Ethical Investing: Does It Make A Real Impact?

Ethical investing, also known as socially responsible investing (SRI), is an investment strategy that allows investors to put their money toward companies that align with their values. While ethical investing has become increasingly popular, with inflows to such funds growing even as overall equity fund flows decline, it is still unclear whether it makes a difference. On the one hand, some evidence suggests that ethical investing can lead to sustainable returns and lower levels of market risk. On the other hand, critics argue that it may not have a significant impact on the world and could result in lower returns for investors. Ultimately, the effectiveness of ethical investing depends on various factors, including the specific approaches taken, the availability of investment options, and the level of commitment from investors and companies.

ESG investing: environmental, social and governance factors

ESG stands for environmental, social, and governance factors. These non-financial factors are increasingly being applied by investors as part of their analysis process to identify material risks and growth opportunities.

The three main components of ESG factors are:

• Environmental – conservation of the natural world.
• Social – consideration of people and relationships.
• Governance – standards for running a company.

Each component has a number of individual factors. For example, environmental factors include climate change and carbon emissions, air and water pollution, and customer satisfaction. Social factors include gender and diversity, while governance factors include executive compensation and political contributions.

It is important to note that there is no definitive taxonomy of individual ESG factors, and they are often interlinked. It can also be challenging to assign a monetary value to these factors.

ESG investing is sometimes referred to as sustainable investing, responsible investing, or impact investing. It grew out of investment philosophies such as Socially Responsible Investing (SRI) but there are key differences. SRI typically uses value judgments and negative screening to decide which companies to invest in, whereas ESG investing looks at finding value in companies.

There is some debate about the effectiveness of ESG investing. Critics argue that it serves as a de facto extension of governmental regulation, with large investment firms imposing ESG standards that governments cannot or do not directly legislate. There are also concerns about greenwashing, where companies embellish their environmental or social practices to appear more responsible.

However, ESG investing can help portfolios avoid holding companies engaged in risky or unethical practices. It also encourages companies to act responsibly and drive real change for the common good.

SRI investing: socially responsible investing

Socially responsible investing (SRI) is an investment strategy that aims to generate both positive social change and financial returns for an investor. SRI can go by many names, including values-based investing, sustainable investing, and ethical investing. The abbreviation "SRI" has also come to stand for sustainable, responsible, and impact investing.

SRI investments can be made into individual companies with good social value or through a socially conscious mutual fund or exchange-traded fund (ETF). These investments tend to mimic the political and social climate of the time. For example, in the 1960s, investors were mainly concerned with contributing to causes such as women's rights, civil rights, and the anti-war movement.

SRI has two inherent goals: social impact and financial gain. However, these do not necessarily go hand in hand. Just because an investment touts itself as socially responsible doesn't mean it will provide investors with a good return, and a promise of a good return is far from an assurance that the nature of the company involved is socially conscious.

Demand for SRI has been increasing. According to a 2019 Morgan Stanley survey, 85% of individual investors are interested in sustainable investing, up from 75% in 2017. Investment research company Morningstar says there were 303 sustainable open-ended mutual funds and exchange-traded funds in 2019, up from 111 in 2014.

There are two main ways to build an SRI portfolio:

• DIY: If you want maximum assurance that the companies you're investing in support your personal definition of SRI, you may want to create your own SRI portfolio.
• Robo-advisors: The majority of people prefer to make socially responsible investments when possible, but it takes work to figure out how committed a company is to ethical practices. Robo-advisors use algorithms to build and maintain an investment portfolio based on your risk tolerance and goals. While they are inexpensive and several offer SRI portfolios, they don't let you add in specific investments you're interested in.

There is evidence that SRI funds may perform as well as, or even better than, traditional funds. A 2020 research analysis from asset-management firm Arabesque Partners found that 80% of the reviewed studies demonstrated that sustainability practices have a positive influence on investment performance. Several other studies have shown that SRI mutual funds can not only match traditional mutual funds in performance but sometimes perform better. There is also evidence that SRI funds may be less volatile than traditional funds.

However, some sources argue that SRI doesn't make much of a difference. For example, according to an article in Vox, when you do the math, impact investing seems worse for your pocketbook than just investing traditionally and donating the difference. In addition, it's hard to invest in particularly promising companies or make them better at what they do.

Impact on business practices

Ethical investing is an investment strategy that allows investors to allocate capital toward companies that align with their personal values and beliefs. This can lead to a range of impacts on business practices as companies seek to attract ethical investors.

Firstly, ethical investing encourages businesses to adopt more sustainable practices. This includes reducing their environmental impact, such as carbon emissions, water usage, and packaging waste. It also involves treating employees with respect, ensuring fair wages, and providing fair working hours and overtime compensation. Ethical investing also incentivizes companies to implement transparent and ethical leadership practices, such as diverse and well-compensated boards of directors.

Secondly, ethical investing can influence a company's products and services. For example, ethical investors may avoid investing in companies that produce tobacco or firearms, or those that engage in environmental degradation or human rights abuses. This can result in companies excluding certain products or services from their offerings to align with the values of ethical investors.

Thirdly, ethical investing can lead to increased regulatory compliance as companies seek to meet ethical standards. This reduces the risk of legal issues and penalties and demonstrates a commitment to ethical business practices.

Finally, ethical investing can enhance a company's reputation and brand recognition, attracting more customers, investors, suppliers, and employees. This can lead to increased profitability and market share for companies that adopt ethical practices.

Overall, ethical investing has the potential to significantly impact business practices by encouraging companies to adopt more sustainable, transparent, and socially responsible operations.

Reporting and transparency

The importance of ethical financial reporting cannot be overstated. It is the cornerstone of corporate integrity and public trust, providing a transparent window into a company's operations for its investors and board of directors. Ethical financial reporting goes beyond presenting accurate figures; it involves a commitment to honesty, fairness, and responsibility in all financial disclosures. This level of transparency ensures that investors receive a clear and truthful picture of a company's financial health, enabling them to make informed investment decisions.

In the context of ethical investing, transparency and reporting are crucial for investors to assess a company's alignment with their values and principles. Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) criteria are increasingly used by investors to evaluate potential investments. The "Governance" aspect of ESG specifically focuses on the transparency and ethical leadership of a company's internal governance practices.

To ensure transparency, investors can refer to annual sustainability reports, corporate governance disclosures, and independent research and ratings from firms like Morningstar and MSCI. These sources provide insights into a company's environmental, social, and governance practices, allowing investors to make informed decisions about whether a company aligns with their ethical standards.

Additionally, companies themselves are embracing transparent reporting beyond traditional financial statements. This includes disclosing information on their environmental impact, social initiatives, and corporate governance practices. This trend towards transparent reporting enables investors to make more informed decisions about the ethical implications of their investments.

However, it is important for investors to be vigilant and look beyond the curtain of ethical investments. Terms like "sustainable" and "socially responsible" are often used interchangeably, and it can be challenging to find investments that perfectly align with one's values. Greenwashing, where companies falsely portray themselves as environmentally friendly, is a risk that investors need to be aware of. Due diligence, relying on reputable ESG scores and ratings, and conducting thorough research are essential to mitigating this risk.

In conclusion, reporting and transparency are vital for ethical investing. They empower investors with the information needed to align their financial decisions with their values and enable companies to build trust and attract conscious consumers. However, investors must remain cautious and diligent in their research to ensure that their investments genuinely adhere to ethical standards.

Returns and risks

Ethical investors may need to accept lower returns or higher fees due to the additional research required to identify suitable investments. However, some evidence suggests that ethical funds may offer lower market risks, especially during volatile periods. For example, during the initial months of the COVID-19 pandemic, 24 out of 26 ESG index funds outperformed their conventional counterparts.

The performance of ethical funds is influenced by various factors, including the specific ethical approach adopted, the quality of fund management, and the level of commitment to ethical practices. Some ethical funds have delivered strong returns over the years. For instance, the Fidelity Mutual Trust, the first publicly offered socially ethical investment fund, has averaged annual returns of 12% since its inception in 1928.

Additionally, ethical investing can be challenging due to the subjective nature of ethics and the complexity of evaluating a company's ethical standards. The concept of "greenwashing," where companies misleadingly promote eco-friendly characteristics, further complicates the process. Nevertheless, ethical investing can lead to positive outcomes for investors and society, making it a popular choice for those seeking to align their investments with their values.

Frequently asked questions