Equity Investments: Understanding Misconceptions And Correct Statements

The accounting and financial reporting requirements for investments in equity securities are a complex area for both preparers and users of financial statements. Equity securities are ownership interests in an entity, such as common stock, preferred stock, and other classes of stock. The correct statement regarding investments in equity securities is that they are classified into three specific types based on the investor's level of influence over the investee company. This statement is supported by accounting sources, which outline the different accounting methods used depending on the level of influence.

Equity investments are consolidated into the investor's financial statements

The equity method acknowledges the economic relationship between the investor and the company they are investing in. It involves recording the investor's share of the company's earnings as revenue from investment on the income statement. The initial investment is recorded at historical cost, and adjustments are made based on the investor's percentage ownership in net income, losses, and dividend payouts. Net income increases the investor's asset value, while losses and dividend payouts decrease it.

For example, if an investor company, ABC Co., purchases 25% of XYZ Corp.'s shares for $200,000, it records a debit of $200,000 to "Investment in XYZ Corp." in its asset account and a credit of the same amount to cash. At the end of the year, if XYZ Corp. reports a net income of $50,000 and pays $10,000 in dividends, ABC Co. would record a debit of $12,500 (25% of the net income) and a credit of the same amount to Investment Revenue. It would also record a debit of $2,500 (25% of the dividends) to cash and a credit of the same amount to "Investment in XYZ Corp."

The equity method is different from the consolidation method, where the investor exerts full control over the company they are investing in, and the cost method, where the investor has no influence or control. The equity method provides a more accurate picture of the economic interest of the investor in the company they are investing in and is, therefore, an important aspect of financial reporting.

No significant influence exists if ownership interest is less than 20%

The idea that no significant influence exists if ownership interest is less than 20% is a common misconception. While it is true that owning 20% or more of a company's shares is often considered to indicate significant influence, it is not the sole determining factor.

Significant influence is defined as the ability to exert power over another company, which can include representation on the board of directors, involvement in policy development, and the interchanging of managerial personnel. Even if an investor owns less than 20% of the shares, they may still hold significant influence if they can affect the value of the company. This could be through their involvement in the company's operations or financial policies, or if they have a substantial investment relative to the company's capitalization.

The determination of significant influence requires an evaluation of the facts and circumstances for each investment and should be assessed on an ongoing basis. For example, an investor with a 19.5% ownership interest and one of five seats on the investee's board of directors is likely to be considered to have significant influence. On the other hand, an investor with a 20% ownership interest may not have significant influence if there are other majority shareholders or if they do not actively participate in the company's decision-making.

The equity method of accounting is generally used when a company holds significant influence over another company it is investing in. This method involves recording the investor company's share of the investee company's earnings as revenue on its income statement. The initial investment is recorded at historical cost, and adjustments are made based on the investor's percentage ownership in net income, loss, and dividend payouts.

In summary, while 20% ownership interest is often a key indicator of significant influence, it is not the sole determining factor. The evaluation of significant influence requires a comprehensive assessment of the investor's relationship with the investee, including their level of ownership, representation on the board, participation in policy-making, and the relative size of their investment.

Equity investments are always reported as long-term assets

The statement "Equity investments are always reported as long-term assets" is incorrect. This is because equity securities can be classified as either current assets or long-term assets.

Equity securities represent an ownership interest in an entity, and can include common stock, preferred stock, warrants, call options, and put options. They are generally classified as current assets on a classified balance sheet, even if there is no intention to dispose of them within a year, as they are available to be used in current operations. Equity investments are required to be presented as a separate line item on the balance sheet.

The introduction of ASU 2016-01 brought about significant changes to the model of accounting for investments in equity securities. Now, almost all investments in equity securities are required to be carried at fair value, with changes in fair value included as a component of earnings. However, there are several exceptions to this measurement model, including investments that are classified and accounted for under the equity method of accounting, investments requiring consolidation, and investments that qualify for the net asset value (NAV) carrying value practical expedient.

The equity method of accounting is used when a company holds significant influence over the company it is investing in, which is usually the case when a company holds around 20% or more of another company's stock. However, owning 20% or more of the shares does not automatically mean that significant influence is exerted. The equity method is a standard technique used to record the profits earned by a company through its investment in another company. The investment is initially recorded at historical cost, and adjustments are made based on the investor's percentage ownership in net income, loss, and dividend payouts. Net income increases the investor's asset value on their balance sheet, while losses or dividend payouts decrease it.

Investments in equity securities are classified into three types

Firstly, equity securities represent ownership of a corporation. The most common type is common stock, which gives the shareholder a claim on a percentage of the issuing company's earnings and assets. Other types include preferred stock, warrants, call options, and put options.

Secondly, debt securities are financial instruments that represent a creditor relationship with a governmental body or corporation. This includes corporate and government bonds, municipal bonds, US Treasury securities, and certificates of deposit (CDs).

Thirdly, hybrid securities combine aspects of both debt and equity. Examples include equity warrants, convertible bonds, and preference shares.

The number of types of securities an investment can be classified into depends on the definition being used. A broader definition of securities includes tradable financial instruments beyond equity and debt, such as derivatives, investment contracts, and notes. Under this definition, there are primarily three types of securities: equity, debt, and hybrids.

The accounting and reporting requirements for investments in equity and debt securities are an area of complexity for preparers and users of financial statements. For example, under US GAAP, investments in equity securities are now required to be carried at fair value, with changes included as a component of earnings.

Equity securities are available to be used in current operations

Equity securities are any securities that represent an ownership interest in an entity. This includes common stock, preferred stock, and other classes of stock, as well as rights to acquire or sell equity, such as warrants, call options, and put options. These securities are generally classified as current assets, even if there is no intention to dispose of them within a year. This classification is due to their availability for use in current operations and not just their potential for conversion into cash.

The classification of equity securities as current assets is further supported by the requirement to present them as a separate line item on the balance sheet or to disclose them in the notes to the financial statements. This separate presentation highlights their significance and availability for use in current operations.

It is worth noting that the classification of equity securities can vary depending on the specific circumstances and accounting methods chosen. For example, under the equity method of accounting, investments in equity securities may be classified differently if they meet certain criteria, such as requiring consolidation or qualifying for specific carrying value practical expedients.

In summary, equity securities are available to be used in current operations, and this is reflected in their classification as current assets on the balance sheet. This classification is important for understanding the liquidity and availability of these assets for short-term operational needs.

Frequently asked questions