Physical Bitcoins: Worthwhile Investment Or Novelty Item?

Bitcoin is a highly volatile investment option that has grown immensely over the last decade. It is the largest cryptocurrency by market cap and has been making headlines for its eye-popping returns. However, it is important to understand the risks associated with investing in Bitcoin, such as its volatility and lack of regulation.

One interesting aspect of Bitcoin is the concept of physical Bitcoin. Physical Bitcoins are usually metal coins imprinted with the information necessary to access BTC coins on the blockchain. They are sold in various denominations and can be purchased from companies like Casascius, Ravenbit, Titan Bitcoin, and Alitin Mint.

While physical Bitcoins may have some aesthetic appeal, they are less safe than using a hardware crypto wallet and are also less convenient and secure when compared to hardware cryptocurrency wallets combined with a metal crypto wallet backup.

So, are physical Bitcoins a good investment? The answer depends on various factors, including your risk tolerance, financial situation, and understanding of the market. It is crucial to do your research and carefully weigh the pros and cons before considering investing in physical Bitcoins or any other form of Bitcoin.

The pros of physical Bitcoin

Physical Bitcoin, an attempt to bring Bitcoin into the physical realm, has its pros and cons. Here are some advantages of owning physical Bitcoin:

• Tangibility: Physical Bitcoins offer a tangible existence to what is otherwise only virtual digits. They bridge the gap between the digital and physical worlds, catering to those who are wary of purely digital assets and prefer having their valuables in a tangible form.
• Decentralization: Physical Bitcoins further decentralize an already decentralized asset. They enable diversification of Bitcoin storage across tangible and intangible realms, enhancing the safety of your holdings.
• Aesthetic appeal: Physical Bitcoins often boast elegant designs, intricate engravings, and a substantial feel that captures the attention of crypto enthusiasts. They can be crafted from metals like brass, silver, or gold, or even plastic, with varying levels of craftsmanship.
• Collectible value: Due to their distinct materials, designs, and finite quantities, some Physical Bitcoins have become collectors' items. Older coins, especially those from limited batches, can acquire a value surpassing the BTC they hold. Their rarity can elevate them to a status akin to vintage collectibles.
• Cold storage: Physical Bitcoins can be used as a form of cold storage, providing an offline option for storing your Bitcoin. This can be an alternative to hardware cryptocurrency wallets, though it is less secure than a hardware wallet with a PIN.
• Lower inflation risk: Bitcoin undergoes predictable inflation at a halved rate every four years, unlike traditional currencies that are subject to hyperinflation. The blockchain system is infinite, so there is little need to worry about your cryptos losing their value over time.

The cons of physical Bitcoin

While physical Bitcoin has its appeal, it also has several drawbacks that investors should be aware of. Here are some of the cons of investing in physical Bitcoin:

• Security risks: Physical Bitcoins have faced security breaches, with many early-minted coins compromised once their codes were exposed. This poses a significant risk to investors, as it could lead to the loss of their investment.
• Practicality concerns: Beyond their novelty as collectibles, the practicality of physical Bitcoin is questionable. This may explain why they never gained widespread adoption during their initial phase.
• Legal hurdles: The creation and use of physical Bitcoin have faced legal challenges, particularly related to financial transmission regulations. These regulatory issues have contributed to the diminished popularity of physical Bitcoin.
• Counterfeiting: As with any physical item of value, there is a risk of counterfeiting. Investors must be cautious and conduct thorough research to ensure they are purchasing authentic physical Bitcoins from reputable sources.
• Limited availability: The production of physical Bitcoin has faced regulatory obstacles, leading to a decrease in the number of companies offering these products. As a result, investors may have limited options for purchasing physical Bitcoin.
• Lack of intrinsic value: Physical Bitcoins do not hold any intrinsic value. Their worth is derived from the private key imprinted on them, which connects to a digital wallet. If the private key is compromised or inaccessible, the physical Bitcoin may lose its value.

The risks of physical Bitcoin

Physical Bitcoins are metal coins imprinted with all the information necessary to access BTC coins on the Bitcoin blockchain. They are typically sold in various denominations, and the information is usually hidden in a tamper-proof way.

Volatility

The price of Bitcoin is highly volatile, as seen by its drastic fluctuations in value. For example, investors who bought Bitcoin in December 2017 at $20,000 saw its value decrease to $7,051 just weeks later. Bitcoin's price recently fell by nearly 11% over 24 hours, just days after hitting an all-time high. If you define security as an investment with a relatively stable price, then Bitcoin may not be a safe bet for your investment portfolio.

Threat of Hacking and Fraud

While Bitcoin's blockchain has never been hacked, individuals can still be hacked if they give out sensitive information, such as their private keys. It is not uncommon for lesser-known exchanges to be hacked. Additionally, there is a fair amount of fraud in the Bitcoin market, with fake exchanges duping unsuspecting investors out of their Bitcoins.

Lack of Regulation

The Bitcoin market is currently operating without any major regulations, and the government doesn't have a clear stance on cryptocurrency. The lack of taxation could also lead to problems should Bitcoin pose competition for government currency.

Technology Reliance

Bitcoin is an online exchange that relies entirely on technology. Without the technology, cryptocurrency is worthless. This makes Bitcoin owners more vulnerable to cyber threats and online fraud.

Block Withholding

New Bitcoins are created by solving mathematical equations called "blocks," which are created every time there is a Bitcoin exchange online. A mining pool can use computational power to mine a block and hide it from honest miners instead of reporting the new block to the network.

Losing Access to Your Bitcoin

Owners can lose access to their Bitcoin if they lose their account passwords or private keys.

Regulatory Uncertainty

Regulatory uncertainty poses a risk to Bitcoin investors. For example, in 2021, China effectively made it illegal for citizens to mine or hold any cryptocurrency. If other countries follow suit, Bitcoin holders could face significant challenges.

Cybersecurity

Cybersecurity is a chief concern for all digital asset holders. Your transactions are only as anonymous and secure as your wallet information and passwords.

The value of physical Bitcoin

Physical Bitcoin is a niche product for collectors and enthusiasts. They are usually metal coins imprinted with the information necessary to access BTC coins on the blockchain. The value of physical Bitcoin products varies depending on their BTC denomination, collectible appeal, and the materials they are made from.

Pros and Cons of Physical Bitcoin

Physical Bitcoins with embedded BTC value are less safe than hardware crypto wallets as the BTC value they contain can be easily accessed by thieves. They are also more cumbersome to use and don't offer any additional benefits. On the other hand, physical Bitcoins can be a novelty item or conversation piece, and some people prefer to have their valuables in a tangible form.

Examples of Physical Bitcoin Products

One of the most famous physical Bitcoin products was made by Casascius. These coins have a private key imprinted on them, hidden by a hologram. The company produced coins in various denominations, ranging from ₿0.1 to ₿1,000. However, Casascius is no longer in operation after being told by U.S. regulators that they would need to acquire a money transmitter business license.

Today, users can purchase physical Bitcoin cards from a company called Ballet. These cards are called "Pure Bitcoin" and come in denominations between 0.1 BTC and 0.005 BTC.

Physical Bitcoin ETFs

The term "physical Bitcoin" can also refer to physical Bitcoin ETFs (exchange-traded funds) that are backed by BTC coins held by the ETF's issuer. An example of such a product is the Fidelity Physical Bitcoin ETP (FBTC), which trades on European stock exchanges.

The future of physical Bitcoin

Physical Bitcoin has been around for years, but it has never become mainstream. In the early years of Bitcoin, several companies made physical Bitcoins, but they have fallen out of popularity recently. The most famous physical Bitcoin product was made by Casascius, which closed after the US regulator FinCEN told the company they would need to acquire a money transmitter business license to continue operations. Today, physical Bitcoins are mostly decorative and used as props or home decoration.

Physical Bitcoin products are usually metal coins imprinted with all the information necessary to access BTC coins on the blockchain. This information is typically hidden in a tamper-proof way. Physical Bitcoins are sold in various denominations representing different amounts of BTC.

While physical Bitcoins have some aesthetic appeal, they are less safe than hardware crypto wallets. The BTC value they contain can easily be accessed by a thief, whereas a hardware wallet requires a PIN. Additionally, you have to trust that the manufacturer of the physical Bitcoin doesn't have access to the private keys imprinted on the coins.

The limited size of the physical Bitcoin industry is a problem, as a number of firms have gone out of business or never even started shipping their products. The market for physical coins is limited, and they are usually marketed as conversation pieces, limited-series collectibles, or 'geek gifts'.

Frequently asked questions