Tithing On Investments: To Give Or Not To Give?

Tithing is a religious practice of donating a portion of one's income to a church or other faith-based organisation. While the specifics of tithing vary across different faiths and denominations, the general idea is that followers give a set percentage of their income—often 10%—to support the work of the church and its wider community.

In recent years, the rise of retail investing has led to an increase in tithing during the month of March, in addition to the traditional month of December. This is because tax season is the easiest time to tithe on realised gains from investments. However, many churches do not provide guidance on this topic, leaving investors unsure of when and how to tithe their investment gains.

Tithing on capital gains can be a complex issue, as investors may see large fluctuations in the value of their investments before they choose to sell. As such, it is generally recommended that investors only tithe on realised gains, rather than unrealised gains, as these are set in stone and easier to calculate. There are two main methods for tithing on capital gains:

1. Tithe on gains at the time the stock is sold

2. Tithe at tax time, when investors are forced to pay taxes on their realised gains for the previous year

Tithing on gross or net income

Tithing is a religious practice of giving a percentage of one's earnings, often understood as 10%, to religious institutions or leaders. The concept of tithing stems from the Old Testament, where Israelites were required to give a tenth of their earnings or crops and animals to the tabernacle or temple.

Today, the question of whether to tithe on gross or net income is a matter of personal interpretation and religious affiliation. Some individuals choose to tithe on their gross income, which refers to their earnings before taxes and other deductions are taken out. Others may choose to tithe on their net income, which is the amount left after taxes and other expenses have been accounted for.

For Christians, the Bible does not provide a clear directive on whether to tithe on gross or net income. While some interpret this as a call to pray and seek God's wisdom on how much to give, others emphasize that Christians are not bound by the Old Testament requirement. Instead, they are called to give generously and cheerfully from the heart, without feeling compelled or guilty.

In the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, members are advised to pay "one-tenth of all their interest annually, which is understood to mean income." However, individuals are encouraged to make their own decisions about what they consider income and how much they choose to tithe.

Ultimately, the decision to tithe on gross or net income depends on personal beliefs and interpretations of religious teachings. It is important to note that tithing is not solely about the amount given but also about the act of giving itself, demonstrating reverence and gratitude to God.

Tithing on retirement accounts

Tithing is a controversial topic, and there are different views on the subject. While some believe that tithing is a Biblical mandate that all Christians should follow, others argue that it has been replaced by a new pattern of giving under the New Covenant.

Tithing, which is defined as giving ten percent of one's income, can be applied to retirement accounts, but there are different approaches to this.

One approach is to consider the retirement account as a new income stream in retirement that has not been tithed on before. This means that if you receive income from a pension, annuity, or withdrawals from retirement accounts such as a 401(k), 403(b), IRA, or SEP, you would tithe on this income. However, if you have already tithed on the contributions to these accounts, then you would not need to tithe on the withdrawals until you have withdrawn more than you contributed.

Another approach is to consider the retirement account as an extension of your income during your working years. If you have consistently tithed on your gross income, including the contributions to your retirement accounts, then you may not need to tithe on the withdrawals from these accounts until you have withdrawn more than you contributed.

Ultimately, the decision on how to tithe on retirement accounts depends on one's personal convictions and interpretation of Biblical teachings. Some may choose to tithe on the full amount of their retirement income, while others may tithe on a percentage or only on any gains made on their investments. It is important to note that tithing is not a legal requirement, but rather a spiritual discipline of giving that is motivated by gratitude and generosity.

Tithing on taxable accounts

Understanding Tithing

Tithing is the practice of contributing a portion of one's income or earnings to a church or place of worship. In many Christian traditions, tithing is understood as giving approximately 10% of one's income, although the specific amount can vary. This act of giving is often seen as a way to support the church, demonstrate one's faith, and contribute to the wider community.

Tax Implications of Tithing

When it comes to taxable accounts, it is essential to understand the tax implications of tithing. In some countries, tithes may be considered charitable donations for tax purposes. This means that individuals may be able to claim tax deductions for their tithes, reducing their taxable income. However, this depends on the tax regulations of the specific country or region. In the United States, for example, tithes to a qualified charitable organization, such as a church, may be tax-deductible.

Personal Beliefs and Church Policies

Ultimately, the decision to tithe on taxable accounts is a personal one. Some individuals may feel that tithing is a private matter between themselves and their church or God, and they may choose not to involve the government or claim tax deductions. Others may view tithing as a way to support their community and may be comfortable claiming tax benefits if they are available. Additionally, church policies or guidelines can also influence an individual's decision. Some churches may have specific expectations or recommendations regarding tithing, including whether it should be based on gross or net income.

Practical Considerations

When considering tithing on taxable accounts, it is important to carefully review one's financial situation. In some cases, the standard deduction offered by tax authorities may be more beneficial than itemizing deductions, including tithes. This is especially relevant if the total amount of tithes and other charitable contributions does not exceed the standard deduction threshold. Additionally, individuals should consult with tax experts or professionals to ensure they comply with applicable tax laws and regulations.

Timing of Tithing

Another consideration is the timing of tithing in relation to tax refunds. Some individuals may choose to tithe before taxes, contributing from their gross income, while others may prefer to tithe after taxes, using their net income. This decision depends on personal beliefs, faith, and the policies of the individual's church. It is worth noting that tithing before taxes typically results in a slightly larger contribution.

In conclusion, tithing on taxable accounts involves navigating personal beliefs, church policies, and tax regulations. Individuals should carefully consider their financial situation, seek expert advice when needed, and make decisions that align with their values and faith.

Tithing on gifts

From a religious perspective, tithing is often associated with the biblical practice of offering a portion of one's income or increase to support the church or religious community. In the Old Testament, tithing was a requirement for the Israelites, who gave 10% of their earnings and agricultural produce to the Tabernacle or Temple. However, in the New Testament, the concept of giving is encouraged without specifying a rigid amount or percentage.

Some religious leaders and followers interpret this as a recommendation to give at least 10% of their income, including gifts, as a way to honour God and support their religious community. They view tithing as an act of worship and thanksgiving, trusting that God will provide blessings and prosperity in return.

On the other hand, some Christians argue that tithing on gifts is not biblically mandated. They differentiate between gifts and income, believing that tithing should be calculated based on one's salary or earnings. Additionally, they emphasize that the biblical tithe consisted of agricultural produce and livestock rather than money.

Ultimately, the decision to tithe on gifts is a personal and spiritual choice. Individuals are encouraged to seek guidance from God and make decisions based on their own beliefs and interpretations of religious teachings. While some may choose to include gifts as part of their tithing, others may opt to exclude gifts from their calculations, focusing solely on their income or earnings.

It is worth noting that tithing can also be done through means other than monetary donations. For example, individuals can donate stocks or other investments directly to the church or religious organization, which can provide tax benefits while still contributing to the community.

Tithing on inheritance

Tithing is a religious practice that involves giving a portion of one's income or earnings to support a church or other religious organization. The amount of the tithe can vary, but it is often suggested as being 10% of one's income.

When it comes to tithing on inheritance, there are a few different perspectives within the Christian faith. Some people believe that inheritance is considered a gift, and therefore, one is not obligated to pay tithing on it. This interpretation is based on the idea that tithing is calculated based on one's "increase" or profit, rather than on gifts or gratuities. In this case, a thank offering for an inheritance might be considered instead, with the amount given being left up to the recipient of the gift.

However, there are also those who believe that tithing should be paid on any form of income, including inheritances. For example, if one inherits a house, land, or other assets, some interpret that the tithe should be paid on the value of those assets when they are sold. This perspective holds that all income, including inheritances, is subject to tithing as a way of showing gratitude to God for one's blessings.

Ultimately, the decision to tithe on an inheritance may depend on individual interpretation and personal beliefs. While some may choose to follow specific guidelines or religious doctrines, others may be guided by their own conscience and sense of stewardship. It is worth noting that the New Testament encourages Christians to give based on all that God has provided, which could include inheritance, but emphasizes that the attitude and cheerfulness with which one gives are more important than the amount or percentage.

Frequently asked questions