Cash Vs Investing: Is Holding Cash Ever Better?

Holding cash can be a good option for those who want to protect their wealth in a volatile market. It is also a good option for those who want to have immediate access to their money in case of emergencies. However, holding cash does not earn any returns and is prone to inflation, which can erode its buying power over time. On the other hand, investing in stocks and bonds can provide higher returns but comes with higher risks. So, has holding cash ever been better than investing? The answer depends on various factors, including an individual's financial situation, risk tolerance, investment goals, and market conditions.

Holding cash can be beneficial for emergency funds and unexpected expenses

Another benefit of holding cash is maintaining control and flexibility. When you hold cash, you have complete control over your funds, knowing that they are safely stowed in a bank account. This provides peace of mind and the ability to easily review your balance and transaction history. Additionally, holding cash offers ultimate flexibility during stressful times. If you need access to your funds in the near future, such as within the next year, cash ensures you have the necessary liquidity when you need it. Investing in the market, on the other hand, carries the risk of losing money in the short term due to market volatility.

It is important to consider the opportunity cost of holding cash. Cash does not earn a return, and inflation can erode its buying power over time. However, this can be mitigated by keeping cash in high-yield savings accounts or money market accounts, which offer higher returns than standard checking or savings accounts. These accounts provide a balance between accessibility and earning potential, allowing you to take advantage of higher interest rates while maintaining liquidity.

A general rule of thumb for emergency funds is to keep around three to six months' worth of living expenses in cash or cash equivalents. This ensures that you have sufficient funds to cover unexpected costs and provides a buffer in case of a job loss or other financial setbacks. By holding this amount in cash, you reduce the risk of having to sell investments at a loss to cover emergency expenses.

Cash is FDIC-insured, providing security and easy access

Cash is a low-risk option for investors, as it is readily available and typically insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) for up to $250,000 per banking institution where deposits are held. This means that cash deposits in checking and savings accounts are protected, providing security for investors.

The FDIC was established to maintain stability and public confidence in the nation's financial system. The insurance limit of $250,000 per depositor per insured bank has been in place since 2010, providing reassurance to those with significant cash holdings. Accounts at federal and state-chartered credit unions are also insured up to $250,000 through the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA). This dual system of insurance ensures that a large portion of an individual's cash holdings is protected, even in the event of a bank failure.

The FDIC-insured limit of $250,000 per depositor per bank covers various types of accounts, including checking, savings, money market deposit accounts, and certificates of deposit (CDs). This protection extends to different ownership categories, such as single accounts, joint accounts, retirement accounts (IRAs and Keogh accounts), and trust accounts. The insurance coverage is per depositor, per bank, ensuring that individuals with multiple accounts or those with joint accounts are covered up to the specified limit.

While FDIC insurance provides security for cash holdings, it's important to note that not all financial products are insured. For example, investments such as stocks, bonds, mutual funds, life insurance policies, annuities, or municipal securities are not covered by FDIC insurance. These types of investments carry their own risks and potential rewards, and investors should carefully consider their options before deciding where to allocate their funds.

In addition to the security provided by FDIC insurance, cash also offers easy access and high liquidity. Cash in checking and savings accounts can be quickly and easily withdrawn or transferred as needed, providing flexibility for individuals who may need immediate access to their funds. This accessibility is particularly valuable for emergency funds or short-term financial goals.

While holding cash provides security and easy access, it's important to consider the opportunity cost and the potential impact of inflation. Cash does not generate returns, and inflation can erode its buying power over time. Therefore, while FDIC insurance protects the nominal value of cash deposits, the purchasing power of those funds may decrease due to inflationary pressures.

In summary, cash is FDIC-insured, providing security for investors by protecting their deposits up to specified limits. Additionally, cash offers easy access and high liquidity, making it a stable option for short-term financial needs. However, investors should be mindful of the potential drawbacks, including the opportunity cost of foregone investments and the impact of inflation on the buying power of cash holdings over time.

Cash investments can be advantageous during rising interest rates

Holding cash can be a good idea if you need the money in the short term, for example, if you are saving for a house deposit or have upcoming cash needs such as a renovation, taxes, or college fees.

Holding cash can also be a good idea if you are risk-averse and want to protect your wealth in a volatile market. Cash is a low-risk, liquid asset that is FDIC-insured for up to $250,000 per banking institution. It gives you complete control over your money and ensures that you have the funds available whenever you need them.

However, holding cash for too long can result in an opportunity cost, as you may miss out on potential investment returns. Cash does not generate any return, and inflation can erode its buying power over time. Therefore, it is generally recommended to invest your money in assets such as stocks, bonds, or real estate to build wealth over the long term.

• Flexibility and Liquidity: Cash provides ultimate flexibility and liquidity, especially if you need access to your funds in the near future. During times of economic uncertainty, having cash on hand can give you peace of mind and help you navigate unexpected expenses or financial challenges.
• Low Risk: Cash is a low-risk asset compared to other investments such as stocks or bonds. It is not subject to market volatility and is FDIC-insured, guaranteeing the safety of your funds up to certain limits. This can be particularly advantageous during rising interest rates when other investments may become riskier.
• Protection Against Inflation: During rising interest rates, inflation tends to be a concern. While cash itself does not earn any interest, it can help protect your purchasing power. As interest rates increase, the cost of borrowing goes up, and the buying power of your cash remains stable, allowing you to purchase more goods and services.
• Opportunity to Invest at Higher Rates: Holding cash during rising interest rates allows you to take advantage of higher returns on investments such as bonds, money market accounts, or fixed-income securities. By waiting for rates to rise, you can lock in higher yields and potentially generate more significant returns over time.
• Diversification: Holding cash as part of your investment portfolio can provide diversification and help balance your risk. During economic downturns or market corrections, cash can serve as a buffer and allow you to take advantage of buying opportunities when asset prices decline.

While cash investments can be advantageous during rising interest rates, it is important to consider your investment goals, time horizon, and risk tolerance. Holding cash for an extended period may result in missed opportunities for growth, so it is crucial to regularly review and adjust your investment strategy accordingly.

Short-term investments can help your money grow, but they are subject to market volatility

Holding cash can be tempting when yields on savings and cash-like investments are attractive. However, it is important to consider your timeframe and how you plan to use the money. If you don't need the funds in the near term, holding cash could be short-sighted.

Short-term investments are typically held for a few minutes to a year or two, with the goal of achieving a quick return on investment. They offer flexibility, as investors can easily convert them into cash when needed. They also allow investors to adapt to changing market conditions and take advantage of higher-yielding investments.

Advantages of short-term investments

• Liquidity: Short-term investments can be easily converted into cash, providing quick access to funds in case of emergencies or unexpected expenses.
• Capital preservation: Short-term investments often prioritise capital preservation by using financial vehicles like savings accounts, money market funds, and short-term bond funds.
• Adaptability: Short-term investments allow investors to adjust their portfolios and take advantage of evolving market conditions.
• Diversification: Short-term investments can help mitigate risk and increase portfolio stability by spreading risk across different asset classes and investment horizons.

Disadvantages of short-term investments

• Lower returns: Short-term investments typically offer lower returns compared to long-term investments.
• Inflation risk: There is a risk that the rate of return might not keep pace with inflation, resulting in a decrease in purchasing power.
• Opportunity cost: Short-term investments may cause investors to miss out on higher returns from long-term investments or more aggressive strategies.
• Interest rate risk: Short-term investments can be impacted by fluctuations in interest rates, making them less attractive compared to other investment options.
• Market volatility: Short-term investments are prone to rapid and drastic price fluctuations, leading to potential substantial losses.
• High transaction costs: Frequent trading associated with short-term investing leads to higher brokerage fees and spreads, which can significantly reduce overall returns.
• Overreliance on market timing: Short-term investing relies heavily on the ability to accurately predict market movements, a challenging task even for experienced investors.
• Emotional decision-making: The fast-paced nature of short-term investing can lead to impulsive decisions driven more by emotion than careful analysis.
• Tax implications: Earnings from short-term investments are generally taxed at a higher rate than long-term gains, reducing net returns.

Short-term investments can be a double-edged sword, offering the potential for quick returns while also posing unique risks and challenges. It is important for investors to carefully consider their financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment timeframe before deciding between short-term and long-term investment strategies.

Long-term investments offer higher returns and better hedge against inflation

Holding cash can be a tempting prospect, especially after a poor year for stocks and bonds. However, history shows that cash investments are rarely the best option for long-term wealth accumulation.

While cash investments are low-risk and provide the security of knowing exactly where your money is, they do not earn any return and are therefore vulnerable to inflation. This means that, over time, cash investments will lose buying power.

Long-term investments, on the other hand, offer higher returns and a better hedge against inflation. Here are some examples of long-term investments that can help protect your portfolio against inflation:

• Stocks: The stock market has a long history of providing attractive returns over the long term. While there may be periods of volatility and poor performance, the overall trend of the stock market is upward. This makes stocks a good option for hedging against inflation.
• Real estate: Real estate investments, such as real estate investment trusts (REITs), tend to perform well during inflationary periods. As inflation rises, so do property values and rental incomes. This helps to keep pace with the rise in inflation.
• Bonds: Bonds are a traditional investment option for income-oriented investors. They provide interest income that often meets or exceeds the rate of inflation. Investing in bonds from foreign issuers can also help to hedge against domestic inflationary cycles.
• Treasury inflation-protected securities (TIPS): TIPS are a type of U.S. Treasury bond that is specifically designed to protect against inflation. The principal value of TIPS changes based on the inflation rate, and the interest rate paid on TIPS will also move up or down in response to changes in inflation.
• Floating-rate bonds: These bonds offer a payout that rises in response to increases in interest rates caused by rising inflation. This can help to mitigate the effects of inflation on your investment.

While holding cash can be a good option for short-term savings goals or emergency funds, it is generally not the best strategy for long-term wealth accumulation. Long-term investments, such as stocks, real estate, bonds, and inflation-protected securities, offer higher returns and provide a better hedge against inflation.

Frequently asked questions