Subprime Mortgages: A Recipe For Financial Disaster And Misery

The subprime mortgage crisis of 2007–2010 was a disaster for the global economy, causing the Great Recession—the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression. The crisis was caused by a combination of factors, including the influx of money from the private sector, banks entering the mortgage bond market, relaxed lending standards, and the predatory lending practices of mortgage lenders. Lenders granted high-risk loans to borrowers who couldn't afford them, and these mortgages were repackaged into mortgage-backed securities (MBS) and sold to investors. When house prices peaked and mortgage refinancing became less viable, mortgage loss rates rose for lenders and investors, leading to mass foreclosures and the devaluation of housing-related securities. The crisis had severe and long-lasting consequences, with nearly 9 million jobs lost in the US during 2008-2009 and a ripple effect felt throughout the global economy.

The subprime mortgage crisis

In the early to mid-2000s, high-risk mortgages became widely available from lenders who funded these mortgages by repackaging them into pools and selling them to investors as mortgage-backed securities (MBSes) and collateralized debt obligations (CDOs). These financial products were initially very attractive to investors as they offered higher interest rates and better returns than government securities, along with attractive risk ratings from rating agencies. However, most of these financial instruments were made up of high-risk subprime mortgages.

The high-risk nature of these mortgages was due to several factors, including the rise in subprime lending, the increase in housing speculation, and the predatory lending practices of mortgage lenders. Many borrowers were approved for these loans despite having poor credit, no assets, and, at times, no income. This was a significant shift from the traditional lending standards, where mortgages were typically only granted to those with strong credit histories and sufficient down payments. The influx of money from the private sector and government policies aimed at expanding homeownership also contributed to the crisis.

As interest rates rose and access to credit became more difficult, many homeowners could no longer afford their mortgage payments. This led to a wave of borrowers missing repayments and becoming delinquent, resulting in mass foreclosures and the devaluation of housing-related securities. The collapse of the housing bubble and the subsequent economic downturn had a ripple effect on the global economy, leading to what became known as the Great Recession. This period of economic decline was the worst since the Great Depression, with millions of jobs lost and many businesses going bankrupt.

Causes of the crisis

The subprime mortgage crisis of 2007–2010 was a collective creation of various entities and factors. It had a ripple effect on the global economy, leading to the Great Recession, which lasted between 2007 and 2009. This was the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression. Here are the key causes of the crisis:

Inability of Homeowners to Make Mortgage Payments

The primary reason many homeowners couldn't make their mortgage payments was the resetting of adjustable-rate mortgages, borrowers overextending their finances, predatory lending practices, and speculation. Adjustable-rate mortgages, such as the 2–28 loan, directly contributed to this issue.

Risky Mortgage Products and Lowered Lending Standards

Lenders offered high-risk mortgage products with unsustainable terms to borrowers who might not have qualified for traditional mortgages. This was facilitated by the influx of money from the private sector and banks entering the mortgage bond market. Lenders granted loans freely due to the free-flowing capital following the dotcom bubble and the reduction in interest rates by central banks to stimulate the economy.

Increased Debt Levels and Concealed Risk

The mortgage-backed security, credit default swap, and collateralized debt obligation sectors of the finance industry offered low-interest rates and high approval rates for subprime mortgages. These attractive terms enticed borrowers to take on more debt, and the risk of default was distributed and potentially concealed through financial products and models.

Government Policies and Inappropriate Regulation

Government policies aimed at expanding homeownership and increasing affordable housing contributed to the crisis. While these policies had good intentions, they resulted in lower lending standards and a higher volume of risky mortgages. Additionally, inappropriate government regulation and monetary policies further encouraged risk-taking and higher debt levels.

Faulty Financial Models and Misunderstanding of Risk

The financial models used to assess the risk of mortgage-backed securities (MBS) and collateralized debt obligations (CDOs) were faulty and did not accurately capture the potential for widespread default. The riskiness of these financial products may have been underestimated or "off the radar" due to the unprecedented nature of the rising home prices and expanded mortgage availability.

The role of lenders

The subprime mortgage crisis was a collective creation of various entities, including central banks, homeowners, lenders, credit rating agencies, underwriters, and investors. While there was no single individual or entity to blame, lenders played a significant role in the crisis.

Lenders were criticised for freely granting loans to individuals who could not afford them. This was due to the influx of capital following the dotcom bubble, which resulted in free-flowing capital. Lenders took on greater risks by approving subprime mortgage loans to borrowers with poor credit histories, no assets, and, in some cases, no income. These mortgages were then repackaged by lenders into mortgage-backed securities (MBS) or collateralized debt obligations (CDOs) and sold to investors. The lenders were able to offload the risky loans within 30 to 60 days, collecting origination fees and passing on the risk of default to investors.

The increased availability of high-risk mortgages was facilitated by rising home prices and the expansion of mortgage credit. Lenders funded these mortgages by pooling them and selling them to investors as mortgage-backed securities. The financial models used to assess risk may have been faulty, and the true riskiness of these securities may not have been fully understood. The demand for subprime mortgages was further fuelled by investors seeking high returns, who purchased these securities at low premiums.

Impact on the global economy

The subprime mortgage crisis had a significant impact on the global economy, leading to what became known as the Great Recession. The crisis caused a severe and prolonged economic downturn, with far-reaching consequences for countries around the world.

One of the key impacts was a disruption in the flow of credit to businesses and consumers. As the crisis unfolded, banks and other financial institutions became increasingly cautious about lending, which resulted in a credit crunch. This made it difficult for businesses to obtain the funds they needed to operate and expand, leading to a slowdown in economic activity. Consumers also found it harder to access credit, which affected their spending power and further contributed to the economic downturn.

The crisis also led to a significant decline in the housing market. As borrowers struggled to make their mortgage payments, many homes went into foreclosure, resulting in a glut of properties on the market. This, in turn, caused a decline in house prices, eroding the wealth of homeowners and reducing the value of housing-related securities. The decline in house prices also had a negative wealth effect on consumer spending, further exacerbating the recession.

The impact of the crisis was particularly severe in the United States, where the crisis originated. The US economy entered a deep recession, with nearly 9 million jobs lost during 2008 and 2009, roughly 6% of the workforce. The crisis also had a significant impact on the European economy, with high unemployment and reduced economic growth.

The global nature of the financial system meant that the impact of the subprime mortgage crisis was felt far beyond the US and European economies. The crisis highlighted the interconnectedness of the global economy, as the losses incurred by financial institutions spread through their worldwide operations and investments. This led to a loss of confidence in the financial system and a reduction in investment and economic activity on a global scale.

The road to recovery

The subprime mortgage crisis was a collective failure, with no single entity or individual to blame. However, it is essential to acknowledge the role of central banks, homeowners, lenders, credit rating agencies, underwriters, and investors in creating the conditions that led to the crisis. The crisis had far-reaching consequences, causing a severe global recession and resulting in job losses and decreased economic growth and consumer spending.

The first step on the road to recovery is to address the issues that led to the crisis. This includes examining the role of each stakeholder and implementing measures to prevent similar occurrences. Central banks, for instance, should focus on maintaining stable interest rates and avoiding aggressive rate cuts that may encourage riskier investments. Lenders should also adopt more stringent lending standards, avoiding the granting of loans to individuals who cannot afford them. Additionally, credit rating agencies should provide accurate risk assessments of investment products to ensure investors are aware of the risks involved.

Another critical aspect of the recovery process is restoring confidence in the financial system. This can be achieved by increasing transparency and improving the regulation and oversight of financial institutions. Governments and regulatory bodies should work together to implement robust standards and guidelines for lending practices, ensuring that the risks associated with mortgage products are well understood and appropriately managed.

Furthermore, it is essential to protect consumers and provide support to those affected by the crisis. Homeowners struggling with mortgage payments should be offered assistance through financial counselling and, if necessary, loan modification programs to help them stay in their homes. It is also crucial to address the issue of excessive consumer debt and provide financial education to help individuals make informed decisions about borrowing and investing.

Finally, to prevent similar crises in the future, it is essential to foster a culture of ethical decision-making in the financial industry. This includes encouraging responsible lending and investing practices and promoting a deeper understanding of the potential impact of financial decisions on the wider economy. By prioritising long-term sustainability over short-term gains, the industry can work towards creating a more resilient and stable financial system.

Frequently asked questions