Pay Off The House Or Invest: The Barefoot Investor's Guide To Financial Freedom

Whether to pay off your house or invest is a common dilemma, and the answer depends on your financial situation, risk tolerance, and life goals. On the one hand, paying off your mortgage early can provide peace of mind, reduce interest costs, and build home equity faster. On the other hand, investing offers the potential for higher returns, liquidity, and tax benefits. Let's explore both options to help you make an informed decision.

Paying off a mortgage early: pros and cons

The decision to pay off your mortgage early or invest depends on your finances, risk tolerance, and financial goals. Here are some pros and cons of paying off your mortgage early to help you make an informed decision.

Pros of paying off your mortgage early:

• Interest savings: You could save thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars in interest payments by paying off your loan early. These interest savings are a guaranteed return on your investment.
• Peace of mind: Being debt-free can ease your financial burden and provide a sense of security. If you experience financial difficulties, having a paid-off home means you don't have to worry about missing mortgage payments and potential foreclosure.
• Build equity faster: Paying down your mortgage quicker increases the equity in your home, which can help you qualify for refinancing at better rates. This built-up equity can also be leveraged for home equity loans or lines of credit, enabling you to make improvements to your home or pay off other high-interest debt.

Cons of paying off your mortgage early:

• Opportunity cost: Paying off your mortgage early means you have less money available for other financial goals, such as retirement savings or emergency funds. You may be sacrificing higher-return investment opportunities.
• Wealth is tied up: Real estate is an illiquid asset, meaning it can't be quickly or easily converted into cash. If you need funds for financial emergencies or investment opportunities, selling your house would take time and depend on finding a buyer.
• Loss of tax breaks: Paying down your mortgage instead of maximising tax-advantaged retirement accounts means giving up certain tax benefits. Additionally, if you normally itemise deductions, you may lose out on tax deductions for mortgage interest.

Ultimately, the decision to pay off your mortgage early or invest depends on your individual circumstances, risk tolerance, and financial priorities. Consult a financial advisor to help you weigh your options and make a decision that aligns with your goals and risk profile.

Investing: pros and cons

Investing your money instead of paying off your mortgage early has its benefits and drawbacks. Here are some of the main ones to consider:

Pros

• Higher returns: The stock market has, over time, yielded higher returns than paying off a mortgage early.
• Liquid investment: Stocks, bonds, and other market investments can be easily sold and accessed if you need the money.
• Employer match: Investing in a retirement account may come with benefits like employer matching and tax breaks.

Cons

• Higher risk: The stock market is more volatile than the housing market, so you need to be sure your investing timeline is long enough to weather any downturns.
• Increased debt: If you invest your money, you will still have mortgage debt to your name.
• Potential loss: There is always a risk that you could lose some or all of your money if you invest it.

Whether you choose to pay off your mortgage or invest depends on your financial situation, risk tolerance, and how much debt you are comfortable with.

The best of both worlds: refinancing and investing

If you're unsure about whether to prioritise paying off your mortgage or investing, you can always do both. This strategy can be particularly attractive in the early years of your mortgage, when small contributions can make a big difference to the interest you'll ultimately pay.

Mortgage rates are currently at a historic low, so it's a great time to refinance. If you took out your mortgage or last refinanced years ago, you'll probably be able to save a significant amount of money by refinancing to a lower interest rate or a shorter mortgage term. Be sure to factor in closing costs when running the numbers.

With the money you save through refinancing, you can then invest. This allows you to reduce the amount you spend on your mortgage overall, while still taking advantage of the higher returns of the stock market.

Before making any significant investment decisions, it's a good idea to consult a financial advisor to discuss the best moves for your portfolio and financial goals.

Factors to consider

When deciding whether to invest or pay off a mortgage, consider the following:

• Do I have sufficient emergency savings?
• Am I putting away enough for retirement?
• How much other debt do I carry?
• What are my prospects for increasing my income?
• What moves (if any) am I looking to make in the next year, or in five years?
• How does my mortgage rate compare to expected portfolio returns?

The economic climate

Mortgage interest rates are influenced by the economy, and these rates have an impact on the decision to pay off a mortgage early or invest. In recent years, mortgage rates have been at historic lows, making it cheaper to hold debt. This economic climate favours investing over early repayment of a mortgage, as the opportunity to generate higher returns through investments is more favourable when interest rates are low.

However, as of 2024, interest rates have increased, in some cases more than doubling since 2020-2021. This shift in the economic climate changes the dynamics of the decision. With higher interest rates, the potential returns from investing become less attractive compared to the interest cost of holding a mortgage. As a result, paying off the mortgage early becomes a more appealing option in this economic climate.

Another factor to consider is the performance of the stock market. The stock market has historically provided strong returns, but it is subject to volatility and fluctuations. In a favourable economic climate with a strong stock market, investing may be more appealing, especially if the potential returns exceed the interest cost of a mortgage. However, in times of market volatility or downward trends, paying down a mortgage may be a safer option to avoid the risk of investment losses.

Additionally, the tax implications of mortgage interest deductions can be influenced by the economic climate and tax policies. In some cases, mortgage interest is tax-deductible, which can make holding a mortgage more attractive. Changes in tax laws or economic conditions that impact these deductions can shift the decision-making process.

In summary, the economic climate, including interest rates, stock market performance, and tax policies, are crucial factors in deciding whether to pay off a mortgage early or invest. The decision should be evaluated based on the specific economic conditions at the time, as well as an individual's financial situation and risk tolerance.

Factors to consider: emergency savings, retirement, debt, income, and market conditions

When deciding whether to pay off your house or invest, there are several factors to consider, including emergency savings, retirement, debt, income, and market conditions.

Emergency Savings

Having a buffer of savings to fall back on in case of unexpected expenses or financial difficulties is crucial. This emergency fund can provide peace of mind and help you avoid taking on additional debt. It is recommended to have at least three months' worth of living expenses set aside in a high-interest savings account or a mortgage offset account. This ensures that you have some financial security and are not completely reliant on debt to cover short-term expenses.

Retirement

Saving for retirement is another important consideration. The earlier you start saving for retirement, the more time your investments have to grow and benefit from compound interest. Retirement savings in tax-advantaged accounts, such as an IRA or 401(k), can provide tax benefits and help you maximize your savings. It is essential to weigh the opportunity cost of paying off your mortgage early versus investing in your retirement, as the money used to pay off your mortgage could potentially earn higher returns if invested.

Debt

The nature of your mortgage debt is also a factor to consider. If you have a high-interest mortgage, it may be more beneficial to pay it off early to reduce the overall interest burden. On the other hand, if you have a low-interest mortgage, investing your money elsewhere may be a better option, as you can potentially earn higher returns. Additionally, consider the tax implications of mortgage interest deductions, which can reduce your taxable income.

Income

Your income and financial circumstances play a significant role in your decision. If you have received a windfall or have extra money each month, you may consider investing it or using it to pay off your mortgage early. However, it is crucial to ensure that paying off your mortgage early does not come at the expense of your other financial goals, such as retirement savings or emergency funds.

Market Conditions

Market conditions and investment risks should also be considered. Investing in the stock market or other financial markets can potentially provide higher returns than paying off your mortgage early, but it also carries the risk of losses. Different investments come with different levels of risk, and it is important to assess your risk tolerance and investment timeline. While historical market returns can provide guidance, it is essential to remember that past performance does not guarantee future results.

In conclusion, when deciding whether to pay off your house or invest, it is crucial to consider emergency savings, retirement planning, the nature of your debt, your income, and market conditions. Seeking advice from a financial planner or advisor can help you make an informed decision based on your specific circumstances and goals.

Frequently asked questions