Social Security Fund: Index Annuities And Government Investment

The Social Security trust funds are accounts managed by the US Department of the Treasury. The funds invest any surplus in special issue US government debt securities. These securities can be redeemed at face value at any time to pay fund obligations. Since the Social Security program began, all securities held by the trust funds have been issued by the Federal Government. The funds have held marketable securities in the past, but they currently only hold special issues.

There are three options to avert the predicted bankruptcy of the Social Security Trust: increase revenues by raising the payroll tax and the earnings cap, reduce benefits, or increase the rate of return on funds in the Social Security Trust. The third option has been the focus of several reform plans, which propose investing in the stock market to increase the rate of return.

However, critics argue that equity investment could interfere with private markets and create the misleading impression that the government can create magic money by issuing bonds and buying equities. Additionally, equity investments involve greater risk.

Pros and cons of investing social security funds in the stock market

The prospect of investing social security funds in the stock market has been a topic of debate for many years, with proponents and critics offering valid points on both sides.

Pros

One of the main advantages of investing social security funds in the stock market is the potential for higher returns. Historically, equity investments have significantly outperformed Treasury securities. For instance, the after-inflation annual return on stocks was 9.5% compared to 1.8% for long-term Treasury bonds over a specific period. This higher expected rate of return for equities means that Social Security might need fewer tax increases or benefit cuts to maintain long-term solvency. Additionally, economists argue that efficient risk-sharing across an individual's lifecycle requires taking on more financial risk when young and less when old. Investing in stocks can be one way to achieve this goal.

Another benefit is that investing in equities through government retirement funds has proven feasible, safe, and effective in other countries, such as Canada. Canada's actively managed fund, the Canada Pension Plan, follows fiduciary standards and uses conservative return assumptions. Similarly, the Railroad Retirement system in the United States has invested in a broad array of assets without interfering in the private market. These examples demonstrate that governments can successfully invest in equities in a sensible and responsible manner.

Cons

One of the primary concerns about investing social security funds in the stock market is the increased risk associated with equities. Stocks are generally riskier than government securities, and this additional risk could introduce potential downsides to the Social Security system. Policymakers must carefully assess the level of risk involved, who will bear this risk, and whether the potential benefits outweigh these risks. Moreover, critics argue that relying on historical rates of return for equities to continue in the future may be dangerous. There is a possibility of lower-than-average equity returns, especially after periods of high stock market prices.

Another disadvantage is the potential interference in private markets. Critics worry that Social Security equity investing could negatively impact the stock market and corporate decision-making. Additionally, there is a concern about creating the impression that the government can simply issue bonds and buy stocks to generate "magic money." This could mislead the public about the complexities of financial markets and the risks involved.

Furthermore, investing social security funds in the stock market requires a significant trust fund to be effective. In the case of the United States, the Social Security trust fund is heading towards depletion, and rebuilding it through additional taxes or borrowing may not be wise or feasible. Therefore, the time for investing social security funds in equities may have passed, as the mechanics alone are not enough to ensure success without the necessary financial resources.

How the Social Security Trust Funds work

The Social Security Trust Funds are financial accounts in the US Treasury, managed by the Department of the Treasury. There are two separate funds: the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) Trust Fund and the Disability Insurance (DI) Trust Fund. The OASI fund pays retirement and survivor benefits, while the DI fund covers disability benefits.

The Social Security Trust Funds are pay-as-you-go structures, where beneficiaries are paid from the contributions of current workers, rather than their own accumulated deposits. All of Social Security's payroll taxes and other income are deposited into these funds, and all benefits and administrative expenses are paid from them. The funds hold money that is not needed in the current year for benefits and administrative costs, and this money is invested by law in special Treasury bonds, guaranteed by the US government. These bonds are available only to the trust funds and are distinct from public issues, which are available to the public. A market rate of interest is paid to the trust funds on the bonds they hold, and when those bonds mature or are needed to pay benefits, the Treasury redeems them.

The trust funds have been accumulating reserves over the years, with a surplus of income over expenses. By 2021, the trust funds had accumulated $2.9 trillion in reserves, but the system began to draw on these reserves to pay benefits. The reserves are expected to be depleted by 2034 or 2035, at which point Social Security's income will still be able to pay around 83% of promised benefits.

There are proposals to address the predicted shortfall, including increasing revenues, reducing benefits, or increasing the rate of return on funds. Some plans suggest investing the funds in the stock market, but this would introduce additional risk to the system.

Social Security Trust Funds' securities

The Social Security Trust Funds are financial accounts in the US Treasury, comprising two separate funds: the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) Trust Fund and the Disability Insurance (DI) Trust Fund. These funds pay retirement, survivors, and disability benefits, and are managed by the Department of the Treasury.

Since the Social Security program began, all securities held by the trust funds have been issued by the Federal Government. There are two types of securities: special issues, which are only available to the trust funds, and public issues, which are available to the public (marketable securities). The trust funds currently hold only special issues but have held public issues in the past.

The trust funds are required by law to be invested in non-marketable securities issued and guaranteed by the "full faith and credit" of the federal government. These securities earn a market rate of interest. The funds are off-budget and treated separately from other federal spending and other trust funds of the federal government.

The Social Security Trust Funds cannot invest in the stock market. However, there have been proposals to allow this as a way to increase the rate of return on funds in the Social Security Trust and avert predicted bankruptcy. These proposals include allowing individuals to use their deposits to invest in the market and permitting the Trust fund to invest directly.

There are risks associated with investing in equities, and it is uncertain whether the benefits would outweigh these risks. Policymakers would need to assess and address these risks and determine whether the potential benefits are worth it.

Social Security Trust Funds' finances

The Social Security Trust Funds are financial accounts in the US Treasury. There are two separate funds: the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) Trust Fund, which pays retirement and survivors benefits, and the Disability Insurance (DI) Trust Fund, which pays disability benefits. Social Security taxes and other income are deposited into these accounts, and Social Security benefits are paid out from them.

The Social Security Trust Funds are invested in Treasury securities. These are regarded as being among the world's safest investments. The funds hold money that is not needed in the current year for benefits and administrative costs, and this money is invested in special Treasury bonds that are guaranteed by the US government. A market rate of interest is paid to the funds on the bonds they hold, and when those bonds mature or are needed to pay benefits, the Treasury redeems them.

Social Security is largely a "pay as you go" program, meaning that today's benefits are funded primarily by the payroll taxes collected from today's workers. For over three decades, Social Security collected more in payroll taxes and other income than it paid in benefits and expenses, and the Treasury invested the surplus in interest-bearing Treasury securities. In 2021, Social Security began redeeming those reserves to help pay benefits.

The projected actuarial deficit for the combined trust funds over the next 75 years is 3.50% of taxable payroll. The projected reserve depletion date for the combined funds is 2035, a year later than the previous projection. The OASI Trust Fund can pay full benefits until 2033, while the DI Trust Fund is projected to be able to pay full benefits through the end of the 75-year projection period (2098).

To address the predicted shortfall, there are three main options: increasing revenues by raising the payroll tax and the earnings cap, reducing benefits, or increasing the rate of return on funds in the Social Security Trust. Some have proposed allowing the Social Security Trust Fund to invest in stocks to increase the rate of return. However, investing in equities would introduce additional risk into the Social Security system, and the potential benefits are somewhat ambiguous due to the possibility of lower-than-average equity returns.

Social Security Trust Funds' future

The future of the Social Security Trust Funds is a topic of ongoing discussion and speculation. The Social Security Trust Funds are made up of the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) and Disability Insurance (DI) Trust Funds, which are currently managed by the Department of the Treasury. The future of these funds is uncertain, with a projected depletion date approaching in the next decade.

Projected Depletion of Social Security Trust Funds

The Social Security Trust Funds are projected to face financing issues in the coming years. According to the Social Security and Medicare Boards of Trustees' 2024 report, the OASI Trust Fund will be able to pay 100% of total scheduled benefits until 2033, after which its reserves will be depleted, and only 79% of benefits will be payable. The combined OASDI fund, which includes both the OASI and DI Trust Funds, is projected to be depleted by 2035, a year later than previously reported.

Options to Address the Issue

To address the impending depletion of the Social Security Trust Funds, several options have been proposed:

• Increase revenues: One option is to increase the payroll tax and the earnings cap, which would boost the funds available to the Social Security Trust.
• Reduce benefits: Alternatively, benefits could be reduced to lower the strain on the Trust Funds.
• Increase the rate of return on funds: Another approach is to invest the Social Security Trust Funds in the stock market to take advantage of potentially higher returns compared to traditional Treasury securities. This option introduces additional risk and has been the subject of debate.

Future Projections

While the future of the Social Security Trust Funds is uncertain, the Social Security Board of Trustees provides annual reports to Congress on their financial and actuarial status. These reports help lawmakers and policymakers make informed decisions and consider various options to address any shortfalls. The long-term sustainability of the Social Security program will depend on the actions taken by Congress and the ongoing economic and demographic factors affecting the funds.

Frequently asked questions