The Crypto Conundrum: Is Investing In Islam's Name?

Cryptocurrency has gained traction among investors in recent years, with Bitcoin hitting a five-year high in November 2021. However, there is a debate among Muslims as to whether cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin are halal or haram. This discussion centres on the compatibility of crypto with Islamic principles and Shariah law. While some scholars argue that crypto is haram due to its speculative nature, lack of regulation, and potential for illegal use, others contend that it is halal because it does not generate interest (riba) and can be used for legitimate financial transactions. The absence of a centralised authority and its high-risk nature are also points of contention. Ultimately, the decision to invest in crypto depends on individual interpretation and comfort with the associated risks.

Crypto is a high-risk investment similar to gambling

Cryptocurrency is a hotly debated topic among Islamic scholars, with some arguing that it is halal and permissible under Islamic law, while others claim it is haram and high-risk, akin to gambling. This article will focus on the argument that crypto is a high-risk investment similar to gambling and provide a detailed explanation of this perspective.

The High-Risk Nature of Crypto

Cryptocurrency, such as Bitcoin, has gained immense popularity in recent years, with many people making significant financial gains while others have faced catastrophic losses. The value of cryptocurrencies is extremely volatile and subject to wild swings. For example, the price of Bitcoin has fluctuated between $3,500 and $65,000 in just a few years, and there have been instances where prices have plunged by tens of thousands of dollars within a matter of weeks. This inherent volatility and uncertainty make crypto a very high-risk investment.

Lack of Intrinsic Value

A prominent group of UK politicians, including the Treasury Committee, have asserted that cryptocurrencies have "no intrinsic value and serve no useful social purpose". They argue that the price of crypto is based purely on speculation and what the market is willing to pay, with no underlying assets or value to back it up. This is in contrast to traditional investments, such as stocks, where the price is influenced by tangible factors such as company performance, management quality, and strategic aims. As a result, investing in crypto is more akin to gambling, where you are betting on the future price movements rather than investing in a company with intrinsic value.

Criminal Activity and Fraud

Crypto has also been criticised for its association with criminal activity and fraud. Due to its decentralised and anonymous nature, it has become a haven for criminals and gamblers looking to make quick money. This was evident in the collapse of several crypto exchanges, such as FTX, highlighting the risky nature of the industry. Additionally, there is a high risk of fraudulent activity, with banks reporting that a significant portion of transactions involving crypto were fraudulent. This further reinforces the notion that investing in crypto is similar to gambling, where there is a high risk of losing money due to criminal activity and a lack of regulatory oversight.

Regulatory and Protection Concerns

Investing in crypto also comes with limited regulatory protection. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) considers crypto to be a high-risk investment, and investors may find themselves unprotected if something goes wrong. Unlike traditional investments, there is no guarantee of financial recompense if the value of crypto plummets or if a crypto exchange collapses. This lack of protection further emphasises the gambling-like nature of crypto investing, as individuals are taking a significant risk with their money without the safety nets typically associated with regulated investments.

In conclusion, crypto is a high-risk investment that shares similarities with gambling. The volatile nature of crypto prices, the lack of intrinsic value, the association with criminal activity, and the limited regulatory protection all contribute to the argument that investing in crypto is akin to gambling. As with any speculative venture, individuals considering investing in crypto should be aware of the risks involved and only invest what they are comfortable losing.

It's used differently to money

One of the main reasons cryptocurrency is considered haram is that it is used differently to money.

Cryptocurrency is a digital or virtual form of currency that uses cryptography for security. Unlike traditional currencies issued by governments, such as the US dollar or the euro, cryptocurrencies are not controlled by a central authority and operate on blockchain technology. This means that transactions can be made without linking to a real-world identity, and they are theoretically immune to government interference or manipulation.

While cryptocurrencies are increasingly being used for transactions, they are not yet universally accepted as legal tender. They are also highly volatile and subject to extreme price fluctuations, which can be seen as a form of "Gharar" or excessive uncertainty, which is discouraged in Islam.

Another key difference between cryptocurrency and traditional money is that the former is not backed by physical assets like gold or other commodities. Cryptocurrencies are digital assets, and their value is stored in a digital ledger. This raises questions about their acceptability in Islamic finance, which typically requires monetary transactions to be backed by tangible assets.

Additionally, cryptocurrency is often used for speculative trading, similar to gambling, which is forbidden in Islam. According to a research paper, most cryptocurrency users have a speculative motive to gain profit rather than using it as a medium of exchange. This speculative nature, along with the lack of regulation and potential for illegal activities, further contributes to the view that cryptocurrency is used differently to money and may be considered haram.

However, it is important to note that not all Muslims agree with this assessment. Some argue that cryptocurrency can be considered a true currency or a digital asset with value. As such, using it for Sharia-compliant goods and services may not be haram. The debate hinges on various interpretations of Islamic laws and principles, and individual Muslims must decide whether they believe crypto is a true currency, a digital asset, or neither.

It's not regulated by governments or financial bodies

The unregulated nature of cryptocurrencies is a significant concern for Muslims considering investing in them. The lack of oversight from financial authorities means the crypto market is vulnerable to potential manipulation and fraudulent financial practices, which directly contradict the principles of fairness and integrity emphasised in Islamic finance.

The decentralised nature of cryptocurrencies means they are not issued or regulated by any central authority, such as a government. This raises the question of whether cryptocurrencies align with the Islamic understanding of a legitimate currency, which should be widely accepted, stable, and backed by the trust of its users.

The unregulated nature of cryptocurrencies also complicates their classification as halal or haram. Without regulation, there is a lack of control and accountability, which are important factors in Islamic finance.

Some Muslims are open to the idea of cryptocurrency becoming accepted if it is better regulated by governments and financial bodies. For example, regulation could enable governments and banks to treat crypto as sharf—the exchange of foreign currency (crypto) into local currency (cash). This could reduce the uncertainty and risk associated with crypto.

However, it is important to note that even with potential regulation, the very nature of cryptocurrencies as decentralised means they will always lack a central authority figure. This is a key consideration for Muslims, as it may mean cryptocurrencies do not align with the Islamic understanding of a legitimate currency.

The unregulated nature of cryptocurrencies has also facilitated their use in illegal activities, such as money laundering and financing for illicit purposes, which are indisputably haram. The anonymity of transactions in the crypto world raises serious ethical concerns in this regard.

In summary, the lack of regulation and oversight in the crypto market is a significant concern for Muslims considering investing. The decentralised nature of cryptocurrencies means they lack a central authority, which may complicate their classification as a legitimate currency in the Islamic understanding. The potential for illegal activities due to the anonymity of transactions is also a critical issue that contradicts Islamic principles. While regulation could help address some of these concerns, the decentralised nature of cryptocurrencies will always be a key consideration for Muslims considering investing in this space.

It can be easily used for illegal activities

Cryptocurrency is a highly attractive tool for criminals and terrorists due to its ease of use, speed, and the promise of anonymity. The absence of a central authority and regulatory requirements means that transactions can be conducted without the need for third-party mediation or validation. This is particularly appealing for one-off sales of drugs, digital data, and terror funding across borders.

The storage of cryptocurrency also presents an advantage for criminals. As digital assets, cryptocurrencies do not take up physical space, reducing the risk of attracting thieves or the attention of authorities. The ease of storage and transfer enables criminals to both steal and launder funds, with the largest cryptocurrency theft of 2020 involving the transfer of $275 million in cryptocurrency to an online wallet.

The irreversibility of cryptocurrency transactions poses another challenge for law enforcement agencies. Criminals can anonymously trade drugs, weapons, explosives, and child pornography, with terrorists also able to ask for funding and donations for extremist organizations without revealing their identities. The Twitter hack of 2020, which saw high-profile individuals' accounts compromised to promote a cryptocurrency scam, is an example of how the speed and irreversibility of transactions enable new types of crimes.

The use of cryptocurrencies for illegal activities is a significant problem, with illicit addresses receiving $14 billion in 2021, up from $7.8 billion in 2020. While the share of illicit activity in the overall cryptocurrency transaction volume is decreasing, the increasing adoption of cryptocurrencies provides new opportunities for cybercriminals.

The debate surrounding the permissibility of cryptocurrency in Islam centres on its compliance with Shariah principles. While some scholars argue that cryptocurrency is halal due to its anti-interest nature and alignment with Islamic finance rules, others believe it is haram because it lacks credibility as a currency. The use of cryptocurrency for illegal activities, such as gambling, drugs, and money laundering, further complicates the discussion.

To summarize, the ease of use, anonymity, and lack of central authority make cryptocurrencies attractive for illegal activities. The increasing adoption of cryptocurrencies has led to a rise in illicit activities, posing challenges for law enforcement agencies. The debate on the permissibility of cryptocurrency in Islam considers its compliance with Shariah principles, with the use of cryptocurrency for illegal purposes being a key factor in this discussion.

It's not real currency

The debate surrounding the status of cryptocurrency in Islamic finance centres on the concept of "Māl". Māl refers to something that can be possessed or stored for future use. For example, birds in the sky cannot be possessed and stored, so they are not considered Māl.

Some Islamic scholars argue that cryptocurrencies do not constitute Māl because they are not physical entities that can be purchased, stored, or traded. Cryptocurrencies are not money in your pocket but digital assets. However, others argue that cryptocurrencies are indeed Māl because they have value to individuals and businesses. They are real digital assets that can be owned, possessed, stored in digital wallets, and traded on exchanges.

Another argument against the status of cryptocurrency as Māl is that it is not a real currency. Cryptocurrencies are not backed by any central government that assigns its value and maintains regulatory standards. They are decentralised and operate outside of conventional banking systems. This means that there is no interest charged or payable, which aligns with Islamic banking laws that are also anti-interest. However, the lack of a central authority regulating the value of cryptocurrencies means that they are prone to high volatility and speculative trading.

The question of whether cryptocurrencies are real currencies centres on their acceptability as mediums of exchange. While some countries, like El Salvador, have accepted Bitcoin as legal tender, others like China have banned cryptocurrencies altogether. The UK and the US are also imposing or planning various regulations. Despite the lack of widespread acceptance, cryptocurrencies are already being used as a medium of exchange across the globe. They have purchasing power, and buyers and sellers use them to facilitate transactions.

In summary, the debate about whether investing in cryptocurrency is haram or halal under Islamic law hinges on the concept of Māl and the status of cryptocurrency as a real currency. While some scholars argue that cryptocurrencies are not Māl because they are not physical entities, others counter that they are indeed Māl because they have value and can be owned, possessed, stored, and traded. Additionally, while cryptocurrencies may not be considered real currencies by some due to the lack of central regulation, they are still used as a medium of exchange and have purchasing power.

Frequently asked questions