Cash Or Invest: The Great Car Buying Dilemma

Paying cash for a car has its pros and cons. On the one hand, you avoid paying interest, stay within budget, and own the car outright. On the other hand, you may miss out on opportunities to build your credit score and take advantage of dealer incentives. So, should you pay cash or invest it?

Well, it depends on your financial situation and goals. If you have the cash to buy a car outright, you could still take out a car loan and use that money for other things, such as investing in stocks or mutual funds, which could yield a higher return than the interest on the loan. However, if you have other high-interest debt, such as credit card debt, it might be better to use your cash to pay that off first.

Ultimately, the decision to pay cash or invest depends on your personal financial situation and your attitude towards debt. If you value financial freedom and peace of mind, paying cash for a car might be the best option. But if you're comfortable with debt and want to keep your savings invested, then a car loan could be a better deal.

Investing your money could yield a better return than the interest on a car loan

When deciding whether to pay cash or take out a loan for a car, it's important to consider the potential return on your money. While paying cash for a car can have its benefits, such as avoiding interest charges and owning the car outright, investing your money could potentially yield a better return.

One key factor to consider is the opportunity cost of using your cash savings. By investing your money instead of paying cash for a car, you may be able to generate a higher return on your investment than the interest rate on a car loan. This is especially true if you can secure a low-interest loan. For example, if you invest in a mutual fund with a historical rate of return of 10% and your car loan's APR is 5%, you could effectively achieve a 5% return on your savings as you pay off your loan.

Additionally, financing a car can provide you with more financial flexibility. By spreading out the cost of the vehicle over time, you may be able to invest your savings or spend them on other financial priorities, such as paying down high-interest debt or saving for retirement. This can be especially beneficial if you have other financial goals that you want to achieve, such as investing in a home or building an investment portfolio.

Furthermore, financing a car can help you build your credit history. Making consistent, on-time payments on an auto loan can improve your credit score, which can be beneficial if you plan to make other major purchases or apply for loans in the future. A stronger credit history can also help you secure lower interest rates on future loans, saving you money in the long run.

However, it's important to remember that financing a car is not always the best option for everyone. If you have the financial means to pay cash for a car without depleting your savings or affecting your financial goals, it may still be the best choice. Additionally, if the interest rate on the loan is higher than what you could reasonably expect to earn by investing your money, paying cash may be a more cost-effective option.

Ultimately, the decision to pay cash or invest your money and take out a loan for a car depends on your financial situation, goals, and tolerance for debt. It's essential to carefully consider the benefits and drawbacks of each option before making a decision.

Paying in cash means you own the car outright

Another benefit of paying in cash is that you avoid paying interest. In most cases, the total interest paid on a car loan over several years can amount to thousands of dollars. By paying in cash, you can save a considerable amount of money that would have gone towards interest charges.

Paying in cash can also help you stay within your budget. When you pay the entire cost of the car upfront, you are less likely to overspend. It is easier to stick to your budget and ensure that you are not spending more than you can afford.

Additionally, paying in cash can give you more negotiating power. Dealers may be more willing to offer discounts or special deals to buyers paying in cash. Flashing actual cash can give your offer legitimacy and make it harder for the dealer to refuse.

Finally, paying in cash means you won't have to worry about monthly payments. This can be a significant advantage if you suddenly lose your job or encounter unexpected expenses. Not having a car payment can provide financial flexibility and peace of mind.

You can build your credit history by financing a car

Whether you should pay cash or finance a car depends on your financial situation, goals, and attitude towards debt. If you have the means, paying cash for a car can help you save money and avoid interest charges. However, financing a car can also have its benefits, including the opportunity to build your credit history.

Diversifying Your Credit Mix

Adding an auto loan to your credit portfolio can positively affect your credit score. Credit scoring models consider how well you manage different types of credit, including installment credit (e.g. student loans and mortgages) and revolving credit (e.g. credit cards and lines of credit). Your credit mix accounts for 10% of your FICO score. By including an auto loan in your credit mix, you can demonstrate your ability to handle different types of credit responsibly.

Improving Payment History

Your payment history is a significant factor in determining your credit score, accounting for 35% of your FICO score. Making regular and timely payments on your auto loan can improve your credit standing over time. Setting up automated bill payments can help you avoid late payments and protect your credit score. Consistent on-time payments can help increase your credit score in the long run.

Length of Credit History

The length of your credit history also matters when it comes to building credit. Older accounts are generally viewed more favourably, so it's advisable to keep your oldest credit accounts open, even if you're not actively using them. Taking out an auto loan can help extend your credit history, especially if you don't have other long-standing loans or credit cards.

Impact of Hard Inquiries

When you apply for an auto loan, lenders typically perform a hard credit check, which can cause a slight drop in your credit score initially. However, this impact is usually short-lived, and multiple inquiries from auto loan applications within a short timeframe are typically combined and counted as one inquiry. Your credit score should rebound and improve as you make timely payments on your loan.

Building Credit Without Taking on Debt

If you're averse to taking on debt, it's important to know that there are other ways to build your credit history without taking out an auto loan. Maintaining one or two credit cards, making timely payments, and keeping your credit utilization ratio below 20% can all contribute to building a solid credit history. Additionally, becoming an authorized user on a friend or relative's credit card can help you inherit their positive credit history.

Paying in cash can give you more power in negotiations

When it comes to buying a car, you can either finance it with a loan or pay in cash. While financing a car has its benefits, paying in cash can give you more power in negotiations. Here's how:

No Monthly Payments

One of the biggest advantages of paying cash for a car is that you won't have to worry about monthly loan payments. For many, this obligation can be overwhelming, and it's much easier to pay cash and be done with the purchase. If you're someone who dislikes debt, this option gives you the freedom of owning something outright.

No Interest Payments

When you take out a loan to buy a car, you have to pay interest on top of the car payments. By the time you've finished paying off the loan, you would have paid a significant amount in interest, increasing the car's final price. Paying in cash helps you avoid this extra cost, making it the smarter financial choice.

Savings

Paying for a car in cash can often lead to savings. Private sellers, in particular, may be happy to accept a lower price if it means a quick transaction and less paperwork. Additionally, dealerships may be more open to negotiating a better deal when you pay in cash, as it simplifies the process and reduces their closing costs and man-hours.

Freedom to Negotiate

As a cash buyer, you have more room to negotiate, even when dealing with a salesperson at a dealership. This leverage can be especially useful if you're doing a trade-in and want to get a good deal on your next car. Since dealerships prefer financing due to the potential for commissions and extras, keeping your payment method a secret until the last minute can help you get a better price.

Fewer Open Accounts on Your Credit Report

Taking out a loan for a car will impact your credit report and may skew your debt-to-income ratio. If you're planning to take out a mortgage or start a business soon, it's crucial to maintain a good credit score. Paying in cash bypasses the credit bureau, keeping your score unaffected.

While paying in cash has its advantages, it's important to consider your financial situation and goals before deciding. Paying in cash may not be the best option if you're looking to build credit or take advantage of financing deals and incentives. Additionally, it can be a drain on your savings account, so ensure you have sufficient funds for emergencies and other expenses.

Financing a car can help you preserve your savings

Financing a car instead of paying in cash can help you preserve your savings in several ways. Firstly, it allows you to spread out the cost of the vehicle over time, making it more manageable for your budget. Instead of a large one-off payment, you can make smaller, fixed monthly payments that fit within your cash flow. This helps you avoid depleting your savings account and leaves you with money in the bank for other purposes, such as unexpected expenses or other investment opportunities.

Secondly, financing a car can free up your cash for investments that may provide a higher return than simply keeping your money in a low-interest-bearing account. For example, if you invest in a mutual fund with a 10% annual rate of return and take out a car loan with a 5% APR, you can effectively achieve a 5% return on your savings as you pay off the loan.

Additionally, financing a car can help you build your credit score. Making consistent, on-time payments on an auto loan can improve your credit history and demonstrate that you are a reliable borrower. This can be beneficial if you plan to make other significant purchases, such as a home or business, that require a strong credit score to secure financing.

Moreover, financing a car may allow you to purchase a better-quality vehicle. With financing, you may be able to afford a more modern and reliable car that requires less maintenance and repair work, ultimately saving you money in the long run.

Finally, financing a car can provide you with negotiation power and added extras that may not be available if you pay in cash. Dealers often prefer financing deals as they can benefit from commissions and incentives associated with car loans. By financing your car, you can take advantage of these incentives and potentially unlock extras from your dealer.

Frequently asked questions