Governments' Bitcoin Investment: Why And How Much?

Bitcoin has become a highly controversial topic since its introduction in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis. Some governments are wary of Bitcoin and have alternated between criticising it and investigating its use for their own ends. Bitcoin's decentralised system has the potential to dismantle the current financial infrastructure and the role of governments in managing and regulating economic policy. Its stateless nature also allows it to be used to circumvent government-imposed capital controls. However, Bitcoin's ecosystem is still rife with misuse, scandals, and criminal activities. Despite this, some governments have shown interest in investing in Bitcoin. For example, Miami is considering integrating Bitcoin into its monetary system and using it for its investment strategy.

Why governments are wary of Bitcoin

Bitcoin has generated controversy since its introduction in 2008. While some governments have embraced it, others are wary of the cryptocurrency. Here are some reasons why governments are cautious about Bitcoin:

Loss of Control Due to Decentralization

Governments traditionally control fiat currencies, such as the dollar or euro, allowing them to influence the economy through monetary policy. They can also track the movement of fiat currencies to identify criminal or fraudulent activities. However, Bitcoin's decentralized nature means that no central authority controls transactions, reducing the government's ability to regulate monetary policy.

Bitcoin Cannot Be Regulated

Bitcoin's decentralized system operates through a peer-to-peer network, bypassing intermediaries like banks and financial institutions. This lack of central control makes it difficult for governments to regulate Bitcoin, which could potentially destabilize the existing financial infrastructure.

Bitcoin Can Circumvent Capital Controls

Bitcoin's stateless nature allows individuals to circumvent capital controls imposed by governments. For example, Chinese citizens, who have an annual limit on foreign currency purchases, may use Bitcoin to transfer money across borders, undermining government authority.

Bitcoin Is Used in Illicit Activities

The anonymity of Bitcoin's network makes it attractive to criminals, as it enables them to camouflage their involvement in illegal activities, such as ransomware, darknet transactions, and sanctioned entity transactions. This has led to concerns about Bitcoin being used for criminal purposes and fraudulent activities.

Fiscal Treatment is Complex

The decentralized nature of blockchain technology, on which Bitcoin operates, makes it challenging for governments to plan monetary policy and tax regulations. The complex fiscal treatment of Bitcoin is a significant concern for governments.

A Threat to Central Banks

Central banks play a crucial role in controlling a country's finance and economy. However, the widespread adoption of Bitcoin could potentially reduce the need for central banks, threatening their business and, by extension, the government's control over the economy.

While governments have valid concerns about Bitcoin, it is important to note that it also offers benefits, such as increased financial inclusion and faster and cheaper transactions. As the world of cryptocurrency continues to evolve, governments are racing to develop their own virtual currencies to compete with Bitcoin and other virtual monies.

How Bitcoin can destabilize the existing financial system

Bitcoin has the potential to destabilize the existing financial system in several ways. Here are some key points that highlight this possibility:

Decentralization and Disruption of the Traditional Financial System:

Bitcoin's decentralized nature is one of its core features. It eliminates the need for intermediaries such as central banks and financial institutions, which traditionally play a pivotal role in managing and regulating economic policies. By removing these intermediaries, Bitcoin can disrupt the existing financial infrastructure and potentially make the role of governments in economic policy-making less significant. This disruption could lead to a rearrangement of the current financial system, where the power to increase or decrease the currency supply is not concentrated in a single authority.

Circumvention of Capital Controls:

Bitcoin enables individuals to circumvent capital controls imposed by governments. For example, in China, citizens are subject to an annual limit on foreign currency purchases. However, in 2020, over $50 billion moved from East Asia-based Bitcoin wallets to wallets in other countries, indicating that Chinese citizens may have used Bitcoin to bypass government regulations and export their wealth. This ability to circumvent capital controls can undermine government authority and destabilize the financial system.

Illicit Activities and Criminal Usage:

Bitcoin's decentralized and pseudonymous nature makes it attractive for criminal activities. The network's algorithmic trust and pseudonymity make it challenging to trace transactions and identify individuals involved in illicit activities. Criminals can use Bitcoin to camouflage their involvement in ransomware, darknet activities, and sanctioned entity transactions. This facilitates nefarious activities and can lead to an increase in criminal transactions, potentially destabilizing the existing financial system.

Inflation and Economic Crises:

Critics of central banks argue that they have a negative impact on consumers and the economy and are responsible for debilitating recessions. The Great Recession of 2008, for instance, was partially attributed to the Federal Reserve's loose monetary policies. Bitcoin proponents suggest that its decentralized nature and limited supply can act as an "inflation-proofing" measure. However, since Bitcoin must be converted to fiat currency for use, it is still subject to inflationary pressures of those currencies.

Speculation and Risk:

Bitcoin has earned a reputation as a favorite for financial speculators and risk-takers. Its price has been driven by hype and the belief that it will continue to rise in value. This speculative nature can lead to volatile price movements and potentially impact the stability of the financial system, especially if a significant number of investors decide to exit the market simultaneously.

While Bitcoin has not yet achieved widespread adoption, its influence continues to grow. Governments and central banks are closely monitoring its impact and exploring ways to integrate or regulate it. The potential for Bitcoin to destabilize the existing financial system remains a concern for authorities, and its future impact will depend on how it evolves and how governments choose to address its challenges and opportunities.

How governments are trying to muscle aside Bitcoin

Bitcoin has generated controversy since its introduction in 2008. Critics point to its role in criminal activities and the absence of legal recognition as reasons for governments to be wary of it. Bitcoin enthusiasts, on the other hand, herald its launch as the advent of a new and equitable monetary system. The reality probably lies somewhere in between.

Governments are trying to muscle aside Bitcoin because it has the potential to upend the existing financial system and undermine their role in it. Bitcoin presents three main challenges to government authority: it cannot be regulated, criminals use it, and it can help citizens circumvent capital controls.

Firstly, Bitcoin cannot be regulated by governments because it is a decentralized digital currency with no central authority in charge. This lack of regulation makes it attractive to criminals, who can use it to facilitate illicit activities such as ransomware, darknet activities, and sanctioned entity transactions.

Secondly, Bitcoin can be used to circumvent government-imposed capital controls. For example, Chinese citizens may have converted local currency to Bitcoin to transfer it across borders and sidestep the government's annual limit on foreign currency purchases.

Finally, Bitcoin has the potential to destabilize the existing financial infrastructure system by removing intermediaries such as banks and financial institutions. In the Bitcoin network, peer-to-peer automated transfers between two parties mean that intermediaries are no longer required to manage and distribute currency. This could make the role of governments in managing and regulating economic policy through intermediaries superfluous.

To blunt the appeal of Bitcoin and other virtual monies, central banks are racing to develop their own digital currencies. However, Bitcoin has not yet experienced enough worldwide adoption to threaten financial systems.

Why governments will eventually defeat cryptocurrencies

Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies have been a source of controversy since their inception, with governments and central banks eyeing them warily and taking actions such as refusing to recognize them as legal tender, treating them as commodities, or even banning them. Some governments, like El Salvador, have adopted Bitcoin as a currency, while others, like India, plan to introduce legislation to outlaw it. This is because cryptocurrencies pose a threat to government authority and the existing financial system in several ways:

Regulation and Control

Firstly, Bitcoin cannot be regulated by governments due to its decentralized nature. It operates through a network of computers and does not require intermediaries like banks or the approval of central authorities. This also means that governments cannot effectively monitor or control Bitcoin transactions, making it difficult to trace illicit activities.

Capital Controls

Secondly, Bitcoin enables citizens to circumvent capital controls imposed by governments. For example, Chinese citizens may have converted local currency to Bitcoin to bypass the annual limit on foreign currency purchases. This undermines the government's ability to prevent currency outflows and protect the value of their fiat currency.

Illicit Activities

Thirdly, the anonymity provided by Bitcoin makes it attractive to criminals engaging in illicit activities such as ransomware, darknet activities, and sanctioned entity transactions. Criminals can use Bitcoin to evade detection and launder money across borders.

Financial Infrastructure Destabilization

Finally, by removing intermediaries and decentralizing the financial system, Bitcoin has the potential to destabilize the existing financial infrastructure. This could disrupt the cycle of trust that underpins the current system and make governments' role in managing and regulating economic policy through intermediaries superfluous.

However, it is important to note that Bitcoin has not yet gained enough worldwide adoption to pose an immediate threat to financial systems. Nonetheless, governments are taking steps to address the challenges posed by cryptocurrencies. Some governments are developing their own virtual currencies to blunt the appeal of Bitcoin and other virtual monies. Others are increasing competition against Bitcoin by phasing out its demand or requiring businesses to decline payments in Bitcoin.

While the characteristics of Bitcoin, such as its decentralized nature and blockchain technology, make it challenging for governments to destroy, their actions will likely have an impact. Increased competition and perception management could weaken Bitcoin's popularity over time. Additionally, the very anonymity and freedom that Bitcoin offers are also its weaknesses, as they are aspects that governments, including democratic ones, dislike and will work to regulate.

How Bitcoin can be used to pay and get paid

Bitcoin has generated controversy since its introduction in 2008. Some governments have adopted it as a currency, while others refuse to recognise it as legal tender. Despite this, there are several ways to use Bitcoin to pay and get paid.

Firstly, you can acquire Bitcoin by accepting it as a payment for goods and services. You can also buy Bitcoin on a regulated cryptocurrency exchange, such as Coinbase, Binance.US, Kraken, or Gemini. These exchanges allow you to exchange fiat money for cryptocurrency and offer features like storing your private keys and technical support.

Once you have Bitcoin, you can use a cryptocurrency wallet to send and receive payments. You can use any wallet that is compatible with the cryptocurrency and exchange you choose. There are hundreds of wallets available, each with different features and varying levels of compatibility with cryptocurrencies. For example, some wallets may only work with a few cryptocurrencies, while others are compatible with nearly all.

When sending a payment, you will typically need to open your wallet app, click "Send Payment" or a similar button, enter the amount you want to send, scan the recipient's QR code or enter their wallet address, and then confirm the transaction.

Receiving a payment is a similar process: open your wallet app, tap "Receive Payment" or a similar button, share your address (your public key) with the sender, and then accept the payment.

A growing number of online retailers and brick-and-mortar stores accept cryptocurrency as a form of payment. Most businesses that do accept cryptocurrency use payment service providers that guarantee the conversion of cryptocurrency to fiat at the time of the transaction, eliminating price slippage. Some notable businesses that accept crypto outright include Microsoft, AT&T, and Home Depot.

Using Bitcoin to pay and get paid offers several advantages. It provides anonymity and pseudonymity, allowing users to conduct financial matters without scrutiny by authorities or others. It is also designed to be peer-to-peer, reducing the need for third-party involvement and associated fees. Bitcoin also allows users to make and receive payments anywhere with an internet connection and enables everyone to access financial services, regardless of their proximity to banks or other financial institutions.

However, there are also some disadvantages to using Bitcoin for payments. Transaction fees for the cryptocurrency network can be high, and the price volatility of Bitcoin means that the value of your cryptocurrency could change significantly between the time you initiate a transaction and when the network approves it. Additionally, because Bitcoin is not regulated, backed, or guaranteed, there may be no recourse if you get scammed or if the exchange you use goes out of business. Finally, transactions on the blockchain cannot be reversed, so errors or mistakes can only be corrected if the recipient voluntarily sends back the overpaid amount.

Frequently asked questions