Borrowing To Invest: Risky Real Estate Mutual Funds

Borrowing money to invest in real estate mutual funds may seem like a good idea, but there are several reasons why this may not be the best decision. Firstly, real estate investments often require third-party financing, which can be risky. While enlisting the services of a mortgage broker can help find a suitable lender, it still requires a large upfront investment and high transaction costs. Additionally, real estate investments are illiquid and difficult to diversify, making it challenging to sell properties quickly or invest in multiple locations or industries. Furthermore, the return on investment is not guaranteed, and selling property may result in a loss. In contrast, mutual funds offer higher returns, diversification, and better liquidity. They are also more manageable and less time-consuming. Therefore, it is essential to carefully consider the risks and benefits before deciding to borrow money for real estate investments.

High upfront costs

Investing in real estate mutual funds involves high upfront costs, making them less accessible to the average investor. Property ownership requires a large amount of capital to get started. In the United States, the average price of a home is $374,900. Even if an investor wants to put just 10% down on the property, that's still $30,000 required just to get started—a steep entrance fee to real estate investment.

For example, buying a three-bedroom apartment in Noida requires an investment of at least Rs 70 to Rs 75 lakh, while the same property in Gurgaon would cost Rs 1 to 1.5 crore. Even if you take out a home loan, you'll need to put 20% down as the down payment from your own pocket, plus registration fees. So, for a Rs 70 to 75 lakh flat, you'd need to pay Rs 15 to 20 lakh upfront. For a Rs 1-1.5 crore property, that figure rises to Rs 20 to 25 lakh.

In addition to the high upfront costs of purchasing a property, there are also significant maintenance expenses, legal procedures, and low liquidity to consider. Real estate investments are not highly regulated, and they are subject to capital gains tax and stamp duty. The illiquidity of real estate means that it can take months to find a buyer, and in a rush to sell, it's common to fail to get a fair price for the property.

Illiquidity

Real estate investments are inherently illiquid due to several factors:

• Lack of Public Markets: Most real estate transactions occur in private markets, which lack the daily pricing and transparency of public markets. Private markets are harder to access and require credibility or status to enter.
• Difficulty of Transacting: Real estate deals involve multiple parties and extensive paperwork, making the process time-consuming and complex.
• Access to Capital: Real estate is a capital-intensive investment, requiring significant equity and debt financing. This complexity slows down transactions and makes it harder to find buyers or sellers.
• Transaction Costs: The costs associated with buying or selling real estate, such as closing costs, can be significant, further reducing the liquidity of these investments.

The illiquid nature of real estate has important implications for investors:

• Wider Bid-Ask Spreads: Illiquid assets tend to have larger discrepancies between the asking price and the bid price due to a lack of ready buyers.
• Greater Volatility: Illiquid assets exhibit higher price volatility, increasing the risk for investors.
• Higher Risk: Illiquid securities carry a higher risk, especially during market turmoil, as investors may struggle to sell their holdings without incurring losses.

Therefore, borrowing money to invest in real estate mutual funds can be risky due to the inherent illiquidity of real estate. It may be challenging to convert these investments into cash quickly, and the value of the investment may fluctuate significantly.

High transaction costs

Real estate investments, including real estate mutual funds, come with high transaction costs. These costs are incurred when buying or selling a good or service and are additional to the cost of the good or service itself. In the case of real estate, transaction costs include agents' commissions and closing costs, such as title search fees, appraisal fees, and government fees. These costs can be significant, ranging from 6% to 10% of the sale price.

Transaction costs are important to consider as they directly impact the net returns on investments. High transaction costs can result in thousands of dollars in losses, not only from the costs themselves but also because they reduce the amount of capital available for investment. For example, an investment of $10,000 per year for 30 years with a steady 6% return would yield approximately $838,000. However, with an annual fund expense of 1%, the investor would pay over $140,000 in fees over the life of the investment, reducing the ending portfolio value to less than $700,000.

To minimize transaction costs, investors can consider strategies such as aggregating trades or adopting a passive investment strategy. Additionally, it is important to select assets with transaction costs at the lower end of the range for their respective asset classes. While it may be challenging to avoid transaction costs entirely, careful selection of brokers or agents can help minimize these fees.

It is worth noting that mutual funds, a common investment instrument, also come with transaction costs. These include load fees, which are commissions paid to brokers, and 12b-1 fees, which cover marketing and selling expenses. Mutual funds also have annual fund operating expenses, which cover the cost of fund management, and shareholder fees, which are sales commissions and other one-time costs when buying or selling shares.

Lack of diversification

Borrowing money to invest in real estate mutual funds can be risky due to a lack of diversification. Diversification is a crucial aspect of investment, as it helps to balance risk and reward. By spreading investments across various asset classes, sectors, and markets, investors can reduce the volatility of their portfolio.

Real estate investments, including mutual funds that focus on this sector, often constitute a significant portion of an investor's portfolio. However, they may not provide sufficient diversification on their own. Real estate values can be influenced by economic conditions, interest rates, and location-specific factors, leading to potential volatility.

To achieve true diversification, investors should allocate their funds across multiple asset classes, such as stocks, bonds, commodities, and alternative investments. This ensures that if one sector or market underperforms, the overall portfolio can still benefit from the performance of other assets.

Additionally, within the real estate sector itself, diversification can be challenging. Investing in a single property or a limited number of properties can expose investors to location-specific risks, such as market slumps or economic downturns in that particular area. Diversifying across multiple properties in different locations and types (residential, commercial, etc.) requires substantial capital, which may not be feasible for many investors.

Furthermore, real estate investments tend to be highly illiquid, making it difficult to quickly buy or sell assets to adjust one's portfolio in response to market changes. This lack of liquidity can hinder an investor's ability to react to market volatility and take advantage of emerging opportunities.

In contrast, mutual funds that invest in a diverse range of stocks or other assets can provide broader exposure to different sectors and reduce the impact of location-specific risks. By investing in a variety of companies and industries, investors can lower the risk associated with any single investment or market.

Therefore, borrowing money specifically for real estate mutual funds may not be the best strategy for achieving a well-diversified portfolio. It is important for investors to carefully consider their investment goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon before making decisions about borrowing and allocating funds.

Risk of selling at a loss

Borrowing money to invest in real estate mutual funds can be risky, and one of the biggest risks is selling at a loss. Here are some key points to consider:

Illiquidity and High Transaction Costs: Real estate investments are highly illiquid, meaning it can take months to find a buyer and sell a property. This lack of liquidity can lead to selling at a loss, especially if there is a rush to sell. Additionally, real estate transactions incur significant closing costs, which can range from 6% to 10% of the sale price, further reducing potential profits.

Market Downturns and Economic Slowdowns: Market downturns, such as the 2008 financial crisis, can result in selling real estate investments at a loss. Economic slowdowns can also lead to property price depreciation, making it challenging to sell without incurring losses.

Underperformance and Strategy Mismatch: Consistent underperformance of a real estate mutual fund compared to similar funds or benchmarks can be a sign that it's time to sell. Additionally, if the fund's investment strategy changes and no longer aligns with your financial goals, selling at a loss may be preferable to holding on to an unsuitable investment.

Tax Implications: Selling real estate investments may trigger capital gains taxes, reducing overall profits. Tax implications can be complex, and it's important to consult with a qualified tax advisor to understand the full tax liability when selling at a loss.

Short-Term Trading Fees: Some mutual funds charge early redemption or short-term trading fees, which can eat into any potential profits when selling at a loss. It's crucial to carefully review the fund's prospectus to understand all associated fees and charges.

Frequently asked questions