Debt Mutual Funds: Worth The Investment Risk?

Debt mutual funds are a type of mutual fund that invests in fixed-income instruments such as government and corporate bonds, treasury bills, and commercial paper. They are also known as fixed-income funds or bond funds. While debt funds are not entirely different from other mutual fund schemes in terms of operation, they score higher in terms of safety of capital. They are ideal for investors who aim for regular income but are risk-averse.

Debt funds are less volatile and, therefore, less risky than equity funds. They are also tax-efficient compared to fixed deposits, especially for investors in higher tax brackets with an investment horizon of more than three years. Debt funds are a good option for those with short-term financial goals of one to three years.

However, it is important to note that debt funds are vulnerable to interest rate risk, and long-term debt funds may give negative returns when interest rates are rising. Additionally, credit risk funds, which invest in lower-rated bonds, carry the risk of losing money if the bond issuer defaults on repayments.

Debt funds vs fixed deposits

Debt Mutual Funds vs Fixed Deposits

Fixed Deposits (FDs) have traditionally been a popular investment vehicle for households, particularly in India. However, in recent times, there has been a shift towards debt mutual funds. When deciding between the two, it is essential to understand the key differences and how they align with your investment goals.

Fixed Deposits

FDs are a type of savings account offered by banks and financial institutions, providing a fixed interest rate and maturity date. They are typically considered low-risk investments, suitable for those seeking fixed returns on their savings. FDs offer guaranteed returns with minimal risk and are not associated with market volatility. Most FDs allow early withdrawals, although this may incur a penalty charge. Additionally, FDs do not impose management costs.

Debt Mutual Funds

Debt mutual funds, on the other hand, invest in fixed-income securities such as bonds and debentures. They offer the potential for higher returns than FDs but also carry more risk. The returns on debt funds are subject to market fluctuations and are not guaranteed. Debt funds are suitable for individuals seeking higher returns than FDs and are willing to accept a higher risk. Debt funds offer flexibility, as investors can redeem their investments at any time, although an exit load may be imposed by some fund houses. Debt funds may also charge nominal expense ratios for handling the funds.

Comparing Returns and Risks

While FDs provide guaranteed returns, debt funds have historically outperformed FDs of similar tenures. Debt funds have the potential to generate moderate to high returns, depending on the overall interest rate movement. During periods of low-interest rates, debt funds can significantly outperform FDs. However, it is important to note that debt funds are subject to market risks, including interest rate risk and credit risk.

Tax Implications

When comparing tax implications, FDs are taxed during the tenure of the investment and on maturity, according to the investor's income tax slab. On the other hand, debt funds offer tax advantages, especially for investors in higher tax brackets. Short-term capital gains in debt funds (investments held for less than 36 months) are taxed similarly to FDs, while long-term capital gains (investments held for more than 36 months) are taxed at a lower rate of 20% with indexation benefits.

Suitability

The suitability of FDs versus debt funds depends on your investment goals, risk appetite, and time horizon. If capital safety and assured returns are paramount, FDs are the preferred option. However, if you are willing to accept some risk and seek potentially higher returns, debt mutual funds can be a good choice. Additionally, debt funds offer the advantage of transparency, as fund portfolios are disclosed monthly, providing complete information on instrument names, credit ratings, and exposures.

In conclusion, both FDs and debt mutual funds have their advantages and disadvantages. FDs offer guaranteed returns and low risk but may provide lower overall returns. Debt funds offer the potential for higher returns but carry market risks. The decision between the two depends on your investment objectives, risk tolerance, and time horizon.

Taxation on debt mutual funds

The tax rate on debt funds is determined by the investor's income tax slab. The short-term capital gains tax rate is 20%, and the long-term capital gains tax rate is now a flat 12.5%, but without any indexation benefits.

Debt mutual funds are classified based on their underlying investments. To qualify as a debt fund, a fund must hold at least 65% of its portfolio in bonds or money market instruments. The tax implications for debt funds depend on the holding period.

For funds purchased before April 1, 2023, short-term (up to 36 months) gains are taxed at the investor's ordinary income tax rate, while long-term gains are taxed at a concessional rate of 20% with indexation benefits. However, after April 1, 2023, all debt fund gains, regardless of holding period, are treated as short-term and taxed at the ordinary income tax rate, which can be up to 30%. This change simplifies tax treatment but may impact long-term investment strategies.

Dividends from debt funds were previously tax-free in the hands of investors because the fund house paid Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT). However, since the DDT was abolished in Budget 2020, dividends are now added to the total income of investors and taxed as per the applicable slab rate.

Capital gains from debt funds were previously classified as long-term or short-term gains based on the period over which the units were held before the sale. If the debt mutual fund unit was sold within 36 months (three years) of purchase, the gains were considered short-term capital gains (STCG) and taxed at slab rates. However, if they were sold after 36 months, the gains were considered long-term capital gains (LTCG) and taxed at 20% with an indexation benefit.

Indexation is the process of adjusting the investment amount or purchase price to account for inflation. The cost of acquisition is adjusted or indexed using the relevant Cost Inflation Index (CII) before the tax on debt mutual funds is calculated.

The Finance Bill 2023 eliminated the indexation benefit on debt mutual funds, and they will now be taxed at investor's slab rates, aligning with fixed deposit taxation. The change may affect mutual fund houses and investors.

Inflation adaptability of debt mutual funds

Debt mutual funds are a good way to diversify your portfolio and protect it from the volatility of the stock market. They are also a good option for short-term financial goals. While debt funds are considered a relatively safe investment, they are not immune to the effects of inflation. However, they do have the potential to keep pace with inflation.

For example, if you have invested in a fixed deposit at 6% interest and the inflation rate is 5%, the adjusted return would be just 1%. Debt funds may deliver relatively higher returns, with liquid funds offering an average of 2% pa more than inflation over the past 19 years.

It is important to note that the incremental returns from liquid funds can be eliminated if you pay tax on the returns. Additionally, if your holding period is less than three years, taxes will eat away at all the incremental returns. However, if you hold for more than three years and take advantage of indexation, you can expect to make some returns above inflation.

When considering debt mutual funds, it is crucial to keep in mind that their performance is closely tied to interest rate movements. In a low-interest-rate economy, debt funds tend to outperform fixed deposits by a considerable margin.

In summary, debt mutual funds can be a good way to adapt to inflation, but it is important to consider their performance in the context of interest rates and your overall investment goals and time horizon.

Debt funds and interest rates

Debt funds are a type of mutual fund that generates returns by lending money to governments and companies. The interest rates on these loans determine the return on debt instruments. When interest rates rise, the value of debt funds and other instruments falls. Conversely, when interest rates fall, the value of debt funds rises. This is because the interest rate on old bonds remains high compared to the new bonds or funds that are floated.

The relationship between bond prices and interest rates is an inverse one. When interest rates fall below the coupon rate, the bond looks more attractive as it carries a higher interest rate than is currently available in the market. This increases demand and pushes prices up. Conversely, if interest rates rise, these bonds become less attractive and their prices fall due to lower demand.

Debt funds are considered a good investment option when an investor wants to preserve their capital and earn better post-tax returns than FDs. They are also a good option for near-term goals. Overnight funds and liquid funds are examples of debt funds with extremely low risk.

Debt funds are also classified based on the type of bonds they invest in. Liquid funds invest in very short-maturity debt instruments, while short-term and medium-term funds invest in bonds maturing from one to seven years. Long-term funds invest in bonds with maturities of seven to ten years or more.

When deciding whether to invest in debt funds, it is important to consider the investment horizon and lending duration. Debt funds are generally considered for investment horizons of one day to up to three years. They offer better post-tax returns compared to FDs if the investor stays invested for at least three years.

Debt funds vs equity funds

Debt funds and equity funds are two of the most important types of mutual funds. They are markedly different in terms of risk, investment goals, returns, and tax efficiency.

Risk

The main distinguishing factor between debt and equity funds is risk. Equity funds have a higher risk profile than debt funds. Investors should understand that risk and return are directly related, meaning higher risk can lead to higher returns. If investors are taking on more risk, they should also consider longer investment tenures. Equity funds are considered more volatile than debt funds, and investors need to have a moderately high to high-risk appetite and longer investment tenures.

Investment Goals

Debt funds are typically used for short to medium-term goals, while equity funds are for long-term goals. Debt funds are suitable for investors who want better returns than a bank savings account or fixed deposits but cannot afford to take high risks. Equity funds, on the other hand, are suitable for investors with long-term investment goals and above-average risk tolerance.

Returns

Equity funds have the potential to offer higher returns than debt funds but carry more risk. Debt funds offer stable but moderate to low returns. Historically, equity funds have generated better returns than debt funds. However, when the market falls, share prices tend to drop more compared to debt instruments.

Tax Efficiency

Debt funds held for less than 36 months are taxed according to the investor's income tax rate. Long-term capital gains from debt funds (held for more than 36 months) are taxed at 20% after allowing for indexation benefits.

Equity funds, on the other hand, offer tax benefits. Capital gains from equity funds held for less than a year are taxed at 15%. Long-term capital gains of up to Rs 1 lakh are tax-exempt, and gains above this amount are taxed at 10%. ELSS funds, a type of equity fund, can offer tax benefits of up to Rs 1,50,000 with a 3-year lock-in period.

In summary, both debt and equity funds have their advantages and suit different investor profiles. Debt funds are ideal for investors seeking lower-risk investments with stable returns. Equity funds, despite their volatility, can provide superior returns over the long term for investors willing to take on higher risk.

Frequently asked questions