Harold Pollack's Index Fund Investment Strategies

In 2013, Harold Pollack, a University of Chicago professor, mentioned in an interview that the best personal finance advice could fit on a 3-by-5 index card. He then jotted down nine rules on an index card, took a picture, and posted it online. The image went viral, and Pollack expanded on the advice in a book, co-written with Helaine Olen, called The Index Card: Why Personal Finance Doesn't Have to Be Complicated. Pollack's index card advises investing in inexpensive, well-diversified mutual funds, such as Vanguard Target 20xx funds. Pollack's entire investment portfolio is spread across around five index funds, and he recommends low-fee stock index funds.

Pollack recommends investing in low-fee total stock index funds

Pollack's advice stems from his belief that the best personal finance advice is simple and straightforward. In 2013, he stated that it "can fit on a 3-by-5 index card, and is available for free in the library". This idea went viral, and Pollack and Olen expanded on these principles in their book.

Pollack's index card includes tips such as saving 20% of your income, paying off your credit card in full each month, and maximising tax-advantaged savings vehicles. However, the core of his investment advice is to focus on low-fee index funds with a reasonable mix of stock and bond funds.

Pollack himself uses low-fee stock index funds and doesn't endorse any particular commercial product. He suggests looking for the biggest firms' low-fee versions and ensuring that fees don't exceed 0.2% per year. Pollack's advice is based on his own experience and research, and he believes that investing doesn't have to be complicated or expensive.

Pollack also emphasises the importance of seeking financial advice from the right sources. He recommends using fee-only financial advisors who are paid directly by their clients, rather than those who earn commissions from steering clients into specific investments. This helps to ensure that the advisor's interests are aligned with the client's interests.

He suggests maxing out a 401(k)

In his viral index card, Harold Pollack suggests maxing out a 401(k) or equivalent employee contribution. Pollack, a public policy professor at the University of Chicago, believes that personal finance is so simple that all the investment advice one needs can be written on an index card. In an interview, Pollack stated that the best personal finance advice is available for free and that paying for advice often leads to incorrect advice. This belief led to the creation of his index card, which he wrote on his daughter's index card and posted online.

Pollack's index card includes nine personal finance tips, with the first being to max out your 401(k) or equivalent employee contribution. This advice is further elaborated on in his book, "The Index Card: Why Personal Finance Doesn't Have to Be Complicated," which he co-authored with financial journalist Helaine Olen. In the book, Pollack and Olen explain the benefits of taking advantage of employer-matched contributions and the tax advantages of 401(k) plans. They emphasize the importance of treating retirement savings as a priority and making contributions automatic.

Pollack's suggestion to max out a 401(k) is based on the belief that it is a tax-advantaged way to save for retirement. By contributing the maximum amount allowed by law to a 401(k), individuals can reduce their taxable income and benefit from tax-deferred growth on their investments. This strategy can help individuals accumulate a substantial nest egg for retirement, especially when combined with employer matching contributions, which are essentially free money.

Additionally, Pollack recommends investing in low-fee, well-diversified mutual funds or index funds rather than individual stocks. This approach aligns with his suggestion to max out a 401(k) as these plans often offer a variety of low-fee investment options, making it easier for individuals to build a well-diversified portfolio. By following Pollack's advice, individuals can keep costs low and reduce the risk associated with investing in individual stocks.

Overall, Pollack's suggestion to max out a 401(k) is part of his simple and straightforward approach to personal finance. By taking advantage of tax-advantaged savings vehicles and investing in low-cost, diversified funds, individuals can set themselves up for a comfortable retirement without the need for complicated strategies or expensive financial advisors.

He advises against buying individual stocks

In his book, *The Index Card: Why Personal Finance Doesn't Have to Be Complicated*, co-authored with Helaine Olen, Pollack advises against buying individual stocks. This is one of the nine rules he wrote on his index card of financial advice. The rule is elaborated on in the book, which suggests investing in diversified mutual funds instead.

Pollack's reasoning behind this rule is that the person "on the other side of the table knows more than you do about this stuff". In other words, when you buy or sell individual stocks, you are likely going up against someone with more knowledge and experience than you. This puts you at a disadvantage and increases the chances of losing money.

Pollack also believes that personal finance is simple and that paying for financial advice is unnecessary. He argues that the best financial advice can be summarised on a single index card and is available for free. In his experience, paying for financial advice often leads to being steered towards wasteful investments that benefit the adviser through commissions.

Instead, Pollack recommends investing in low-fee total stock index funds, ideally through a 401(k) or similar retirement account. This type of investment is well-diversified and has low fees, reducing the risk of losing money. It also requires less time and attention compared to actively picking individual stocks.

Pollack's advice is based on his own experience and research as a public policy professor at the University of Chicago. While he acknowledges that some people may have successfully invested in individual stocks, he maintains that, for most people, the risks outweigh the potential rewards.

Pollack recommends paying off credit card debt in full each month

In his viral index card, Harold Pollack recommends paying off credit card debt in full each month. This is because credit cards are essentially loans with high interest rates, and if the balance is not paid off, the debt can quickly accumulate.

Pollack advises against running up credit card debt and ignoring reward programs, as these can lead to careless spending. Instead, he suggests using credit cards transactionally and paying off the balance at the end of each month. This approach can help individuals build wealth and avoid the negative consequences of credit card debt.

Pollack also emphasizes the importance of saving and investing. He recommends saving 10-20% of one's income, maximizing tax-advantaged savings vehicles like Roth, SEP, and 529 accounts, and investing in low-fee total stock index funds or mutual funds. By following these strategies, individuals can improve their financial situation and work towards achieving their financial goals.

In addition to his index card, Pollack also co-authored a book, "The Index Card: Why Personal Finance Doesn't Have to Be Complicated," with financial journalist Helaine Olen. The book expands on the principles outlined in the index card and offers more detailed advice on personal finance.

By following Pollack's recommendations, individuals can take control of their finances, reduce debt, and work towards achieving their financial goals. Paying off credit card debt in full each month is a crucial step in this process, as it helps prevent the accumulation of high-interest debt and allows individuals to focus on saving and investing for the future.

He suggests opening a Roth IRA if you don't have a 401(k)

In his book, *The Index Card: Why Personal Finance Doesn't Have to Be Complicated*, co-authored with Helaine Olen, Pollack suggests that people without a 401(k) should open a Roth IRA. This is one of the nine rules he wrote on an index card in 2013, which later went viral and inspired the book.

Pollack's advice is aimed at simplifying personal finance. He believes that the best financial advice is often straightforward and can fit on a single index card. In the book, he and Olen expand on the rules he wrote on the card, providing more detailed explanations and adding a tenth rule.

Pollack's suggestion to open a Roth IRA is part of his advice on retirement planning. He emphasizes the importance of starting to save for retirement early, either through an employer-sponsored plan like a 401(k) or an individual retirement account like a Roth IRA.

A Roth IRA offers tax advantages, as contributions are made with after-tax dollars, and investment gains are tax-free. This means that when you withdraw money during retirement, you don't have to pay taxes on it. It's a good option for young people, as it offers flexibility and allows them to benefit from compound interest over time.

Pollack also recommends maximizing tax-advantaged savings vehicles, such as Roth accounts, to take advantage of their low fees and potential for significant returns. He suggests that people focus on low-fee index funds, which provide a simple and passive investment strategy.

By following Pollack's advice and opening a Roth IRA, individuals without access to a 401(k) can take control of their retirement savings and benefit from the tax advantages and flexibility that this type of account offers.

Frequently asked questions