Mortgage Market: Navigating The Perfect Storm

The state of the mortgage market is a key indicator of the broader economy's health. As of March 2025, the mortgage market is sluggish, with high mortgage rates and home prices hampering activity. Americans owe $12.61 trillion on their mortgages, with mortgage debt accounting for 69.9% of US consumer debt. Mortgage originations have dropped significantly since 2021, when they hit a record high of $4.51 trillion. In 2024, originations rose to $1.69 trillion, a 12.9% increase from 2023. The housing market frenzy during the COVID-19 pandemic, spurred by record-low mortgage rates, contributed to a $3 trillion increase in outstanding mortgage debt. While there are signs of improvement, such as a slight decline in mortgage rates and an increase in home sales, the market still faces challenges, including a shortage of houses and high inflation.

Americans owe $12.61 trillion in mortgage debt

The state of the mortgage market is closely tied to the housing market, which has been sluggish in recent years due to steep mortgage rates and high home prices. Despite this, the housing market remains an integral part of the economy, and understanding its dynamics can shed light on the broader economic landscape.

As of 2025, Americans owe a staggering $12.61 trillion in mortgage debt, spread across 85.10 million mortgages. This translates to an average debt of $148,120 per person with a mortgage on their credit report. Notably, mortgage debt accounts for a significant portion of U.S. consumer debt, representing 69.9% of the total.

The surge in mortgage debt can be attributed to two primary factors: an increase in the number of people with active mortgages and the rise in the size of mortgages. The COVID-19 pandemic played a pivotal role, as record-low mortgage rates during this period spurred a housing market frenzy. Many buyers locked in these low rates, enabling them to increase their purchase prices or pursue cash-out refinances while maintaining similar monthly payments compared to pre-2020 levels.

While the housing market has faced challenges due to high mortgage rates and limited inventory, it is important to note that delinquency rates remain low. As of 2025, only 0.70% of borrowers are seriously delinquent, defined as being late on monthly payments by 90 days or more. This indicates that, despite economic headwinds, most borrowers are staying current on their mortgage payments.

Mortgage rates have been volatile, with the average interest rate for a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage in 2024 at 6.73%. In 2025, rates have continued to fluctuate, ranging from a low of 6.63% in early March to a high of 7.04% in mid-January. These rates are significantly higher than the historic lows seen in 2021, which contributed to a peak in mortgage originations that year.

Mortgage rates are at a 20-year high

Mortgage rates have been steadily rising since their record lows in 2020 and 2021, which were caused by emergency actions by the Federal Reserve during the COVID-19 pandemic. This allowed many buyers to increase their purchase prices or take advantage of cash-out refinances. However, the economic recovery from the pandemic has seen a sharp reversal of this trend, with rates now at their highest level since 2005.

The average 30-year fixed-rate mortgage is currently 6.78%, up from 6.76% the previous week. This is significantly higher than the long-time average, which is an extra monthly cost of $1,300, or $15,900 per year. For context, a $200,000 mortgage at the 2016 rate of 3.65% would have a monthly cost of $915. At today's rates, the same mortgage would cost $2,074 per month, or $2,800 at the 1981 rate of 16.63%causing issues in the housing market, with people with low mortgage rates reluctant to move, and buyers facing much higher costs. This is causing a lack of supply, which is driving prices up further. The combination of rising home prices and elevated mortgage rates means that housing affordability is a significant problem.

The housing market is sluggish

Mortgage rates tend to fall during economic downturns, but lower rates also increase demand, pushing house prices up. This dynamic makes it challenging to buy a house when both rates and prices are favourable. The Federal Reserve's rate hikes in 2022, in response to inflation, slowed the housing market, leading to sharp drops in home sales. While home prices initially hit record levels, they have since stabilised or fallen slightly.

Market uncertainties, such as new policies from the Trump administration, also play a role in the sluggish housing market. Potential changes in immigration and tariff policies may impact the labour market and building supply costs, respectively. Additionally, the Federal Reserve's actions to reduce its balance sheet of mortgage-backed securities have kept mortgage rates elevated, as private investors need to step up to fill the demand.

The housing market frenzy during the COVID-19 pandemic, spurred by record-low mortgage rates, contributed to the current situation. Many buyers locked in these low rates, allowing them to increase their purchase prices or take advantage of cash-out refinances. However, as rates have climbed higher, buyers are now facing steeper monthly payments, and sellers are receiving lower offers.

While inventory is growing, it is still a seller's market, and the combination of high home prices and elevated mortgage rates continues to hamper market activity.

Interest rates are volatile

Mortgage rates tend to be higher than yields on the benchmark 10-year Treasury note. In 2025, modestly declining mortgage rates tracked with 10-year Treasury bond yield changes. However, mortgage rates are influenced by a variety of factors, and it is challenging to predict how changes in interest rates will affect the housing market. For example, while lower rates typically increase demand as more buyers enter the market, this can also lead to rising house prices.

The Federal Reserve's actions can also influence mortgage rates. In 2022, as inflation spiked, the Fed enacted increases of up to three-quarters of a point, slowing the housing market and causing home sales to drop. Now that inflation is down, these rate hikes have stopped, but it is unclear how this will impact the housing market in the long term.

In addition to the Federal Reserve, other factors, such as the labour market, immigration policies, and building supply costs, can also affect interest rates. For instance, possible immigration crackdowns may reduce the construction labour force, while tariff policies could impact the cost of building supplies. As a result, interest rates could adjust higher if inflation becomes a significant issue again.

While it is challenging to time the market perfectly, buyers should consider their financial situation and comfort level with the terms offered. Buying a home when both mortgage rates and home prices are favourable can be challenging, and waiting for a recession to lower rates may not be the best strategy. Instead, buyers should focus on finding the right home at the right price and ensure they are financially prepared to commit to the terms offered.

There is a shortage of houses

The US mortgage market is currently facing a challenging situation due to a combination of factors, including high mortgage rates, increased debt, and a shortage of houses. While the market remains an integral part of the economy, understanding the dynamics of the housing market can provide insights into the broader economic landscape. As of March 2025, Americans collectively owe $12.61 trillion in mortgage debt, with an average of $148,120 per person with a mortgage on their credit report. This debt accounts for a significant portion of US consumer debt.

One of the critical issues impacting the market is the shortage of houses available for sale. This shortage has been attributed to various factors, including the after-effects of the Great Recession of 2007-2008, which caused a sharp decline in new home builds. Data from the St. Louis Fed indicates that new home builds peaked in January 2006 and plummeted to a low of 478 in April 2009. While there has been a recent increase in single-family home building, the total number of new builds as of February 2025 has not yet reached pre-recession levels.

The high-interest-rate environment has also played a role in the housing shortage. Elevated mortgage rates have made it challenging for buyers, reducing their purchasing power. Additionally, homeowners with low mortgage rates are reluctant to move, further limiting the available housing inventory. This situation has resulted in a competitive market with bidding wars, driving up home prices and exacerbating the affordability crisis.

The housing shortage is not evenly distributed across the country. According to Realtors.com, the South is leading the way in addressing the housing supply gap, while the Northeast may never see an end to the crisis. Texas accounted for 15% of new home construction permits in 2024, showcasing the regional disparities in construction activity.

Looking ahead, there are concerns about the potential negative impact of Trump administration policies on construction efforts. Tariffs on Canada, for instance, could increase the cost of softwood lumber, a crucial material in homebuilding. Additionally, possible immigration crackdowns may lead to a labor shortage in the construction sector, further hindering construction activities.

Frequently asked questions