Investments Of Passion: Collectibles

People invest in collectibles for a variety of reasons. For some, it's about diversifying their portfolio and making a financial gain. For others, it's a passion project driven by nostalgia, emotional satisfaction, or the thrill of the hunt. The value of collectibles is often subjective and based on factors such as rarity, condition, and the interest of future collectors. While investing in collectibles can be rewarding, it's important to approach it with caution due to the risks involved, including high costs, illiquidity, and the potential for fraud.

Diversification of portfolio

Diversification is an investment technique that aims to increase returns and decrease overall risk by allocating capital across investment types and industries.

Collectibles are considered alternative investments and can be a great way to diversify your portfolio. They are a physical asset that can be easily transported and sold anywhere in the world.

• Complementary Investments: Collectibles can act as a complementary investment to traditional stocks and bonds. By investing in collectibles, you can decrease the overall risk profile of your portfolio. For example, if you invest in stocks related to the package delivery industry, investing in collectibles can balance out the risk, as their values are not closely related.
• Non-Correlated Investments: Collectibles are non-stock diversification options that can help balance your portfolio. Their value is often based on factors such as rarity, emotional appeal, and nostalgia, rather than just the monetary worth of the item. This means that their prices may not always move in tandem with the stock market, providing a hedge against stock market volatility.
• Hedging Against Inflation: Some collectibles, such as fine wine, increase in value over time due to their limited supply and increasing demand. These types of collectibles can act as a hedge against inflation, protecting your portfolio from its erosive effects.
• Store of Value: Collectibles, particularly tangible objects with a history of retaining their value, can protect your wealth during troubled financial times or economic downturns. Their value is often based on supply and demand rather than being linked directly to the performance of the economy or the stock market.
• Potential Returns: Some collectibles can offer greater returns than traditional investments. For example, certain vintage cars, rare artworks, and historical memorabilia can appreciate significantly in value over time, providing the potential for substantial financial gains.

While investing in collectibles can provide diversification benefits, it is important to remember that they also come with certain risks. These include the potential for lower returns compared to the stock market, illiquidity, high transaction costs, and the need for proper storage and insurance. Therefore, it is generally recommended that collectibles comprise only a small portion of your overall investment portfolio.

Store of value

Many investors choose to protect their wealth by investing in tangible objects that have a history of retaining their value or appreciating during financially turbulent times. While the value of stocks and bonds is generally linked to the economy, the price of collectibles depends on supply and demand. Some collectibles, such as fine wine or spirits, increase in value with age.

Collectibles are part of a group of unique asset classes that can help investors diversify their portfolios. Sometimes, the prices of collectibles and the stock market move in opposite directions, so collectibles can help reduce losses during a down market or times of inflation.

However, collectibles are generally considered alternative investments and are less reliable than stocks or bonds. Their value can be more subjective and prone to fluctuations based on trends in collector interest. They also don't typically generate passive income and often incur maintenance costs.

The Knight Frank Luxury Investment Index, which tracks the prices of the top 10 most popular investment collectibles, showed that collectible wines appreciated by 9% on average in 2018, while rare whiskies topped the list with a 40% appreciation in value over the same period. In comparison, stamps had 0% annual appreciation, and jewellery values decreased by 5%.

Overall, collectibles can be a store of value, especially during challenging economic periods. However, their performance can be unpredictable, and they may not provide the same level of reliability as traditional investments.

Potential returns

Collectibles can be a great investment, with the potential to deliver better-than-decent returns. The return on shrewd purchases can be greater than traditional investments like stocks and bonds. Art, stamps, coins, and vintage automobiles are known for their financial returns, but baseball cards, old photographs, and relics of history can bring similar returns.

For example, a near-mint-condition copy of Spiderman's first appearance in a comic book sold at Heritage Auctions for $3.6 million in 2021. The comic book, Amazing Fantasy No. 15, sold for 12 cents in 1962, the year it was issued.

Another example is the first edition of The Amazing Spider-Man comic. Stan Lee’s timeless story sold for a mere $0.12 when it was first published in 1962. In 2011, a copy sold for an eye-popping $1.1 million.

Some other notable sales include:

• Jeff Koons' "Rabbit" sculpture sold for $91.1 million in 2019.
• A pearl pendant once owned by Marie Antoinette sold for $36.2 million at auction in 2018.
• A hand-painted bottle of The Macallan 1926 60-Year-Old single malt Scotch went for $1.5 million at Christie's in London in 2018.
• A Rolex Daytona 6239 watch sold for $17.8 million at auction in 2017.
• A 5-inch ceramic bowl manufactured during China’s Northern Song Dynasty sold at a Sotheby’s auction for $2.25 million in 2013.
• A Mickey Mantle baseball card sold for $2.88 million at the Texas-based Heritage Auctions in 2018.

Collectibles are often subject to the tastes, moods, and perceptions of buyers and sellers, which can be temporary and can diminish overnight. The value of collectibles depends on their rarity and how appealing they are to future collectors based on trends.

Nostalgia also plays a role in a collectible’s value. Nostalgia cycles tend to arrive in 20- to 30-year waves. That is to say, something that’s popular now has the potential to become a collectible two or three decades later as people get the itch to reconnect with their past.

However, there are no guarantees that this will happen. It is also important to note that collectibles are generally illiquid, taxable investments that don't produce an income unless you can sell them. They can also lose their value if broken, damaged, lost, or stolen.

Enjoyment of ownership

The enjoyment of physical ownership is a key factor in the appeal of collectibles. Collectors often display their items privately or publicly, taking pleasure in the recognition and admiration they receive. In the 17th and 18th centuries, aristocratic collectors were proud of their "cabinets of curiosities", which served as evidence of their wealth and discernment.

Collectors also derive satisfaction from the thrill of the hunt, the process of searching for and finding a rare item. This can be emotionally satisfying, as physical objects can stir memories of bygone days and simpler, happier times.

Collectors are often members of clubs with people who share their interests. They meet regularly and travel together to swap meets and auctions, assisting each other in finding missing pieces for their collections. In this way, being a collector can help build and maintain a social circle.

The Wealth Report Attitudes Survey 2018 from Knight Frank ranks "joy of ownership" as the top motivation for collectors, ahead of capital appreciation, safe financial haven, portfolio diversification, and social status.

Tax benefits

The US government taxes the sale of collectibles at a higher rate than the sale of stocks and bonds. Long-term capital gains from investing in collectibles are generally subject to a maximum of 28% federal tax rate, as opposed to the standard 15% long-term capital gains tax rate for traditional investments.

However, there are ways to reduce the amount of tax owed on collectible sales. For example, if you sell a collectible item that you have owned for more than a year, it may be subject to a maximum long-term capital gains tax of 28% when you sell it. But if you sell it after owning it for less than a year, you will be taxed at your ordinary income tax rate.

Additionally, the amount you owe the IRS is determined by your basis—the amount you paid for the collectible when you bought it, plus any auction or broker fees. You can also add to your basis any money you spent restoring, refurbishing, or maintaining your collectible. Subtract your basis from the sale price—you will be taxed on the difference.

Another strategy to reduce taxes on collectibles is to donate them to a charity, which will then sell them. You can deduct the fair market value of the collectible piece on your taxes if you itemize.

Finally, investing in collectibles can provide tax benefits by helping to diversify your portfolio. By adding this asset class to your holdings, you can reduce your overall investment risk.

Frequently asked questions