Valuing Investment Funds: Strategies For Success

Valuing an investment fund is a complex process that requires a good understanding of the fund's structure, performance, and potential risks and returns. The value of an investment fund is determined by subtracting its liabilities from its assets, which gives us the net asset value (NAV). NAV per share is calculated by dividing the NAV by the number of outstanding shares, and it is the price at which the fund's shares are traded. There are several approaches to valuing an investment fund, including the market approach, the asset approach, and the income approach. The market approach considers the prices of similar companies, while the asset approach focuses on the net asset value of the fund. The income approach, on the other hand, looks at the income-producing capability of the fund. When valuing an investment fund, it is important to consider the fund's management fees, performance fees, and the potential risks and returns associated with the investments.

Net Asset Value (NAV)

The formula for calculating NAV is straightforward: NAV = Assets - Liabilities. For example, if an investment fund has assets worth $100 million and liabilities of $10 million, its NAV will be $90 million. This simple calculation offers valuable insights into the fund's value, helping investors and fund managers make informed decisions.

To determine the per-share NAV, we take the NAV and divide it by the total number of outstanding shares. This calculation is essential for pricing fund shares. For instance, if a mutual fund has an NAV of $100 million and investors own 10,000,000 shares, the per-share NAV will be $10. This per-share value is crucial for buying and selling fund shares.

NAV is particularly relevant for mutual funds and unit investment trusts. The per-share NAV serves as the price at which these funds' shares trade on the market. It's important to note that NAV can change daily, influenced by the fund's asset and liability changes. Therefore, investors need to stay updated with the latest NAV calculations to make timely and well-informed investment decisions.

When assessing the performance of a mutual fund, investors often compare NAV differentials between two dates. However, this approach has limitations as it doesn't account for income distributions, such as dividends and capital gains, which reduce the NAV. A more reliable measure of mutual fund performance is the annual total return, providing a broader perspective on the fund's overall performance.

The Income Approach

There are four basic steps in the Income Approach:

• Estimate gross income for the subject property.
• Process the income stream – estimate and deduct the allowed vacancy and collection losses and the expenses from potential gross income to obtain the income to be capitalized.
• Select the appropriate capitalization method.
• Apply the appropriate capitalization multiplier or rate to the income to be capitalized to generate a value indicator.

Discounted Cash Flow (DCF)

DCF analysis can be applied to value a stock, company, project, or other assets or activities. It is widely used in the investment industry and corporate finance management.

DCF analysis estimates the value of return that an investment generates after adjusting for the time value of money. It can be applied to any projects or investments that are expected to generate future cash flows.

The DCF is often compared with the initial investment. If the DCF is greater than the present cost, the investment is profitable. The higher the DCF, the greater the return on the investment. If the DCF is lower than the present cost, investors may be better off holding onto their cash.

The first step in conducting a DCF analysis is to estimate the future cash flows for a specific time period, as well as the terminal value of the investment. The period of estimation can be the investment horizon. A future cash flow might be negative if additional investment is required for that period.

The next step is to determine the appropriate rate to discount the cash flows to a present value. The cost of capital is usually used as the discount rate, which can vary significantly for different projects or investments. If a project is financed through both debt and equity, the weighted-average cost of capital (WACC) approach can be applied.

The DCF formula is as follows:

> DCF = CF1 / (1 + r)1 + CF2 / (1 + r)2 + CFn / (1 + r)n

>

> where:

> CF1 = The cash flow for year one

> CF2 = The cash flow for year two

> CFn = The cash flow for additional years

> r = The discount rate

DCF analysis can help investors who are considering whether to acquire a company or buy securities. It can also assist business owners and managers in making capital budgeting or operating expenditures decisions.

However, it is important to note that DCF relies on estimations of future cash flows, which may prove to be inaccurate. DCF analysis should not be used in isolation, and companies and investors should also consider other known factors when evaluating an investment opportunity.

The Market Approach

The primary advantages of the market approach are that it is based on publicly available data on comparable transactions and can, therefore, require fewer subjective assumptions than alternative approaches. The main disadvantage is that it can be impractical when there are few or no comparable transactions, such as in the case of a private company operating in a niche market with few competitors.

Example of the Market Approach

Suppose you are looking to purchase a new apartment. You find a listing for an apartment in your preferred neighbourhood offered at $200,000. The unit is a 1-bedroom, 1,000 square-foot apartment with 1 bathroom. It is in good structural condition but requires some minor renovations. Although it is in a desirable neighbourhood, its view is obscured, and it does not have an in-suite washing or drying machine.

You feel that the asking price is too high, so you decide to determine the apartment's fair market value by looking up similar apartments in the same neighbourhood that sold in the last year. You assemble your findings in a table, adjusting for factors such as the number of bedrooms and bathrooms, the view, and whether renovations are required.

Looking at these results, you see that the apartments' price per square foot ranges from $140 to $275, with the higher prices belonging to those with more bedrooms and bathrooms, better views, in-suite appliances, and no need for renovations.

By contrast, the apartment you are seeking to purchase is priced at $200 per square foot and has fewer of these desirable features than even the cheapest-priced apartment in your table. This seems to justify your intuition that the apartment is overpriced. Based on this information, you decide to make an offer of $150,000, which the seller accepts.

Value investing is a strategy that involves buying stocks that are priced below their intrinsic value. The investor's goal is to hold these stocks until the market realises their true value, at which point the stock price will rise, generating gains for the investor.

Value investing can be further broken down into passive, contrarian, and activist strategies. Passive value investing involves screening for undervalued stocks based on certain financial criteria, such as price-to-book (P/B) or price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios. Contrarian value investing involves buying stocks that the market has overlooked or undervalued due to overreactions to news or events. Activist investing involves targeting companies that are undervalued because their management team can make changes to boost their value.

The Asset Approach

The net asset value (NAV) is the value of an investment fund determined by subtracting its liabilities from its assets. The fund's per-share NAV is then obtained by dividing the NAV by the number of shares outstanding. The per-share NAV is the price at which the shares of the funds registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) trade.

Absolute valuation models value assets based only on the characteristics of that asset. These models are known as discounted cash flow (DCF) models and value assets like stocks, bonds, and real estate, based on their future cash flows and the opportunity cost of capital.

Relative valuation models determine the value based on the observation of market prices of similar assets. For example, investors use the price multiples comparable public companies trade at to get an idea of relative market valuations. Stocks are often valued based on comparable valuation metrics such as the price-to-earnings ratio (P/E ratio), price-to-book ratio, or the price-to-cash flow ratio.

Frequently asked questions