Diamonds: A Risky Investment Gamble

While diamonds are widely regarded as a symbol of luxury and status, they are not a good investment. Diamonds are a depreciating asset, and their value is not determined by their intrinsic value but by their resale value. When a diamond is sold at retail, it instantly loses a huge portion of its value. The resale market for diamonds is also illiquid, and most people will have a hard time selling a diamond.

Additionally, diamonds do not have a universal price per gram, and their valuation is often subjective. Diamonds are also not fungible, and they cannot be easily exchanged for one another. The market for diamonds is neither liquid nor standardised, making it difficult to resell diamonds and realise their value.

Diamonds are not an investment, they are a depreciating asset

Diamonds are often touted as a good investment, but the reality is that they are a depreciating asset. In this article, we will explore the reasons why diamonds are not a good investment and why you should avoid them if you are looking to grow your wealth.

Lack of Intrinsic Value

An asset's value is driven by the future cash flow it will generate. For example, a car is a depreciating asset because its value decreases over time as it gets older and suffers wear and tear. Similarly, diamonds do not have any intrinsic value that can generate cash flow. They are not used in any industrial processes and their value is purely based on their aesthetic appeal and scarcity.

High Retail Markup

When you buy a diamond from a retailer, you are paying a significant markup on the original price. This markup can range from 30% to 200%, depending on the store. This means that you are already losing a large portion of your investment the moment you walk out of the store. For example, if you pay $1500 for a diamond that the retailer bought for $1000, you have instantly lost 33% of your capital.

Difficult to Resell

The market for diamonds is illiquid, which means that it is difficult to resell them. Retail jewellers often prefer not to buy back diamonds from customers because they would have to offer a wholesale price, which would be much lower than the original retail price. As a result, individuals who buy diamonds at retail prices and then try to resell them often suffer significant losses.

Subjective Valuation

Unlike gold, which has a universal price per gram, diamonds do not have a standard pricing metric. Each diamond is unique and must be valued based on its individual characteristics such as cut, colour, clarity, and carat weight. This makes it difficult to determine the true value of a diamond and increases the risk of overpaying.

Alternative Investments

There are better alternatives to investing in diamonds if you are looking for a solid store of value. Gold and silver, for example, are commodities that can be purchased on financial markets and have a long history of holding their value over time. They are also more liquid than diamonds, making them easier to buy and sell.

In conclusion, while diamonds may have some advantages as a physical commodity, they are not a good investment. Their value is subjective and difficult to determine, they are illiquid and difficult to resell, and they do not generate any cash flow. If you are looking to grow your wealth, there are much better alternatives available in the financial markets.

Diamonds are illiquid and not fungible

Diamonds are not a good investment because they are illiquid and not fungible. Illiquidity refers to the degree to which an asset can be bought or sold in the market without causing a significant movement in its price. In other words, it is challenging to sell diamonds at a price close to their purchase price. This is due to several factors, including the markup on diamonds, which can range from 100% to 200% at retail stores. When trying to resell a diamond, one would have to sell it at a lower price than what they paid for it, resulting in a loss. Retailers are also hesitant to buy back diamonds from customers as they do not want to make a low offer that might be deemed insulting and undermine the notion that diamonds are a good investment.

Diamonds are also not fungible, meaning they are unique and cannot be easily exchanged with each other. Each diamond has to be valued on its individual merits, and this valuation is often subjective. Diamond professionals use the 4 Cs (carats, colour, cut, and clarity) when classifying and pricing diamonds, and it is challenging to make apples-to-apples comparisons between diamonds due to the complexity of these dimensions. This lack of fungibility also makes diamonds illiquid and, consequently, very expensive to transact.

Diamonds are not a good investment unless you are a diamond dealer

The first issue is that diamonds are a depreciating asset. The moment a diamond ring is bought, it loses a huge chunk of its value. This is because the resale market for diamonds is illiquid, and most people will have a hard time selling a diamond. When buying a diamond, you are paying a mark-up of anywhere between 30-200% for retail pricing. This means that for you to make a 10% return on your diamond investment, the world diamond prices must rise by 65%. This is an extremely optimistic view, and it is unlikely that this will happen anytime soon.

Additionally, there is no universal price per gram for diamonds. Every diamond has to be valued on its individual merits, and most of the time, that valuation is subjective. This makes choosing which diamond to buy a tricky process.

Another problem is that the market for diamonds is neither liquid nor fungible. Retail jewellers, especially prestigious stores, prefer not to buy back diamonds from customers because the offer would most likely be considered too low. The markup on a diamond may range from 100-200%, but if they were to buy diamonds back from customers, they would have to buy them back at wholesale prices. This would mean a substantial loss for the customer.

Diamonds are also not a good investment because they are not subject to the same economic forces as other commodities. For example, the price of gold is often affected by inflation, but diamonds are not. This means that diamonds are not a good hedge against inflation.

Finally, the people who turn a profit on "investment-grade" diamonds are usually diamond dealers/retailers who are actively marketing and selling to foolish wannabe investors. These diamonds have extremely huge carat sizes (above 20 carats for colourless diamonds), extremely high carat sizes (plus good clarity) for rare coloured diamonds, or a rich history (such as being celebrity-owned). Unless you are a diamond dealer with access to these types of diamonds, it is unlikely that you will make a profit from investing in diamonds.

Diamonds are not a good investment unless you are buying extremely rare diamonds

Diamonds are not a good investment for the average person. They are a depreciating asset, and their resale value is usually much lower than the retail price. However, extremely rare diamonds may be a good investment for those with deep pockets.

Diamonds are a depreciating asset

Diamonds are often marketed as a good investment, but this is not true for the average consumer. Diamonds are a depreciating asset, and their value is based on the flawed concept that they can store value, appreciate, and hedge against inflation. In reality, diamonds are not an investment at all. The market for them is neither liquid nor fungible, and their resale value is usually much lower than the retail price.

The resale value of diamonds is low

When you buy a diamond, you typically pay a markup of between 30% and 200% for retail pricing. This means that you immediately lose a large portion of your investment. For example, if you pay $1,500 for a diamond that costs the retailer $1,000, you have already lost 33% of your capital ($500/$1,500). To make matters worse, the resale market for diamonds is illiquid, and most people will have a difficult time selling their diamonds. Jewelry stores and pawn shops are usually not interested in buying back diamonds, as they would have to pay below wholesale prices, which would result in a loss for them. As a result, consumers often suffer enormous losses when trying to resell their diamonds.

Diamonds are subject to high taxes and hidden costs

When investing in diamonds, it is important to consider the high taxes and hidden costs involved. Unless you are buying from a non-VAT area, a private seller, or a VAT-registered company, you will lose a significant percentage of your investment to taxes. Additionally, there may be retailer markups, the cost of a setting, and insurance expenses, all of which will further reduce the potential return on your investment.

Diamonds take a long time to increase in value

Diamonds are not a good short-term investment. Their value tends to increase very slowly over time, and it can take years for them to generate a profit. Therefore, investing in diamonds means that your money will be locked up for a long period, and there is no guarantee that you will make a profit when you eventually sell.

Diamonds are difficult to value

Unlike gold, which has a universal price per gram, diamonds do not have a standard price. Each diamond must be valued individually based on its unique characteristics, such as carat weight, colour, cut, and clarity. This makes it challenging to determine the true value of a diamond and increases the risk of overpaying or selling at a loss.

Diamonds are not easily traded

Despite claims that diamonds are easily liquidated, the reality is that the diamond market is neither liquid nor fungible. This means that it can be challenging to find buyers or sellers, and the transaction process can be complex and time-consuming.

Diamonds may be a good investment for high-net-worth individuals

While diamonds are generally not a good investment for the average person, extremely rare and high-value diamonds may be a different story. These include diamonds with extremely large carat sizes, rare coloured diamonds, or diamonds with a rich history, such as celebrity-owned pieces. However, these types of diamonds are typically very expensive, costing upwards of $1 million.

In conclusion, diamonds are not a good investment for most people due to their illiquidity, high taxes and markups, and slow appreciation in value. However, extremely rare and high-value diamonds may be a worthwhile investment for high-net-worth individuals who can afford to take on the risk.

Diamonds are not a good alternative investment

Diamonds are often touted as a good investment opportunity, but there are several reasons why this may not be the case.

Firstly, diamonds are not subject to the same economic forces as other commodities. For example, gold prices are often affected by inflation, but diamonds are not. This means that diamonds are not a good hedge against economic downturns or inflation.

Secondly, the diamond market is neither liquid nor fungible. Diamonds are difficult to resell, and even if you can find a buyer, you will likely suffer a substantial loss on your original purchase price. This is because the diamond market operates on large markups, with retail prices often 100-200% higher than wholesale prices. So, if you buy a diamond at retail and then try to sell it, you will have to sell it for less than wholesale to incentivise a buyer to take on the risk of purchasing it from you.

Thirdly, the value of a diamond is highly subjective and dependent on its individual characteristics. Unlike gold, which has a universal price per gram, every diamond must be valued based on its unique features such as cut, colour, clarity, and carats. This makes it very difficult to determine the true value of a diamond and whether it will appreciate over time.

Additionally, the diamond market is heavily controlled by a few large companies, particularly De Beers, which has historically monopolised the supply chain to keep diamond prices inflated. This further reduces the potential for diamonds to be a good investment, as the market is not operating on free-market principles.

Finally, diamonds are not a good alternative investment because they do not provide the same level of liquidity and transparency as other investment options, such as stocks or financial markets. It can be challenging to find a buyer for a diamond, and the resale value is often much lower than the original purchase price.

In conclusion, while diamonds may have some advantages as an investment, such as their durability, portability, and steady demand, the drawbacks significantly outweigh the benefits. Diamonds are not a good alternative investment due to their illiquidity, subjectivity in valuation, lack of fungibility, and the market control exerted by large companies.

Frequently asked questions