Cryptocurrency Investment: High Risk, High Reward Potential

Investing in cryptocurrency is risky due to its volatility, lack of regulation, and susceptibility to hacking and cyber-attacks. Cryptocurrencies are decentralised and not backed by governments or central banks, which makes them highly speculative. The market is also less transparent than traditional stocks, and transactions are irreversible. The value of cryptocurrencies is driven entirely by supply and demand, which can lead to significant gains or losses for investors. Additionally, there is a risk of fraud and cybercrime, as well as technical glitches and human error.

Volatility and unpredictability

The value of cryptocurrencies is extremely volatile and unpredictable. This volatility can lead to significant gains, but also staggering losses. For example, the value of Bitcoin rose over 1,000% in 2017, but by August 2018, its value had dropped by more than half.

The volatility of cryptocurrencies is driven by supply and demand, rather than any inherent value. This makes investing in cryptocurrency highly speculative. The dramatic rise and fall of cryptocurrency values are not based on the price and quality of what the currency is worth, but rather on the speculative nature of the market.

The unregulated nature of the industry also contributes to its volatility. Cryptocurrencies are not backed by any government or central bank, and there is limited regulatory protection compared to traditional financial products like stocks, bonds, and mutual funds. The lack of regulation also means that consumer protections are minimal or non-existent, and transactions are often irreversible.

The market for cryptocurrencies is also not very transparent, making it difficult for investors to make informed decisions. Additionally, the lack of regulation means that cryptocurrencies are susceptible to fraud and cyber-crime. There is a considerable risk of hacking, phishing, and other malicious activities, as well as virtual Ponzi schemes and fake websites.

The highly volatile nature of cryptocurrencies means that investing in them is a serious gamble. It is often compared to gambling in Las Vegas—it can be exciting and you might walk away with a lot of money, but you shouldn't gamble with money that you can't afford to lose. If you're looking to grow your money for the future, it's generally recommended to stick to more traditional investment options.

Lack of regulation

Investing in cryptocurrency is extremely risky, and one of the main reasons for this is the lack of regulation in the industry. Cryptocurrencies are currently unregulated by governments and central banks, and this lack of regulatory clarity threatens to slow down mainstream adoption.

The unregulated nature of the industry means that consumers are exposed to a high risk of fraud and cyber-crime. For example, in June 2011, the Japan-based Mt. Gox exchange experienced a security breach in which $450 million worth of Bitcoin was stolen. In 2016, nearly 120,000 units, worth US$72 million, of bitcoins were stolen from the Bitfinex exchange in Hong Kong, leading to an immediate 23% drop in pricing. Cryptocurrency exchanges based in the U.S. must register as a national securities exchange with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which has mandatory requirements regarding cybersecurity. However, this does not eliminate the risk of fraud and cyber-crime.

The lack of regulation also means that there is limited consumer protection in the event of fraud or theft. With no issuing or regulating country or authority for cryptocurrencies, consumers have very little recourse in cases of fraud or theft, and law enforcement often has limited ability to seize the cryptocurrency or to take other remedial action.

The unregulated nature of the industry also means that there is a risk of money laundering, black market activity, and other illegal activity. There is also a risk that institutional investors could lose significant amounts of money due to market failures of stablecoins, crypto-focused hedge funds, and crypto exchanges. This could, in turn, lead to concerns about systemic risk and financial stability.

To address these concerns, there have been calls for stronger financial regulation and supervision of the cryptocurrency industry. Specifically, some have recommended that crypto-asset service providers should be licensed, registered, and authorized, with clear rules governing their activities. It has also been suggested that stablecoin issuers should be subject to strict prudential requirements to maintain monetary and financial stability. In addition, there should be clear requirements regarding the engagement of regulated financial institutions with crypto, particularly with respect to custody services.

While some countries have enacted bans on cryptocurrency to reduce risk, others have implemented targeted restrictions, such as restricting the use of certain crypto derivatives or crypto promotions. However, it is important for regulatory authorities to quickly manage risks from crypto while not stifling innovation in the industry.

Susceptibility to fraud and cyber-crime

Despite being designed to be theft-proof, cryptocurrencies are susceptible to fraud and cyber-crime. The decentralised nature of blockchain technology means that, once a transaction has been executed, it is irreversible. This makes cryptocurrencies an attractive prospect for criminals, who can use them to launder the proceeds of their crimes.

Cryptocurrency fraud is a growing global concern, with governments reporting an increase in the frequency of, and losses from, scams. Between 2017 and 2018, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission registered a 190% increase in losses for victims of scams involving cryptocurrencies. In 2019, the UK's Financial Conduct Authority issued a warning to the public after reports of cryptocurrency scams tripled.

There are 29 different types of cryptocurrency fraud identified in academic literature, and 32 in grey literature. The most common types include Ponzi schemes, phishing scams, and fake crypto wallets. In 2016, the Japan-based Mt. Gox, then the largest Bitcoin exchange, experienced a security breach in which $450 million worth of Bitcoin was stolen. In 2017, the Slovenian cryptocurrency exchange NiceHash was hacked, resulting in a loss of $64 million.

Cryptocurrency exchanges based in the US must register as a national securities exchange with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which has mandatory requirements regarding cybersecurity. However, with no issuing or regulating country or authority for cryptocurrencies, there is very little recourse in cases of fraud or theft, and law enforcement often has a limited ability to seize the currency.

Limited consumer protection

The unregulated nature of cryptocurrency trading means that consumers are exposed to a variety of risks with little protection. Consumers have reported issues with executing transactions and transferring assets between exchanges. Many have also faced difficulties accessing their funds due to platform failures, identity verification issues, security holds, or technical problems.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has identified several common risk themes in crypto-asset complaints, including hacks by malicious actors, romance scams, and "pig butchering", where fraudsters gain the victim's confidence and trick them into setting up crypto-asset accounts. The CFPB also highlights the difficulty of obtaining restitution in cases of fraud or account hacks, as crypto-asset platforms often require mandatory arbitration and limit class-action suits.

The unregulated nature of the crypto market has led to a lack of consumer protection in other areas as well. For example, there are often inadequate disclosures about the risks and suitability of the investment, aggressive and misleading marketing practices, and a lack of recourse and redress for consumers who experience losses. In addition, the lack of sound regulation and supervision has resulted in weak governance and risk management by crypto firms, uncertain operational resilience, and opacity.

The risks posed by the lack of consumer protection in the crypto market are particularly acute for consumers in emerging markets and developing economies (EMDEs), where access to traditional financial services is challenging. The largest growth of crypto use has been in EMDEs, and these consumers may be lower-income and more vulnerable to financial shocks.

Uncertain future regulation

The future of cryptocurrency regulation is uncertain, with different countries taking different approaches. In the US, the regulatory environment for digital assets is confusing and uncertain. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) sees cryptos as securities, while the Commodities Futures Exchange Commission (CFTC) refers to them as commodities. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) treats them as taxable assets. The Biden administration has frozen a proposal from FinCEN, an agency of the US Treasury Department, that would have established requirements for transactions involving legal tender digital assets or convertible cryptocurrency. Under the proposed rules, banks and money services businesses (MSBs) would have been required to verify the identities of customers, submit reports, and keep records of transactions over a certain amount.

The SEC chair, Gary Gensler, has said that the crypto industry could come under greater regulation to protect investors and prevent market manipulation. However, the CFTC and FinCEN will also play a role in shaping future regulations. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen has expressed concern over the potential use of cryptocurrencies for money laundering and terrorism financing, but also said that the US needs to encourage their use for legitimate activities. She intends to work with other regulators to implement an effective regulatory framework.

In the UK, the cryptocurrency exchange Binance has been banned from regulated activities in its markets. In contrast, El Salvador has moved to accept Bitcoin as legal tender.

The uncertain regulatory environment has led to calls for stricter regulation from lawmakers and investors. The complex nature of cryptocurrencies has resulted in different interpretations of how they should be understood and regulated. This has created friction among regulators, which is a key obstacle to the quick rollout of new regulations.

The future of cryptocurrency regulation remains uncertain, even as multiple federal agencies and departments continue to grapple with questions related to tokens and exchanges or platforms. In the long term, more stringent regulation could add legitimacy to cryptocurrencies and protect both exchanges and investors.

Frequently asked questions