Etc Crypto: A Smart Investment Move?

Crypto exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are a more accessible way to invest in cryptocurrencies, allowing investors to gain exposure to these currencies through their regular brokerage accounts. Crypto ETFs can be a good investment option for those who want to avoid the complex or time-intensive world of digital wallets and crypto exchanges. However, it's important to note that investing in crypto ETFs carries risks, including the volatile nature of the crypto market and the evolving regulatory landscape. Before investing, it's advisable to understand the differences between crypto ETFs and direct investment in crypto, such as higher fees and less control over the digital assets.

Crypto ETFs vs direct investment in crypto

Crypto Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) are a convenient way to invest in cryptocurrency through your regular brokerage account, without the hassle of direct crypto ownership or storage. Crypto ETFs can be traded with the same ease as buying and selling stocks. They are traded on stock exchanges, tracking the prices of cryptocurrencies, either individually or in a group.

There are two types of Crypto ETFs:

• Spot Crypto ETFs: These ETFs track the price of a specific cryptocurrency by holding the actual coin. They are ideal for investors who want an easy way to invest in crypto without the complexities of owning and storing the currency.
• Crypto Futures ETFs: Futures ETFs do not directly hold cryptocurrency. Instead, they track cryptocurrency prices through futures contracts, which are based on speculation on the future price of the currency.

Benefits of Crypto ETFs

• Simplicity: For most investors, buying shares in an ETF is far simpler than buying and holding crypto directly.
• Security: An ETF doesn’t require you to own any cryptocurrency, so there is less exposure to hacking risk or loss.
• Diversification: Crypto ETFs make it easier to gain exposure to several cryptocurrencies, enabling you to diversify within the crypto world.

Drawbacks of Crypto ETFs

• Fees: Investing in a crypto ETF tends to be more expensive than buying cryptocurrency directly. Crypto ETFs have higher expense ratios than other ETFs.
• Lack of ownership: You won't own the crypto directly, and even the fund might not if it’s a crypto futures ETF.
• Less control: You rely on the fund manager’s strategies, so more complex or precise strategies are unavailable.
• Volatility: The crypto market is highly volatile, and unregulated.
• Limited trading hours: You can only buy and sell ETFs during regular market hours, whereas crypto exchanges often run 24 hours a day.

Direct Investment in Crypto

Directly investing in crypto gives you more control and enables you to buy or sell precisely the amount of each coin you select. It also has lower costs and allows you to trade at all hours of the day. However, buying crypto directly can be complicated and time-intensive, especially for those who are new to crypto or investing in general.

For many investors, the simplicity and ease of crypto ETFs outweigh the drawbacks. However, crypto enthusiasts who are knowledgeable about the market and comfortable with the complexities may prefer to buy crypto directly. Before investing in either option, it is important to do your own research and understand the risks involved.

Regulatory considerations

The regulatory landscape for crypto is ever-changing, and these changes can significantly impact the performance and availability of crypto investments. The legality of cryptocurrency is still not settled in some jurisdictions, and the regulatory environment varies widely across countries. Some nations have prohibited the issuance or holding of crypto assets, while others have actively sought to attract companies in this space. This fragmented global response has resulted in a race to the bottom, with crypto entities migrating to jurisdictions with the most relaxed regulatory requirements.

The regulatory considerations for crypto investors are multi-faceted. Firstly, the lack of central authority in cryptocurrencies can pose legal and financial risks to owners. The absence of a central governing body means that investors may face legal complications and limited recourse in the event of transaction issues or ownership disputes. Additionally, the decentralised nature of cryptocurrencies has led to concerns about fraud, money laundering, and other financial crimes. Regulatory agencies and tax authorities are still working to understand the complex dynamics of this new asset class.

From a tax perspective, cryptocurrency investors need to stay apprised of evolving government pronouncements. In the US, the IRS has classified cryptocurrencies as property, subjecting investors to capital gains tax laws. Cryptocurrency profits are taxable, and the wise investor should consider reporting their holdings as foreign assets. The specific reporting requirements, such as the need to file FinCEN Form 114, remain unclear and are actively debated. Given the severe penalties for non-compliance, consulting a tax professional familiar with cryptocurrency is essential.

The regulatory considerations also extend to businesses accepting cryptocurrencies as payment. While registration and licensing requirements are typically mandated for financial institutions, the evolving legal status of cryptocurrencies creates ambiguity for businesses operating in this space. Business owners and managers must ensure they comply with proper legal procedures, including protection against money laundering and fraud, at both the local and state levels.

The regulatory landscape for crypto is a dynamic and complex arena. Investors must remain vigilant and informed about the changing regulations and their potential impact on their investments.

Pros and cons of crypto ETFs

Crypto ETFs, or exchange-traded funds, are a way to invest in cryptocurrencies using traditional market instruments. They are traded on traditional exchanges like the NYSE or Nasdaq, rather than on a cryptocurrency exchange. Crypto ETFs can be an attractive option for investors who are familiar with stock assets but are hesitant to enter the crypto market directly. Here are some of the pros and cons of investing in crypto ETFs:

Pros of Crypto ETFs:

• Simplicity and Familiarity: Crypto ETFs are easier to invest in than cryptocurrencies. They can be bought, sold, and held using traditional brokerage accounts, eliminating the need for setting up digital wallets and understanding technical aspects such as private and public keys. This simplicity makes crypto investments more accessible to a wider range of investors.
• Regulation and Security: Crypto ETFs are issued by regulated companies, reducing the risk of fraud, scandals, or collapses associated with direct crypto investments. The regulation also adds transparency and credibility to the industry. Additionally, since ETFs are traded on traditional exchanges, they are highly regulated, providing protection against price manipulation within the ETF markets.
• Diversification and Risk Mitigation: Crypto ETFs hold a basket of digital tokens and currencies, providing diversification and reducing the impact of losses if a specific currency's price drops. This diversification also minimises the risk of hacking attacks and theft, as the ETFs don't directly hold any crypto assets.
• Tax Efficiency: In some countries, crypto ETFs are regulated by governments, making them eligible for investments through government-regulated tax plans, such as retirement savings plans and tax-free savings accounts. This unlocks tax efficiency benefits for investors.

Cons of Crypto ETFs:

• Loss of Independence: One of the main advantages of cryptocurrencies is their independence from financial regulators. However, with crypto ETFs, the cryptocurrencies become as controlled as any traditional asset supervised by governments, which goes against the idea of an alternative financial platform.
• Reduced Volatility: ETFs inherently reduce the volatility of the underlying cryptocurrencies. Volatility is an attractive feature for traders and investors in the crypto market, and its reduction may be seen as a disadvantage.
• Tracking Error: Crypto ETFs may not always accurately track the price movements of the underlying cryptocurrencies. This discrepancy, known as tracking error, can occur due to management fees, transaction costs, or logistical issues. As a result, the value of the ETF may not directly match the exact current value of the cryptocurrencies it tracks.
• Regulatory Uncertainty: The regulatory landscape for cryptocurrencies is still evolving, with authorities worldwide implementing new regulations. Changes in regulations can impact the legality, trading, and valuation of crypto assets, introducing uncertainty for investors in crypto ETFs.
• Cost: Crypto ETFs often come with management fees, which can be relatively high compared to regular ETFs. These costs can add up over time and impact the overall returns of the investment.

Types of crypto ETFs

Crypto ETFs, or cryptocurrency exchange-traded funds, are a type of exchange-traded product that enables investors to add crypto exposure to their investment portfolios. They are traded on exchanges and held in traditional brokerage accounts. Crypto ETFs can be broadly classified into single-asset, multi-asset, and industry ETFs, with 'spot' and 'futures' ETFs as further subdivisions.

Single-asset crypto ETFs focus on one type of cryptocurrency, such as Bitcoin or Ethereum, providing direct and concentrated exposure to the price movements of a specific digital asset. These ETFs are suitable for investors with a strong belief in the future performance of a particular cryptocurrency.

Multi-asset crypto ETFs, on the other hand, invest in various digital assets, spreading the risk across different cryptocurrencies. This diversification helps mitigate the impact of poor performance by a single asset on the overall portfolio.

Crypto industry ETFs focus on companies operating in the crypto industry rather than the cryptocurrencies themselves. These include centralised crypto exchange providers, Bitcoin mining operators, and tech companies adopting crypto or blockchain-based solutions.

Spot ETFs directly hold the underlying cryptocurrency, such as Bitcoin or Ethereum, and their value closely follows the spot price of these assets. While offering direct exposure to cryptocurrency prices, spot ETFs also carry the risks associated with the highly volatile crypto market.

Futures ETFs, on the other hand, invest in futures contracts on the digital asset. These contracts are agreements to buy or sell the cryptocurrency at a predetermined price and future date. Futures ETFs provide exposure to cryptocurrency price movements without requiring the fund to hold the underlying asset, potentially reducing risks related to custody and security.

When choosing between spot and futures crypto ETFs, investors consider factors such as their desire for a direct link to the cryptocurrency market and their outlook on immediate price trends. Spot ETFs appeal to those seeking a direct connection, while futures ETFs offer a buffer from day-to-day price changes.

Some examples of crypto ETFs include the BetaShares Crypto Innovators ETF (CRYP), the Global X 21Shares Bitcoin ETF (EBTC), and the Global X 21Shares Ethereum ETF (EETH).

Crypto ETFs vs buying crypto directly

Crypto ETFs vs. Buying Crypto Directly

When it comes to investing in crypto, there are two main options: crypto ETFs and buying crypto directly. But which option is the best for you? Let's take a detailed look at the pros and cons of each to help you decide.

Crypto ETFs

Crypto Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) are a type of exchange-traded product that enables investors to add crypto exposure to their investment portfolios. Crypto ETFs are traded on exchanges and held in traditional brokerage accounts, just like typical ETFs. There are two main types of crypto ETFs:

• Spot Crypto ETFs: These ETFs invest directly in cryptocurrency and trade on behalf of investors. For example, a spot Bitcoin ETF buys bitcoins and stores them on behalf of investors.
• Crypto Futures ETFs: These ETFs do not hold digital tokens. Instead, they invest in crypto futures contracts, which are agreements to buy or sell a specific quantity of crypto at a preset price on a future date.

Pros of Crypto ETFs

• Simplicity and Convenience: Investing in crypto ETFs is generally simpler and more convenient than buying crypto directly. With crypto ETFs, you can skip the complex process of setting up a crypto wallet and navigating crypto exchanges. You can simply buy and sell shares in crypto ETFs from your regular brokerage account.
• Diversification: Crypto ETFs make it easier to diversify your investments across multiple cryptocurrencies, reducing the risk associated with investing in a single crypto coin.
• Security: Crypto ETFs do not require you to own or store any cryptocurrency directly, reducing the risk of hacking or loss compared to holding crypto in a wallet.
• Professional Fund Management: Crypto ETFs are managed by professional fund managers, which can be beneficial in the complex and rapidly evolving crypto space.

Cons of Crypto ETFs

• Fees: Crypto ETFs tend to have higher fees than buying crypto directly. You may need to pay brokerage trade fees and the fund's expense ratio, which can range from 0.39% to 1.5%.
• Lack of Ownership: With crypto ETFs, you don't directly own the underlying crypto assets. Even in a crypto futures ETF, the fund itself may not hold any digital tokens.
• Limited Trading Hours: Unlike cryptocurrencies, which can be traded 24/7, crypto ETFs can typically only be bought and sold during regular market hours.
• Regulation: The crypto market is largely unregulated, and the funds themselves are subject to the regulations of the exchanges they trade on. This may be seen as a positive or negative, depending on your perspective.

Buying Crypto Directly

Buying crypto directly involves purchasing and holding cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, Ethereum, or Solana on a crypto exchange or through a broker.

Pros of Buying Crypto Directly

• Higher Potential Gains: Cryptocurrencies are highly volatile, which means there is a potential for higher gains (and losses) compared to crypto ETFs.
• Volatility: Market volatility can be attractive to investors, as it presents more opportunities for profit. Crypto ETFs, on the other hand, aim to reduce volatility.
• Lower Fees: Buying crypto directly typically involves lower fees than investing in crypto ETFs.
• Direct Ownership and Control: When you buy crypto directly, you have full ownership and control over your digital assets, including the ability to trade and exchange them as you wish.
• 24/7 Trading: Cryptocurrencies can be traded at any time, unlike crypto ETFs, which are subject to market hours.

Cons of Buying Crypto Directly

• Complexity: Buying and holding crypto directly can be complex and time-consuming, especially for those new to the space.
• Security Risks: Cryptocurrencies are vulnerable to cyber attacks, fraud, and security issues associated with digital wallets.
• Regulatory Concerns: The legality of cryptocurrency is not settled in all jurisdictions, and there is a risk of major regulatory changes that could impact the value of your investments.

Both crypto ETFs and buying crypto directly have their advantages and disadvantages. Crypto ETFs offer simplicity, diversification, and professional management but come with higher fees and less direct ownership. On the other hand, buying crypto directly provides direct ownership, lower fees, and the potential for higher gains, but it is more complex and carries higher security and regulatory risks. Ultimately, the best option for you will depend on your investment goals, risk tolerance, and level of comfort with cryptocurrencies.

Frequently asked questions