Prepayment Penalties: Commercial Mortgage's Common Fine Print

Prepayment penalties are a common feature of commercial mortgages, and they can significantly impact the total cost of the loan. These penalties are fees charged by lenders when borrowers repay their loans ahead of schedule. While prepayment penalties are typically associated with mortgages and auto loans, they are also imposed on some business loans. The specific terms and conditions of prepayment penalties can vary depending on the state and the loan agreement. In commercial real estate loans, prepayment penalties are often implemented to compensate lenders for their financial loss if the loan is paid off early. This helps to ensure that the lender receives an adequate income from the interest on the loan.

Characteristics and Values of Prepayment Penalties on Commercial Mortgages

Prepayment penalties are fees charged when a borrower repays a loan early

Prepayment penalties are fees charged to a borrower who repays a loan before the predetermined time outlined in the loan agreement. These penalties are common in commercial real estate loans, including conventional loans, mortgage-backed securities, and multi-family homes. The purpose of a prepayment penalty is to compensate lenders for their financial loss if the loan is paid off early, as they typically aim to lock in their profits for a certain duration.

There are several types of prepayment penalties, and they can vary depending on the state and the loan agreement. Here are some common types:

• Defeasance: This involves replacing the original loan collateral (the property) with other collateral, typically government-backed securities like treasury bonds. The interest collected from these bonds ensures the lender receives an identical rate of return compared to the original loan. Defeasance is often associated with commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS loans) and life insurance company loans.
• Yield Maintenance: This type of penalty allows the lender to receive the net present value of the remaining interest payments that would have been paid if the loan had not been prepaid. It is calculated by determining the present value of future interest the lender would have earned if the loan had been carried to full term.
• Step-Down (or Graduated) Prepayment Penalty: This is a predetermined schedule in the loan agreement where the prepayment penalty decreases over time. For example, a common structure is a 5-4-3-2-1 step-down, where the penalty is 5% of the outstanding balance in the first year, 4% in the second, and so on.
• Soft Step-Down: This variation of the step-down penalty starts lower and declines more slowly. For instance, instead of a 5-4-3-2-1 structure, a soft step-down penalty might be 4-3-3-2-2-1.
• Lockout: This is a period during which a commercial real estate loan cannot be repaid in full. While it is not technically a prepayment penalty, it restricts the borrower's options for the property, such as sale or refinance.
• Fixed: This is a standard prepayment fee, often negotiable, where borrowers may be able to attain a smaller penalty in exchange for a higher interest rate.

It is important to note that prepayment penalties are typically negotiable to a certain extent, and borrowers may be able to shorten the duration of the loan, secure an alternative form of prepayment penalty, or ensure the loan is assumable, allowing for the transfer of property without paying off the original loan.

Lenders implement different strategies for prepayment penalties

• Defeasance: This strategy involves replacing the loan with a portfolio of government securities, such as treasury bonds. The bond coupons serve as collateral, allowing the lender to collect interest from the bonds rather than from the commercial loan. This option can be complex and expensive, requiring the involvement of professionals such as accountants and attorneys.
• Yield Maintenance: This strategy requires the borrower to pay a fee to the lender to compensate for the lost interest. The fee is calculated by determining the present value of the future interest the lender would have earned if the loan had been carried to the end of the prepayment penalty period.
• Step-down or Graduated Prepayment: This strategy involves a penalty that decreases over time. The percentage of the penalty may decline year by year, for example, 6% in the first year, 5% in the second, and so on. There are also soft step-down options, which start lower and decline more slowly, such as a 4-3-3-2-2-1 structure.
• Lockout: This is not technically a prepayment penalty, but it is worth mentioning. A lockout period is when a commercial real estate loan is not allowed to be repaid in full, and the borrower must wait for the period to expire before paying off the loan prior to maturity. This can restrict the borrower's future options, such as selling the property or refinancing.

It is important to note that commercial loan prepayment penalties are often negotiable to some extent. Borrowers may be able to shorten the duration of the loan, attain a smaller fixed or step-down penalty, or secure an alternative form of prepayment penalty that is more economically beneficial. It is recommended to review the term sheet in detail before negotiating prepayment penalties.

Prepayment penalties are common in fixed-rate commercial real estate loans

Prepayment penalties are a common feature of fixed-rate commercial real estate loans. These penalties are fees charged to borrowers who repay their loans ahead of schedule. Lenders implement these fees to ensure they receive adequate income from the loan, even if the borrower repays it early. The prepayment penalty compensates the lender for their financial loss and helps them maintain their yield or profit from the loan.

There are several types of prepayment penalties, and they can vary by lender. The most common types include lockout, fixed, step-down, defeasance, and yield maintenance. A lockout period occurs when a commercial real estate loan is not allowed to be repaid in full, restricting the borrower's future options. During this period, borrowers must wait until the lockout expires if they wish to pay off the loan before maturity. While it is not a typical option, some borrowers choose to pay off their mortgage during the defeasance period, which involves a complex process requiring the assistance of accountants and attorneys.

Defeasance is a process where the borrower replaces the original collateral (the property) with other collateral, typically government securities or bonds, that provide the lender with the same income as the original loan. Yield maintenance requires the borrower to pay a fee to the lender to compensate for the lost interest, calculated based on the present value of future interest. Step-down prepayment, also known as a graduated prepayment penalty, involves a predetermined schedule in the loan agreement, where the penalty decreases over time. For example, a common structure is a 5-4-3-2-1 step-down, where the penalty is 5% of the outstanding balance if prepaid in the first year, 4% in the second, and so on.

While prepayment penalties are common, they are often negotiable to a certain extent. Borrowers may be able to shorten the loan duration, obtain a smaller fixed or step-down penalty, or secure an alternative form of prepayment penalty that is more economically beneficial. It is important for borrowers to carefully review the term sheet and understand the different types of prepayment penalties before agreeing to a commercial real estate loan.

Commercial loan prepayment penalties are often negotiable

A lockout period occurs when a commercial real estate loan is not allowed to be repaid in full. While lockout periods can't always be avoided, they can restrict a borrower's future options, such as the sale or refinance of a property. In some cases, a loan with a lockout period may be desirable, as it can provide a borrower with stable financing.

Defeasance is a process where the borrower replaces the original collateral (the property) with other collateral, typically government securities or bonds, that will provide the lender with the same amount of income as the original loan. This type of penalty can be complex and expensive, and it is not typically chosen by borrowers.

Yield maintenance requires the borrower to pay a fee to the lender to make up for the lost interest. This type of penalty is calculated by determining the present value of future interest the lender would have earned if the loan had been carried to the end of the term.

Step-down prepayment involves a penalty that decreases over time. This type of penalty can be structured as a standard step-down, with a higher initial percentage that declines over time, or as a soft step-down, with a lower initial percentage that declines more slowly.

Borrowers may be able to negotiate more favourable terms for prepayment penalties, depending on their situation. For example, borrowers may be able to shorten the duration of the loan, thereby reducing the duration of the penalty. They may also be able to attain a smaller fixed or step-down penalty, often in exchange for a higher interest rate, or secure an alternate form of prepayment penalty that is more economically beneficial. Additionally, borrowers may be able to assure that the loan is assumable, allowing for the transfer of property without paying off the original loan.

Prepayment penalties are legal in most states

There are several types of prepayment penalties. The most common are lockout, fixed, step-down, defeasance, and yield maintenance. A lockout period occurs when a commercial real estate loan is not allowed to be repaid in full. The loan terms will not allow for prepayment in any form, and the borrower must wait for the lockout period to expire if they wish to pay off the loan before maturity. While not a typical option, borrowers may elect to pay off their mortgage during the defeasance period, which involves a complex process requiring the involvement of accountants, attorneys, and other professionals.

Yield maintenance is another type of prepayment penalty, calculated by finding the present value of future interest the lender would have earned if the loan had been carried through to the end of the prepayment penalty period. This calculation is typically performed by the lender, who utilises yield maintenance frequently. Defeasance, on the other hand, uses government-backed securities (treasury bonds) to maintain an identical rate of return for the lender. The bond coupons replace the mortgage as collateral, allowing the lender to collect interest from the bonds rather than the commercial loan.

Step-down prepayment involves a penalty that decreases over time. In some cases, there is a soft step-down prepayment structure, where the initial percentage is lower and decreases at a slower pace. This type of penalty can be advantageous as it provides a specific timeframe for the borrower to pay off the loan. It is important to note that commercial loan prepayment penalties are often negotiable to a certain extent, and borrowers may be able to shorten the duration of the loan or attain a smaller fixed or step-down penalty.

Frequently asked questions