Kids And Debt: Are Loans Passed On?

Lending money to your children is a common practice for many parents, whether it's for a first car, higher education costs, or a down payment on a first home. While the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) generally does not concern itself with most family loans, there are tax implications to consider, especially for larger loans. This introduces a dynamic to the parent-child relationship that can lead to resentment or other complicated issues. Therefore, it is essential to carefully evaluate whether a family loan is the best option and to structure the loan appropriately.

Family loans vs. gifts

Lending money to your children throughout their lives is a common occurrence for many parents. This could be for a variety of reasons, such as helping them buy their first car, assisting with higher education costs, or contributing to a down payment on their first home. While this is a great way to foster a child's independence and encourage responsibility, it's important to understand the implications of a loan versus a gift.

The main difference between a loan and a gift is the expectation of repayment. A loan is typically documented with a contract and a repayment schedule, whereas a gift is an amount given without any obligation or expectation of repayment. From a tax perspective, a loan does not trigger any kind of gift tax exemption amount and can be provided in larger amounts because there is no annual exclusion limit. However, if you do not charge interest on a significant loan, the IRS may consider the amount of interest you should have charged as a gift, which would count towards your annual gift-giving limit. For 2024, a single individual can gift $18,000 per year to any other individual, including family members, without incurring gift tax implications.

On the other hand, a family loan may be a better option in certain situations. For example, if your child is not creditworthy or lacks the required down payment for a home, a family loan can help them purchase a home sooner than they otherwise would be able to. It can also instill a sense of ownership and responsibility. Additionally, with the current low-interest rates, parents have less interest income to report, and children can pay less interest than they would to a bank.

It's important to carefully consider the potential impact on your relationship with your child and their relationships with any siblings. Introducing lender-debtor dynamics to the family can lead to resentment or other complicated interpersonal issues. To avoid this, it's recommended to have a solid repayment plan in place and treat the loan like any other financial transaction, with a written agreement, interest rate, and fixed repayment schedule.

Student loans

As a parent, you have several options when it comes to helping your child with their student loans. Firstly, you can take out a parent student loan, where you (or another family member/guardian) are solely responsible for repayment. Alternatively, you could apply for a cosigned student loan, where you share the responsibility for repayment with the primary borrower (usually your child). While the former option places the financial obligation solely on the parent, the latter can help your child build their credit history if the loan is repaid on time.

Parent PLUS loans are a popular option for parents looking to cover the difference between the amount of federal student aid their child receives and the full cost of attendance. These loans are provided by the federal government and are available to biological or adoptive parents. While they don't have strict credit requirements, making it easier for parents to obtain them, they carry higher interest rates and origination fees than other federal student loans. It's important to carefully evaluate this option, as parents may end up with long-term financial repercussions if they borrow more than they can repay.

Another option is to simply help your child with their monthly expenses, such as groceries or medical bills, rather than paying off their student loans directly. This can ease their financial burden without taking on additional debt yourself. Additionally, you can encourage your child to apply for financial aid, which can come in the form of grants, scholarships, work-study programs, or student loans. The first step is usually to complete the FAFSA (Free Application for Federal Student Aid), where factors such as household size and age will be considered to determine the amount of aid your child is eligible for.

If you choose to pay off your child's student loans directly, it's worth noting that you may need to file a gift tax return and pay any applicable gift taxes. However, paying off your child's loans is unlikely to lead to tax liability on its own. Additionally, making small monthly payments while your child is still in college can help lower their overall debt.

Before making any decisions, it's important for parents to carefully consider their financial situation and how taking on additional debt might impact their future plans, especially if they are nearing retirement age. While it's natural to want to provide the best for your children, the burden of student debt can have long-term consequences, so thoughtful planning is essential.

Tax implications

Lending money to your children can have tax implications, and it is important to be aware of these before proceeding. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) generally isn't concerned with most family loans, especially smaller loans under $10,000. They also don't care how often loans are handed out, whether interest is charged, or if your child pays you back.

However, there are exceptions. If you loan a significant amount of money to your children, over $10,000, you should consider charging interest as a lender. If you don't charge interest, the IRS can say the amount of interest you should have charged was a gift, and this will count towards your annual gift-giving limit of $18,000 per individual as of 2024. If you give more than this amount to one individual, even if they are your child, you are required to file a gift tax form.

If you are giving your child a "student loan" to help fund their higher education, you can draw up a contract like any other loan. When they graduate and start a repayment schedule, your children can take the student loan interest deduction on any interest paid to you. Interest income is taxable income, and you will need to pay income tax on interest payments and report them to the IRS.

A written agreement for the loan is also beneficial if your child doesn't pay you back, as you can take a tax deduction for a non-business bad debt on your federal income tax return. You don't have to pay gift tax to the IRS on the amount, but to take a bad debt deduction, you must prove that the debt is worthless and there is no chance of repayment.

If you are lending a significant sum to a family member, it is a good idea to consider the potential tax consequences. For example, if you give a large amount of money to your child and call it a loan to avoid filing a gift tax return, the IRS may deem it a gift if the loan is not legal and enforceable. The IRS will look at several factors to determine whether a transaction is a loan or a gift, and if they determine that the loan's purpose was to avoid taxes, they can re-characterise it as a taxable gift.

Impact on the parent's finances

Lending money to your children can have a significant impact on your finances, and it is important to consider the potential financial consequences before doing so.

Firstly, it is essential to distinguish between small loans and more significant loans. In the US, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is generally not concerned with small loans to family members, typically those under $10,000. These loans do not need to be reported, and there are no tax implications. However, for larger loans, the IRS may get involved, and there could be tax consequences. If you loan a significant amount, over $10,000, it is advisable to charge interest to avoid gift tax implications. The interest must be based on the applicable federal rates (AFRs) set by the IRS or the borrower's net investment income. If you do not charge interest, the IRS may consider the foregone interest as a gift, which counts towards your annual gift-giving limit of $18,000 per individual as of 2024. Exceeding this limit triggers a gift tax form requirement, with a 40% tax on amounts over $12.92 million.

Another financial consideration is the potential for resentment or complicated interpersonal issues within the family. Lending money to children can affect relationships with them and their siblings. It is essential to assess how the loan may impact these relationships and whether it could cause resentment, especially if other siblings feel they are being treated unfairly. A loan with a solid repayment plan can help mitigate these issues and ensure your child understands the importance of financial independence.

Furthermore, if you are considering a loan to fund your child's education, it is vital to explore all options and set clear expectations. This includes investigating 529 plans, scholarships, grants, and federal aid before turning to student loans. If you do opt for a student loan, ensure you understand the repayment options and potential financial hardships. Communicate with your child about the loan, setting clear expectations for how the funds will be used. Help them manage this money to ensure it is not frivolously spent.

In conclusion, lending money to your children can have a substantial impact on your finances, and it is crucial to carefully consider the potential tax implications, the effect on family dynamics, and the specific details of the loan, especially if it is for education.

Impact on the child's financial independence

Financial independence is a crucial aspect of a child's journey into adulthood, and it can be influenced by various factors, including loans taken by parents. While loans can provide much-needed funds for significant expenses, they can also have implications for the child's future financial decisions and relationships.

Firstly, loans taken by parents can impact a child's financial independence by creating a sense of financial responsibility and awareness. When parents involve their children in financial discussions and planning, it helps them understand the importance of money management and the potential consequences of loans. This knowledge can empower children to make informed decisions about their finances as they transition into adulthood.

Additionally, the type of loan a parent takes can have varying effects on a child's financial independence. For instance, student loans taken by parents to fund their child's education can alleviate the immediate financial burden on the child. However, it may also impact the child's future financial decisions. In some cases, parents paying off their student loans may prioritize this over investing in tax-advantaged accounts for their children's education, potentially affecting the child's ability to secure financial aid or scholarships.

Moreover, the dynamics between parents and children can be influenced by loans. Introducing lender-debtor dynamics within a family can be complex and requires careful consideration. While a loan can help a child achieve their goals, such as buying a home or starting a business, it is essential to assess the potential impact on the parent-child relationship and the child's relationships with siblings. A well-structured family loan with a solid repayment plan can foster a sense of financial responsibility and ownership in the child.

The financial situation of the parents also plays a role in the child's financial independence. When parents provide financial assistance to their children, it can sometimes impact their finances, especially for those with lower incomes. This may, in turn, affect the level of support they can offer, potentially influencing the child's ability to manage their finances independently.

Furthermore, cultural and societal factors can influence the impact of loans on a child's financial independence. In some cultures, it is common for children to live with their parents for extended periods, which can impact their sense of financial independence. While some may view this arrangement positively, others may perceive it as a hindrance to their financial autonomy.

In conclusion, loans taken by parents can have both immediate and long-term effects on a child's financial independence. While they can provide necessary financial support, they can also shape the child's relationship with money, their parents, and their siblings. Therefore, it is essential to carefully consider the potential consequences and involve the child in financial discussions to foster a healthy understanding of financial responsibility.

Frequently asked questions