and institutional adoption.
• Technological advancements: The development of more investment instruments, such as options and futures on Bitcoin and Ethereum, and the emergence of stablecoins, which are linked to the value of fiat currencies, enhance the attractiveness of cryptocurrencies as an investment option.
• Institutional adoption: Major financial institutions, such as Block and PayPal, are making it easier to buy and sell cryptocurrencies on their platforms, providing greater accessibility and legitimacy to the market.
• Diversification benefits: Cryptocurrencies can provide positive diversification effects for investors, particularly against rising inflation.
• Global acceptance: El Salvador became the first country to adopt Bitcoin as legal tender in 2021, and an increasing number of retailers are likely to start accepting cryptocurrency payments, further mainstreaming its use.

In conclusion, while the future of cryptocurrency as a global currency is uncertain, its growing popularity, increasing regulatory acceptance, and technological advancements suggest that it could become a significant part of the global financial system. However, addressing the challenges and risks associated with its decentralised nature and anonymous usage will be crucial in determining its long-term success and widespread adoption.

Frequently asked questions