The Mortgage Industry: A Broken System?

The mortgage industry is currently facing one of its biggest downturns in history. In the face of inflation, competition, market volatility, and economic uncertainty, the industry is experiencing an exodus of professionals, with many finding themselves disenchanted with the once-thriving sector. The mortgage origination industry is confronted with headwinds of risk, strategy, and efficiency, as companies with cumbersome processes struggle to navigate the challenging landscape. Mortgage rates have soared, and the outlook for housing is pretty bleak. The industry is also grappling with issues such as overhead efficiency, market knowledge gaps, and the impact of technological advancements. As the market contracts, lenders are struggling to earn sufficient profits, and the question of how to manage servicing assets looms large.

The mortgage industry is facing one of its biggest downturns in history

Firstly, the industry is experiencing "unbelievable volatility" in mortgage rates, which have reached their highest point since the pandemic, almost doubling in the last year. This has significantly impacted the total origination volume, which is expected to decrease from $2.26 trillion in 2022 to $2.05 trillion in 2023, a substantial decline from the $4.4 trillion in loans written in 2021. The refinancing sector is particularly affected, with a projected drop of 24%, while purchase money lending is also expected to slip by 3%. The housing outlook is further exacerbated by rising inflation, currently pushing 8%, which is well above the Fed's target rate. As a result, consumers are facing increased financial strain, with consumer credit delinquencies reaching a five-year high, partly driven by mortgage debt.

Secondly, the mortgage industry is witnessing an exodus of professionals, with many disenchanted by the current market conditions and the challenges in achieving financial success. There has been a 15% year-over-year decrease in mortgage employees, and 60% of mortgage professionals are living paycheck to paycheck, according to a survey by Everee. The high turnover rates and lead trouble have led to concerns about the industry's outlook and job security.

Additionally, lenders are struggling to earn sufficient profits from the origination of new mortgage assets, and many have burned through the equity accumulated during the pandemic boom years. This has resulted in a polarization within the mortgage finance industry, with lenders facing a "regional ditch," characterized by a lack of market knowledge and insufficient funds to hire the right talent.

To navigate this challenging period, mortgage executives must focus on risk management, strategy, and efficiency. They need to make prudent decisions regarding the servicing assets when selling off production and carefully consider the consequences of each path. Emphasizing customer-centric approaches and developing long-term advisory strategies can help build repeat customer business. Furthermore, companies must improve operational efficiency, reduce overheads, and broaden their product offerings to adapt to the adverse environment.

While the industry faces significant headwinds, there is a silver lining. The National Association of Realtors estimates that 50 million people are in their prime home-buying years, indicating strong demand for houses and mortgages in the coming years.

The industry is seeing an exodus of employees

The mortgage industry has traditionally been seen as a lucrative field, with a boom in refinancing from 2020 to 2021 attracting many newcomers. However, a "perfect storm" of market volatility, inflation, competition, and economic uncertainty has since disenchanted many professionals.

As of May 2023, there were 343,000 mortgage employees in the United States, a 15% decrease year-over-year and an 18% drop from the peak of 420,000 in July 2021. This exodus is evident in the number of valid loan officers, which fell below 90,000 in Q2 2023, compared to over 180,000 during the COVID-19 pandemic's peak market activity.

Several factors have contributed to this trend. Firstly, the Federal Reserve's plan to taper mortgage-backed security purchases by $5 billion will cause market volatility and impact the financials of many originators. Secondly, the Mortgage Bankers Association predicted a significant drop in refinancing volume in 2022, creating high-level financial risk for originators. Thirdly, consumer credit delinquencies have reached a five-year high, signalling growing financial strain among borrowers driven by mortgage debt.

The result is an industry facing significant challenges. Loan officers are struggling with reduced income, with 60% living paycheck to paycheck, and many are considering leaving. Those who remain are faced with the challenge of adapting to a changing market. As Anthony Yap, a marketing director at Express Capital, observed, originators with structured teams will be more successful than loan officers working independently.

The exodus has also impacted the companies left behind. They are faced with the challenge of recruiting and retaining talent, especially as they may not be able to match the compensation that originators earned in the booming 2020-2021 market. As a result, companies are cutting expenses and increasing volume to spread out fixed costs.

There is a lack of market knowledge and cash flow

The mortgage industry is currently facing one of its biggest downturns in history. A combination of factors, including inflation, competition, market volatility, and economic uncertainty, has led to a decline in overall mortgage activity and employment. The industry has also experienced a wave of disenchantment among professionals, with many choosing to leave due to the challenging market conditions.

This exodus from the industry can be attributed to the financial strain and uncertainty caused by the current market environment. Lenders are struggling to earn enough money on the origination of new mortgage assets, and the decline in home loan volume has further reduced profits. As a result, lenders are facing a lack of cash flow and market knowledge, making it challenging to hire the right talent and compete in the market.

The issue of cash flow is particularly prominent, with many lenders burning through their equity and facing scant profits. This has resulted in a polarization within the mortgage finance industry, where lenders who do not meet certain financial thresholds struggle to compete. The reduction in force seen across the industry has also impacted efficiency, as remaining employees are unable to keep up with the increased workload.

To address the lack of market knowledge and cash flow, lenders should focus on risk management, strategy, and efficiency. This includes making prudent decisions regarding the servicing of assets, such as whether to sell or retain servicing rights. Additionally, lenders should prioritize data accuracy and reliability to make informed choices and maintain loan quality.

Furthermore, lenders should consider broadening their product offerings to include non-qualified mortgage (non-QM) loans, which can help them navigate the adverse environment. Seeking external talent with relevant experience and expertise can also provide valuable insights and improve their competitive position. By focusing on these strategic initiatives, lenders can improve their financial positioning and better navigate the challenging market conditions.

Companies are struggling to make money

The mortgage industry is facing significant challenges, with companies struggling to make money and many professionals leaving the industry. Several factors, including inflation, competition, market volatility, and economic uncertainty, have led to a decline in mortgage activity and profitability.

Data shows that overall mortgage activity has dropped significantly, with a 74% decrease from the third-quarter highs in 2021 to the first quarter of 2023. This decline has had a direct impact on industry employment, with a 15% year-over-year decrease in the number of mortgage employees as of May 2023. The situation is further exacerbated by the high cost of living, with 60% of mortgage professionals living paycheck to paycheck, leading to a potential exodus of talent from the industry.

The challenges in the mortgage industry are not limited to employment issues. Mortgage companies are facing difficulties in maintaining profitability due to various factors. One significant challenge is the decrease in refinancing volume. The Mortgage Bankers Association predicted a massive drop of nearly $1 trillion in refinancing volume in 2022, creating high-level financial risk for many originators. This is particularly concerning for companies that prospered in 2020 and 2021 due to ultra-low rates. With the Federal Reserve's plan to taper mortgage-backed security purchases, market volatility is expected to increase, impacting the financial stability of mortgage firms.

Additionally, lenders are struggling to earn enough money on the origination of new mortgage assets. The limited revenue generated from servicing rights alone is not sufficient to sustain their organizations. Lenders are facing tough decisions regarding the servicing assets when selling off their production. They must consider whether to sell or retain servicing rights and, if retained, whether to service loans in-house or through a sub-servicer. These decisions have financial implications and impact customer satisfaction, making it crucial for lenders to have objective data and industry insights to navigate these challenges effectively.

The current challenges in the mortgage industry have led to an air of uncertainty and concern among professionals. While some choose to leave the industry, others are reassessing their career goals and exploring new opportunities. The high turnover rates and financial strain among borrowers, driven partly by mortgage debt, contribute to the overall sentiment of difficulty in the industry.

There is a high level of risk for mortgage firms

The mortgage industry is currently experiencing one of its biggest downturns in history. This is due to a confluence of factors, including inflation, competition, market volatility, and economic uncertainty. Mortgage rates have reached their highest point since the pandemic, and the industry has seen an exodus of professionals, with many feeling disenchanted and disillusioned with the sector.

The mortgage industry is also facing challenges due to inertia or resistance to change. Decision-making in uncertain environments carries significant risk, and CEOs and decision-makers must navigate this carefully. Lenders are struggling to earn enough money on the origination of new mortgage assets, and strategic decisions regarding servicing assets become critical for survival. The polarization within the mortgage finance industry, referred to as the "regional ditch," further exacerbates the financial strain. Lenders who do not meet certain financial thresholds will find it challenging to compete when the market recovers.

Additionally, the mortgage industry is facing a talent exodus, with a 15% year-over-year decrease in employees and a high percentage of professionals living paycheck to paycheck. High turnover rates and layoffs have impacted the industry, and many who have left may not return due to the emotional scars of job loss and the difficulty in finding new employment. The current market environment demands nimble and efficient organizations, and companies with cumbersome mortgage origination processes will find it challenging to maneuver.

Overall, the high level of risk for mortgage firms is evident in the market volatility, financial strain, strategic challenges, and talent exodus facing the industry.

Frequently asked questions