Cryptocurrency: Halal Investment Or Haram Gamble?

There is ongoing debate among Muslims as to whether cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin are halal. Islam has strict financial laws, and because crypto is a new concept, Sharia law around this type of currency can be difficult to interpret. Cryptocurrency is a high-risk investment, and its value is extremely volatile. This makes it similar to gambling, which is forbidden in Islam. Cryptocurrencies are also unregulated and not backed by governments or financial bodies, and are often used for makruh or haram purchases. However, some Muslims are open to the idea of cryptocurrency becoming accepted in Islam if it is better regulated. Cryptocurrency doesn't generate interest or riba, which is haram. Ultimately, whether crypto is halal or haram depends on how it is used.

Cryptocurrency is a high-risk investment similar to gambling

The high-risk nature of cryptocurrency investments has sparked comparisons to gambling. While some people have made millions by investing in cryptocurrencies, it is also incredibly easy to lose everything. The value of these crypto assets is bound to fluctuate, and there is a real danger that investors will lose their money. Financial journalist Paul Lewis has gone so far as to advise people never to buy cryptocurrency, stating that it is not a proper investment because it does not produce a return. The only way to make money is by selling the cryptocurrency at a future date when it is worth more, which is not how investments typically work.

The speculative nature of cryptocurrencies has also triggered debate among Muslim scholars over its permissibility. Islamic law principles emphasise real economic activity based on physical assets and frown upon pure monetary speculation. Cryptocurrencies are products of financial engineering and objects of speculation, and thus sit uneasily with Islam. However, some scholars have deemed cryptocurrencies permissible, arguing that they have become socially acceptable and commonly used.

The question of whether cryptocurrency is a legitimate investment or a gamble depends on one's strategy. If one buys crypto with the sole purpose of getting rich overnight, it can be considered gambling. However, if one believes that cryptocurrency is the way of the future and will be around for decades, buying it now could be seen as an investment.

Investing in cryptocurrency always carries a high degree of risk. It is important to be strategic and careful and only invest money one can afford to lose. Diversifying one's portfolio and ensuring it is as strong and stable as possible can help reduce the risk of losing everything if crypto fails.

It's used differently to money

Cryptocurrency is a digital currency exchange and digital payments platform that uses blockchain technology. It is a peer-to-peer electronic cash system. It is different from traditional currencies in several ways. Firstly, cryptocurrencies are purely digital, whereas traditional currencies can be held physically. Secondly, cryptocurrencies are decentralized, meaning no person or group has exclusive control over the protocol. Traditional currencies, on the other hand, are centralized and controlled by governments and central banks. Thirdly, cryptocurrencies are transparent, as all transactions are available for viewing on public blockchains, while traditional currencies are generally private. Another difference is that cryptocurrencies often have a fixed maximum supply, creating scarcity, whereas the supply of traditional currencies is elastic and can be borrowed into existence. Finally, cryptocurrencies are borderless and can be sent anywhere in the world, whereas traditional currencies are issued by specific governments and are often limited in their reach.

These differences have led to debates among Islamic scholars about whether cryptocurrency is halal or haram. Some argue that cryptocurrency is permissible under Islamic principles because it is inherently anti-interest and operates outside of conventional banking systems, aligning with Islamic banking laws. Additionally, the finite supply of cryptocurrencies makes them less likely to be subject to inflation, which is an important element of Islamic finance. On the other hand, some scholars argue that cryptocurrency is haram because it is highly speculative and does not hold enough credibility as a currency. They believe that the wild price fluctuations and shadowy origins of cryptocurrencies make them akin to gambling, which is forbidden in Islam.

The lack of central authority and governance in cryptocurrencies is a key point of contention. While some scholars view this as a positive aspect that aligns with Islamic principles, others argue that it makes cryptocurrencies uncertain and risky. The fact that cryptocurrencies are not backed by any physical assets or commodities, such as gold or oil, further adds to the uncertainty.

Overall, the debate around the permissibility of cryptocurrency in Islam is ongoing, and there is no clear consensus among Islamic scholars. While some Muslims have embraced cryptocurrency as a viable alternative to the traditional financial system, others remain cautious and seek guidance from religious authorities.

It's not regulated by governments or financial bodies

The lack of regulation by governments or financial bodies is one of the main reasons why some Muslims consider cryptocurrency to be haram. The absence of regulatory oversight can lead to uncertainty and risk associated with crypto investments. This is particularly concerning for Muslims as Islamic law, or Sharia, has robust financial components that aim to protect against financial harm and ensure fairness in business and investing.

Cryptocurrency is not backed or guaranteed by any central authority, such as a government or financial institution. This means that the value of cryptocurrency is highly volatile and subject to significant fluctuations due to market forces of supply and demand. As a result, investing in cryptocurrency is often compared to gambling, which is forbidden in Islam. The speculative nature of crypto investments, where individuals buy crypto with the hope that its value will increase, further reinforces the perception of it being a form of gambling.

The unregulated nature of cryptocurrency also raises concerns about its potential use for unlawful or haram activities. Cryptocurrency ownership and exchange are untraceable, making it appealing for makruh or haram purchases. For example, in 2018, Bitcoin worth $872 million was exchanged on the dark web. The lack of regulatory controls can make it challenging to prevent such activities and protect individuals from financial harm.

However, it is important to note that the views on cryptocurrency among Muslims are diverse. While some scholars advise against investing in crypto due to its unregulated nature, others argue that better regulation could make it more permissible within Islam. For instance, some Muslims are open to the idea of crypto if it is properly regulated by governments and financial bodies, allowing for more transparency and reduced risk.

Additionally, the absence of regulatory bodies in crypto can also be viewed as a feature that aligns with Islamic financial principles. Cryptocurrency operates outside of conventional banking systems and interest-based transactions, which are prohibited in Islam. The decentralised nature of blockchain technology, which underlies crypto, ensures transparency and security without the need for central control. This aspect of crypto may be seen as inherently Sharia-compliant by some Muslims.

Crypto operates outside of conventional banking systems

The decentralised nature of crypto eliminates the need for third-party intermediaries like banks, making transactions much simpler and cheaper. This means that customers and banks can benefit from cost savings, as they no longer need to pay fees for processing or transferring funds.

Additionally, cryptocurrencies are not subject to government or central bank regulations, making them an attractive option for international transactions. Crypto is also faster than conventional payment systems, allowing users to transmit money safely and swiftly without waiting days for transaction confirmations.

Since crypto operates outside of government control, it allows citizens of underdeveloped nations to access financial services like investing and trading that were previously unavailable due to political or economic constraints. These new investment opportunities can help stimulate economic growth and create jobs by encouraging innovation and entrepreneurship in these regions.

However, the fact that crypto operates outside of government control also means that there is no legal recourse if someone’s funds are stolen or lost through fraudulent activity. This is a concern for many banks, who worry about the lack of anti-money laundering (AML) and know-your-customer (KYC) regulations surrounding crypto transactions.

It's difficult to interpret Shariah law around this new type of currency

The question of whether cryptocurrency is haram or halal according to Shariah law is a complex and evolving debate among Islamic scholars. On the one hand, some scholars argue that cryptocurrencies carry elements of uncertainty, wagering, and harm, which go against the central tenets of Islamic law. For example, Asrorun Niam Sholeh, the head of religious decrees for the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI), has stated that cryptocurrencies are forbidden according to Shariah law because they violate state laws and are not backed by any physical assets.

On the other hand, other scholars argue that cryptocurrencies are permissible under Islamic principles. For instance, Mufti Muhammad Abu-Bakar, a former advisor to Blossom Finance, has interpreted that all currencies have a speculative element, and this does not automatically make cryptocurrency haram. Similarly, the Fiqh Council of North America has unanimously decided that Bitcoin is permissible, and the Sharia Advisory Council branch of Malaysia's security commission has advised that trading and investing in cryptocurrencies is permissible as well.

The lack of a central authority in Islam to make a final ruling on this issue further complicates the matter. While there is no official decree banning cryptocurrency, the varying interpretations of Shariah law among Islamic scholars make it difficult for Muslims to determine whether investing in cryptocurrency aligns with their religious beliefs.

Additionally, the decentralized nature of cryptocurrency and the lack of a central governing body overseeing it present unique challenges when applying traditional Islamic financial principles. For example, the absence of interest in cryptocurrency transactions aligns with Islamic teachings, but the high volatility and speculative nature of cryptocurrency prices may be seen as a form of gambling, which is prohibited in Islam.

Furthermore, the rapid evolution of the cryptocurrency market and the emergence of new coins and exchanges make it challenging to provide clear-cut guidelines for Muslims. While some scholars advocate for a wait-and-see approach, others emphasize the need for ongoing discussion and analysis of each crypto coin against Islamic finance principles.

In conclusion, it is challenging to provide a definitive interpretation of Shariah law regarding cryptocurrency due to the novelty of this asset class, the lack of central authority in Islam, and the evolving nature of the cryptocurrency market. As such, Muslims seeking to invest in cryptocurrency should carefully consider their own research, values, and interpretations of their faith when making investment decisions.

Frequently asked questions