Charity Investment Fund Distribution: Public Access And Impact

Public charities and private foundations are both charitable organisations that are exempt from federal income tax. However, they differ in how they raise and distribute funds. Public charities solicit periodic donations from the public and must receive at least one-third of their contributions from the general public, while private foundations are usually funded by a single large endowment from an individual, family, or corporation. This key difference in funding sources has implications for their operations and the tax benefits they offer to donors. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for effective philanthropy and tax planning.

Public charities are publicly supported or function to support other public charities

Public charities are either publicly supported or function to support other public charities. An organization is considered publicly supported if it meets one of two tests. Firstly, if it receives a substantial part of its support from publicly supported organizations, government units, and/or the general public through donations. Secondly, if it receives no more than one-third of its support from gross investment income and more than one-third of its support from contributions, membership fees, and gross receipts from activities related to its exempt functions.

Public charities are considered more desirable than private foundations as they must appeal to public sentiment and strive to capture contributions from donors. They are also more attractive to donors as they offer higher tax-deductible giving limits and more flexibility in making donations.

Public charities that are supported by other public charities are known as "supporting organizations". These organizations are classified as either Type I, Type II, Type III functionally integrated, or Type III non-functionally integrated supporting organizations. They are typically formed to benefit, perform the functions of, or carry out the purposes of one or more specified publicly supported organizations.

Private foundations are subject to a 2% tax on net investment income

Private foundations are generally funded by a single large endowment from an individual, family, or corporation. They are separate legal entities, typically established and funded by a single benefactor, usually an individual, family, or business. Private foundations are subject to a 2% tax on net investment income for tax years commencing on or before December 20, 2019.

Net investment income is defined as the excess of a private foundation's gross investment income and capital gain net income over its allowable deductions. Gross investment income includes interest, dividends, rents, royalties, and payments with respect to securities loans. However, it excludes any income considered unrelated business taxable income, as this would be subject to unrelated business income tax.

Capital gain net income is determined using standard capital gain rules, but with some exceptions. Similar to gross investment income, capital gain net income excludes any income that is unrelated business taxable income. Additionally, no gain or loss is considered for property used for the foundation's exempt purpose for at least a year if it is exchanged for a similar property that will serve the same purpose.

To calculate the net investment income value subject to tax, the sum of the foundation's gross investment income and capital gain net income is reduced by all ordinary and necessary expenses incurred for income production or collection, or for managing property held for income production. These expenses can include officer compensation, employee salaries and wages, outside professional fees, interest, rent, and taxes on property used in the foundation's operations.

It is important to note that if these expenses are incurred for both investment and exempt activities, they must be allocated accordingly between the two. Charitable contributions, net operating losses, and certain corporate deductions are not allowed as deductions.

The 2% tax rate on net investment income for private foundations existed from January 1, 1985, through December 20, 2019. However, under specific conditions, this rate could be reduced to 1%. The applicable tax rate during this period was determined using a complex formula.

The Further Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2020 simplified the process by introducing a flat tax rate of 1.39% for taxable years starting after December 20, 2019. This flat rate makes it easier for private foundations to calculate their net investment income tax liability.

Private foundations must report any net investment income excise tax owed on Form 990-PF and make the necessary payments. These filings are generally due by the 15th day of the fifth month following the end of the foundation's tax year, or the 11th month if an extension was obtained. If the net investment income excise tax owed is $500 or less, a single payment can be made with the Form 990-PF filing. However, if the tax amount exceeds $500, the foundation is required to make estimated installment payments using Form 990-W.

Public charities include hospitals, schools, churches, and grant-making organisations

Public charities are organisations that are tax-exempt and are classified as such by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). They are distinct from private foundations in several ways, including their sources of funding and how they operate. While private foundations are usually funded by a single individual, family, or corporation, public charities are funded by the public and include hospitals, schools, churches, and grant-making organisations.

Public charities are a diverse group of nonprofit institutions that play a crucial role in American society. They help form and strengthen communities and provide various services that would otherwise be performed by the government in some countries. The IRS defines "charitable" purposes as:

> relief of the poor, the distressed, or the underprivileged; advancement of religion; advancement of education or science; erecting or maintaining public buildings, monuments, or works; lessening the burdens of government; lessening neighbourhood tensions; eliminating prejudice and discrimination; defending human and civil rights secured by law; and combating community deterioration and juvenile delinquency.

Public charities include hospitals, schools, and universities, as well as churches and other religious organisations. They have active fundraising programmes and receive contributions from various sources, including the general public, governmental agencies, corporations, private foundations, and other public charities. They may also receive income from activities related to their exempt purposes.

Grant-making organisations are another type of public charity. These organisations, often called public foundations, provide grants to other charities or individuals. Most public foundations are publicly supported charities, receiving funds from multiple sources such as private foundations, individuals, government agencies, and fees for their charitable services. Some public foundations are considered charities simply due to their legal relationship with other public charities.

Public charities are subject to public scrutiny due to their public funding, which helps ensure they adhere to appropriate standards of conduct. They must also meet certain compliance requirements to maintain their tax-exempt status.

Private foundations are usually funded by an individual, family or corporation

Private foundations are charitable organisations that are typically established and funded by a single source, usually an individual, family, or corporation. They are independent legal entities that are set up for solely charitable purposes.

Private foundations differ from public charities in the way they raise funds. While public charities solicit periodic donations from the public, private foundations are usually funded by a single benefactor through an endowment of funds. This can include a variety of assets such as publicly traded securities, life insurance, annuities, real estate, and private equity. The funding source gives private foundations greater control over their operations and allows them to ignore public opinion. However, it also leads to criticism as they can support socially contentious projects.

Private foundations are subject to more stringent tax laws and regulations than public charities. They are required to make charitable distributions throughout their taxable year and pay a nominal excise tax of 1.39% on their net investment income. Donors to private foundations can claim tax deductions on their contributions, with limits of 30% of adjusted gross income for cash gifts and 20% for long-term appreciated publicly traded assets.

There are two types of private foundations: operating foundations and non-operating foundations. Operating foundations are directly involved in charitable projects, such as running a museum, zoo, or research facility. On the other hand, non-operating foundations, which make up the majority, serve their charitable purpose primarily by making grants to other charities. While they can operate programs, it is not their primary focus.

Public charities are more subject to public scrutiny

Public charities are also subject to greater scrutiny because they are less open to public scrutiny than private foundations. Private foundations are subject to various operating restrictions and excise taxes for failure to comply with those restrictions. They are also required to make annual distributions of at least 5% of their assets, while public charities are not.

The higher level of public scrutiny on public charities can help ensure adherence to appropriate standards of conduct, even in the absence of the more strict rules and regulations governing private foundations. Since 1969, private foundations have been subject to stricter federal rules than public charities, including strict prohibitions on self-dealing and limits on the amount of stock they can hold in any one company.

However, in recent years, the IRS has been requiring that public charities adhere to many of the private foundation rules when making certain kinds of grants or payments to individuals, charities, and non-charities. This is particularly true for charities that administer funds that are considered to be donor-advised.

Frequently asked questions