The Legality Of Cryptocurrency Investments: What You Need To Know

Investing in cryptocurrencies has become increasingly popular, but it's important to understand the legal implications before diving in. The legal status of cryptocurrencies varies across the world, and even within individual countries, the regulations can be complex and ambiguous. For example, in the United States, the sale and purchase of cryptocurrencies are legal in all 50 states, but the government heavily regulates how virtual currencies are taxed and traded. The lack of centralised authority and the newness of cryptocurrencies compared to traditional currencies contribute to the legal ambiguity surrounding them.

Cryptocurrencies and taxes

The IRS treats cryptocurrencies as property, and so sales are subject to capital gains tax rules. This means that any gains or losses made from cryptocurrency transactions are calculated by taking the difference between the fair market value of the goods or services received and the adjusted cost basis (the amount paid for the cryptocurrency plus any fees). For example, if you buy a car with Bitcoin and the Bitcoin used to purchase the car has increased in value since you bought it, you will have to pay tax on the gain.

It is the responsibility of the cryptocurrency owner to report all transactions to the IRS, and to keep records and receipts for every purchase and sale. If you are unsure how to report transactions properly, it is recommended that you consult a tax advisor.

In the US, the IRS has defined cryptocurrencies as property rather than currencies, which means that individual investors are subject to capital gains tax laws when reporting profits and expenses on their annual tax returns. However, if you are an employee and receive cryptocurrency as a salary, it is taxable as income based on the value of the cryptocurrency in US dollars at the time it was paid.

In terms of foreign bank account regulations, as of August 2023, federal law does not consider a foreign cryptocurrency account to be a "reportable account". This means that cryptocurrency account holders are not required to disclose their foreign accounts to the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN). However, this could change at any time, as FinCEN intends to propose amending the filing requirements to include cryptocurrency holdings.

Crypto Taxes: What You Need to Know

• You will be asked on your tax return whether you have received, sold, sent, exchanged, gifted, or otherwise disposed of a digital asset during the tax year.
• You are required to report and pay taxes on any profits made from cryptocurrency transactions.
• Buying crypto is not a taxable event. You only incur taxes when you sell, trade, or dispose of cryptocurrency.
• Crypto tax rates depend on your taxable income, tax filing status, and how long you owned the crypto before selling it. Short-term gains are taxed as ordinary income, while long-term gains are taxed at a lower rate.
• If you mine cryptocurrency as a business, you may be able to deduct your expenses.
• Gifting crypto is treated the same as gifting any other asset and may be subject to the gift tax.
• Inherited cryptocurrency is treated like any other inherited asset and may be subject to estate taxes.
• The wash-sale rule (which applies to the sale of stocks and other assets) does not apply to cryptocurrency.

Cryptocurrency regulation in the US

Cryptocurrency is not considered legal tender in the US, but it is legal. Cryptocurrency exchanges are also legal and fall under the regulatory scope of the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA). This means that cryptocurrency exchange service providers must register with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), implement an AML/CFT program, maintain appropriate records, and submit reports to the authorities.

The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) considers cryptocurrencies to be securities and applies securities laws to digital wallets and exchanges. The Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), on the other hand, has adopted a more relaxed approach, describing Bitcoin as a commodity and allowing cryptocurrency derivatives to trade publicly.

The US Treasury has emphasized the urgent need for crypto regulations to combat global and domestic criminal activities. In 2021, the Biden administration turned its attention to stablecoins, intending to address the danger of the tokens' growth in value.

Cryptocurrency investors in the US need to be aware of the legal and tax implications of their holdings. The IRS has defined cryptocurrencies as property, so individual investors are subject to capital gains tax laws when reporting cryptocurrency profits and expenses on their annual tax returns. Cryptocurrency wallets may soon be required to file FinCEN Form 114, a report for US taxpayers with substantial holdings in foreign bank accounts.

Cryptocurrency regulation in the UK

In 2020, the UK confirmed that crypto assets are property, but it has no specific cryptocurrency laws and cryptocurrencies are not considered legal tender. The regulatory uncertainty associated with cryptocurrencies prompted the UK government to create a dedicated task force in 2018. The UK government expressed its intention to make the UK a global hub for crypto asset technology and investment.

The sale of cryptocurrency in the UK is subject to sales regulations that fall into three broad categories: the financial promotions regime, prospectus regulation, and consumer protection and online/distance selling legislation. Crypto exchanges have registration requirements in the UK. From January 10, 2021, all UK crypto asset firms with a presence or market product in the UK, or that provide services to UK resident clients, have had to register with the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).

The FCA's guidance also stresses that entities engaging in activities involving crypto assets must comply with the Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017 (MLRs). The FCA has stated that it will consider the commercial element, commercial benefit, the relevance to other business by the relevant firm, and the regularity/frequency of activities as factors impacting its decisions on whether crypto asset activity is carried on.

The UK's proposed approach to crypto asset regulation is detailed in the Consultation. One of the core design principles of the new regulatory regime is "same risk, same regulatory outcome", meaning a focus on achieving the same regulatory outcome where possible, regardless of the technology used.

The UK government intends to adopt a phased approach and bring crypto assets within the existing regulatory framework. Firstly, the government has introduced legislation to bring "qualifying crypto assets" into the scope of the existing financial promotions regime. Secondly, the government has legislated to introduce a regime that will allow the regulation of fiat-backed stable coins that are used for payments. Thirdly, the government intends to introduce a regime to regulate broader crypto asset activities, such as the trading of and investment in crypto assets. Fourthly, in more nascent areas of the market, the government will actively seek views to inform future policy development.

Cryptocurrency regulation in India

History of Cryptocurrency in India:

The first cryptocurrency, Bitcoin, was introduced in India in 2009. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI), the country's central bank, issued a cautionary statement in 2013, warning users about the potential risks associated with virtual currencies. In 2017, the RBI prohibited banks and regulated entities from providing services to individuals or businesses dealing in cryptocurrencies, effectively banning crypto transactions. However, in March 2020, the Supreme Court of India overturned the RBI's ban, stating that it violated citizens' fundamental rights. This decision legalised cryptocurrency usage in India.

Current Status of Cryptocurrency Regulation:

Currently, cryptocurrencies are not regulated in India. The government has advised its citizens against transacting with cryptocurrencies, stating that they are not legal tender. However, there is no explicit ban on cryptocurrency trading in the country. The government has proposed a new bill, the "Cryptocurrency and Regulation of Official Digital Currency Bill, 2021," which aims to ban private cryptocurrencies while promoting the underlying technology. The bill also seeks to create a facilitative framework for the introduction of an official digital currency issued by the RBI.

Taxation of Cryptocurrencies:

In the 2022 Union Budget, the Indian government took a significant step towards regulating the cryptocurrency industry by officially classifying digital assets, including cryptocurrencies, as "virtual digital assets." The government announced a flat 30% income tax on the transfer of these assets. Additionally, a 1% tax deducted at source (TDS) is applicable if the buyer's payment exceeds the threshold limit.

Challenges and Concerns:

One of the main challenges in regulating cryptocurrencies in India is the decentralised nature of these currencies and the lack of a central authority or intermediary. This makes it difficult to ensure consumer protection and prevent fraud, financial loss, and other risks. Another concern is the potential impact on the Indian rupee if a large number of investors choose to invest in digital coins instead of traditional rupee-based savings. There are also security risks, such as cyberattacks on wallets and exchange mechanisms.

Global Perspective:

India is not alone in navigating the complexities of cryptocurrency regulation. The lack of global consensus or frameworks has led to varying approaches across countries. While some countries have banned cryptocurrencies completely, others have embraced them with favourable regulations. India has the opportunity to play a leading role in cryptocurrency regulation during its presidency of the G20, contributing to significant progress in this area.

The regulation of cryptocurrencies in India is an ongoing process, with the government taking steps towards creating a comprehensive framework. While the future of cryptocurrency regulation in India remains uncertain, the country's start-ups and investors are optimistic about the potential and future of cryptocurrencies in the country.

Cryptocurrency regulation in the EU

Cryptocurrency is legal in the European Union, and the EU has been working to create a regulatory environment that stimulates the growth and advancement of the blockchain industry. However, the virtual currency regulation in the EU is still in its early stages, and most member states have undertaken separate legislative strategies.

The European Banking Authority (EBA) has called for standardized regulations for cryptocurrency operations within the EU to eliminate unfair regulatory arbitrage and protect investors. The EBA has noted that the current financial regulations are inadequate, and there is a need for a regional framework.

The EU's anti-money laundering (AML) laws have been extended to cover the crypto industry, and the 5th AML Directive aims to bring virtual currency exchanges and custodial wallet providers under the existing European AML legislation. This means that virtual currency exchanges and custodians will have to register with the relevant AML authority, identify users, monitor transactions, report suspicious activities, and provide greater access to information for national investigators.

The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has suggested that the EU regulate the cryptocurrency space with existing legislation rather than creating new rules and laws. The ESMA specifies that most crypto assets are covered by the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, which requires corresponding laws to be passed and incorporated into each member state's legal system.

The EU's Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation, which went into effect in June 2023, sets safeguards and establishes rules for companies or vendors providing financial services using cryptocurrencies.

Overall, the EU is working towards creating a regulatory environment that supports the blockchain industry, and the authorities are cognizant of the impact of distributed ledger technology on the financial sector.

Frequently asked questions