Next-Door Neighbors: The Pros And Cons Of Buying The House Next Door As An Investment

Buying the house next door can be a convenient investment opportunity, but it's important to carefully consider the financial and personal implications. On the one hand, purchasing the neighbouring property can provide a lucrative side hustle, especially if you're looking to rent it out. Being close by allows you to oversee repairs, attract the right tenants, and easily manage the property. However, it's essential to evaluate the financial viability, as investing in real estate comes with risks and costs. Additionally, having tenants next door can be seen as an advantage or a disadvantage, depending on your perspective and relationship with them. Before making a decision, it's crucial to weigh the pros and cons and ensure it aligns with your short- and long-term goals.

Pros and cons of being a landlord

Pros

• Income: Rental income can help pay off a buy-to-let mortgage, and if you own the property outright, you'll make a profit.
• Tax benefits: Rental income is taxable, but there are several deductible expenses, including repairs, upgrades, installations, depreciation, insurance, accounting processes, and professional services.
• Equity and property value: The longer you own the property, the more equity you build, increasing your net worth. Real estate also tends to increase in price over time.
• Long-term investment: Rental homes are a long-term investment that can produce income for decades, even after the mortgage is paid off.
• Flexibility: Being a landlord is like running your own business. You can decide when to sell the property, and you can make your own schedule.
• Natural talents: If you're a people person, handy with repairs, or good at managing crises, being a landlord can allow these qualities to shine.

Cons

• Time-consuming: Being a landlord requires a significant investment of time and money. Even if you hire property managers, you'll still need to make final decisions and deal with tenant emergencies.
• Running your properties like a business: As a landlord, you have legal and ethical obligations to your tenants, including providing a safe home, choosing tenants fairly, and answering their calls for support.
• Liability and compliance: Landlords must follow laws and regulations, such as the Fair Housing Act and Americans with Disabilities Act, and may need to take legal action against tenants or vice versa.
• Tenant screening and eviction: Screening tenants is necessary but restricted by laws and regulations, and evicting tenants can be difficult, costly, and stressful.
• Maintenance and repairs: Rental properties require thorough budgeting for annual upkeep and long-term maintenance, such as new roofs, siding, and appliance updates.

Pros and cons of living next door to your tenants

There are several pros and cons to living next door to your tenants.

Pros

• You can keep an eye on tenant behaviour and put a stop to any criminal activity, businesses being run out of the unit, or actions that are in violation of the lease.
• If the property needs any exterior repairs, you’ll know immediately.
• Undesirable tenants may keep looking when they hear you live in the building.
• You’ll care more about the property and take better care of it.
• Communication might be easier when you see your tenants regularly.
• You can take advantage of owner-occupied mortgages, insurance policies, etc.
• You can subsidise your own housing costs.
• You can respond quickly to any maintenance requests or concerns.
• Tenants are happy they can reach you at any time.
• It's easier to get issues sorted quickly as they will also affect you.

Cons

• Tenants might knock on your door at all hours to complain or report a problem.
• Noisy tenants will affect your peace and quiet.
• It’s harder to live next to a tenant with whom you have issues.
• If a tenant locks themselves out, they’ll be knocking on your door.
• Shared areas might not be maintained to your liking.
• Not all expenses are tax-deductible.
• Lack of privacy – tenants may feel like they are being monitored.
• Landlords may enter the tenant's flat without consent, which is illegal.
• Landlords may perform inspections without giving official notice.
• Landlords may criticise tenants for the property not being immaculate.
• It can be awkward enforcing late fees and sending eviction notices to tenants who are also your neighbours.

How to approach your neighbour about buying their house

If you're considering buying the house next door as an investment, there are a few things you should keep in mind when approaching your neighbour. Here are some steps to guide you through the process:

Make Initial Contact:

• If you don't know your neighbour well, start by making casual contact to put them at ease and understand their attitude and character. This will help you gauge their receptiveness to the idea of selling their house.
• If you already have a relationship with them, take the opportunity to ask them casually about their feelings towards the neighbourhood and the city. They might share some complaints or concerns that you can use as arguments in favour of them selling their house to you.

Do Your Research:

• Before making an offer, it's important to do your due diligence. Find out if your neighbours own the house or if they are renting it from someone else. It could also be that their family owns the house, and they are just living there.
• Learn about your neighbours' situation. How long have they lived there? Do they plan to stay long-term or are they considering a change? Understanding their intentions can help you tailor your approach.
• Get to know your neighbours as people. What's important to them? What are their likes and dislikes? This information will be valuable when you discuss buying their house.
• Let your neighbours get to know you as well. Share your values, family dynamics, and how well you maintain your property. This will help them understand your motivations for wanting to buy their house and assure them that you will take care of it.

Test the Waters:

• Before making a formal offer, drop subtle hints to gauge your neighbours' reaction. Mention that you need more space or express your admiration for their property. You can even joke about buying their house to see how they respond.
• If you sense resistance or hesitation, take some time to warm them up to the idea before making a formal offer.

Understand the Market:

Research the value of their house and the surrounding neighbourhood. This will help you make a reasonable offer that is in line with market trends and expectations.

Make the Offer:

• Once you have established a relationship and done your research, it's time to make the offer. Write a letter to your neighbours expressing your interest in buying their house and outlining your offer. Use your knowledge of their situation to frame the offer in a way that appeals to their needs or desires. For example, if they've mentioned disliking the weather, suggest they could move to a place with a better climate.
• Choose a suitable time to deliver the letter, preferably during the weekend when people are more relaxed and receptive. After giving them the letter, repeat the key points and don't linger too long so they have space to consider your offer.

Follow Up:

• Since your offer is unsolicited, you might encounter resistance or hesitation. Gently follow up a few days later with each decision-maker in the household separately. This increases your chances of success, as one part of the family may be more inclined to sell than the other. Try to get them on your side to convince their partner or family member.
• A week or so later, visit the whole family again to see if they have made a decision. This is also a good opportunity to provide additional details to your offer, such as your willingness to cover closing costs and home inspection fees. Reassure them that you are not trying to rush them out and that you are happy to wait until they find a new place before starting any renovations or tenant showings.

Remember, buying the house next door is a sensitive matter. Be respectful, friendly, and casual throughout the process. Even if they decline your offer, you will still be neighbours, so maintaining a positive relationship is important.

How to finance the purchase of your neighbour's house

There are several ways to finance the purchase of your neighbour's house as an investment. Here are some options to consider:

Conventional Bank Loan

A conventional bank loan is a standard mortgage that conforms to the guidelines set by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. While it is not backed by the government, it is a common option for financing real estate investments. Typically, a down payment of 20% of the home's price is expected, but lenders may accept less depending on your credit score and income. However, for investment properties, lenders often require a larger down payment of around 30%. Conventional loans offer lower interest rates and longer repayment periods compared to other options, making them more affordable in the long term. Keep in mind that these loans have strict qualification requirements, including higher credit scores and lower debt-to-income ratios.

Hard Money Loan

Hard money loans are short-term, high-interest loans often used for flipping properties. These loans are based on the property's after-repair value. They are suitable for investors who want to renovate and resell the property for a profit. While hard money loans may be easier to qualify for than conventional loans, they come with higher interest rates and shorter repayment timelines.

Private Money Loan

Private money loans are borrowed from individuals, such as friends or family members. The terms and interest rates can vary significantly depending on the relationship with the lender. These loans are typically secured by a legal contract, and defaulting on payments can have repercussions on personal relationships. Private money loans often have higher interest rates and fees compared to traditional bank loans due to the increased risk for the lender.

Tapping Home Equity

You can use the equity in your current home to secure an investment property. This can be done through a home equity loan, home equity line of credit (HELOC), or cash-out refinance. You may be able to borrow up to 80% of your home's equity value to fund the purchase and necessary repairs or renovations. However, it's important to consider the risks involved, as failure to repay the loan could result in foreclosure on your primary residence.

Commercial Loans

If you are planning to buy a multi-unit residential property or a mixed-use development, a commercial loan may be an option. These loans have specific rules and requirements and are typically used for properties intended for business purposes. Commercial loans often have shorter terms and may require larger down payments. They can offer higher borrowing limits and competitive interest rates, especially for borrowers with strong credit and solid business plans.

Government-Backed Loans

Government-backed loans offer more flexible options for first-time homebuyers or those with lower credit scores. These loans usually have lower down payment requirements and more accessible qualification criteria. However, there may be additional fees and mortgage insurance premiums associated with these loans.

Partnership or Joint Venture

You can also consider pooling resources with another investor or a group of investors to buy and manage the property. This approach allows for shared risks and responsibilities and can provide access to additional expertise and resources. However, it's important to carefully consider the potential for conflict and the complexity of legal structures involved.

The benefits of investing in real estate near your home

There are several benefits to investing in real estate near your home. Firstly, it is a convenient way to enter the real estate market, especially if you are looking to rent out the property. By investing in a property close to home, you can easily oversee any repairs or maintenance issues that may arise, saving you time and money. Additionally, you are already familiar with the neighbourhood, which can help you attract the right tenants and ensure they settle in comfortably.

Another advantage is the potential to increase the value of your existing property. By purchasing the neighbouring property, you can choose your neighbours, improve the overall aesthetics of the area, and remove any eyesores or run-down structures that may be negatively impacting the value of your home.

Investing in real estate near your home also allows you to keep a close eye on your tenants and easily manage check-ins and check-outs, especially if you plan to use the property for short-term rentals like Airbnb. This level of accessibility and involvement can make the transition to becoming a landlord much smoother.

Furthermore, having a rental property close to home can provide financial benefits beyond just the rental income. For example, you may be able to get better prices when making improvements or repairs to your own home and the rental property simultaneously.

However, it is important to remember that putting all your eggs in one basket may not be the wisest financial decision. Diversifying your property investments across different markets and locations can help hedge your bets and reduce risk. Before investing in real estate near your home, be sure to do your research and carefully consider the potential impact on your financial future.

Frequently asked questions