Housing Market: Safe Investment Or Risky Business?

Housing is the largest asset owned by most households, and it is a major means of wealth accumulation, particularly for the middle class. However, there is limited understanding of how households view housing as an investment relative to financial assets. Compared to other investment types, like stocks, annuities, and cryptocurrencies, real estate is widely considered a low-risk investment. However, some argue that the risk of single homeownership is close to the standard deviation of a traditional investment portfolio, and it provides a substantially lower investment return.

The overall housing market is safer than market investments

While the overall housing market is safer and less volatile than market investments, an individual home is far riskier than the overall housing market. Individual homeownership has some serious drawbacks, like location risk and illiquidity. A single home is not very liquid, as it can take months to sell.

Compared to other investment types, like stocks, annuities, and cryptocurrencies, real estate is widely considered a low-risk investment. Real estate investments often outperform other investment types over the long term, providing benefits that generally outweigh any risk. People will always need a place to live, so as a basic need, housing is an inelastic commodity, and is less affected by changes in economic conditions than more volatile investments like stocks.

However, the risk of single homeownership has an annual standard deviation of roughly 12%, which is close to the standard deviation of a traditional investment portfolio of 60% stocks and 40% bonds. This means that a home is not significantly safer than most investment portfolios, and it provides a substantially lower investment return. Historically, home equity mostly just keeps pace with inflation and provides no real return.

Housing represents the largest asset owned by most households and is a major means of wealth accumulation, particularly for the middle class. Housing offers households an accessible source of leverage and a commitment device for saving through an amortization schedule. For an owner-occupied residence, it also provides stability and hedges for rising housing costs.

Individual homeownership is riskier than the overall housing market

While the overall housing market is considered a safer investment than stocks, annuities, and cryptocurrencies, individual homeownership is far riskier than the overall housing market.

Individual homeownership has some serious drawbacks, like location risk and illiquidity. A single home is not very liquid, as it can take months to sell. It also requires more time to manage. The risk of single homeownership has an annual standard deviation of roughly 12%, which is close to the standard deviation of a traditional investment portfolio of 60% stocks and 40% bonds. This means that a home is not significantly safer than most investment portfolios, and it provides a substantially lower investment return.

Historically, home equity mostly just keeps pace with inflation and provides no real return. According to Professor Robert Shiller, one of the leading experts on housing prices in the United States, the real inflation-corrected prices of homes showed almost no change from 1890 to 1990, and showed losses in the 2000s.

However, housing offers households an accessible source of leverage and a commitment device for saving through an amortization schedule. For an owner-occupied residence, it also provides stability and hedges for rising housing costs.

Real estate is a low-risk investment compared to stocks, annuities, and cryptocurrencies

Real estate is widely considered a low-risk investment compared to stocks, annuities, and cryptocurrencies. While the overall housing market is safer and less volatile than market investments, an individual home is far riskier than the overall housing market. Individual homeownership has some serious drawbacks, like location risk and illiquidity.

Real estate investments often outperform other investment types over the long term, providing benefits that generally outweigh any risk. People will always need a place to live, so as a basic need, housing is an inelastic commodity. This means it is less affected by changes in economic conditions than more volatile investments like stocks.

Stocks are subject to unexpected changes in market conditions; they can see impressive growth overnight, but they can also steeply decline without warning. And, unlike real estate values, stock prices don’t always rebound. Even if the stock market, as a whole, recovers from a sudden drop, there is no guarantee that the stocks in your portfolio will bounce back.

Cryptocurrency is an investment of high risk and high reward. The volatility of the crypto market is too high a risk for most serious investors.

Because real estate is less risky than stocks, investors can make a greater absolute amount of money in real estate. This is due to the higher confidence a real estate investor has in investing more money in real estate due to lower risk. Real estate investors are also able to borrow more money to buy a more expensive investment due to lower risk.

Single homeownership has a similar risk to most investment portfolios

While the overall housing market is considered safer and less volatile than market investments, an individual home is far riskier than the overall housing market. Single homeownership has an annual standard deviation of roughly 12%, which is close to the standard deviation of a traditional investment portfolio of 60% stocks and 40% bonds. This means that a home is not significantly safer than most investment portfolios, and it provides a substantially lower investment return.

Historically, home equity has mostly just kept pace with inflation and provided no real return. According to Professor Robert Shiller, one of the leading experts on housing prices in the United States, the real inflation-corrected prices of homes showed almost no change from 1890 to 1990, and showed losses in the 2000s.

Individual homeownership has some serious drawbacks, like location risk and illiquidity. A single home is not very liquid, as it can take months to sell. However, housing offers households an accessible source of leverage and a commitment device for saving through an amortization schedule. For an owner-occupied residence, it also provides stability and hedges for rising housing costs.

Housing is a major means of wealth accumulation

Compared to other investment types, like stocks, annuities, and cryptocurrencies, real estate is widely considered a low-risk investment. People will always need a place to live, so housing is an inelastic commodity, less affected by changes in economic conditions than more volatile investments.

However, the risk of single homeownership has an annual standard deviation of roughly 12%, which is close to the standard deviation of a traditional investment portfolio of 60% stocks and 40% bonds. This means that a home is not significantly safer than most investment portfolios, and it provides a substantially lower investment return. Historically, home equity mostly just keeps pace with inflation and provides no real return.

There are also serious drawbacks to individual homeownership, like location risk and illiquidity. A single home is not very liquid, as it can take months to sell. For investors, there is also the risk of vacant rental units.

Despite these risks, housing can still be a good investment. While the overall housing market might be safer and less volatile than market investments, an individual home is far riskier than the overall housing market. For an owner-occupied residence, it also provides stability and hedges for rising housing costs.

Frequently asked questions