Alpha Investments: Why The Hate?

Alpha Investments is a YouTube channel run by Rudy, a former Wall Street worker who now makes a living trading Magic: The Gathering cards. He has a large following, with around 350,000 subscribers, but is disliked by many players of the game. This is mainly because his content focuses on Magic as an investment strategy, which some feel is at odds with the spirit of the game and pushes up card prices. He has also been accused of market manipulation, although he denies this.

People dislike Alpha Investments because it treats Magic: The Gathering like an investment rather than a game

Rudy has been playing Magic since the early days and has a passion for vintage cards. He quit his job in finance to focus on Magic full-time, buying and selling cards and running card stores. He spends millions of dollars a year on Magic products and has a vast collection of vintage cards. While he resells most of what he buys, he also has a private collection of old cards that he will not sell. He funds his business and his hobby through various investments and other businesses, such as rental properties.

Rudy has been accused of market manipulation and spreading misinformation to benefit his business. He has done large buyouts of certain cards and has been accused of promoting buyouts of cards that he already owned, driving up their prices. He has also been accused of spreading false rumours and giving bad investment advice. However, some people defend him, arguing that he is simply providing entertainment and that there is no regulation against his actions.

While Rudy has a large following and many find his videos entertaining, his focus on treating Magic as an investment can make the game less accessible to players by raising prices. Some people also dislike his abrasive personality and view him as a scammer. Overall, the dislike for Alpha Investments stems from the fact that it treats Magic: The Gathering like an investment rather than a game, which goes against what most players want from the game.

Alpha Investments' buyouts of cards can negatively impact players' ability to buy cards at reasonable prices

Alpha Investments is a YouTube channel that focuses on the financial aspects of Magic: The Gathering. The channel is run by Rudy, who has been accused of manipulating the market and driving up card prices with his buyouts of cards. This has negatively impacted players' ability to buy cards at reasonable prices, as it has created an artificial demand and limited the supply. Some people also believe that Rudy intentionally gives his viewers bad advice so that he can recover from his own bad investments. In addition to his buyouts, Rudy has also been accused of trying to sell a Lotus with a fake signature.

While some viewers enjoy his content and find his investment strategies interesting, others believe that his actions are harmful to the game and the community. Some players have been priced out of certain formats, such as Legacy, due to the increased cost of cards. This has led to frustration and resentment among some members of the Magic community.

It is worth noting that the issue of buyouts and price spikes is not unique to Alpha Investments or Rudy. Other individuals and groups also engage in this practice, and it is a widespread issue within the Magic community. However, the actions of Alpha Investments and similar entities have contributed to the rising cost of cards and negatively impacted the ability of players to acquire them at reasonable prices.

The channel's host, Rudy, is disliked for his abrasive and sarcastic personality

The host of the Alpha Investments YouTube channel, Rudy, is known for his sarcastic and abrasive personality, which has garnered a mixed response from viewers. While some find his content entertaining, others have described him as "a shithead", "a grifter", and "a scammer".

Rudy's content primarily revolves around Magic: The Gathering, a trading card game. He provides insights and predictions regarding the game's products and their market value. Rudy's expertise and track record in this area have earned him a significant following, with viewers eagerly awaiting his recommendations. However, his influence on the market has also led to criticism, with some accusing him of market manipulation.

Rudy's videos can have a significant impact on the prices of Magic: The Gathering cards and products. For example, in September 2022, he released a video claiming that a particular set of booster boxes was underpriced, which caused an immediate increase in their price. This type of influence has drawn comparisons to figures like Elon Musk and Warren Buffett, whose statements can sway the stock market.

While Rudy's content may be entertaining to some, his focus on the financial aspects of Magic: The Gathering has led to accusations of treating the game as an investment rather than a game. This perspective has left a sour taste in the mouths of players who want access to cards at reasonable prices. Additionally, his content has been described as negative, with some viewers finding his jokes repetitive and his videos overly long.

In conclusion, Rudy's sarcastic and abrasive personality, combined with his influence on the Magic: The Gathering market, has led to a mixed response from viewers. While some appreciate his insights and entertainment value, others criticise his impact on the game and its community.

Rudy's content is considered to lack substance, with videos being overly long and filled with rambling

Rudy's videos often feature him opening boxes and talking about the market. However, some viewers have complained that he doesn't do enough research about the cards in the set or their value. One user said that "he doesn't know the prices at all", while another claimed that "he talks so much but says very little". Another user said that "he has like four jokes that go on auto", with another agreeing that "he talks and talks and talks and says nothing".

Some viewers have also criticised Rudy's videos for being too negative, with one user saying that "he goes out of his way to stir up controversy over nothing". Others have complained that his content is too biased, with one user saying that "his content is heavily biased since he's invested in nearly every sealed product there is". Another user said that "he's fine, provided that you understand that he's mainly looking out for his own bottom line and not trying to do you/his Patreons any favours".

Despite these criticisms, some users have defended Rudy's content. One user said that "if you watch Rudy, I don't think you should trust you when it comes to your own financial interests", while another said that "if you know to filter out the BS, he has some genuine videos that are extremely informative". Another user said that "he understands how markets work", and that "he has the best handle on sealed product inventory and distributor updates".

Rudy has been accused of market manipulation and spreading misinformation

Alpha Investments is a YouTube channel run by Rudy, a content creator who specialises in Magic: The Gathering (MTG) finance and investment strategies. Rudy has been accused of market manipulation and spreading misinformation.

Rudy's influence over the MTG market is significant. He has a large following of viewers who eagerly await his insights and predictions regarding MTG products. As a result, just one video from him can significantly impact the prices of MTG cards and products. For example, in September 2022, Rudy released a video claiming that Throneville Drain booster boxes should be priced at around a thousand dollars each. This immediately caused prices to climb by an additional $35, bringing the total price to $180 per box.

Rudy has been accused of market manipulation due to his ability to influence MTG prices with his videos. In one instance, he reported on a specific card buyout, only to later reveal that he had a "generous position" in that card before reporting on the buyout. In another example, Rudy told his viewers to relax about the hype surrounding the War of the Spark Mythic edition, claiming it would be heavily printed and distributed. However, he bought as many copies as he could because he knew it would actually be scarce.

In addition to market manipulation, Rudy has also been accused of spreading misinformation. He has been known to give conflicting advice, such as telling people to buy out a card that he himself had a large position in, only to later recommend selling it. He has also been accused of pushing bad advice onto his viewers to recover from his own bad investments. Furthermore, Rudy has been criticised for his association with VintageMagic, an organisation with reports of shady behaviour.

Overall, while Rudy provides entertainment and insights for his viewers, he has also been accused of market manipulation and spreading misinformation. His influence on the MTG market is undeniable, and viewers are advised to approach his content with a critical eye.

Frequently asked questions