Bitcoin: Asset Or Equity?

Bitcoin is a cryptocurrency with a volatile value that has soared and dipped over the years. It has been described as a speculative asset, a get-rich-quick scheme, and a type of equity. Bitcoin's value is unstable, and its transaction processing is slow, making it an unlikely candidate for a widely used currency. Instead, it is often treated as a highly volatile store of value or a commodity asset that can be traded like gold or silver. Bitcoin also exhibits equity-like characteristics, such as its built-in cap on the number of bitcoins that can be mined and circulated, similar to a company's limited number of shares.

Bitcoin's value as a speculative asset

Bitcoin is a speculative asset, a get-rich-quick scheme. Its meteoric rise in value has been fuelled by speculation and its limited supply.

Bitcoin's value is underpinned by its decentralised, peer-to-peer nature, which allows it to bypass financial institutions and act as an alternative exchange mechanism to traditional currencies. Its supply is totally inelastic, with a fixed issuance schedule that is halved every four years, up to a final amount of 21 million bitcoins. This limited supply can be anti-inflationary compared to the supply of money from central banks, contributing to its appeal as a speculative asset.

Bitcoin's value is also driven by its use as a store of value and a medium of exchange. It can be used to buy and sell goods and services, competing with traditional currencies and influencing their value. However, its high volatility and slow transaction processing speed hinder its widespread adoption as a currency.

The speculative nature of Bitcoin is further emphasised by its lack of correlation with traditional asset classes such as stocks, bonds, and commodities, both in normal times and during financial turmoil. This low correlation implies low risk from a macro perspective, as a significant fall in Bitcoin's value is less likely to affect other assets.

While Bitcoin has no intrinsic value and is highly volatile, it offers diversification benefits and the potential for significant returns, making it attractive to speculative investors with a high-risk tolerance.

Bitcoin's equity-like characteristics

Bitcoin has several equity-like characteristics. Firstly, it is a speculative asset, a get-rich-quick scheme. Its value is highly volatile, and its transaction processing is slow. Its value is not based on any underlying use, unlike other assets, and its value is based purely on speculation.

Secondly, Bitcoin is a decentralised currency. It is not controlled by any government or entity, and no single person or group owns, runs, or controls it. Instead, the system is changed using bottom-up agreements called consensus. This means that Bitcoin is free, open, and permissionless, allowing users to buy, sell, send, or receive it 24/7/365 without needing to create an account or ask for permission.

Thirdly, Bitcoin is censorship-resistant and pseudo-anonymous. It does not require trusted third parties like banks or governments, and it is challenging to "ban" or stop Bitcoin transactions without shutting down the Internet or using physical force. While transactions are tied to addresses with randomly generated letters and numbers, it is still possible to link these addresses to real-life names if users do not take precautions to protect their privacy.

Lastly, Bitcoin is a disruptive force in the financial world. It disrupts central banks' monopoly on issuing money and disintermediates the payments system, undermining banks' ability to charge fees for currency exchanges, transfers, and transactions. This opens up a range of new opportunities and makes it a vehicle for speculation.

Bitcoin as a currency

Bitcoin is a cryptocurrency, a virtual currency, designed to act as money and a form of payment outside the control of any one person, group, or entity. It was introduced to the public in 2009 by an anonymous developer or group of developers using the name Satoshi Nakamoto. It has since become the most well-known and largest cryptocurrency in the world.

Bitcoin was created as a way to conduct transactions without the intervention of a trusted third party, such as a central bank or financial institution. Its emergence amid the global financial crisis, which shook trust in banks and even governments, was perfectly timed. Bitcoin enabled transactions using only digital identities, granting users some degree of anonymity.

Bitcoin's blockchain technology is truly ingenious and groundbreaking. It has shown how programs running on networks of computers can be harnessed to securely conduct payments, within and between countries, without relying on avaricious financial institutions that charge high fees.

However, Bitcoin has not been without its problems. Its value is unstable, and its transaction processing is too slow. The most important feature of a currency is that it be a stable store of value. This is vital for an economy to attract the investment it needs. Instability in currency values means that an investor cannot accurately predict the value of future earnings, making investments less valuable, and thus, less likely to happen.

Another basic feature of a currency is to facilitate transactions. Yet, to protect the security of the blockchain that makes cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin so secure, processing Bitcoin transactions is very slow. In fact, because of a limit on the number of transactions that can be completed in a day, it sometimes takes days to complete a simple transaction.

Bitcoin is also highly volatile and does not behave like any other conventional asset. It has been described by many scholars as an economic bubble. It has no intrinsic value and is not backed by anything. Bitcoin investors seem to be relying on the greater fool theory—that is, all you need to profit from an investment is to find someone willing to buy the asset at an even higher price.

Bitcoin is not without its consequences. Transactions are processed by "miners" using massive amounts of computing power in return for rewards in the form of Bitcoin. By some estimates, the Bitcoin network consumes as much energy as entire countries like Argentina and Norway, not to mention the mountains of electronic waste from specialized machines used for such mining operations that burn out rapidly.

Bitcoin as a commodity

Bitcoin is a cryptocurrency, but it is also considered a commodity. Commodities are generally defined as basic goods that can be bought and sold, with their prices heavily influenced by supply and demand. In commerce, commodities are interchangeable with other goods of the same type. For example, a piece of corn is interchangeable with another piece of corn, regardless of who produced it.

Bitcoin exhibits these characteristics. Each bitcoin is identical and interchangeable, and its price is driven by supply and demand, independent of any producer or "centralized entity".

In 2015, the U.S. Commodities Trading Future Commission (CFTC) defined bitcoin and other virtual currencies as commodities under the U.S. Commodity Exchange Act (CEA). The CFTC's decision was stated in a settlement order:

> " [T]he definition of a “commodity” is broad […] Bitcoin and other virtual currencies are encompassed in the definition and properly defined as commodities."

The CFTC's position is supported by the text of the CEA, which defines "commodity" in general and categorical terms, "not by type, grade, quality, brand, producer, manufacturer, or form."

The classification of bitcoin as a commodity has regulatory implications. In the U.S., the CFTC polices certain wrongdoing in commodities trading, while the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) regulates securities, such as stocks, bonds, and derivatives. If bitcoin were classified as a security, exchanges may avoid listing it to prevent the risk of being fined by the SEC for listing unregistered securities.

The debate over the classification of cryptocurrencies as securities or commodities is ongoing, and it is likely that the regulatory landscape will be complex and varied, depending on the specific token and the jurisdiction.

Bitcoin's role in promoting blockchain

Bitcoin is a cryptocurrency that operates without a financial system or government authorities. It is powered by blockchain technology, which is a type of shared database that stores information in blocks linked together via cryptography. The Bitcoin blockchain is a decentralised, distributed ledger that is shared among a computer network's nodes.

Since its introduction in 2009, Bitcoin has played a significant role in promoting blockchain technology. Firstly, it has brought widespread attention to the potential of blockchain as a secure and transparent way to record transactions. The Bitcoin blockchain is a public ledger that anyone can view and inspect, providing transparency into the transaction history. This transparency, combined with the decentralised nature of the blockchain, ensures that transactions are irreversible and cannot be altered without consensus from all network participants. This immutability makes it difficult for fraudulent activities to occur, as any changes to the blockchain would require the majority of the network to agree.

Secondly, Bitcoin has demonstrated the potential for blockchain to disrupt traditional financial systems. Bitcoin allows for peer-to-peer transfers on a digital network, bypassing the need for centralised third parties like banks to facilitate transactions. This has led to increased interest in using blockchain technology in banking and payments, with potential benefits including faster transaction processing times and reduced costs.

Additionally, Bitcoin has highlighted the ability of blockchain to provide a secure and private means of storing and transferring value. Bitcoin wallets use public and private keys to assign ownership and enable transactions, providing users with a level of anonymity while preserving transparency. This has led to the exploration of blockchain technology in various industries beyond finance, such as healthcare and supply chain management, where secure and transparent data storage and tracking are crucial.

Finally, Bitcoin's success has sparked the development of thousands of other cryptocurrencies and decentralised finance (DeFi) applications built on blockchain technology. This has further contributed to the adoption and innovation of blockchain, with new use cases and applications being explored beyond just cryptocurrency.

In summary, Bitcoin has played a pivotal role in promoting blockchain technology by showcasing its potential for secure, transparent, and decentralised record-keeping, as well as its ability to disrupt traditional financial systems and provide a secure means of value transfer.

Frequently asked questions