China's Bitcoin Investment: Exploring The Mystery

Despite China's ban on cryptocurrency trading and mining since 2021, Chinese investors have continued to find loopholes to invest in Bitcoin. The struggling Chinese market and rising marginal benefits of cryptocurrency have made Bitcoin an attractive investment option for those seeking to diversify their portfolios and hedge against economic uncertainty. The decentralised nature of Bitcoin, its potential for high returns, and the possibility of bypassing capital controls have driven many Chinese investors to embrace it, despite the risk of regulatory crackdowns. This has led to a thriving underground crypto market in China, with investors turning to Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) and offshore crypto exchanges to circumvent the ban.

Chinese investors' workarounds to buy Bitcoin

Although China banned crypto trading, ownership, mining, and investing in 2021, Chinese investors are still finding ways to buy Bitcoin. Here are some of the methods they are using:

Crypto Exchanges

Crypto exchanges such as OKX and Binance still offer trading services to Chinese investors, guiding them to use fintech platforms such as Alipay and WeChat Pay to convert yuan into stablecoins for trading cryptocurrencies. These exchanges allow trades by mainland users, even though warnings are displayed on their sites against such activity.

Overseas Bank Accounts

Mainland investors can open overseas bank accounts to buy crypto assets. After Hong Kong's endorsement of digital assets, Chinese citizens have been using their $50,000 annual forex purchase quotas to move money into cryptocurrency accounts in the territory.

Bank Cards

Some investors use bank cards issued by small rural commercial banks to buy cryptocurrencies through grey-market dealers, capping each transaction below the radar at 50,000 yuan ($6,978).

Digital Wallets

Digital wallet online games such as MetaMask, designed to buy and sell NFTs, can also be used to hold and trade cryptos.

Hong Kong

Hong Kong, a Chinese special administrative region, has endorsed crypto trading. Brick-and-mortar crypto exchange stores have opened in Hong Kong's business and shopping districts, where customers can buy cryptocurrencies with minimal amounts of HK$500 ($64) and without providing identity documents.

Peer-to-Peer Exchanges

It is possible to buy cryptocurrency in China without providing ID through a P2P exchange, but these are less secure and more challenging to use.

The Chinese government's ban on Bitcoin

The Chinese government has been taking an increasingly hardline stance against cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin, in recent years. In 2021, the People's Bank of China (PBOC) declared that all cryptocurrency transactions were illegal, effectively banning digital tokens such as Bitcoin. This ban was the culmination of a series of restrictions and crackdowns on the industry, which began in 2017 with the prohibition of cryptocurrency exchange operations within China.

The PBOC has cited several reasons for its ban on cryptocurrencies. Firstly, they argue that cryptocurrencies facilitate financial crime and pose a risk to the country's financial system due to their highly speculative nature. There are also concerns that cryptocurrencies enable capital flight from China, allowing residents to acquire foreign assets and circumvent capital controls. Additionally, the decentralised nature of Bitcoin and other blockchain-based cryptocurrencies goes against the Chinese government's desire for greater state intervention and control over the financial system, as evidenced by the development of the digital yuan.

Despite the ban, there is evidence that the Chinese crypto market is still active, with investors employing creative ways to access Bitcoin and other crypto assets. These include using overseas bank accounts, taking advantage of Hong Kong's open endorsement of digital assets, and trading on foreign exchanges. The Chinese government has continued to crack down on these activities, with warnings, increased restrictions, and prosecutions for those involved in "illegal financial activities".

The impact of China's ban on Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies is significant, given that China is one of the world's largest cryptocurrency markets. The ban has contributed to fluctuations in the global price of cryptocurrencies and has led to a decline in Bitcoin's energy use in the country. However, the effectiveness of the ban is questionable, as enforcing such a strict prohibition on cryptocurrency transactions is challenging.

While there have been rumours that China may ease restrictions on digital assets, there is currently no evidence to support this. The Chinese government's stance on cryptocurrencies remains largely negative, and it is unlikely that they will relax the ban anytime soon.

Hong Kong as a hub for Chinese Bitcoin investors

Hong Kong has ambitions to become a hub for the crypto sector, despite mainland China's ban on cryptocurrency transactions. In August 2023, the city issued the first licenses to regulate crypto exchanges offering trading in tokens like Bitcoin and Ether. This move is part of Hong Kong's effort to attract capital and talent back to the city, after its reputation was damaged by strict Covid-19 restrictions and a crackdown on political dissent.

Hong Kong's new rules allow retail investors to trade cryptocurrencies on exchanges licensed by the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC). The SFC has strict criteria for which virtual assets can be bought and sold, with platforms needing to consider factors such as a coin's time in circulation, market capitalization, and average daily trading volume.

Hong Kong's push to become a crypto hub appears to have quiet backing from Beijing, even as China maintains its ban on crypto trading. Analysts suggest that Hong Kong's crypto legalisation could serve as a model for policy formulation in other regions of China if it proves successful.

The city's endorsement of digital assets has attracted Chinese citizens, who are using their $50,000 annual forex purchase quotas to invest in cryptocurrency accounts in Hong Kong. Additionally, Chinese investors are using creative ways to own Bitcoin and other crypto assets, such as by opening overseas bank accounts or using bank cards issued by small rural commercial banks to buy cryptocurrencies through grey-market dealers.

Hong Kong's Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are, however, likely not available to mainland Chinese investors. This is not surprising given China's restrictive stance on crypto, with the country banning the trading and mining of tokens in 2021.

Despite the ban, China's crypto market recorded an estimated $86.4 billion in raw transaction volume between July 2022 and June 2023, surpassing Hong Kong's $64 billion in crypto trading during the same period.

Hong Kong, a Chinese special administrative region, is thus becoming a hub for Chinese Bitcoin investors, with the potential to shape crypto-related policies in the mainland.

The Chinese government's endorsement of crypto trading in Hong Kong

China has had a rocky relationship with cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin. While crypto trading and mining have been banned in the country since 2021, that hasn't stopped Chinese citizens from finding creative ways to invest in crypto. They do so by using grey-market dealers, overseas bank accounts, and rural commercial banks to escape scrutiny and make purchases.

Hong Kong, a special administrative region of China, has taken steps to enable retail investors to trade virtual assets on licensed platforms. This has been seen as an endorsement of crypto trading by the Chinese government, as it provides a way for its citizens to invest in cryptocurrencies.

Hong Kong's new rules, which came into effect on June 1, 2023, allow retail investors to trade larger tokens like Bitcoin and Ether. This is a significant shift from the previous ban on cryptocurrencies and a move towards embracing the nascent asset class. The Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission has implemented a new licensing system, making it illegal for unlicensed exchanges to market to Hong Kong investors. As of now, only OSL Digital Securities Limited and Hash Blockchain Limited have been licensed, but several other companies have expressed interest in applying for licenses.

The timing of Hong Kong's policy change is notable, as it coincides with a white paper released by the Beijing Municipal Science and Technology Commission and the Zhongguancun Science and Technology Park Management Committee. The paper affirmed a commitment to supporting blockchain-related companies, indicating a potential crypto renaissance in the country.

The impact of Hong Kong's new approach could be significant due to China's economic power. China's economic downturn has made investments on the mainland risky, and many Chinese citizens are looking to allocate assets offshore. Cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, with its reputation as a "safe haven," have become an attractive option.

While the Chinese government has not officially endorsed crypto trading, its allowance in Hong Kong provides a test case for a potential reversal of its ban on the mainland. The city's role as a special administrative region gives China the opportunity to explore the crypto space while maintaining control over its economy.

The future of crypto in China remains uncertain, but Hong Kong's endorsement of digital assets and the continued interest from Chinese investors suggest a potential shift in the government's stance.

The Chinese government's development of blockchain technology

China's relationship with blockchain technology and Bitcoin is complex. While crypto trading, ownership, mining, and investing are very much alive in China, the country has banned crypto trading since 2021. However, the Chinese government has been actively promoting the development and innovation of blockchain technology, recognising its potential beyond cryptocurrencies.

The Chinese government views blockchain as a critical breakthrough in core technologies. In 2019, President Xi Jinping called for accelerating blockchain development and innovation, resulting in 26 provinces issuing 117 policies and documents containing provisions for blockchain development between 2016 and 2021. The government has also provided substantial policy support, with the Ministry of Science and Technology approving the establishment of the National Blockchain Technology Innovation Centre. This centre will focus on integrating blockchain technology into China's economy and individuals' livelihoods, aiming to make it central to the country's digital infrastructure.

The Chinese blockchain market has been growing rapidly, expanding from USD $14.4 million in 2017 to USD $930 million in 2021 and is expected to continue growing. The government has prioritised blockchain technology in its "14th Five-Year Plan," recognising its importance in the digital economy. China has also launched the Blockchain Service Network (BSN), a global infrastructure network for deploying blockchain applications, led by the State Information Center.

While China has banned cryptocurrency-related activities, it actively promotes blockchain technology in other areas. This is known as non-crypto blockchain, which has applications in finance and digital governance. For example, China's judiciary system uses blockchain as a trusted ledger for storing evidence, improving traceability and auditing. Six major banks in China also utilise cross-chain protocols for inter-bank information sharing and are working towards achieving cross-chain transfers of credit card points and other on-chain assets.

China's development of blockchain technology focuses on research and development (R&D) for functions beyond cryptocurrency transactions, including large-scale consensus algorithms, smart contract technology, privacy protection, cross-chain protocols, and blockchain storage. These applications are commercially applied in the finance and digital governance sectors, with China's digital yuan rollout showcasing its interest in virtual money.

In conclusion, while China has banned crypto trading, it actively promotes and invests in blockchain technology, recognising its potential to revolutionise various sectors and drive digital transformation. The Chinese government's support has led to a thriving blockchain industry, with the country aiming to become a leader in this innovative technology.

Frequently asked questions