Commemorative Coins: Worthy Investment Or Costly Collectible?

Commemorative coins are produced to celebrate a special event, person, or place. They are distinct from standard minting as they are not typically recognised as legal tender and can be produced by private companies. While they are attractive items to have on display, commemorative coins are not always a good investment. They are usually sold as souvenirs and rarely enter everyday circulation. Their value is determined by a number of factors, including scarcity, demand, and purity. However, most commemorative coins fall short in these metrics, making them a poor investment when compared to true numismatic coinage.

Commemorative coins are not legal tender

Commemorative coins are often issued by various companies advertising themselves as "mints" while indirectly representing their coins as viable investments. They are beautifully designed and themed after admirable individuals, events in history, or landmarks, making them attractive to collectors. However, they may not be considered good investments.

Commemorative coins are not intended for general circulation and are therefore not legal tender. They are usually minted in limited numbers, making them valuable and more collectable. In the UK, for example, commemorative coins are issued by the Royal Mint to celebrate national events of significant importance, such as royal occasions like a Diamond Jubilee or Royal Wedding. While these coins are classed as legal tender under UK law, they are not accepted by banks, shops, or businesses for cash transactions. The term 'legal tender' only allows UK coins to be accepted for payment of debts in court.

In the United States, the US Mint has also minted numerous commemorative coins that are not intended for general circulation but are still legal tender. Commemorative medals produced by the US Mint are similar to coins but do not have a face value and are therefore not legal tender.

Commemorative coins are typically purchased for personal enjoyment or as attractive display items. Their value lies in their collectability, and they are often sought-after by collectors due to their limited numbers, aesthetic appeal, or rarity. However, they are not considered a good investment as they do not always appreciate in value.

It is important to understand the difference between commemorative coins and genuine numismatic coins. Numismatic coins, or rare coins made from pure precious metals, have an intrinsic value that tends to increase over time. They are a better investment option as they protect against stock market failures, wars, national debt, severe inflation, and the devaluation of paper money.

Commemorative coins are often gold-plated, not gold

Commemorative coins are often issued by companies advertising themselves as "mints" while indirectly representing their coins as viable investments. They are usually beautifully designed and themed after admirable individuals, momentous historical events, or landmarks, making them attractive to collectors. However, they may not be considered good investments due to various factors, including the fact that they are often gold-plated and not solid gold.

The word "gold" is powerful and persuasive and is used by companies selling commemorative coins to influence consumer behaviour. It is important for consumers to be aware that items marketed as gold commemorative coins are typically "gold-plated" and have a very thin layer of gold covering them. This gold layer is nearly imperceptible, and the cost of refining these items can exceed their actual worth. The same is true for "plated" or "layered" commemorative silver coins.

The media often plays a role in promoting these coins, with companies making various claims about their value and scarcity. For example, they may advertise that only a limited number of commemorative coins are available for purchase without disclosing how many have already been sold. This can create a false sense of urgency and lead to economic hardships for consumers who believe they are making a wise investment.

The certificates of authenticity included with some commemorative gold or silver coins should also be viewed with scepticism. These certificates are not officially affixed to the coins, allowing unscrupulous sellers to move them among different commemorative coin sets.

Therefore, while commemorative coins may have aesthetic appeal and provide personal enjoyment for collectors, they are not always a good investment. Their value can be unpredictable, and they may not appreciate over time. Instead, investing in numismatic or rare coins made from pure precious metals like gold or silver offers a more solid investment option, as these coins have intrinsic value and tend to increase in value during times of financial distress.

Advertisements for commemorative coins can be misleading

Firstly, commemorative coins are often advertised as "gold" or "silver" coins, but this is misleading. Typically, these coins are only "gold-plated" or "silver-plated", with a thin layer of gold or silver covering them that is nearly imperceptible. The cost of refining these items is often higher than their actual worth.

Radio, print media, and television remain largely unregulated in this market, allowing companies to make misleading claims and cleverly skirt the truth about the real values of commemorative coins. For example, advertisements may claim that only a limited number of coins are left for purchase, without disclosing how many have already been sold. This gives a false impression of scarcity and can mislead consumers into thinking they are making a valuable investment.

Additionally, the authenticity certificates included with commemorative coins may not be as meaningful as they seem. These certificates are not officially affixed to the coins, and unscrupulous sellers can move them among different commemorative coin sets.

The value of commemorative coins is often based more on their collectability than on any inherent worth. While gold and silver proof commemorative coins are minted in limited numbers and can be sought-after by collectors, their value can be unpredictable and subject to fluctuations in demand.

In summary, while commemorative coins may have aesthetic appeal and be attractive to collectors, their value as an investment can be misleading. It is important for consumers to carefully research and understand the true worth of these coins before making any purchases.

Commemorative coins are not a good investment

Firstly, commemorative coins are not considered legal tender and are often barred from circulation. This means that they do not have any intrinsic value as a medium of exchange. Banks, building societies, and shops are not obliged to accept commemorative coins, and you may struggle to find a secondary market for them.

Secondly, commemorative coins are often produced in high numbers, which can saturate the market and drive down their value. The demand for these coins tends to be highest right after their release, and it quickly drops off when the next collectible coin is released. As a result, you may find it challenging to sell your commemorative coins at a later date.

Thirdly, commemorative coins often contain very little gold or silver. They may be marketed as "gold" or "silver" coins, but in reality, they are often gold-plated or silver-plated, with a thin layer of these precious metals covering a base metal. This makes them costly to refine and may result in their value being lower than their production cost.

Additionally, the authenticity certificates that come with commemorative coins may not be worth much. These certificates are not officially affixed to the coins, and unscrupulous sellers may move them between different coin sets.

Finally, commemorative coins are geared towards collectors and those interested in historic memorabilia rather than serious investors. If you are looking for an investment that will optimise your return on investment and protect your wealth, you would be better off investing in genuine numismatic coins made from gold or silver, which have an intrinsic value as a precious metal.

Commemorative coins are collectible items

Commemorative coins are distinct from standard minting in that they are not always recognised as legal tender and can be produced by private companies rather than official government mints. This lack of regulation means that there is no standard purity rating for commemorative coins, making it difficult for investors to accurately gauge their value. Additionally, private sellers often overstate the value of commemorative coins, and the high dealer premiums mean that buyers may lose money immediately after purchase.

The value of commemorative coins is influenced by factors such as scarcity, demand, and purity. However, most commemorative coins fall short in these areas. They are often produced in high numbers, leading to a saturated market. Demand for these coins tends to peak right after their release and then quickly drops off as the next collectible coin captures the public's interest.

Furthermore, the allure of commemorative coins as investments is often based on misleading marketing. Companies selling commemorative coins may use persuasive language and clever advertising to influence consumer behaviour. For example, they may emphasise the limited availability of a particular coin without disclosing how many similar coins are already in circulation.

Overall, while commemorative coins may have value to collectors, they may not be considered a good investment option. Their value is largely based on collectability rather than intrinsic worth. If one is seeking to invest in coins with potential for appreciation, numismatic coins or genuine gold and silver rare coins may be a better choice.

Frequently asked questions